Assembling aircraft stiffened panels using friction stir welding offers potential to reduce fabrication time in comparison to current mechanical fastener assembly, making it economically feasible to select structurally desirable stiffener pitching and novel panel configurations. With such a departure from the traditional fabrication process, much research has been conducted on producing strong reliable welds, with less examination of the impact of welding process residual effects on panel structural behaviour and the development of appropriate design methods. This article significantly expands the available panel level compressive strength knowledge, demonstrating the strength potential of a welded aircraft panel with multiple lateral and longitudinal stiffener bays. An accompanying computational study has determined the most significant process residual effects that influence panel strength and the potential extent of panel degradation. The experimental results have also been used to validate a previously published design method, suggesting accurate predictions can be made if the conventional aerospace design methods are modified to acknowledge the welding altered panel properties.
Zink W. Advanced aircraft fuselage structures. In: The European symposium on assessment of power beam welds, GKSS Research Centre, Geesthact, Germany, 4–5 February 1999.
2.
GibsonASterlingS. A design and test programme involving welded sheet-stringer compression panels. 21st International council of the aeronautical sciences congress, 13–18 September, 1998, Melbourne, Australiapaper no. ICAS-98-7.7.4.
3.
DracupBJArbegastWJ. Friction stir welding as a rivet replacement technology. Proceedings of the 1999 SAE aerospace automated fastening conference and exposition, 5–7 October 1999, Memphis, TN, USA.
4.
ZinkW. Laser beam welding for aircraft structures. Aeromat 2000 conference, 27–29 June 2000, Seattle, WA, USA.
5.
IrvingP. End of the aircraft rivet-the coming of the welded aircraft. Aerogram2001; 10(2): 10–13.
6.
MendezPFEagarTW. Welding processes for aeronautics. Adv Mater Processes2001; 159(5): 39–43.
7.
ZinkW. Welding fuselage shells. Ind Laser Solutions2001; 4(7): 7–10.
8.
Hoffman EK, Hafley RA, Wagner JA, et al. Compression buckling behaviour of large-scale friction stir welded and riveted 2090-T83 Al-Li alloy skin-stiffener panels. Report no. NASA/TM-2002-211770, August 2002. Washington, DC: NASA.
9.
MurphyALynchFPriceM. The static strength analysis of friction stir welded stiffened panels for primary fuselage structure. Proceedings of international council of the aeronautical sciences, ICAS 2004, 29 August–3 September 2004, Yokohama, Japanpaper no. ICAS-2004-5.6.3.
10.
ZhangXLiY. Damage tolerance and fail safety of welded aircraft wing panels. AIAA J2005; 43(7): 1613–1623.
11.
LynchFPriceMMurphyA. Analysis of weld configuration for laser welded skin-stringer fuselage sub-panels in compression. 4th International conference on thin-walled structures, 22–24 June 2004, Loughborough, England145–152.
12.
MurphyALynchFPriceM. Modified stiffened panel analysis methods for laser beam and friction stir welded aircraft panels. Proc IMechE Part G: J Aerospace Engineering2006; 220: 267–278.
13.
MurphyAPriceMCurranR. The integration of strength and process modeling of friction-stir-welded fuselage panels. AIAA J Aero Comput Inform Comm2006; 3: 159–176.
14.
MurphyAMcCuneWQuinnD. The characterisation of friction stir welding process effects on stiffened panel buckling performance. Thin Walled Struct2007; 45: 339–351.
15.
WidenerCTweedyBBurfordD. Path independence of allowables based friction stir butt welds. 7th AIAA aviation technology, integration and operations conference (ATIO), 18–20 September 2007, Belfast, Northern Irelandpaper no. AIAA 2007-7864.
16.
YoonJWBrayGHValenteRAF. Buckling analysis for an integrally stiffened panel structure with a friction stir weld. Thin Walled Struct2009; 47(12): 1608–1622.
17.
SerroniGSquillaceAPriscoU. Aircraft panels stiffened by friction stir welded extruded parts: mechanical characterization. La Metallurgia Italiana2011; 1: 35–39.
18.
LequeuPhMuzzoliniREhrstromJC. High-performance friction stir welded structures using advanced alloys. Proceedings of the 17th advanced aerospace materials and processes conference and exposition (AeroMat 2006), 15–18 May 2006, Seattle, WA, USA.
19.
BruhnEF. Analysis and design of flight vehicle structures, 1st ed. Cincinnati, OH: Tri-State Offset Company, 1973.
20.
LynchCMurphyAPriceM. The computational post buckling analysis of fuselage stiffened panels loaded in compression. Thin Walled Struct2004; 42(10): 1445–1464.
21.
CavalierePNobileRPanellaFW. Mechanical and microstructural behaviour of 2024-7075 aluminium alloy sheets joined by friction stir welding. Int J Mach Tools Manuf2006; 46: 588–594.
MyhrORGrongO. Process modelling applied to 6082-T6 aluminium weldments - ii. Application of model. Acta Metall Mater1991; 39(11): 2703–2708.
24.
ASTM E837-08. Standard test method for determining residual stresses by the hole-drilling strain-gage method, West Conshohocken, PA: American Society for Testing and Materials, 2008.
25.
ASTM E9-89a. Standard test methods of compression testing of metallic material at room temperature, West Conshohocken, PA: American Society for Testing and Materials, 1989.
26.
RambergWOsgoodWR. Description of stress-strain curves by three parameters. Technical Note No. 902, July 1943. Washington, DC: National Advisory Committee of Aeronautics.
27.
BeckerAA. Understanding non-linear finite element analysis – through illustrative benchmarks, 1st ed. Glasgow: NAFEMS, 2001.
28.
NASA. NASA astronautics structures manual, vol. 3. NASA TM X-73307, 1961. Washington, DC: NASA.
29.
Engineering Sciences Data Unit. ESDU structures sub-series. Engineering sciences data units, London: ESDU International Ltd, 1965.
30.
MurphyAPriceMGibsonA. Toward virtual testing of airframe stiffened panels. Proceedings of Royal aeronautical society – virtual testing conference, 25–26 October 2006, London, UK.
31.
SingerJArboczJWellerT. Buckling experiments: experimental methods in buckling of thin-walled structures, 1st ed. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons, 1997.
32.
CederqvistLReynoldsAP. Factors affecting the properties of friction stir welded aluminum lap joints. Weld J2001; 80(12): 281–287.
33.
DubourgaLMeratibAJahazicM. Process optimisation and mechanical properties of friction stir lap welds of 7075-T6 stringers on 2024-T3 skin. Mater Des2010; 31(7): 3324–3330.
34.
BrookerMJVan DeudekomAJKalleeSW. Applying friction stir welding to the ariane 5 main motor thrust frame. Proceedings of the European conference on spacecraft structures, materials and mechanical testing, 29 November–1 December 2000, Noordwijk, NetherlandsESASP-468, p.507. Paris: European Space Agency.
35.
FersiniDPirondiA. Fatigue behaviour of A12024-T3 friction stir welded lap joints. Eng Fract Mech2007; 74(4): 468–480.
36.
EricssonMLai-ZheJSandstromR. Fatigue properties of friction stir overlap welds. Int J Fatigue2007; 29(1): 57–68.
37.
MishraRSMaZY. Friction stir welding and processing. Mater Sci Eng R2005; 50(1–2): 1–78.
38.
McCuneRMurphyAPriceM. The influence of friction stir welding process idealisation on residual stress and distortion predictions for future airframe assembly simulations. J Manuf Sci Eng2012; 134(3): 031011–031011.
39.
RoyR. A primer on the Taguchi method, Dearborn, MI: Society of Manufacturing Engineers, 1990.
40.
ThomasWMJohnsonKIWiesnerCS. Friction stir welding – recent developments in tool and process technologies. Adv Eng Mater2003; 5(7): 485–490.
