Predictive modeling of the rail grinding process using a distributed cutting grain approach

Abstract

High-density railway lines experience a high rate of deterioration on the running surface of the rails; it can be addressed by rail grinding in order to reduce the frequency of rail replacement. Rail grinding includes additional complex features beyond what is usually considered in conventional grinding. Although extensive empirical experience exists to describe rail grinding, it can still be considered to be an emerging field that is in need of predictive theoretical guidance. This paper presents a newly developed modeling approach that is intended to provide a theoretical understanding of the rail grinding process and allow the prediction of rail grinding behavior and performance. The modeling is a bottom-up approach that starts from individual cutting grains and builds up to the rail grinding train level. First, grain distribution modeling is used to build a uniform template for the grinding simulation, based on the assumption of spherical grains with normally distributed sizes. Second, one representative slice is extracted as a grinding surface with stable grains. Protrusion heights and spacing distances of the cutting grains are analyzed to obtain the features of the grinding surface. Then the spherical grains are transformed into decahedrons with arbitrary poses, so as to closely approximate the actual surface of a grinding wheel. Third, the interactions of the cutting grains are combined into a model of a single grinding wheel and compared to test results from a single-wheel test. This allows for the connection between the utilized grinding parameters and the grinding results to be isolated, which is validated with supporting experiments performed on a single wheel. The individual wheel relationships can be combined into a full multi-wheel grinding pattern for estimating the simulation results of a multi-wheel grinding train. Eventually, the comparison between the simulations and grinding tests is used to show the effectiveness of the predictive rail grinding modeling at the level of a rail grinding train.

Keywords

Rail grinding grain distribution grinding pattern rail defects railway track track maintenance

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Zarembski AM and Hagan B. Effectiveness of high speed rail grinding on metal removal and grinding productivity. Railway Track Struct 2012; 108(6): 44–48.

Zarembski

Zhi

. Analyzing rail grinding patterns. Railway Track Struct 2013; 109(6): 46,48,50,52–46,48,50,52.

Cannon

Edel

Grassie

Sawley

. Rail defects: an overview. Fatigue Fract Engng Mater Struct 2003; 26(10): 865–886.

Oostermeijer

. Review on short pitch rail corrugation studies. Wear 2008; 265(9-10): 1231–1237.

Zarembski

. The art and science of rail grinding Inc, Omaha, Neb: Simmons-Boardman Books Inc., 2005.

Grassie

Kalousek

. Rail corrugation characteristics causes and treatments. Proc IMechE, Part F: J Rail and Rapid Transit 1993; 207(16): 57–68.

Sato

Matsumoto

Knothe

. Review on rail corrugation studies. Wear 2002; 253: 130–139.

Grassie

. Rail irregularities, corrugation and acoustic roughness: characteristics, significance and effects of reprofiling. Proc IMechE, Part F: J Rail and Rapid Transit 2012; 226(5): 542–557.

Kalker

. Survey of wheel-rail rolling contact theory. Veh Syst Dyn: Int J Veh Mech Mobility 1979; 8(4): 317–358.

10.

Shen

Hedrick

Elkins

. A comparison of alternative creep force models for rail vehicle dynamic analysis. Veh Syst Dyn: Int J Veh Mech Mobility 1983; 12(1–3): 79–83.

11.

Jin

Wen

Wang

. Three-dimensional train–track model for study of rail corrugation. J Sound Vib 2006; 293: 830–855.

12.

Johansson

Nielsen

JCO

. Rail corrugation growth–influence of powered wheelsets with wheel tread irregularities. Wear 2007; 262(11–12): 1296–1307.

13.

Nielsen

JCO

Ekberg

Lunden

. Influence of short-pitch wheel rail corrugation on rolling contact fatigue of railway wheels. Proc IMechE, Part F: J Rail Rapid Transit 2005; 219: 177–187.

14.

Meehan

Daniel

WJT

Campey

. Prediction of the growth of wear-type rail corrugation. Wear 2005; 258(7–8): 1001–1013.

15.

Torstensson

Schilke

. Rail corrugation growth on small radius curves-measurements and validation of a numerical prediction model. Wear 2013; 303(1–2): 381–396.

16.

Magel E, Sroba P, Sawley, K and Kalousek J. Control of rolling contact fatigue in rails. Report, Federal Railroad Administration. In: Proceedings the AREMA 2004 Annual Conference, Nashville, TN, USA, 2004. Available at: www.arema.org.

17.

Ringsberg

Bjarnehed

Johansson

Josefson

. Rolling contact fatigue of rails—finite element modelling of residual stresses, strains and crack initiation. Proc IMechE, Part F: J Rail Rapid Transit 2000; 214(1): 7–19.

18.

Zarembski

. High speed rail grinding for high speed rail. In: The seventh world congress on high speed rail, Beijing: People’s Republic of China, 2010.

19.

Zarembski

. High-speed rail grinding and metal removal. Transport Res Board 2012; 108(6): 44–46.

20.

Tyfour

. Predicting the effect of grinding corrugated rail surface on the wear behavior of pearlitic rail steel. Tribol Lett 2008; 29(3): 229–234.

21.

Grassie

. Rail corrugation: advances in measurement, understanding and treatment. Wear 2005; 258(7–8): 1224–1234.

22.

Scroba

Roney

. Rail grinding best practices. In: Proceedings of AREMA Annual Conference. Chicago, 2003.

23.

Grassie

Saxon

Smith

. Measurement of longitudinal irregularities and criteria for acceptable grinding. J Sound Vib 1999; 227(5): 949–964.

24.

Grassie

. Rolling contact fatigue on the British railway system: treatment. Wear 2005; 258(7–8): 1310–1318.

25.

Schoech

. Rolling contact fatigue mitigation by grinding. Proceedings of the Rail Tech Europe Conference, Utrecht, 2007.

26.

Satoh

Iwafuchi

. Effect of rail grinding on rolling contact fatigue in railway rail used in conventional line in Japan. Wear 2008; 265(9–10): 1342–1348.

27.

Scroba

Magel

Prahl

. Getting the most from rail grinding. Railway Track Struct 2003; 99(12): 30–33.

28.

Zarembski M and Patel P. Estimating maintenance costs for mixed higher speed passenger and freight rail corridors. In: The 2010 Joint Rail Conference, Urbana, IL, 2010.

29.

Schoech

. New rail maintenance trends in Europe: anti headcheck profiles and preventive cyclical grinding, 2009.

30.

Hyde

Fletcher

. Planning rail grinding using crack growth predictions. J Mech Syst Transport Logistics 2010; 3(1): 216–225.

31.

Magel

Kalousek

. The application of contact mechanics to rail profile design and rail grinding. Wear 2002; 253(1-2): 308–316.

32.

Schoech W, Heyder R and Grohmann D. Contact geometry and surface fatigue guidelines for appropriate rail maintenance. In: The seventh international conference on contact mechanics and wear of rail/wheel systems Brisbane, Australia, 2006.

33.

Anderson

Warkentin

Bauer

. Experimental and numerical investigations of single abrasive-grain cutting. Int J Mach Tools Mf 2011; 51(12): 898–910.

34.

Agarwal

Venkateswara Rao

. Modeling and prediction of surface roughness in ceramic grinding. Int J Mach Tools Mf 2010; 50(12): 1065–1076.

35.

Agarwal

Venkateswara Rao

. Predictive modeling of force and power based on a new analytical undeformed chip thickness model in ceramic grinding. Int J Mach Tools Mf 2013; 65: 68–78.

36.

Jiang

Hong

. Study on micro-interacting mechanism modeling in grinding process and ground surface roughness prediction. Int J Adv Mfg Technol 2013; 67(5-8): 1035–1052.

37.

Cao

Guan

. Modeling and simulation of grinding surface topography considering wheel vibration. Int J Adv Mfg Technol 2013; 66(5-8): 937–945.

38.

Rüttimann

Roethlin

Buhl

Wegener

. Simulation of hexa-octahedral diamond grain cutting tests using the SPH method. Proc CIRP 2013; 8: 322–327.