Evaluation of the computer simulation model NTVPM for assessing military tracked vehicle cross-country mobility

Abstract

In the United States and some other NATO (North Atlantic Treaty Organization) countries, the NATO Reference Mobility Model is currently used to evaluate military ground vehicle mobility. The module of the NATO Reference Mobility Model for predicting the cross-country performance of military vehicles is empirically based and was developed using test data collected decades ago. The NATO Reference Mobility Model has inherent limitations, such as the uncertainty whether its empirical relations can be extrapolated beyond the test conditions upon which they were derived or whether it can be used for evaluating new-generation military vehicles. This suggests that there is a need for the development of a physics-based model that takes into account the advancements in terramechanics and modelling/simulation techniques. This paper describes the results of a detailed evaluation of a physics-based model – the Nepean Tracked Vehicle Performance Model – for assessing military tracked vehicle cross-country performance. The performance of a notional tracked vehicle (an armoured personnel carrier) predicted by the latest version of the Nepean Tracked Vehicle Performance Model is compared with test data obtained on sandy terrain, muskeg and snow-covered terrain. The correlations between the predicted and measured performance are evaluated using the coefficient of correlation, coefficient of determination, root mean square deviation and coefficient of variation. The applications of the Nepean Tracked Vehicle Performance Model to predicting the maximum possible vehicle speed (speed-made-good) on a given terrain, the sensitivity of vehicle performance to variations in the values of terrain parameters and the mean maximum pressure are demonstrated. The results of this study indicate that the Nepean Tracked Vehicle Performance Model has potential to form the basis for the development of the next-generation cross-country performance assessment methodology for military tracked vehicles.

Keywords

Coefficient of correlation coefficient of variation root mean square deviation computer simulation models cross-country performance mean maximum pressure physics-based models tracked vehicle mobility

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Wong

. Terramechanics and its applications to the evaluation of terrestrial and extraterrestrial vehicle mobility: theory into practice. Int J Vehicle Des 2014; 65: 384–410.

Ahlvin

Haley

. NATO reference mobility model edition II, NRMM II users guide. Technical report no. GL-92-19, December 1992. Vicksburg, MI: U.S. Army Engineer Waterways Experiment Station.

Wong

. Terramechanics and off-road vehicle engineering. 2nd ed. Oxford: Elsevier, 2010.

Bekker

. Off-the-road locomotion. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press, 1960.

Wong

Garber

Preston-Thomas

. Theoretical prediction and experimental substantiation of the ground pressure distribution and tractive performance of tracked vehicles. Proc IMechE, Part D: J Transport Engineering 1984; 198: 265–285.

Wong

. Optimization of the tractive performance of articulated tracked vehicles using an advanced computer simulation model. Proc IMechE, Part D: J Automobile Engineering 1992; 206: 29–45.

Wong

. Application of the computer simulation model NTVPM-86 to the development of a new version of the infantry fighting vehicle ASCOD. J Terramechanics 1995; 32: 53–61.

Wong

Preston-Thomas

. Investigation into the effects of suspension characteristics and design parameters on the performance of tracked vehicles using an advanced computer simulation model. Proc IMechE, Part D: J Transport Engineering 1988; 202: 143–161.

Wong

Huang

. An investigation into the effects of initial track tension on soft ground mobility of tracked vehicles using an advanced computer simulation model. Proc IMechE, Part D: J Automobile Engineering 2006; 220: 695–711.

10.

Wong

Huang

. Approaches to improving the mobility of military tracked vehicles on soft terrain. Int J Heavy Veh Syst 2008; 15: 127–151.

11.

Wong

. Development of high-mobility tracked vehicles for over snow operation. J Terramechanics 2009; 46: 141–155.

12.

Schunn

Wallach

. Evaluating goodness-of-fit in comparison of models to data. In: Tack

(ed.) Psychologie der Kognition: Reden und Vortrage anlasslich der Emeritierung von Werner Tack. Saarbrueken: University of Saarland Press, 2005, pp.115–154.

13.

Wong

Preston-Thomas

. On the characterization of the pressure-sinkage relationship of snow covers containing an ice layer. J Terramechanics 1983; 20: 1–12.

14.

Bodin

. Improving the mobility performance of tracked vehicles in deep snow (ISSN: 1402-1544). Doctoral Thesis, Department of Applied Physics and Mechanical Engineering, Luleå University of Technology, Luleå, 2002.

15.

Wong

Senatore

Jayakumar

et al . Predicting mobility performance of a small, lightweight track system using the computer-aided method NTVPM. J Terramechanics 2015; 61: 23–32.

16.

Richmond

Shoop

Blaisdell

. Cold regions mobility models. Report no. 95-1, January 1995. Hanover, NH: Army Corps of Engineers Cold Regions Research and Engineering Laboratory.

17.

Rowland

. Tracked vehicle ground pressure and its effect on soft ground performance. In: Proceedings of the 4th international conference of the international society for terrain-vehicle systems, Stockholm, April 24–28 1972, pp.353–384.

18.

Rowland

. A review of vehicle design for soft ground operation. In: Proceedings of the 5th international conference of the international society for terrain-vehicle systems, Detroit, MI, June 2–6 1975, pp.179–219.

19.

British Ministry of Defence, Defence Standard 23-6. Technology guidance for military logistics vehicles, issue 4, 1 November 2005.

20.

Wong

. On the role of mean maximum pressure as an indicator of cross-country mobility of tracked vehicles. J Terramechanics 1994; 31: 197–213.

21.

Wong

. Data processing methodology in the characterization of the mechanical properties of terrain. J Terramechanics 1980; 17: 13–41.