A novel measurement method based on the double ball bar (DBB) is proposed to improve the positioning accuracy of industrial robots. The kinematic model is established based on the Modified Denavit-Hartenberg (MD-H) method. A measurement posture of the tool center point (TCP) tilted 30° is proposed to ensure that all joints can fully move, and a spherical spiral trajectory is adopted to increase the stroke in the Z direction. This paper combines the error sensitivity analysis with the identification to reduce the dimensionality of parameter identification. A sub-space identification based on the Levenberg-Marquardt algorithm is proposed, and the corresponding error model is established. The experiments are completed on the ABB IRB120 industrial robot. The experiment demonstrated that the sub-space identification method has better identification accuracy, and the full movement of all joints is conducive to improving the calibration effect. Compared with the conventional calibration method based on the DBB, the calibration effect of the proposed method is improved by 22.82%.
MaLBazzoliPSammonsPM, et al. Modeling and calibration of high-order joint-dependent kinematic errors for industrial robots. Robot Comput Integr Manuf2018; 50: 153–167.
4.
JiangZXHuangMTangXQ, et al. Observability index optimization of robot calibration based on multiple identification spaces. Auton Robot2020; 44: 1029–1046.
5.
KhalilWKleinfingerJ. A new geometric notation for open and closed-loop robots. In: Proceedings. 1986 IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation, San Francisco, USA, 7–10 April 1986, pp. 1174–1179. New York: IEEE.
6.
HayatiSMirmiraniM.Improving the absolute positioning accuracy of robot manipulators. J Robotic Syst1985; 2: 397–413.
7.
ChoYDoHMCheongJ.Screw based kinematic calibration method for robot manipulators with joint compliance using circular point analysis. Robot Comput Integr Manuf2019; 60: 63–76.
8.
AbderrahimMWhittakerAR.Kinematic model identification of industrial manipulators. Robot Comput Integr Manuf2000; 16: 1–8.
9.
ZhuangHRothZSHamanoF.A complete and parametrically continuous kinematic model for robot manipulators. IEEE Trans Robot Autom1992; 8: 451–463.
10.
GaoGBSunGQNaJ, et al. Structural parameter identification for 6 DOF industrial robots. Mech Syst Signal Proc2018; 113: 145–155.
11.
KangZWangLSunAB, et al. Two-step calibration of 6-DOF industrial robots by grouping kinematic parameters based on distance constraints. Measurement2024; 235: 114906.
12.
LuoZHXiaoJLLiuSJ, et al. A dynamic parameter identification method for the 5-DOF hybrid robot based on sensitivity analysis. Ind Robot2024; 51: 340–357.
13.
WuJHZhangDQLiuJ, et al. A moment approach to positioning accuracy reliability analysis for industrial robots. IEEE Trans Reliab2019; 69: 1–16.
14.
JiangZXHuangMTangXQ, et al. A new calibration method for joint-dependent geometric errors of industrial robot based on multiple identification spaces. Robot Comput Integr Manuf2021; 71: 102175.
15.
LuoXZhangYJZhangL.Study of error compensations and sensitivity analysis for 6-Dof serial robot. Eng Comput2021; 38: 1851–1868.
16.
LuoGYZouLWangZ, et al. A novel kinematic parameters calibration method for industrial robot based on Levenberg-Marquardt and differential evolution hybrid algorithm. Robot Comput Integr Manuf2021; 71: 102165.
17.
CaoSMChengQLGuoYJ, et al. Pose error compensation based on joint space division for 6-DOF robot manipulators. Precis Eng2022; 74: 195–204.
18.
HeJHGuLFYangGL, et al. A local POE-based self-calibration method using position and distance constraints for collaborative robots. Robot Comput Integr Manuf2024; 86: 102685.
19.
GarciaLBielkeUNeumannC, et al. Theo. Online position correction approach of an industrial robot by using a new photogrammetric measurement system. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part B J Eng Manuf2023; 237: 2119–2129.
20.
QiaoYChenYPChenB, et al. A novel calibration method for multi-robots system utilizing calibration model without nominal kinematic parameters. Precis Eng2017; 50: 211–221.
21.
IbarakiSUsuiR.A novel error mapping of bi-directional angular positioning deviation of rotary axes in a SCARA-type robot by “open-loop” tracking interferometer measurement. Precis Eng2022; 74: 60–68.
22.
NubiolaABonevIA.Absolute robot calibration with a single telescoping ballbar. Precis Eng2014; 38: 472–480.
23.
SlamaniMJoubairABonevIA.A comparative evaluation of three industrial robots using three reference measuring techniques. Ind Robot2015; 42: 572–585.
24.
YangPGuoZGKongYB.Plane kinematic calibration method for industrial robot based on dynamic measurement of double ball bar. Precis Eng2020; 62: 265–272.
25.
KuricITlachVSágaM, et al. Industrial robot positioning performance measured on inclined and parallel planes by Double Ballbar. Appl Sci-Basel2021; 11: 1777.
26.
ChenGLiTChuM, et al. Review on kinematics calibration technology of serial robots. Int J Precis Eng Manuf2014; 15: 1759–1774.
27.
WuZMGuoPZhangY, et al. Kinematic calibration for industrial robot using a telescoping ballbar. Int J Intell Robot2020; 12595: 285–295.
28.
LevenbergK.A method for the solution of certain non-linear problems in least squares. Q Appl Math1944; 2: 164–168.
29.
AntonelliGChiaveriniSFuscoG.A calibration method for odometry of mobile robots based on the least-squares technique: theory and experimental validation. IEEE Trans Robot2005; 21: 994–1004.
30.
MarquardtD.An algorithm for least-squares estimation of nonlinear parameters. SIAM J Appl Math1963; 11: 431–441.
31.
LiZBLiSLuoX.Efficient industrial robot calibration via a novel unscented Kalman filter-incorporated variable step-size Levenberg–Marquardt algorithm. IEEE Trans Instrum Meas2023; 72: 2510012.
32.
DengXGeLZLiRF, et al. Research on the kinematic parameter calibration method of industrial robot based on LM and PF algorithm. In: 2020 Chinese Control and Decision Conference (CCDC), Hefei, China, 23–25 May 2020, pp. 2198–2203. New York: IEEE.
33.
LiuJLuoQ. Modeling and simulation of robotic arm in Matlab for industrial applications. In: 2019 11th International Conference on Intelligent Human-Machine Systems and Cybernetics (IHMSC), Hangzhou, China, 24–25 August 2019, pp. 346–349. New York: IEEE.
34.
WangHJiangXG. Geometric errors identification and correction based on the unit dual quaternion differential motion linearization. Measurement2025; 248: 116916.
35.
DrielsMPathreU.Robot calibration using an automatic theodolite. Int J Adv Manuf Technol1994; 9: 114–125.
36.
ZhangYZZhuWSRosendoA.QR code-based self-calibration for a fault-tolerant industrial robot arm. IEEE Access2019; 7: 773349–73356.
