This article offers historical context for psychiatrist Aaron T. Beck's creation of the Beck Depression Inventory (BDI), a widely celebrated patient-rated depression scale. Beck built the BDI in the late 1950s as part of a large psychoanalytic depression research project. Although he later broke with psychoanalysis and rose to fame as father of cognitive behavior therapy (CBT), the meaning he attributed to lowered BDI scores post-CBT bore the stamp of his psychoanalytic mentor, Leon J. Saul, a pioneer in the quantitative study of psychoanalysis. Saul endowed lowered scores on his own rating scales with a political story of recovery, a tale of hostile forces tamed, reason restored, democracy safeguarded. Rather than abandon Saul's political recovery story, Beck interwove it into a medical recovery story (a return to pre-morbid functioning) commensurate with the era of randomized controlled trials and the DSM-III. This persistence of a Saulian recovery story in Beck's interpretive framework for lowered BDI scores post-CBT suggests that further historical inquiry is warranted into the quantitative strains of American psychoanalysis, and that Beck's quantitative revolution with CBT may not have been as clear a break with psychoanalysis as has been assumed.
AlexanderF. (1934) ‘The Influence of Psychologic Factors Upon Gastro-intestinal Disturbances: A Symposium: I. General Principles, Objectives, and Preliminary Results’, Psychoanalytic Quarterly3(4): 501–39.
2.
AlexanderF. (1951[1942]) Our Age of Unreason: A Study of the Irrational Forces in Social Life. Philadelphia, PA: J. B. Lippincott.
3.
AlexanderF.SaulL. J. (1940) ‘Respiration and Personality—A Preliminary Report: Part 1. Description of the Curves’, Psychosomatic Medicine2(2): 110–18.
4.
AlexanderF.WilsonG. W. (1935) ‘Quantitative Dream Studies: A Methodological Attempt at a Quantitative Evaluation of Psychoanalytic Material’, Psychoanalytic Quarterly4(3): 371–407.
5.
BarclayD. (1960, 21 February) ‘Rearing a Child of Good Will’, New York Times Magazine, Section SM, p. 52.
6.
BechP. (2006) ‘Rating Scales in Depression: Limitations and Pitfalls’, Dialogues in Clinical Neuroscience8(2): 207–15.
7.
BechP. (2009) ‘Fifty Years With the Hamilton Scales for Anxiety and Depression’, Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics78: 202–11.
8.
BeckA. T. (1961) ‘A Systematic Investigation of Depression’, Comprehensive Psychiatry2(3):163–70.
9.
BeckA. T. (1962) ‘Reliability of Psychiatric Diagnoses: 1. A Critique of Systematic Studies’, American Journal of Psychiatry119(3): 210–16.
10.
BeckA. T. (1963) ‘Thinking and Depression: I. Idiosyncratic Content and Cognitive Distortions’, Archives of General Psychiatry9(4): 324–33.
11.
BeckA. T. (1964) ‘Thinking and Depression: II. Theory and Therapy’, Archives of General Psychiatry10(6): 561–71.
12.
BeckA. T. (1967) Depression: Clinical, Experimental and Theoretical Aspects. New York, NY: Hoeber.
13.
BeckA. T. (1976) Cognitive Therapy and the Emotional Disorders. New York, NY: International Universities Press.
14.
BeckA. T. (1991) ‘Cognitive Therapy: A 30-Year Retrospective’, American Psychologist (46)4: 368–75.
15.
BeckA. T. (1999) Prisoners of Hate: The Cognitive Basis of Anger, Hostility, and Violence. New York, NY: HarperCollins.
16.
BeckA. T. (2005) ‘Buddhism and Cognitive Therapy’, Cognitive Therapy Today10: 1–4.
17.
BeckA. T.BeckR. W. (1972) ‘Screening Depressed Patients in Family Practice: A Rapid Technic’, Postgraduate Medicine52(6): 81–5.
18.
BeckA. T.GuthrieT. (1956) ‘Psychological Significance of Visual Auras: Study of Three Cases With Brain Damage and Seizures’, Psychosomatic Medicine (18)2: 133–42.
19.
BeckA. T.HurvichM. S. (1959) ‘Psychological Correlates of Depression: 1. Frequency of “Masochistic” Dream Content in a Private Practice Sample’, Psychosomatic Medicine21(1): 50–5.
20.
BeckA. T.RushA. J.ShawB.EmeryG. (1979) Cognitive Therapy of Depression. New York, NY: Guilford.
21.
BeckA. T.SethiBrij B.TuthillR. W. (1963) ‘Childhood Bereavement and Adult Depression’, Archives of General Psychiatry9(3): 295–302.
22.
BeckA. T.ValinS. (1953) ‘Psychotic Depressive Reactions in Soldiers Who Accidentally Killed Their Buddies’, American Journal of Psychiatry110(5): 347–53.
23.
BeckA. T.WardC. H. (1961) ‘Dreams of Depressed Patients: Characteristic Themes in Manifest Content’, Archives of General Psychiatry5(5): 462–7.
24.
BeckA. T.WardC. H.MendelsonM.MockJ.ErbaughJ. (1961) ‘An Inventory for Measuring Depression’, Archives of General Psychiatry (4)6: 561–71.
25.
BeckA. T.WardC. H.MendelsonM.MockJ.ErbaughJ. (1962) ‘Reliability of Psychiatric Diagnoses: 2. A Study of Consistency of Clinical Judgments and Ratings’, American Journal of Psychiatry119(4): 351–7.
26.
BeckA. T.WeissmanA.LesterD.TrexlerL. (1974) ‘The Measurement of Pessimism: The Hopelessness Scale’, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology42(6): 861–5.
27.
BlytheH. (2025) ‘Mental Recovery, Citizenship Roles, and the Mental After-Care Association, 1879–1928’, History of the Human Sciences38(5): 22–48.
28.
BollingL. (1941) ‘Community in Clover’, Common Ground2(1): 23–7.
29.
BrosinH. W. (1955) ‘On Discovery and Experiment in Psychiatry’, American Journal of Psychiatry111(8): 561–75.
30.
BrownT. M. (1987) ‘Alan Gregg and the Rockefeller Foundation’s Support of Franz Alexander’s Psychosomatic Research’, Bulletin of the History of Medicine61(2): 155–82.
BuchananR. (1994) ‘The Development of the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory’, Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences30(2): 148–61.
33.
BuchananR. (2003) ‘Legislative Warriors: American Psychiatrists, Psychologists, and Competing Claims Over Psychotherapy in the 1950s’, Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences39(3): 225–49.
34.
CannonW. B. (1967[1932]) The Wisdom of the Body. New York, NY: W. W. Norton.
35.
ClarkM. (1973, 8 January) ‘Coping With Depression’, Newsweek, p. 53.
36.
CohenL.MalamudR.ThaleT. (1944) ‘Measurement of Chronic Psychotic Over-Activity by the Norwich Rating Scale’, Journal of General Psychology30: 65–74.
37.
CusinC.YangH.YeungAFavaM. (2010) ‘Rating Scales for Depression’, in BaerL.BlaisM. A. (eds) Handbook of Clinical Rating Scales and Assessments in Psychiatry and Mental Health. Totowa, NJ: Humana Press, pp. 7–35.
38.
DavisH. (1965) ‘Alexander Forbes, 1882–1965’, Journal of Neurophysiology28(5): 986–8.
39.
DavisH.SaulL. J. (1931) ‘Action Currents in the Auditory Tracts of the Midbrain of the Cat’, Science74: 205–6.
40.
DavisD. M.WarrenS. L. (1929) ‘A New Combined Table for Cystoscopy, Roentgenography and Fluoroscopy’, Journal of Urology22(3): 339–46.
41.
DeckerH. S. (2013) The Making of DSM-III®: A Diagnostic Manual's Conquest of American Psychiatry. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
42.
DrorO. E. (1999) ‘The Affect of Experiment: The Turn to Emotions in Anglo-American Physiology, 1900–1940’, Isis90(2): 205–37.
43.
DunbarH. F. (1935) Emotions and Bodily Changes: A Survey of Literature on Psychosomatic Interrelationships 1910–1933. New York, NY: Columbia University Press.
44.
FriedmanA. S.CowitzB.CohenH. W.GranickS. (1963) ‘Syndromes and Themes of Psychotic Depression: A Factory Analysis’, Archives of General Psychiatry9: 102–7.
45.
GoldhirshM. I. (1961) ‘Manifest Content of Dreams of Convicted Sex Offenders’, Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology63(3): 643–5.
46.
GreeneJ. A.PodolskyS. H. (2012) ‘Reform, Regulation, and Pharmaceuticals—the Kefauver–Harris Amendments at 50’, New England Journal of Medicine367(16): 1481–3.
47.
GriefM. (2015) The Age of the Crisis of Man: Thought and Fiction in America, 1933–1973. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
48.
GrinkerR. R.Sr. (1969) ‘Psychoanalysis and the Study of Autonomic Behavior’, in RogowA. A. (ed.) Politics, Personality and Social Sciences in the Twentieth Century: Essays in Honor of Harold D. Lasswell. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press, pp. 107–22.
49.
GrinkerR. R.MillerJ.SabshinM.NunnR.NunnallyJ. C. (1961) The Phenomena of Depression. New York, NY: Hoeber.
50.
HamburgD. A. (1961) ‘Recent Trends in Psychiatric Research Training’, Archives of General Psychiatry4(3): 215–24.
51.
HamiltonM. (1960) ‘A Rating Scale for Depression’, Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery, and Psychiatry23(1): 56–62.
52.
HeyckH. (2012) ‘Producing Reason’, in SoloveyM.CravensH. (eds) Cold War Social Science: Knowledge Production, Liberal Democracy, and Human Nature. New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 99–116.
53.
HoweD. W. (2009) Making the American Self: Jonathan Edwards to Abraham Lincoln. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
54.
KochU. (2019) ‘The Uses of Trauma in Experiment: Traumatic Stress and the History of Experimental Neurosis, c. 1925–1975’, Science in Context32(3): 327–51.
55.
KuhnT. S. (1962) The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
56.
LambS. (2010) Pathologist of the Mind: Adolf Meyer, Psychobiology and the Phipps Psychiatric Clinic at the Johns Hopkins Hospital, 1908–1917. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
57.
LasswellH. D. (1938a) ‘A Provisional Classification of Symbol Data’, Psychiatry1(2): 197–204.
58.
LasswellH. D. (1938b) ‘What Psychiatrists and Political Scientists Can Learn From One Another’, Psychiatry1(1): 33–9.
59.
LasswellH. D. (1960[1930]) Psychopathology and Politics. New York, NY: Viking Press.
60.
LemovR. (2011) ‘X-rays of Inner Worlds: The Mid-Twentieth-Century American Projective Test Movement’, Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences47(3): 251–78.
61.
LeysR. (1991) ‘Types of One: Adolf Meyer’s Life Chart and the Representation of Individuality’, Representations34: 1–28.
62.
LiebermanJ. A. (2015) Shrinks: The Untold Story of Psychiatry. New York, NY: Little, Brown.
63.
LitchfieldE. H. (1941) Voting Behavior in a Metropolitan Area. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press.
64.
LoebA.BeckA. T.DiggoryJ. (1971) ‘Differential Effects of Success and Failure on Depressed and Nondepressed Patients’, Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease152(2): 106–14.
65.
LoebA.FeshbachS.BeckA. T.WolfA. (1964) ‘Some Effects of Reward Upon the Social Perception and Motivation of Psychiatric Patients Varying in Depression’, Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology68(6): 609–16.
66.
LorrM. (1954) ‘Rating Scales and Check Lists for the Evaluation of Psychopathology’, Psychological Bulletin51(2): 119–27.
67.
LuceroR.MeyerR. (1951) ‘A Behavior Rating Scale Suitable for Use in Mental Hospitals’, Journal of Clinical Psychology7: 250–4.
68.
LyerlyS. B.AbbottP. S. (1966) Handbook of Psychiatric Rating Scales (1950–1964). Bethesda, MD: National Institute of Mental Health.
69.
MarkowitzN. D. (1970) The Rise and Fall of the People’s Century: Henry Agard Wallace and American Liberalism, 1941–1948. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press.
70.
MetcalfeM.GoldmanE. (1965) ‘Validation of an Inventory for Measuring Depression’, British Journal of Psychiatry111: 240–2.
71.
MizrachiN. (2001) ‘From Causation to Correlation: The Story of Psychosomatic Medicine 1939–1979’, Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry25(3): 317–43.
72.
MizrachiN. (2002) ‘Epistemology and Legitimacy in the Production of Anorexia Nervosa in the Journal Psychosomatic Medicine 1939–1979’, Sociology of Health & Illness24(4): 462–90.
73.
OverallJ. E.HollisterL. E.PokornyA. D.CaseyJ. F.KatzG. (1962) ‘Drug Therapy in Depressions: Controlled Evaluation of Imipramine, Isocarboxazide, Dextroamphetamine-amobarbital, and Placebo’, Clinical Pharmacology & Therapeutics3(1): 16–22.
74.
ParloffM. B.ElkinI. (1992) ‘The NIMH Treatment of Depression Collaborative Research Program’, in FreedheimD. K. (ed.) History of Psychotherapy. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association, pp. 442–9.
75.
PorterT. M. (1996) Trust in Numbers: The Pursuit of Objectivity in Science and Public Life. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
76.
RamsdenE. (2018) ‘A Neurotic Dog’s Life: Experimental Psychiatry and the Conditional Reflex Method in the Work of W. Horsley Gantt’, Isis109(2): 276–301.
77.
RaskinA. (1970) ‘Measuring Change in Psychiatric Patients’, in Statistics in Mental Health Programs: Selected Papers From Annual Meetings of the National Conference on Mental Health Statistics, No. 1. Washington,DC: National Institute of Mental Health, pp. 49–52.
78.
RosnerR. I. (2005) ‘Psychotherapy Research and the National Institute of Mental Health, 1948–1980’, in PickrenW. E.SchneiderS. F. (eds) Psychology and the National Institute of Mental Health. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association, pp. 113–50.
79.
RosnerR. I. (2014) ‘The “Splendid Isolation” of Aaron T. Beck’, Isis105(4): 734–58.
80.
RosnerR. I. (2018) ‘Three Myths and Truths About Beck’s Early Years’, in LeahyR. L. (ed.) Science and Practice in Cognitive Therapy: Foundations, Mechanisms, and Applications. New York, NY: Guilford Press, pp. 13–28.
81.
RosnerR. I. (2020) ‘Manualizing Psychotherapy: Aaron T. Beck and the Origins of Cognitive Therapy of Depression’, in ShamdasaniS.LowenthalD. (eds) Exploring Transcultural Histories of Psychotherapies. London: Routledge, pp. 39–61.
82.
RotzelG. (1971) The School in Rose Valley: A Parent Venture in Education. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
83.
RushA. J.BeckA. T.KovacsM.HollonS. (1977) ‘Comparative Efficacy of Cognitive Therapy and Pharmacotherapy in the Treatment of Depressed Outpatients’, Cognitive Therapy and Research1: 17–37.
84.
SalkindM. R. (1969) ‘Beck Depression Inventory in General Practice’, Journal of the Royal College of General Practitioners (18)88: 267–71.
85.
SaulL. J. (1939) ‘Hostility in Cases of Essential Hypertension’, Psychosomatic Medicine1(1): 153–61.
86.
SaulL. J. (1943) ‘Some Aspects of Psychiatry in the Training Station’, American Journal of Psychiatry100(1): 74–9.
87.
SaulL. J. (1945) ‘Psychological Factors in Combat Fatigue: With Special Reference to Hostility and the Nightmares’, Psychosomatic Medicine7(5): 257–72.
88.
SaulL. J. (1947) Emotional Maturity. Philadelphia, PA: J. B. Lippincott.
89.
SaulL. (1948, November) ‘What Kind of Adult Will Your Child Be?’, Woman's Home Companion 75: 112–14.
90.
SaulL. (1949, 2 April) ‘Unstable Children Called Major Problem for Nation’, Philadelphia Inquirer, p. 13.
91.
SaulL. J. (1951) Bases of Human Behavior: A Biologic Approach to Psychiatry. Philadelphia, PA: J. B. Lippincott.
92.
SaulL. J. (1956) The Hostile Mind: The Sources and Consequences of Rage and Hate. New York, NY: Random House.
93.
SaulL. J. (1958) Technic and Practice of Psychoanalysis. Philadelphia, PA: J. B. Lippincott.
94.
SaulL. J. (1964, 27 October) ‘Psychiatrist Emphasizes Synthesis’, Swarthmore College Phoenix, p. 3.
95.
SaulL. J. (1977) The Childhood Emotional Pattern and Corey Jones: A Psychoanalytical Biography. New York, NY: Van Nostrand Reinhold.
96.
SaulL. J.BeckA. T. (1961) ‘Psychodynamics of Male Homosexuality’, International Journal of Psychoanalysis42: 43–8.
97.
SaulL. J.DavisH. (1933) ‘Action Currents in the Central Nervous System, 1. Action Currents of the Auditory Tracts’, Archives of Neurology & Psychiatry29(2): 255–9.
98.
SaulL. J.DavisH.DavisP. A. (1949) ‘Psychologic Correlations With the Electroencephalogram’, Psychosomatic Medicine11(6): 361–76.
99.
SaulL. J.RomeH.LeuserE. (1946) ‘Desensitization of Combat Fatigue Patients’, American Journal of Psychiatry102(4): 476–8.
100.
SaulL. J.SheppardE. (1956) ‘An Attempt to Quantify Emotional Forces Using Manifest Dreams: A Preliminary Study’, Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association4(3): 486–502.
101.
SaulL.SheppardE.SelbyD.LhamonW.SachsD.MasterR. (1954) ‘The Quantification of Hostility in Dreams With Reference to Essential Hypertension’, Science119:382–3.
102.
SchaferR. (1954) Psychoanalytic Interpretation in Rorschach Testing: Theory and Application. New York, NY: Grune & Stratton.
103.
SchaferR. (1959[1948]) The Clinical Application of Psychological Tests: Diagnostic Summaries and Case Studies. New York, NY: International Universities Press.
104.
SchillingR.CasperS. T. (2015) ‘Of Psychometric Means: Starke R. Hathaway and the Popularization of the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory’, Science in Context28(1): 77–98.
105.
SchmidtH.FondaC. (1956) ‘The Reliability of Psychiatric Diagnosis: A New Look’, Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology52(2): 262–7.
106.
SchmittF. O. (1994) ‘Hallowell Davis (31 August 1896–22 August, 1992)’, Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society138(3): 414–19.
107.
SchwabJ.BialowM.ClemmonsR.MartinPHolzerC. (1967) ‘The Beck Depression Inventory With Medical Inpatients’, Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica43(3): 255–66.
108.
SeidelmanR. (2015) Disenchanted Realists: Political Science and the American Crisis. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press.
109.
SpitzerR. L.WilliamsJ. B. W.GibbonM.FirstM. B. (1992) ‘The Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-III-R (SCID): I: History, Rationale, and Description’, Archives of General Psychiatry49(8): 624–9.
110.
SteinM. (1986) ‘A Reconsideration of Specificity in Psychosomatic Medicine: From Olfaction to the Lymphocyte’, Psychosomatic Medicine48(1): 3–22.
111.
StunkardA. J. (1975) ‘Presidential Address—1974: From Explanation to Action in Psychosomatic Medicine: The Case of Obesity’, Psychosomatic Medicine37(3): 195–236.
112.
TalbertR.Jr. (1987) FDR’s Utopian: Arthur Morgan of the TVA. Jackson, MS: University Press of Mississippi.
113.
WardC. H.BeckA. T.MendelsonM.MockJ.ErbaughJ. (1962) ‘The Psychiatric Nomenclature: Reasons for Diagnostic Disagreement’, Archives of General Psychiatry7(3):198–205.
114.
WardC. H.BeckA. T.RascoeE. (1961) ‘Typical Dreams: Incidence Among Psychiatric Patients’, Archives of General Psychiatry5(6): 606–15.
115.
WarrenS. L. (1930) ‘A Roentgenologic Study of the Breast’, American Journal of Roentgenology and Radium Therapy24(2): 113–24.
116.
WeckowiczT. E.MuirW.CropleyA. J. (1967) ‘A Factor Analysis of the Beck Inventory of Depression’, Journal of Consulting Psychology31(1): 23–8.
117.
WeissmanA. (1976) ‘The Dysfunctional Attitude Scale: An Inventory Designed to Measure the Relationship Between Cognitive Distortions and Emotional Disorders’ [Unpublished manuscript], University of Pennsylvania.
118.
WhiteB. V. (1984) Stanley Cobb: A Builder of the Modern Neurosciences. Boston, MA: Francis A. Countway Library of Medicine.
119.
WittenbornJ. R. (1955) The Wittenborn Psychiatric Rating Scale. New York, NY: Psychological Corporation.
120.
WolffH. G. (1946) ‘New York Academy of Medicine, Section of Neurology and Psychiatry, and the New York Neurological Institute’, Archives of Neurology & Psychiatry55(1): 68–74.
121.
WorboysM. (2012) ‘The Hamilton Rating Scale for Depression: The Making of a “Gold Standard” and the Unmaking of a Chronic Illness, 1960–1980’, Chronic Illness9(3): 202–19.
