The Quasi Market in Health Care: Pre-requisites,Problems and Prospects

Abstract

This paper evaluates the operation of the quasi market in health care after the implementation of the reforms set out in the White Paper ‘Working for Patients’ (DoH, 1989a), which replaced the largely state run monopoly provision of health and social services by a state financed internal market. Lying behind the reforms was the assumption that the move away from bureaucratic, to market oriented, systems in the allocation of health and social care would lead to improvements in service efficiency, and responsiveness. This was to be achieved by separating state authorities' purchasing and providing roles, and the introduction of contracts. Using the framework developed by Le Grand and Bartlett (1993), this paper assesses the extent to which the internal market for acute services in Northern Ireland is meeting the expected outcome criteria of efficiency, responsiveness, choice, quality and equity. A survey of purchasers and providers of acute hospital services was conducted, followed by in-depth interviews with the stakeholders in the contracting process. Analysis of the quantitative data, and preliminary consideration of the qualitative data, would indicate that the potential benefits are yet to be fully realised.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Appelby, J. , et al. (1990), ‘The Use of Markets in the Health Service: The NHS Reforms and Managed Competition’, Public Money and Management, Vol 10, No. 4, pp.27-33.

Bartlett, W. (1991), ‘Quasi markets and Contracts: A Markets and Hierarchies Perspective on NHS Reform’, Public Money and Management, Vol 11, No.3, pp.53-61.

Boyett, I. , and Finlay, D. (1995), ‘The Quasi-Market, the Entrepreneur and the Effectiveness of the NHS Business Manager’, Public Administration, Vol. 73, No. 3, Autumn, pp.393-411.

Department of Health, (1989a), Working for Patients, (London: HMSO).

Department of Health, (1989b), Caring for People, (London: HMSO).

Kay, N.M. (1993), ‘Markets, False Hierarchies and the Role of Asset Specificity’, in Pitelis, C. (ed), Transaction Costs, Markets and Hierarchies, (Oxford: Basil Blackwell Publishers).

Le Grand, J. , and Bartlett, W. (1993), ‘The Theory of Quasi Markets ’ in Le Grand J. and Bartlett W. (eds), Quasi-Markets and Social Policy, (London: Macmillan).

Maynard, A. (1993), ‘Competition in the UK National Health Service: Mission Impossible?’, Health Policy, Vol. 23, pp. 193-204.

Propper, C. (1995), ‘Regulatory Reform of the NHS Internal Market’, Health Economics, Vol. 4, pp.77-83.

10.

Ranade, W. (1995), ‘The Theory and Practice of Managed Competition in the National Health Service’, Public Administration, Vol. 73, No. 2, Summer, pp.241-262.

11.

Robsinson, R. , and Le Grand, J. (1994) (eds), Evaluating the NHS Reforns, (London: Kings Fund Institute).

12.

Scrivens, E. , and Henneh, A. (1989), ‘Working for Patients: making the internal market effective’ Public Money and Management, Vol. 9, No. 4, pp.53-57.