Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

The concept of a tier is central to the structure of local government. However there has been no clear definition of the concept, and the term has been applied in vague and inconsistent ways. Furthermore, no procedure exists for identifying the number of tiers in a local government system. In order to resolve these problems a pure model of a hierarchical local government tier structure is outlined, and the concepts of parallel, partial and comprehensive tiers are introduced and defined. This framework is then applied to the British debate about unitary authorities. It is shown that these units are not single-tier author ities but form part of a vertically fragmented structure. In consequence many of the arguments used in favour of the current structural changes to British local government are not valid because they assume that the reforms will create single-tier units.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Barlow, I.M. , (1991), Metropolitan Government, ( London, Routledge).

Boyne, G.A. , (1992), 'Local Government Structure and Performance: Lessons from America?', Public Administration, Vol 70, No.3, pp.333-357.

Boyne, G.A. , Jordan, J. , and McVicar, M. , (1995), Local Government Reform: A Review of the Process in Scotland and Wales, (London, Local Government Communications/ Joseph Rowntree Foundation).

Brand, J. , (1974), Local Government Reform in England, ( London, Croom Helm).

Chisholm, M. , (1995), 'Some Lessons from the Review of Local Government in England', Regional Studies, Vol,29. No.6., pp.563-569.

Cochrane, A. , (1993), Whatever Happened to Local Government, (Buckingham, Open University Press).

Cole, M.S. and Boyne, G.A. , (1995), 'So You Think You Know What Local Government Is? ', Local Government Studies, Vol.21, No.2., pp191-202.

Davis, J. , (1988), Reforming London, (Oxford, Clarendon Press).

Department of the Environment , (1991), Local Government Review: The Structure of Local Government: A Consultation Paper, (London, Department of the Environment).

10.

Department of the Environment (1983), Streamlining the Cities, (London, Department of the Environment).

11.

Gustafsson, A. , (1991), 'The Changing Local Government and Politics of Sweden', in Batley, R and Stoker, G , (eds), Local Government in Europe , (London, Macmillan), chapter 12.

12.

Hayton, K. , (1993), 'Two into One Won't Go', Local Government Policy-Making, Vol.19, No.4., pp.7-18.

13.

Henney, A. (1984), Inside Local Government, ( London, Sinclair-Browne).

14.

Keith-Lucas, B. , (1980), The Unreformed Local Government System, (London, Croom Helm).

15.

Leach, S. , (1995), 'The Strange Case of the Local Government Review' , in Stewart, J. and Stoker, G. , (ed)., Local Government in the 1990s, chapter 4, (London, Macmillan ).

16.

Leach, S. And Game, C. , (1991), 'English Metropolitan Government Since Abolition: An Evaluation of the English Metropolitan County Councils', Public Administration, Vol.69, No.2, pp. 141-170.

17.

Leach, S. , et.al, (1991), After Abolition, (Birmingham , Inlogov).

18.

Lipman, V.D. (1949), Local Government Areas 1834-1945, ( Oxford, Blackwell).

19.

Lyons, W.E. , D. Lowery and R. De Hoog , (1992), The Politics of Disatisfaction, ( London, Sharpe).

20.

Norton, A. , (1994), International Handbook of Local and Regional Government , (Aldershot: Edward Elgar).

21.

Ostrom, E. , (1972), 'Metropolitan Reform: Propositions Derived From Two Traditions', Social Science Quarterly, Vol.53., pp.474-93:

22.

Pycroft, C. , (1995), 'Restructuring Local Government: The Banham Commission's Failed Historic Enterprise', Public Policy and Administration , Vol.10., No.1., pp.49-62.

23.

Redcliffe-Maud Report (1969), Report of the Royal Commission on Local Government in England 1966-69, (Chairman Lord Redcliffe-Maud), Vol 1, Cmnd 4040 (London, HMSO).

24.

Richards, P.G. , (1975), The Reformed Local Government System, 2nd edn, (London. Allen and Unwin).

25.

Smellie, K.B. , (1968), A History of Local Government. 4th edn, (London, Allen and Unwin ).

26.

Stanyer, J. , (1976), Understanding Local Government, ( Oxford, Martin Robertson)

27.

Stoker, G. , (1988), The Politics of Local Government, ( London, Macmillan).

28.

Warren, J.J. , (1953), The English Local Government System, 3rd edn, (London, Pitman ).

29.

Welsh Office , (1991), The Structure of Local Government in Wales: A Consultation Paper, (Cardiff , Welsh Office).

Evaluating the Structure of Local Government: the importance of tiers

Abstract

Get full access to this article

References