Recent years have witnessed a considerable extension in the defined activities covered by the CCT regime in UK local government. While the 1980s saw CCT applied to mainly manual services (such as refuse collection), the 1990s have witnessed the spread of compulsory competition into white-collar professions and services such as Housing Management. Recent accounts of CCT have tended to assess its overall impact within a framework that is mainly informed by the emphasis on how the management of local public services will benefit from the contemporary introduction of Competition and Quasi-Markets. While CCT has clearly had some important managerial implications, this article argues that its more important political impact has been to intensify central control and regulation in order to restructure the local welfare state. In this sense, the vocabulary of the market has served to camouflage a process of centralisation which is characteristic both of New Right ideology and more traditional concerns within the UK political system.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Ashbumer, L., Ferlie, E. & Fitzgerald, L. (1994), 'Quasi-Markets and the development of competition in the NHS: An initial analysis of their impact'Paper presented to 24th PAC conference, University of York, September 1994.
2.
Ascher,K. (1987), The Politics of Privatisation, ( London, Macmillan).
3.
Bogason, P. (1991), 'Danish Local Government - Towards an Efficient Welfare State' in Hesse, J J (ed), Local Government and Urban Affairs in International Perspective.
4.
Bramah, M. (1994), 'Competition and the threat to democracy' in Municipal Journal, 18-24th February p.19
5.
Carnaghan, R. & Bracewell-Milnes, B. (1993), Testing the Market: CCT for Government Services in the UK and Abroad, (IEA Research Monograph No 49, London).
6.
Clarke, M. & Stewart, J. (1991), Choices for Local Government, ( London, Longman).
7.
Centre For Local Economic Strategies (1990), Seconds Out, Round Two: The First Round of CCT. CLES Research Studies No 6.
8.
Cochrane, A. (1993a), 'Local Government' in Maidment, R and Thompson, G (eds), Managing The United Kingdom. (London, Sage).
9.
Cochrane, A. (1993b), Whatever Happened To Local Government. (Buckingham, Open University Press).
10.
Cockburn, C. (1977), The Local State. (London, Pluto Press).
11.
Dearlove, J. (1979), The Reorganisation of British Local Government . (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press).
12.
Department of Environment (1994), CCT and local government in England: Annual report for 1993. (London, HMSO).
13.
Dunleavy, P. (1986), 'Explaining the privatisation boom: public choice v radical explanations' in Public Administration Vol 64 No 1 pp.13-34.
14.
Dobson, N. (1993), 'Tendering law's double whammy' in Municipal Journal 21-27th May pp.24-25.
15.
Fenwick,J Snape, S. Ranade, W & Harrop K., (1994), 'Competition without Compulsion' in Local Government Management Vol 1 no 9 pp. 14-15.
16.
Fenwick, J., Shaw, K. & Foreman, A. (1993), CCT in Local Government: The Experiences of Local Authorities in the North of England. (University of Northumbria Research Papers).
17.
Fenwick, J., Shaw, K. & Foreman, A. (1994), 'Managing Competition in UK Local Government' in International Journal of Public Sector Management. Vol 7 No 6.
18.
Foster, D. (1993), 'Industrial Relations in Local Government: The Impact of Privatisation' in Political Quarterly Vol 64 No 1.
19.
Goldsmith,M. (1986), 'The status of local government' in Goldsmith, M (ed), Essays on the Future of Local Government. (University of Salford).
20.
Greenwood, R. (1983), 'Pressure from Whitehall' in Rose, R and Page, E (eds), Fiscal Stress in Cities, (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press).
21.
Hambleton, R. (1990), 'Consumerism, Decentralisation and Local Democracy' in Public Administration Vol 66 Summer, pp.125-147.
22.
King, D. (1993), 'Government Beyond Whitehall' in Dunleavy, P et al (eds), Developments in British Politics 4. (London, Macmillan).
23.
Le Grande, J and Bartlet, W (eds) (1993), Quasi-Markets and Social Policy . (London, Macmillan).
24.
Local Government Information Unit (1994), CCT on the Record: A Review of the experiences of CCT under the Local Government Act 1988. (Sheffield, Centre For Public Services/LGIU).
25.
Local Government Management Board (1994), CCT Information Services Survey Report No 9. (LGMB).
26.
Maidment, R and Thompson, G (eds), (1993), Managing the United Kingdom . (London, Sage.)
27.
McGuirk, T. (1992), The Competitive Edge: A Study of the early trends in CCT. (London, Institute of Public Finance/CIPFA).
28.
Oecd (1991), Public Management Developments - Updates. (Paris, OECD).
29.
Parker, D. (1990), 'The 1988 Local Govemment Act and CCT' in Urban Studies No 5.
30.
Public Sector Privatisation Research Unit (1992), Disaster for Quality. (PSPRU).
31.
Steering Committee On Local and Regional Authorities (1993), The Role of Competitive Tendering in the Efficient Provision of Local Services. (Strasbourg, Council of Europe Press).
32.
Shaw, K., Fenwick, J. and Foreman, A. (1993), 'Client and Contractor Roles in Local Government: Some observations on managing the split' in Local Government Policy-Making Vol 20 No 2.
33.
Shaw, K., Fenwick, J. and Foreman, A. (1994), 'CCT for Local Government Services: The experiences of local authorities in the North of England' in Public Administration Vol 72 No 2.
34.
Solesbury, W. (1993), 'Reframing Urban Policy' in Policy and Politics Vol 21 No 1 pp.31-38.
35.
Snape, S. (1994), Contracting Out by Dutch Municipalities. (Research Papers, University of Northumbria).
36.
Stewart, J. and Walsh, K. (1992), 'Change in the Management of Public Services' in Public Administration Vol 70 Winter pp.499-518.
37.
Stoker, G. (1990), 'Regulation theory, local government and the transition from Fordism' in King, D and Pierre, J (eds), Challenges to Local Government . (London, Sage). Syzmanski, S. and Wilkins, S. (1993), 'Cheap Rubbish: Competitive Tendering and Contracting Out in Refuse Collection' in Fiscal Studies August.
38.
Walsh, K. (1991), Competitive Tendering for Local Authority Services: Initial experiences. (HMSO, London ).
39.
Walsh, K. and Davies, H. (1993), Competition and Service: The Impact of the Local Government Act 1988. (London, HMSO ).
40.
Utley, M. and Hooper, N. (1993), 'Corporate culture, public bureaucracy and competitive tendering' in International Journal of Public Sector Management Vol 6 No 1.
41.
Williams, T. (1993), 'Local government role-reversal in the new contract culture' in Bennett, R (ed) Local Government in the New Europe. (London, Bellhaven Press).
