Public Choice Theory and the Reform of Local Government in Britain: From Government to Governance

Abstract

This paper describes and analyses current and ongoing reforms of British local government in a public choice framework. These involve a shift from a vertically-integrated corporate institutional form of direct service provision by British local government to one of an enabling function within a horizontally- coordinated network of multi-agency service provision. It considers a fundamental reappraisal of the form of democracy and the way in which it can be secured, a questioning of the behavioural characteristics of local government in relation to the public interest, a reinstatement of the public interest, a reinstatement of the rights and responsibilities of the individual and of the family, a reduction of local government's role in providing the welfare state and a preference for multiple solutions provided by agencies in place of monolithic provision by local government monopolies. Such functional decentralisation is in marked contrast to the political decentralisation in other European countries.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alexander A. (1991) Managing Fragmentation: Democracy, Accountability and the Future of Local Government Inaugural Professorial Lecture Scottish Local Authorities Management Centre Glasgow: University of Strathclyde.

Arrow K.J. (1959) Rational Choice Functions and Orderings Economica Vol 26 pp 121-7.

Arrow K.J. (1963) Social Choice and Individual Values New Haven and London: Yale University Press.

Bailey S.J. (1982) The Political Economy of Local Government Finance The Fraser of Allander Institute Quarterly Economic Commentary Vol 8 No 2 pp 49-64.

Bailey S.J. (1988) Local Government Finance in Britain in Bailey S J and Paddison R (1988b).

Bailey S.J. (1990) Implementing Local Public Choice: The Community Charge in T Younis (ed) Implementation in Public Policy Aldershot : Dartmouth.

Bailey S.J. and Paddison R. (1988a) The Reform of Local Government Finance in Britain London: Routledge.

Bailey S.J. and Paddison R. (1988b) Local Government Finance: International Perspectives London: Routledge.

Black D. (1948) On the Rationale of Group Decision Making Journal of Political Economy Vol 56 pp 23-24.

10.

Bramley G. , Le Grand J and Low W. (1989) How Far is the Poll Tax a Community Charge? The Implications of Service Usage Evidence Policy and Politics Vol 17 No 3 pp 187-205.

11.

Brooke R. (1992) Local Government in the 1990s: 15 Key Questions for Research Local Government and Policy Making Vol 18 No 5 pp 33-40.

12.

Buchanan J.M. and Tulloch G. (1962) The Calculus of Consent: Logical Foundations of Constitutional Democracy Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.

13.

Burgess T. and Travers T. (1980) Ten Billion Pounds: Whitehall's Takeover of the Town Halls London: Grant McIntyre .

14.

Cochrane A. (1991) The Changing State of Local Government: Restructuring for the 1990s Public Administration Vol 69 pp 281-301.

15.

Common R. and Flynn N. (1992) Contracting for Care York: Joseph Rowntree Foundation.

16.

Doe (1992) Public Perceptions of Local Government: Its Finance and Services Department of the Environment London: HMSO.

17.

Downs A. (1957) An Economic Analysis of Democracy New York: Harper and Row.

18.

Hollis G. , Ham G. and Ambler M. (1992) The Future Role and Structure of Local Government Harlow: Longman.

19.

John P. and Block A. (1991) Attitudes to Local Government: A Survey of Electors York: Joseph Rowntree Foundation .

20.

Jones G.W. and Ranson S. (1989) Is There a Need for Participative Democracy? An Exchange Local Government Studies Vol 15 No 3 pp 1-10.

21.

Jones G.W. and Stewart J. (1985) The Case for Local Government (2nd edition) London: Allen Unwin .

22.

Le Grand J. and Winter D. (1987) The Middle Classes and the Defence of the British Welfare State in Goodin R, Le Grand J et al Not Only the Poor. The Middle Classes and the Welfare State London: Allen and Unwin.

23.

Meadowcroft M. (1991) The Politics of Electoral Reform London: Electoral Reform Society.

24.

Newton K. and Karran T. (1985) The Politics of Local Expenditure London: Macmillan.

25.

Olson M. (1965) The Logic of Collective Action: Public Goods and the Theory of Groups Cambridge Massachusetts: Harvard University Press.

26.

Olson M. (1982) The Rise and Decline of Nations: Economic Growth, Stagflation and Social Rigidities New Haven: Yale University Press.

27.

Olson M. (1986) A Theory of the Incentives Facing Political Organisations: Neo Corporatism and the Hegemonic State International Political Science Review Vol 7 No 2 pp 165-189.

28.

Pampel F.C. and Williamson J.B. (1989) Age, Class, Politics and the Welfare State Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

29.

Parkinson M. (1987) Reshaping Local Government Hermitage: Policy Journals .

30.

Rao N. ( 1990) The Changing Role of Local Housing Authorities: An Interim Assessment London: Policy Studies Institute.

31.

Reich R.B. (1987) The Power of Public Ideas New York: Harper Business.

32.

Stewart J. and Stoker G. (1989) The Future of Local Government Basingstoke: Macmillan.

33.

Tiebout C. (1956) A Pure Theory of Local Expenditures Journal of Political Economy Vol 64 pp 416-424.

34.

Thes (1992) Times Higher Education Supplement 31 January pp 1 and 4-5.

35.

Tullock G. (1967) Towards a Mathematics of Politics Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.

36.

Young K. (1988) Local Government in Britain: Rationale, Structure and Finance In Bailey S J and Paddison R (1988a).

37.

Wistow G. , Knapp M. , Hardy B. and Allen C. (1992) From Providing to Enabling: Local Authorities and the Mixed Economy of Social Care Public Administration Vol70 pp 25-45.