‘Cabined,cribbed,confined,bound in’ or ‘we are not a government poodle’: Structure and agency in museums and galleries

Abstract

Arguments within political science, public administration and public policy about how to both conceptualise and operationalise structure and agency in analysis have tended to operate at the level of ontology – and occasionally at the level of epistemology. This paper argues that development at the methodological level is required to make sense of the complexities of this debate. An analysis of how structure and agency can be applied to the museums policy sector is utilised to demonstrate the importance of linking methodology to epistemology and ontology, and to show the analytical consequences that arise from this.

Keywords

Policymaking public administration theory methodology museums structure and agency

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adeney

Wyatt

(2004) Democracy in South Asia: Getting beyond the structure-agency dichotomy. Political Studies 52: 1–18.

Archer

(1988) Culture and Agency, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Archer

(1995) Realist Social Theory: The Morphogenetic Approach, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Archer

(2000) For structure: Its reality, properties and powers: a reply to Anthony King. Sociological Review 48: 464–472.

Archer

(2003) Structure, Agency and the Internal Conversation, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Archer

Elder-Vass

(2012) Cultural systems or norm circles? An exchange. European Journal of Social Theory 15: 93–115.

Benton

Craib

(2011) Philosophy of Social Science: The Philosophical Foundations of Social Thought, 2nd ed. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

Bevir

Rhodes

(2003) Interpreting British Governance, London: Routledge.

Bevir

Rhodes

(2006) Governance Stories, London: Routledge.

10.

Bhaskar R (1979) The Possibility of Naturalism: A Philosophical Critique of Contemporary Human Sciences. Brighton: Harvester.

11.

Bhaskar

(1994) Plato Etc, London: Verso.

12.

Bhatti

(2012) Translating Museums: A Counterhistory of South Asian Museology, Walnut Creek: Left Coast Press.

13.

Brady

Collier

Box-Steffensmeier

(2009) Overview of political methodology: Post-behavioral movements and trends. In: Goodin

(ed.) The Oxford Handbook of Political Science, Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 1005–1053.

14.

Bulpitt

(1983) Territory and Power in the United Kingdom: An Interpretation, Manchester: Manchester University Press.

15.

Burnham

Lutz

Grant

(2008) Research Methods in Politics, 2nd ed. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

16.

Chalmers

(1999) What Is This Thing Called Science?, 3rd ed. Maidenhead: Open University Press.

17.

Colebatch

(1998) Policy, Buckingham: Open University Press.

18.

Cruickshank

(2010) Structures, agents and criticism: Assessing Bhaskar’s fact-to-value and value-to-fact arguments. Politics 30: 168–173.

19.

Deacon

(2004) Review article: Different interpretations of agency within welfare debates. Social Policy and Society 3: 447–455.

20.

Dowding

(2001) There must be an end to confusion: Policy networks, intellectual fatigue, and the need for political science methods courses in British Universities. Political Studies 49: 89–105.

21.

Duncan

(1995) Civilizing Rituals: Inside Public Art Museums, London: Routledge.

22.

Dunleavy

(1991) Democracy, Bureaucracy and Public Choice, Hemel Hempstead: Harvester Wheatsheaf.

23.

Elder-Vass

(2007) For emergence: Refining archer’s account of social structure. Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour 37: 25–44.

24.

Elder-Vass

(2010) The Causal Power of Social Structures: Emergence, Structure and Agency, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

25.

Fyfe

(1996) A Trojan horse at the tate: Theorizing the museum as agency and structure. In: Macdonald

Fyfe

(eds) Theorizing Museums, Oxford: Blackwell, pp. 203–228.

26.

Giddens

(1984) The Constitution of Society, Cambridge: Polity.

27.

Goodwin

Grix

(2011) Bringing structures back. In: the ‘Governance Narrative’, the ‘Decentred Approach’ and ‘Asymmetrical Network Governance’ in the education and sport policy communities. Public Administration 89: 537–556.

28.

Gray

(2002) Local government and the arts. Local Government Studies 28(1): 77–90.

29.

Gray

(2007) Commodification and instrumentality in cultural policy. International Journal of Cultural Policy 13: 201–215.

30.

Gray

(2008) Instrumental policies: Causes, consequences, museums and galleries. Cultural Trends 17(4): 209–222.

31.

Gray

(2009) Managing cultural policy: Pitfalls and prospects. Public Administration 87: 574–585.

32.

Gray C (2012a) Museums policy: Structural invariants and political agency? Paper to the International Centre for Cultural and Heritage Studies, University of Newcastle. Available at: http://www2.warwick.ac.uk/fac/arts/theatre_s/cp/staff/gray/research/ (accessed 18 September 2013).

33.

Gray C (2012b) The Structure of Cultural Policy. Paper to the 7th International Conference on Cultural Policy Research, Barcelona. Available at: http://www2.warwick.ac.uk/fac/arts/theatre_s/cp/staff/gray/research/(accessed 18 September 2013).

34.

Gray

Wingfield

(2011) Are governmental culture departments important? An empirical investigation. International Journal of Cultural Policy 17: 590–604.

35.

Hampsher-Monk

Hindmoor

(2010) Rational choice and interpretive evidence: Caught between a rock and a hard place? Political Studies 58: 47–65.

36.

Harrison

(2013) Heritage: Critical Approaches, Abingdon: Routledge.

37.

Hay

(2002) Political Analysis: A Critical Introduction, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

38.

Hay

(2004) Theory, stylized heuristic or self-fulfilling prophecy? The status of rational choice theory in public administration. Public Administration 82: 39–62.

39.

Hay

(2006) Political ontology. In: Goodin

Tilly

(eds) The Oxford Handbook of Contextual Political Analysis, Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 78–96.

40.

Hay

(2009a) King Canute and the “Problem” of structure and agency: On times, tides and heresthetics. Political Studies 57: 260–279.

41.

Hay

(2009b) Your ontology. My ontic speculations…On the importance of showing one’s (ontological) working. Political Studies 57: 892–898.

42.

Hay

(2013) Treating the symptom not the condition: Crisis definition, deficit reduction and the search for a new British growth model. British Journal of Politics and International Relations 15: 23–37.

43.

Hay

Rosamond

(2002) Globalisation, European integration and the discursive construction of economic imperatives. Journal of European Public Policy 9: 147–167.

44.

Hay

Wincott

(1998) Structure, agency and historical institutionalism. Political Studies 46: 951–957.

45.

Hill

(2005) Culture and Class in English public museums, 1850–1914, Aldershot: Ashgate.

46.

Hood

(1983) The Tools of Government, London: Macmillan.

47.

Hooper-Greenhill

(2007) Museums and Education: Purpose, Pedagogy, Performance, Abingdon: Routledge.

48.

Howlett

(2011) Designing Public Policies: Principles and Instruments, London: Routledge.

49.

Janes

(2009) Museums in a Troubled World: Renewal, Irrelevance or Collapse?, Abingdon: Routledge.

50.

Jessop

(2005) Critical realism and the strategic-relational approach. New Formations 56: 40–53.

51.

Jessop

(2007) State Power: A Strategic-Relational Approach, Cambridge: Polity.

52.

Kellstedt

Whitten

(2009) The Fundamentals of Political Science Research, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

53.

Lawley

(2003) Local authority museums and the modernizing government agenda in England. Museum and Society 1(2): 75–86.

54.

Leahy

(2012) Museum Bodies: The Politics and Practices of Visiting and Viewing, Farnham: Ashgate.

55.

Lewis

(2002) Agency, structure and causality in political science: A comment on Sibeon. Politics 22: 17–23.

56.

Lowndes

Pratchett

Stoker

(2006) Local political participation: The impact of rules-in-use. Public Administration 84: 539–561.

57.

McAnulla

(2005) Making hay with actualism? The need for a realist concept of structure. Politics 25: 31–38.

58.

McCall V and Gray C (2014) Museums and the ‘New Museology’: Theory, practice and organizational change. Museum Management and Curatorship.

59.

Macdonald

(2002) Behind the Scenes at the Science Museum, Oxford: Berg.

60.

Manheim

Rich

Wilnat

(2008) Empirical Political Analysis: Quantitative and Qualitative Research Methods, 7th ed. New York: Pearson Longman.

61.

Marsh

(2010) Meta-theoretical issues. In: Marsh

Stoker

(eds) Theory and Methods in Political Science, 3rd ed. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 212–231.

62.

Martin

Dennis

(2010) Human Agents and Social Structures, Manchester: Manchester University Press.

63.

Mohan

Lampert

(2013) Negotiating China: Reinserting African agency into China-Africa relations. African Affairs 112: 92–110.

64.

Newman

McLean

(1998) Heritage builds communities: The application of heritage resources to the problem of social exclusion. International Journal of Heritage Studies 4(3–4): 143–153.

65.

Newman

McLean

(2004) Presumption, policy and practice: The use of museums and galleries as agents of social inclusion. International Journal of Cultural Policy 10: 167–181.

66.

Nisbett

(2013) Protection, survival and growth: an analysis of international policy documents. International Journal of Cultural Policy 19: 84–102.

67.

Olsen

(2010) Realist Methodology, Los Angeles: Sage.

68.

Osborne

Rose

(1999) Do the social sciences create phenomena? The example of public opinion research. British Journal of Sociology 50: 367–396.

69.

Parker

(2000) Structuration, Buckingham: Open University Press.

70.

Pennings

Keman

Kleinnijenhuis

(2006) Doing Research in Political Science: An Introduction to Comparative Methods and Statistics, 2nd ed. London: Sage.

71.

Peters

(2010) The Politics of Bureaucracy: An Introduction to Comparative Public Administration, 6th ed. Abingdon: Routledge.

72.

Pleasants

(2009) Structure, agency and ontological confusion: a response to Hay. Political Studies 57: 885–891.

73.

Pollock

(2012) The Essentials of Political Analysis, 4th ed. Washington: CQ Press.

74.

Ross

(2004) Interpreting the New Museology. Museum and Society 2(2): 84–103.

75.

Royseng S (2008) The ritual logic of cultural policy. In: Paper presented at the 5th international conference on cultural policy research, Istanbul, 2008.

76.

Sandell R (2007) Museums, Prejudice and the Reframing of Difference. Abingdon: Routledge.

77.

Sharrock

Button

(2010) The structure problem in the context of structure and agency controversies. In: Martin

Dennis

(eds) Human Agents and Social Structures, Manchester: Manchester University Press, pp. 17–33.

78.

Sibeon

(1999) Agency, structure, and social chance as cross-disciplinary concepts. Politics 19: 139–144.

79.

Stam

(1993) The informed muse: The implications of “The New Museology” for museum practice. Museum Management and Curatorship 12: 267–283.

80.

Suchy

(2006) Connection, recollection, and museum missions. In: Genoways

(ed.) Museum Philosophy for the Twenty-First Century, Lanham: AltaMira Press, pp. 47–57.

81.

UNESCO (2003) Convention for the Safeguarding of the Intangible Cultural Heritage, Paris: UNESCO.

82.

Vergo

(1989) The New Museology, London: Reaktion Books.

83.

West

Smith

(2005) “We Are Not a Government Poodle”: Museums and social inclusion under new labour. International Journal of Cultural Policy 11: 275–288.

84.

Wight

(1999) They shoot dead horses don’t they? Locating agency in the agent-structure problematique. European Journal of International Relations 5: 109–142.

85.

Wight

(2003) The agent-structure problem and institutional racism. Political Studies 51: 706–721.

86.

Wight

(2004) State agency: Social action without human activity. Review of International Studies 30: 269–280.

87.

Willmott

(1999) Structure, Agency and the sociology of education: Rescuing analytical dualism. British Journal of Sociology of Education 20: 5–21.

88.

Wilson

(2002) The British Museum: A History, London: The British Museum Press.