This article asks who works in Whitehall today. We argue that there are points of consensus about the nature of ‘Whitehall’, including generalism, internal labour markets, Oxbridge education, and lifetime careers. An analysis of 306 biographies of the top team of the UK civil service, which goes beyond existing published use of biographical data on the topic, allows us to compare the civil service with this model. We find that in every respect the descriptive usefulness of a Whitehall model is weak. Whitehall is no longer marked by internal labour markets, Oxbridge dominance, or lifetime careers, and there are signs of reduced generalism. Furthermore, many of the most politically salient departments appear to be leading the way towards a different public sector model premised on managerial, policy expertise rather than civil service generalism and loyalty.
Campbell C., Wilson GK ( 1995) The End of Whitehall: Death of a Paradigm?Oxford: Blackwell.
9.
Chapman RA ( 2004) The Civil Service Commission 1855-1991: A Bureau Biography . London: Routledge.
10.
Committee on the Civil Service (Fulton Committee) ( 1967) The Report of the Committee on the Civil Service, cmnd. 3638. London: HMSO.
11.
Dargie C., Locke R. ( 1999) ‘The British Senior Civil Service’ . in Page EC, Wright V (eds) Bureaucratic Elites in Western European States: A Comparative Analysis of Top Officials. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
12.
Day P., Klein R. ( 1997) Steering but not Rowing? The Transformation of the Department of Health: A Case Study. Bristol: Policy.
13.
Dod’s (2007) Dod’s Civil Service Companion 2007. London: Dod’s.
14.
Duggett M.(2009) ‘The State of UK Governance: Whitehall Structures and Functions under Brown’. Public Policy and Administration24(1): 103-11.
15.
Edwards B., Fall M. ( 2005) The Executive Years of the NHS: The England Account 1985-2003 . London/Oxford: The Nuffield Trust/Radcliffe.
16.
Foster C. ( 2005) British Government in Crisis. Oxford : Hart.
17.
Fry GK ( 1993) Reforming the Civil Service: The Fulton Committee on the British Home Civil Service of 1966-1968. Edinburgh : Edinburgh University Press.
18.
Glover M. ( 2007) The Whitehall Model. London : The Constitution Unit.
19.
Glover M., Holsen S. ( 2008) ‘Downward Slope?: FOI and Access to Government Information’ . in Hazell R (ed) Constitutional Futures Revisited: Britain’s Constitution to 2020. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
20.
Greenleaf WH ( 1987) The British Political Tradition: A Much Governed Nation, Pt. I, Vol. III. London: Methuen .
21.
Greer SL ( 2008) ‘Whitehall’. in Hazell R (ed) Constitutional Futures Revisited: Britain’s Constitution to 2020. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
22.
Greer SL, Jarman H. (forthcoming) ‘The United Kingdom’. in Frits van der Meer (ed) Civil Service Systems in Western Europe Revisited. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar .
23.
Hennessy P. ( 1989) Whitehall. London: Fontana.
24.
Hood C. ( 1991) ‘A Public Management for all Seasons? ’ Public Administration69: 3-19.
25.
Hood C., Dunsire A. ( 1981) Bureaumetrics: The Quantitative Comparison of British central government agencies. Tuscaloosa: University of Alabama Press.
26.
Jarman H. and Greer SL ( 2010) ‘In the Eye of the Storm: Public Servants and Managers in the UK Department of Health’. Social Policy and Administration44(2): 172-192.
27.
Kaufman G. ( 1980, 1997 edn) How to be a Minister. London: Faber and Faber.
28.
Lodge G., Rogers B. ( 2006) Whitehall’s Black Box: Accountability and Performance in the Senior Civil Service. London: IPPR.
29.
Lodge G., Kalitowski S. ( 2007) Innovations in Government: International Perspectives on Civil Service Reform. London: IPPR.
30.
Massey A., Pyper R. ( 2005) Public Management and Modernisation in Britain . Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan .
31.
Matas Dalmases J. ( 1995) Els Alts Càrrecs: Política i Administració a la Generalitat de Catalunya. Barcelona: Escola de Administració Pública de Catalunya.
32.
Miller K. (2009) ‘Public Policy Dilemma; Gender EqualityMainstreaming in UK Policy Formulation’ . Public Money and Management29(1): 43-50.
33.
Page EC, Jenkins B. ( 2005) Policy Bureaucracy: Government with a Cast of Thousands . Oxford: Oxford University Press .
34.
Page EC, Wright V. ( 1999) ‘Introduction’. in Page EC, Wright V (eds) Bureaucratic Elites in Western European States: A Comparative Analysis. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
35.
Painter C. ( 2008) ‘A Government Department in Meltdown: Crisis in the Home Office’. Public Money and Management28(5): 275-82.
36.
Rhodes RAW ( 1988) Beyond Westminster and Whitehall. Lonon: Unwin Hyman.
37.
Rhodes RAW, Carmichael P., McMillan J., and Massey A. ( 2003) Decentralizing the Civil Service. Maidenhead: Open University Press.
38.
Rhodes RAW, Weller P. ( 2005) ‘Westminster Transplanted and Westminster Implanted: Explanations for Political Change’. in Patapan H, Wanna J, and Weller P (eds) Westminster Legacies: Democracy and Responsible Government in Asia, Australia and the Pacific. Sydney: University of New South Wales Press.
39.
Richards D. ( 1997) The Civil Service under the Conservatives, 1979-1997: Whitehall’s Political Poodles?Brighton: Sussex Academic Press.
40.
Richards D. ( 2008) New Labour and the Civil Service: Reconstituting the Westminster Model. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan .
41.
Rose R. ( 1984) ‘The Political Status of the Higher Civil Servants in Britain’. in Suleiman EN (ed) Bureaucrats and Policy Making: Comparative Perspectives . New York: Holmes and Meier.
42.
Rose R. ( 1987) Ministers and Ministries: A Functional Analysis . Oxford: Clarendon.
43.
Sandberg R. ( 2006) ‘A Whitehall Farce?: Defining and Conceptualising the British Civil Service’. Public Law: 653-63.
44.
Savage G. ( 1996) The Social Construction of Expertise: The English Civil Service and Its Influence, 1919-1939. Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press.
45.
Silberman BS ( 1993) Cages of Reason: The Rise of the Rational State in France, Japan, the United States, and Great Britain. Chicago, IL : University of Chicago Press.
46.
Theakston K. ( 1995) The Civil Service since 1945. Oxford : Blackwell.
