The policy developments culminating in the creation of a self-regulatory body for charity fundraising for England, Scotland and Wales are explored. Underpinned by literature on regulation, the paper identifies policy chronology and processes leading to the establishment of a 'Fundraising Standards Board' in 2006. It reports on the roles of some leading charities in driving the policy forward and draws on the metaphor of the 'shadow of the state' as ever present in self-regulation systems. It considers the prior complexity of UK charity fundraising regulation and suggests that this latest development reflects a market-based view of the fundraising environment, rather than one which delivers new accountabilities.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Association of Charity Shops (2005), Directors' Report and Financial Statement for year ending 31 March, 2005, (London).
2.
AFP [Association of Fundraising Professionals] ( 2004), Charity Oversight and Reform Roundtable, Oral Comment and Statement for the Record, (Senate Committee on Finance ), Alexandria, VA, July, www.senate.gov/~finance/Roundtable/Paulette%20Maehara,%20AFP/afpcom.pdf.
3.
Bekkers, R. (2003), 'Trust, accreditation and philanthropy in the Netherlands', Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, Vol 32, No 4, pp.596-615.
4.
Better Regulation Task Force (2005), Better Regulation for Civil Society, (London: Better Regulation Commission).
5.
Black, J. (2002), Critical Reflections on Regulation, The Centre for Analysis of Risk and Regulation, discussion paper series, paper 4, (London School of Economics and Political Science)
6.
Brearley, C. (2001), Confidence in Fundraising Charities - a submission to the PIU project on modernising the legal and regulatory framework for charities and the voluntary sector with some suggestions for raising confidence in fund-raising charities. November, unpublished.
7.
Buse, R. (2003), The Future of the self-regulation of charity fundraising , Buse Commission, Phase 1 Report, Rodney Buse Associates Ltd. [online]: www.busecommission.org.uk.
8.
Buse, R. (2004), The future of self-regulation of charity fundraising , Buse Commission, Phase 2 Report, Rodney Buse Associates Ltd. [online]: www.busecommission.org.uk.
9.
Cancer Research UK (2004), Submission on the Draft Charities Bill to the Joint Committee, [online]: info.cancerresearchuk.org/publicpolicy/consultations/charitiesbill/?a=5441 .
10.
Charity Commission (2005) Regulating for the future: listening to external views- challenging assumptions. [online]: www.charitycommission.gov.uk/Library/spr/pdfs/dhasurv.pdf .
11.
Commons Hansard (2005), Home Department, Regulation of Fundraising Scheme, Fiona Mactaggart , 14 March, Column 5WS.
12.
Commons Hansard (2006), Home Department, Fundraising (Self-Regulation), Paul Goggins , 6 February, Column 38WS.
13.
Community Interest Companies (2006), 'What teeth will the regulator have?' Frequently Asked Questions for Community Interest Companies [online]: www.cicregulator.gov.uk/faq.shtml .
14.
Connolly, C. and Dhanani, A. (2005), Accounting Narratives: The reporting practices of British Charities, Fifth Workshop on the Challenges of Managing the Third Sector, European Institute for Advanced Studies in Management, Queen's University, Belfast , 6-7 September.
15.
DeMarzo, P., Fishman, M. and Hagerty, K. (2005), 'Self regulation and government oversight', Review of Economic Studies, Vol 72, pp.687-706.
16.
Department for Social Development (2005), Consultation on the review of charities administration and legislation in Northern Ireland in 2005. Charities Branch, Voluntary & Community Unit, Department for Social Development Northern Ireland.
17.
Douthwaite, S. and Harrow, J. (2005), 'Am I my sister's keeper? Perspectives on impending self-regulation in charity fundraising', Proceedings of the National Council of Voluntary Organisations/ Voluntary Sector Studies Network 'Researching the Voluntary Sector', Tenth Annual Conference, The University of Warwick, 30 August - 1 September.
18.
Ebrahim, A. (2003), 'Accountability in practice: mechanisms for NGOs ', World Development, Vol 31, No 5, pp.813-829.
19.
Echenberg, H. (1995), Self-Regulation of the voluntary sector: a preliminary literature review. Publication for the Voluntary Sector Roundtable, May 14. [online]: www.vsr-trsb.net/publications/echen.html .
20.
European Commission (2005), Draft recommendations to member states regarding a code of conduct for non profit organisations to promote transparency and accountability best practices . Directorate-General Justice, Freedom and Security, JLS/D2/DB/NSK D (2005) 8208, 22 July, Brussels.
21.
FSB [Fundraising Standards Board] (2006), www.fsboard.org.uk/what-is-the-fsb.aspx [accessed 26 July 2006]
22.
Gunningham, N. and Rees, J. (1997), 'Industry self-regulation: an institutional perspective ', Law & Policy, Vol 19, No 4, pp.363-414.
23.
Harrow, J. and Douthwaite, S. (2005), All grown up now? Policy maturity or infancy in UK fundraising self-regulation, Association for Researchers in Nonprofit and Voluntary Action (ARNOVA) 34th Annual Conference , Washington DC, November 17-19.
24.
Home Office (2005), Written Ministerial Statement, Regulation of Fundraising Scheme, [online]: www.homeoffice,gov.uk/docs4/WMS-self-regulation-March05.
25.
Home Office (2005a), Principles for Assessing the Success of Self-Regulation of Fundraising: A consultation paper, Charities Unit, March 2005.
26.
Home Office (2006), Report on the response to the consultation on Principles for Assessing the Success of Self-Regulation of Fundraising, Charities and VCS Development Unit, Active Communities Directorate, Home Office. London, February.
27.
Hood, C., Rothstein, H., Baldwin, R., Rees, J. and Spackman, M. (1999), 'When risk society meets the regulatory state: exploring variation in risk regulation regimes', Risk Management: an International Journal, Vol 1, No 1, pp.21-34.
28.
Hutter, B.M. (2006), The Role of Non-State Actors in Regulation, The Centre for Analysis of Risk and Regulation, discussion paper series, paper 37 London School of Economics and Political Science.
29.
Institute of Fundraising (2002), Discussion paper five: an independent framework for the regulation offundraising , (Public Action, Private Benefit paper 20), Discussion paper series, November 20, London, pp.1-10
30.
Institute of Fundraising, (2005), ' Funding for self-regulation', [online]: www.institute-of-fundraising.org.uk/self_reg.html .
31.
Institute of Fundraising (2006), ' Fundraising Standards Board unveils logo for self regulation', News, 19 April, [online]: www.institute-of-fundraising.org.uk/ .
32.
Irvin, R. (2005), 'State regulation of nonprofits: accountability regardless of outcome', Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly , Vol 34, No 2, pp.161-178.
33.
Kassirer, J. (2001), 'Pseudoaccountability', Annals of Internal Medicine, Vol 134, No 7, pp.587-590
34.
Kingdon, J. (2002), Agendas, Alternatives and Public Policies, 2nd edition (New York: Longman).
35.
Lee, S. ( 2003), 'The regulation of fundraising: in search of the public good or an intractable problem of vested interest?' International Journal of Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Marketing, Vol 8, No 4, pp.307-314.
36.
Lee, S. ( 2004), 'Developing alternate fundraising regulatory frameworks ', Fourth Annual Charity Law Conference, London, 26 February.
37.
Lloyd, R. (2005), The Role of NGO Self-Regulation in Increasing Stakeholder Accountability, One World Trust, [online]: www.oneworldtrust.org/pages/download.cfm?did=298.
38.
Lloyd, R. and de Las Casas, L. (2005), 'NGO self-regulation: enforcing and balancing accountability', Alliance Extra (December) [online]: www.allavida.org/alliance/axdec05e.html.
39.
Lords Hansard (2005), 21 March 2005, Lord Bassam of Brighton, column GC50/51/52.
40.
Mayo, E. (2005), The good fundraiser: response to proposals on the Regulation of fundraising scheme by the Self-Regulation Steering Committe , (London: National Consumer Council ).
41.
McGarvey, N. (2001), 'Reviews: New Perspectives on Accountability', Public Administration, Vol 79, No 4, pp.949-959.
42.
National Council for Voluntary Organisations ( 2005), Response to European Commission Consultation on Code of Conduct for Transparency and Accountability by Non Profit Organisations . Response from NCVO, SCVO, WCVA, NICVA on European Commission Consultation, 23 August, [online]: www.ncvovol.org.uk/policy/index.asp?id=1184 .
43.
Newman, A. and Bach, D. (2001), 'In the shadow of the state: self regulation trajectories in a digital age', Annual Convention of the American Political Science Association. San Francisco, CA, 30 August - 2 September.
44.
Newman, A. and Bach, D. (2004), 'Self-regulatory trajectories in the shadow of public power: resolving digital dilemmas in Europe and the United States', Governance, Vol 17, No 3, pp.387-413.
45.
Parker, C. (2000), Reinventing Regulation Within the Corporation: Compliance-Oriented Regulatory Innovation, Administration and Society, Vol 32, No 5, pp.529-565.
46.
Porter, T. and Ronit, K. (2006), 'Self-regulation as policy process: the multiple and criss-crossing stages of private rule-making', Policy Sciences, Vol 39, No 1, pp.41-72.
47.
Pratten, B. (2004), 'Charity Law reform: implementing the Strategy Unit Proposals', International Journal of Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Marketing, Vol 9, No 3, pp.191-201.
48.
Prime Minister's Strategy Unit (2002), Private action: public benefit: a review of charities and the wider not-for-profit sector, (London: UK Cabinet Office ).
49.
Public Fundraising Regulatory Association ( 2004), Written Evidence submitted to the Joint Committee on the Draft Charities Bill, June, [online]: www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/jt200304/jtselect/jtchar/660/660we115.htm .
50.
Scott, C. (2004), 'Regulation in the age of governance: the rise of the post-regulatory state', in J. Jordana and D. Levi-Faur (eds), The politics of regulation: institutional reforms for the age of governance , (Cheltenham: Edward Elgar), pp.145-174.
51.
Shields, J. (2002), 'Capturing Civil Society: The Third Sector in the Shadow of the State', The SRC Sarwan Sahota Lecture, Ryerson University, Toronto , Canada, 21 February, pp.1-23.
52.
Sidel, M. (2005), 'The guardians guarding themselves: a comparative perspective on nonprofit self-regulation', Chicago - Kent Law Review, Vol 80, pp.803-836, Chicago/Kent Symposium, 'Who Guards the Guardians?' [online]: www.lareview.kentlaw.edu/articles/80-2/Sidel.pdf
53.
Steering Committee (2004), The Self-Regulation of Fundraising: A paper prepared by a Steering Committee consisting of representatives from the Charities Aid Foundation, Institute of Fundraising, Public Fundraising Regulatory Association, National Council for Voluntary Organisations, Association of Chief Executives of Voluntary Organisations, Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations, Charity Law Association and the Charity Commission, November, 1-13,CAF. [online]: www.institute-of-fundraising.org.uk/documents/CAF%24Final%20report.doc.
54.
Tamuz, M. (2001), 'Learning disabilities for regulators: the perils of organisational learning in the air transportation industry', Administration and Society, Vol 33, No 3, pp.276-302.
55.
Third Sector (2006), Fundraising Standards Board delays its launch, 6 September, p.1.
56.
Wolch, J. (1990), The Shadow State: Government and Voluntary Sector in Transition, (New York: The Foundation Center).
