Richard Crossman - a member of Harold Wilson’. Cabinet from 1964-1970 - wrote widely about the relationship between ministers and the civil service, and, with particular reference to his famous Diaries of a Cabinet Minister, he continues to be cited as an influential figure who questioned the veracity of the traditional model of public administration. This article will move beyond an examination of Crossman’. own words, and a case will be considered, involving Crossman, where it appears that officials did play a large role in changing existing party policy. However, this case study - which draws heavily on archive material - will not be taken from Crossman’. time at the Ministry of Housing (1964-1966), where his bruising battles with ‘the Dame’ have become political folklore, but rather from a later period in which Crossman believed he had largely mastered the civil service
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Abel-Smith, B. (1953), The Reform of Social Security, Fabian Research Series No 161, ( London: Fabian Publications/ Victor Gollancz ).
2.
Abel-Smith, B. and Townsend, P. (1955), New Pensions for the Old, Fabian Research Series No 171, ( London: Fabian Publications ).
3.
Bochel, C. and Bochel, H. (2004), The UK Social Policy Process, ( Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan ).
4.
Bridgen, P. (1999), ‘Remedy For All Ills: Earnings-Relation and the Politics of Pensions 1950s/1960s’, an unpublished paper given at the conference ‘Relative decline and relative poverty: signposts to the sixties?’ at the University of Bristol, 13 May 1999.
5.
Bridgen, P. (2000), ‘The One Nation Idea and State Welfare’ , Contemporary British History, Vol 14, No 3, pp. 83-104 .
6.
Craig, F. (ed.) (1970), British General Election Manifestos 1918-1966, ( Chichester: Political Reference Publications ).
7.
Crossman, R. (1972), The Politics of Pensions, Eleanor Rathbone Memorial Lectures No 19, ( Liverpool: Liverpool University Press ).
8.
Crossman, R. (1975), The Diaries of a Cabinet Minister: Volume 1, Minister of Housing 1964-66, ( London: Hamish Hamilton and Jonathan Cape ).
9.
Crossman, R. (1975), The Diaries of a Cabinet Minister: Volume 3, Secretary of State for Social Services 1968-1970, ( London: Hamish Hamilton and Jonathan Cape ).
10.
DHSS (Department of Health and Social Security) (1969), National Superannuation and Social Insurance, Cmnd. 3883, ( London: HMSO ).
Ellis, B. (1989), Pensions in Britain 1955-1975, ( London: HMSO ).
13.
Fawcett, H. (1996), ‘The Beveridge Strait-jacket: Policy Formation and the Problem of Poverty in Old Age’ , Contemporary British History, Vol 10, No 1, pp. 20-42 .
14.
Hannah, L. (1986), Inventing Retirement: The development of occupational pensions in Britain, ( Cambridge: Cambridge University Press ).
15.
Howard, A. (1990), Crossman: The Pursuit of Power, ( London: Jonathan Cape ).
16.
Kingdom, J. (1999), Government and Politics in Britain, 2nd ed., ( Cambridge: Polity Press ).
17.
Labour Party (1957), National Superannuation: Labour’. Policy For Security in Old Age, ( London: Labour Party ).
18.
Labour Party (1963), New Frontiers for Social Security, ( London: Labour Party ).
19.
LPA (Labour Party Archives) (1956), Minutes of the Study Group on Security and Old Age, 4 July 1956.
20.
LPA (1967), HART 11/3, The Pension Formula for the New Scheme, 27 July 1967.
21.
Morgan, J. (1981), The Backbench Diaries Richard Crossman, ( London: Hamish Hamilton and Jonathan Cape ).
22.
PRO (Public Record Office) (1964a), T 227/2216, National Insurance Review Committee, 14 July 1964.
23.
PRO (1964b), PIN 47/147, Working Group on Pensions, 18 August 1964.
24.
PRO (1965a), T 227/2216, Official Committee on Social Security Review, 5 February 1965.
25.
PRO (1965b), T 227/2216, Official Committee on Social Security Review, 12 February 1965.
26.
PRO (1966a), PREM 13/1209, Note by Burke Trend to Wilson, 18 May 1966.
27.
PRO (1967a), CAB 165/133, Ministerial Committee on Social Services Sub-Committee on Social Security Cash Benefits, 13 March 1967.
28.
PRO (1967b), CAB 134/3303, Ministerial Sub-Committee on Earnings-related Pensions, First Report of the Official Committee on Social Security, 10 March 1967.
29.
PRO (1967c), CAB 134/3303, Ministerial Sub-Committee on Earnings-related Pensions, 12 October 1967.
30.
PRO (1967d), CAB 134/3303, Ministerial Sub-Committee on Earnings-related Pensions, The Question Whether New Scheme Pensions Should Contain A Flatrate Element Or Be Fully Earnings-related, note by the Secretaries, 24 July 1967.
31.
PRO (1967e), CAB 134/3303, Ministerial Sub-Committee on Earnings-related Pensions, 5 December 1967.
32.
PRO (1968a), CAB 134/3304, Ministerial Sub-Committee on Earnings-related Pensions, Memorandum by the Official Committee on Social Security, 30 April 1968.
33.
PRO (1968b), T227/2589, Earnings Related Pension Scheme 1968 Discussions with: 1) The Lord President’. Group of Academic Experts 2) Confederation of British Industry and the Trade Union Congress, letter from Serpell to Houghton, 10 May 1968.
34.
PRO (1968c), T227/2589, Letter from Crossman to Balogh, 7 May 1968.
35.
PRO (1968d), T227/2589, Official briefs related to the Lord President’. Meeting on 16 May 1968, 15 May 1968.
36.
PRO (1968e), T227/2589, ‘TWO social security funds?’Note by Professor Brian Abel-Smith, 18 June 1968.
37.
PRO (1968f), T227/2589, Note from Jordan-Moss to Serpell, including two draft letters from the Chief Secretary to the Lord President, 10 May 1968.
38.
Theakston, K. (1992), The Labour Party and Whitehall, ( London: Routledge ).
39.
Theakston, K. (2000), ‘Ministers and Civil Servants’, in R. Pyper and L. Robins (eds), United Kingdom Governance, ( Basingstoke: Macmillan ).
40.
Theakston, K. (2003), ‘Richard Crossman: The Diaries of a Cabinet Minister’ , Public Policy and Administration, Vol 18, No 4, pp. 20-40 .
