Horizontal or Vertical Support: Dilemmas for Patient Advice and Liaison Services in the NHS

Abstract

Every hospital, mental health, primary care and specialist trust in the English National Health Service (NHS) should have a Patient Advice and Liaison Service (PALS), to provide information and support to NHS patients with questions or concerns. PALS should also act as a catalyst for service improvement. This article draws on findings from a qualitative study of London PALS. In particular, it focuses on data generated during observation of meetings of PALS staff in each of London’. five Strategic Health Authority (SHA) sectors, over a period of nearly two years. It describes two types of support received by PALS staff horizontal peer support (the sector meetings themselves; other informal and local PALS contacts; the National PALS Development Group) and vertical hierarchical support (the trusts where PALS are based; Strategic Health Authorities; the Department of Health (DoH)). PALS staff appreciated horizontal support more unequivocally than vertical. Both types of support (horizontal and vertical) reflect parallel government agendas. The Government intends the NHS to become a much flatter hierarchy, and in non-hierarchical structures, staff are expected to look to peers for support. However, a centralised performance management regime also requires staff to look upwards for guidance. As ‘boundary spanners’ working between services and service users, PALS staff are at risk of isolation, and need both types of support to be effective

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abbott, S. and Killoran, A. (2005), Mapping public health networks, ( London: Health Development Agency ). www.publichealth.nice.org.uk/page.aspx?o=503346.

Abbott, S. , Meyer, A. , Copperman, J. , Bentley, J. and Lanceley, A. (2005a), ‘Quality criteria for Patient Advice and Liaison Services: what do patients and the public want?’ , Health Expectations, Vol 8, No 2, pp. 126-137 .

Abbott, S. , Chapman, J. , Shaw, S. , Carter, Y. , Petchey, R. and Taylor, S. (2005b), Flattening the NHS hierarchy: the case of public health’ , Policy Studies, Vol 26, No 2, pp. 133-148 .

Abelson, J. (2001), ‘Understanding the role of contextual influences on local health care decision-making: case study results from Ontario, Canada’ , Social Science and Medicine, Vol 53, No 6, pp. 777-793 .

Anderson, J.M. (1996), ‘Empowering patients: issues and strategies’ , Social Science and Medicine, Vol 43, No 5, pp. 697-705 .

Carter, Y. , Shaw, S. and Sibbald, B. (2000), ‘Primary care research networks: an evolving model meriting national evaluation’ , British Journal of General Practice, Vol 50, No 460, pp. 859-860 .

Citron, J. , (1989), The Citizens Advice Bureaux. For the community by the community, ( London: Pluto Press ).

Department of Health (DoH) (2001), Shifting the balance of power within the NHS. Securing Delivery, ( London: Department of Health ).

Department of Health (DoH) (2002), Supporting the Implementation of Patient Advice & Liaison Services: A resource pack, ( London: Department of Health ).

10.

Exworthy, M. , Powell, M. and Mohan, J. (1999), ‘The NHS: quasi-market, quasi-hierarchy and quasi-network?’ , Public Money and Management, Vol 19, No 4, pp. 15-22 .

11.

Ferlie, E. , and Pettigrew, A (1996), ‘Managing through networks: some issues and implications for the NHS’ , British Journal of Management, Vol 7, pp. S81-S99 .

12.

Flynn, R. , Pickard, S. and Williams, G. (1995), ‘Contracts and the quasi-market in community health services’ , Journal of Social Policy, Vol 24, No 4, pp. 529-550 .

13.

Goodwin, N. , 6, P. , Peck, E. , Freeman, T. and Posaner, R. (2004), Managing across diverse networks: lessons learned from other sectors. Findings from a review of the literature. Summary report for the Service Development and Organisation programme within the NHS R&D programme. www.sdo.lshtm.ac.uk/pdf/studyinghealthcare_Goodwin-policyreport.pdf (accessed 4/11/04).

14.

Hamblin, R. (1998), ‘Trusts’, in Le Grand J. , Mays N. and Mulligan J.A. , Learning from the NHS Internal Market. A review of the evidence, ( London: King’. Fund Publishing ).

15.

Hughes, D. and Griffiths, L. (1999), ‘On penalties and the Patient’. Charter: centralism v de-centralised governance in the NHS’ , Sociology of Health and Illness, Vol 21, No 1, pp. 71-94 .

16.

Johnson, T. (1993), ‘Expertise and the state’, in Gane, M. and Johnson, T. (eds), Foucault’. new domains, ( London: Routledge ).

17.

Johnson, A. and Silburn, K. (2000), ‘Community and consumer participation in Australian health services -an overview of organisational conduct and participation process’ , Australian Health Review, Vol 23, No 3, pp. 113-121 .

18.

Kempson E (1995), Money advice and debt counselling, ( London: Policy Studies Institute ).

19.

Kewell, B. , Hawkins, C. and Ferlie, E. (2002), ‘Calman-Hine reassessed: a survey of cancer network development in England, 1999-2000’ , Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice, Vol 8, No 3, pp. 303-311 .

20.

Laing, A. and Hogg, G. (2002), ‘Political exhortation, patient expectation and professional execution: perspectives on the consumerization of health care’ , British Journal of Management, Vol 13, pp. 173-188 .

21.

Light, D. (2001), ‘Managed competition, governmentality and institutional response in the United Kingdom’ , Social Science and Medicine, Vol 52, pp. 1167-1181 .

22.

Meyer, J. , Bentley, J. , Abbott, S. , Lanceley, A. and Copperman, J. (2005), Learning the lessons from PALS: a report on the findings of a qualitative study to evaluate the introduction of Patient Advice and Liaison Services in London, ( London: City University, School of Nursing and Midwifery, Department of Adult Nursing (Care for Older People).

23.

Richards, L. (1998), Using NVivo in Qualitative Research, ( London: Sage Publications ).

24.

Rhodes, R. (1997), Understanding governance. Policy networks, governance, reflexivity and accountability, ( Buckingham: Open University Press ).

25.

Secretary of State for Health (2000), The NHS Plan, ( London: Department of Health ).

26.

Secretary of State for Health , (2004), The NHS Improvement Plan, ( London: Department of Health ).

27.

Shackley P. and Ryan, M. (1994), ‘What is the role of the consumer in health care?’ , Journal of Social Policy, Vol 23, pp. 517-541 .

28.

Sheaff, R. , Marshall, M. , Rogers, A. , Roland, M. , Sibbald, B. and Pickard, S. (2004), ‘Governmentality by network in English Primary healthcare’ , Social Policy and Administration, Vol 38, pp. 89-103 .

29.

Wilson, P.M. (2001), ‘A policy analysis of the Expert Patient in the United Kingdom: self-care as an expression of pastoral power?’ , Health and Social Care in the Community, Vol 9, No 3, pp. 134-142 .

30.

Wong, K. (1999), A thousand years experience in NHS complaints. The evidence of CHC officers, ( London: Society of CHC staff ).