The Northcote/Trevelyan report of 1854 is cited frequently, but it is not always properly understood in the context of its time. Various myths have grown up that have become entrenched in textbooks. Among them are the views that it founded the modem civil service; that it called for a unified civil service; that it established the cult of the generalist all rounder; that it aimed to promote the interests of the middle class as opposed to the aristocracy; and that it envisaged a clear distinction between political and administrative careers. This article seeks to dispel these myths by looking at the intentions of the reformers of the 1854. However, it is argued that Northcote/Trevelyan remains important in so far as its ideas dovetailed with many of the developments of the following decades.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Anderson, O. (1965), ‘The Janus face of mid-nineteenth radicalism: the Administrative Reform Association of 1855’ , Victorian Studies, Vol 8, pp. 229-242 .
2.
Budge, I. , Crewe, I. , McKay, D. , and Newton, K. , (1998), The New British Politics, ( Harlow: Addison Wesley Longman ).
3.
Chapman, R.A. (2000), ‘Setting standards in a new organization: the case of the British Civil Service Commission’ in Chapman, R. (ed) Ethics in Public Service for the New Millenium, ( Aldershot: Ahsgate ).
4.
Chapman, R.A. and Greenaway, J.R. (1980), The Dynamics of Administrative Reform, ( London: Croom Helm ).
5.
Cohen, E.W. (1941), The Growth of the British Civil Service, 1780-1939, ( London: Allen and Unwin ).
6.
Corker, P. and Jones, A. (2002), Contemporary British Politics and Government, ( Liverpool: Liverpool Academic Press ).
7.
Demetriadi, Sir Stephen (1921), A Reform of the Civil Service, ( London: Cassell ).
8.
Dowding, K. (1995). The Civil Service, ( London: Routledge ).
9.
Finer, S.E. (1952), The Life and Times of Sir Edwin Chadwick, ( London: Methuen ).
10.
Fulton Report . (1968). The Civil Service. Vol 1. Report of the committee 1966-68, Cmnd. 3638, ( London: HMSO ). Gladstone Papers, British Library.
11.
Gowan, P. (1987), ‘The origins of the administrative elite’ , New Left Review, Vol 162, March/April, pp. 4-34 .
12.
Greenaway, J.R. (1983), ‘Warren Fisher and the transformation of the British Treasury, 1919-1939’ , Journal of British Studies, Vol 23, pp. 125-142 .
13.
Greenaway, J.R. (1985), ‘Parliamentary reform and civil service reform: a nineteenth-century debate reassessed’ , Parliamentary History, Vol 4, pp. 157-169 .
14.
Greenwood, J. and Wilson, D. (1984), Public Administration in Britain, ( Hemel Hemsted: Allen and Unwin ).
15.
Hart, J. (1960), ‘Sir Charles Trevelyan at the Treasury’ , English Historical Review, Vol 75, pp. 92-110 .
16.
Hart, J. (1972), ‘The genesis of the Northcote-Trevelyan report’ in Sutherland, G. , (ed) Studies in the Growth of Nineteenth-century Government, ( London: Routledge and Kegan Paul ).
17.
Heyck, T.W. (2002), A History of the Peoples of the British Isles. From 1688 to 1914, ( London: Routledge ).
18.
Horton, S. (1993), ‘The civil service’ in Farnham, D. and Horton, S. (eds) Managing the New Public Services ( Basingstoke: Macmillan ).
19.
Hughes, E. (1954), ‘Civil service reform 1853-5’ , Public Administration, Vol 32, pp. 17-51 .
20.
Hughes, O.E. (2003), Public Management and Administration, ( Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan , 3rd edn. Iddesleigh Papers, British Library.
21.
Johnson, P. (1995), The Offshore Islanders: a History of the English People, ( London: Phoenix ).
22.
Kellner, P. and Crowther-Hunt Lord , (1980) The Civil Servants: an Inquiry into Britain' Governing Class, ( London and Sydney: Macdonald and Jayne' ).
23.
Kingdom, J. (1999), Government and Politics in Britain: an Introduction, ( Cambridge: Polity , 2nd edn.).
24.
Kingsley, J.D. (1944), Representative Bureaucracy: an Interpretation of the British Civil Service, ( Ohio: Antioch Press ).
25.
Mackintosh, J.P. (1982), The Government and Politics of Britain, ( London: Hutchinson , 5th edn.)
26.
Madgwick, P. (1994), A New Introduction to British Politics, ( Cheltenham: Stanley Thornes ).
27.
Morley J. (1903), The Life of William Ewart Gladstone, 3 vols ( London: Macmillan ).
28.
O'Halpin, E. (1987), Head of the Civil Service: a Study of Sir Warren Fisher, ( London: Routledge ).
29.
Papers on the reorganisation of the civil service 1855, Parliamentary Papers. 1854-55, [1870] XX.
30.
Parris, H. (1969), Constitutional Bureaucracy: the Development of British Central Administration since the Eighteenth Century, ( London: Allen and Unwin ).
31.
Pilkington, C. (1999), The Civil Service in Britain Today, ( Manchester: Manchester UP ).
32.
Pyper, R. (1995), The British Civil Service, ( Hemel Hempsted: Prentice Hall / Harvester Wheatsheaf ).
33.
Report on the Organisation of the Civil Service (1854) [Nothcote/Trevelyan Report]. Parliamentary Papers, 1854, [1713], XXVII, p.1.
34.
Reports of Committees of Inquiry into Public Offices and Papers Connected Therewith, (1854). Parliamentary Papers, 1854, [1715], XXVII, p.33.
35.
Richards, D. and Smith, M.J. (2002), Governance and Public Policy in the UK, ( Oxford: Oxford UP ).
36.
Roseveare, H. (1969), The Treasury: the Evolution of a British Institution, ( London: Allen Lane ).
37.
Shefter, M. (1977), ‘Party and patronage: Germany, England and Italy’ , Politics and Society, Vol 7, pp. 403-451 .
38.
Theakston, K. (1999), Leadership in Whitehall, ( Macmillan: Basingstoke ).
39.
Trevelyan Papers, University of Newcastle upon Tyne Library.
40.
Wright, M. (1969), Treasury Control of the Civil Service, 1854-1874, ( London: Oxford University Press ).
