Two different models of the game between police and public, one with two-sided incomplete information and the other with multiple strategies, lead to the same results as my previous research: changes in penalties at equilibrium do not affect crime but instead affect police behavior. I compare these models with alternative models of the police-public game which come to different conclusions. I provide reasons for the differences in the conclusions, as well as empirical evidence against which the different models can be evaluated.
Andenaes, Johannes
(1975) `General Prevention Revisited: Research and Policy Implications', The Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology66: 338-365.
2.
Antunes, George
and A. Lee Hunt (1973) `The Impact of Certainty and Severity of Punishment on Levels of Crime in American States: An Extended Analysis', The Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology64: 486-83.
3.
Avio, Kenneth
and C. Scott Clark (1976) Property Crime in Canada: An Econometric Study. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
4.
Bailey, William C.
and Roland W. Smith (1972) `Punishment: Its Severity and Certainty', Journal of Criminal Law, Criminology and Police Science63: 530-539.
5.
Beha, James A., II
(1977) `And Nobody Can Get Out: The Impact of a Mandatory Prison Sentence for the Illegal Carrying of a Firearm on the Use of Firearms and the Administration of Criminal Justice in Boston', Boston University Law Review57: 98-146, 289-333.
6.
Bennett, Trevor
and Richard Wright (1984) Burglars and Burglary: Prevention and the Offender. Brookfield, VT: Gower.
7.
Bentham, Jeremy
(1789) An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation. (Reprinted 1970) James H. Burns and H.L.A. Hart (eds). London: Athlone Press.
8.
Bianco, William
, Peter Ordeshook and George Tsebelis (1990) `Crime and Punishment: Are Two-Person One-Shot Games Enough?', American Political Science Review84: 569-586.
9.
Blumstein, Alfred
and Daniel Nagin (1977) `Deterrent Effect of Legal Sanctions on Draft Evasion', Stanford Law Review29: 241-276.
10.
Blumstein, Alfred
, Jacqueline Cohen and Daniel Nagin (1978) Deterrence and Incapacitation: Estimating the Effects of Criminal Sanctions on Crime Rates. Washington, DC: National Academy of Sciences.
11.
Brier, Stephen S.
and Stephen E. Fienberg (1980) `Recent Econometric Modeling of Crime and Punishment: Support for the Deterrence Hypothesis?', Evaluation Review4: 147-191.
12.
Cameron, Samuel
(1988) `The Economics of Crime and Deterrence: A Study of Theory and Evidence', Kyklos41: 301-323.
13.
Chauncey, Robert
(1975) `Deterrence: Certainty, Severity and Skyjacking', Criminology12: 447-473.
14.
Chiricos, Theodore G.
and Gordon P. Waldo (1970) `Punishment and Crime: An Examination of Empirical Evidence', Social Problems18: 200-217.
15.
Cox, Gary
(forthcoming) `A Note on Crime and Punishment', Public Choice.
16.
Durkheim, Emile
(1964) The Division of Labour in Society. New York: Free Press.
17.
Ehrlich, Isaac
(1973) `Participation in Illegitimate Activities: A Theoretical and Empirical Investigation', Journal of Political Economy81: 521-565.
18.
Friedman, Milton
(1953) Essays in Positive Economics. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
19.
Frost, Brian F.
(1976) `Participation in Illegitimate Activities: Further Empirical Findings', Policy Analysis2: 477-492.
20.
Gibbs, Jack P.
(1968) `Crime, Punishment and Deterrence', Southwestern Social Science Quarterly48: 515-530.
21.
Hirshleifer, Jack
and Eric Rasmusen (1992) `Are Equilibrium Strategies Unaffected By Incentives?', Journal of Theoretical Politics4: 343-357.
22.
Joint Committee of New York Drug Law Evaluation
(1978) The Nation's Toughest Drug Law: Evaluation of the New York Experience. National Institute of Law Enforcement and Criminal Justice.
23.
Kohfeld, Carol W.
and John Sprague (1990) `Demography, Police Behavior, and Deterrence', Criminology28: 111-136.
24.
Loftin, Colin Milton Heumann
and David McDowall (1983) `Mandatory Sentencing and Firearms Violence: Evaluating an Alternative to Gun Control', Law and Society Review17: 287-318.
25.
Mayer, Thomas
(1991) `Comments on Tsebelis' “Penalty Has No Impact On Crime” ', Rationality and Society3: 266-268.
26.
Nagin, Daniel
(1978a) `Crime Rates, Sanction Levels, and Constraints on Prison Population', Law and Society12: 341-366.
27.
Nagin, Daniel
(1978b) `General Deterrence: A Review of the Empirical Evidence', in A. Blumstein, A. Nagin and J. Cohen (eds) Deterrence and Incapacitation: Estimating the Effects of Criminal Sanctions on Crime Rates. Washington, DC: National Academy of Sciences.
28.
Ostrom, Elinor
, Roger B. Parks and Gordon P. Whitaker (1978) Patterns of Metropolitan Policing. Cambridge, MA: Ballinger Publishing.
29.
Paternoster, Raymond
(1989) `Decisions to Participate in and Desist from Four Types of Common Delinquency: Deterrence and the Rational Choice Perspective', Law and Society Review23: 7-40.
30.
Piliavin, Irving
, Rosemary Gartner, Charles Thornton and Ross L. Matsueda (1986) `Crime Deterrence and Choice', American Sociological Review51: 128-135.
31.
Pontell, Henry N.
(1978) `Deterrence: Theory Versus Practice', Criminology16: 3-22.
32.
Rapoport, Anatol
(1990) `Comments on Tsebelis', Rationality and Society2: 508-511.
33.
Reckless, Walter C.
(1967) The Crime Problem, 4th edn.New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts.
34.
Ross, H. Laurence
(1973) `Law Science and Accidents: The British Road Safety Act of 1967', Journal of Legal Studies2: 1-79.
35.
Ross, H. Laurence
(1982) Deterring the Drinking Driver. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.
36.
Ross, H. Laurence
(1984) `Social Control Through Deterrence: Drinking-and Driving Laws', Annual Review of Sociology10: 21-35.
37.
Salem, Richard G.
and William J. Bowers (1970) `Severity of Formal Sanctions as a Deterrent to Deviant Behavior', Law and Society Review5: 21-40.
38.
Schuessler, Karl
(1952) `The Deterrent Effect of the Death Penalty', The Annals284: 54-62.
39.
Sellin, Thorsten
(1967) `Homicides in Retentionist and Abolitionist States', in T. Sellin (ed.) Capital Punishment, pp. 135-138. New York: Harper and Row.
40.
Silberman, Matthew
(1976) `Toward a Theory of Criminal Deterrence', American Sociological Review41: 442-461.
41.
Teeven, J.J., Jr
(1972) `Deterrent Effects of Punishment: The Canadian Case', Canadian Journal of Criminology and Corrections14: 68-82.
42.
Tittle, Charles R.
(1969) `Crime Rates and Legal Sanctions', Social Problems16: 409-423.
43.
Tsebelis, George
(1989) `The Abuse of Probability in Political Science: The Robinson Crusoe Fallacy', American Political Science Review83: 77-91.
44.
Tsebelis, George
(1990a) Nested Games: Rational Choice in Comparative Politics. Berkeley: University of California Press.
45.
Tsebelis, George
(1990b) `Penalty Has No Impact on Crime: A Game Theoretic Analysis', Rationality and Society2: 255-286.
46.
Tsebelis, George
(1990c) `Response to Anatol Rapoport', Rationality and Society2: 512-516.
47.
Tsebelis, George
(1991) `The Effect of Fines on Regulated Industries: Game Theory vs. Decision Theory'Journal of Theoretical Politics3: 81-101.
48.
Tsebelis, George
(forthcoming) The Monitoring Game: Crime, Regulation, Workfare, and Congressional Oversight.
49.
Tullock. Gordon
(1974) `Does Punishment Deter Crime?', The Public Interest14: 103-111.
50.
Waldo, Gordon P.
and Theodore G. Chiricos (1972) `Perceived Penal Sanction and Self-Reported Criminality: A Neglected Approach to Deterrence Research', Social Problems19: 522-540.
51.
Weissing, Franz
and Elinor Ostrom (1991a) `Irrigation Institutions and the Games Irrigators Play: Rule Enforcement without Guards', in R. Selten (ed.) Game Equilibrium Models II: Methods, Morals and Markets. Berlin: Springer Verlag.
52.
Weissing, Franz
and Elinor Ostrom (1991b) `Crime And Punishment: Further Reflections On The Counterintuitive Results of Mixed Strategy Equilibria Games', Journal of Theoretical Politics3: 343-350.
53.
Wilson, James Q.
(1983) Thinking About Crime, Revised edn.New York: Vintage Books.
54.
Wilson, James Q.
and Richard J. Herrnstein (1985) Crime and Human Nature. New York: Simon and Schuster.
55.
Witte, Ann D.
and Diane F. Woodbury (1985) `The effect of Tax Laws and Tax Administration Tax Compliance: The Case of the US Individual Income Tax', National Tax Journal38: 1-13.
56.
Zimring, Franklin E.
(1972) `Of Doctors, Deterrence, and the Dark Figure of Crime - A Note on Abortion in Hawaii', The University of Chicago Law Review39: 698-721.
