This paper provides a novel axiomatic analysis of exploitation as the unequal exchange of labour in economies with heterogeneous optimising agents endowed with unequal amounts of physical and human capital. A definition of exploitation is proposed, which emphasises the relational nature of exploitation and the resulting inequalities in the allocation of labour and income. It is shown that, among all of the major definitions, this is the only one which satisfies two formally weak and normatively salient axioms, and allows one to generalise a number of core insights of exploitation theory.
DuménilG (1980) De la Valeur aux Prix de Production. Paris: Economica.
2.
DuménilG (1984) The so-called ‘transformation problem’ revisited: a brief comment. Journal of Economic Theory33: 340–348.
3.
DuménilGFoleyDKLévyD (2009) A note on the formal treatment of exploitation in a model with heterogeneous labor. Metroeconomica60: 560–567.
4.
DworkinR (2000) Sovereign Virtue: The Theory and Practice of Equality. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
5.
FlaschelP (1983) Actual labor values in a general model of production. Econometrica51: 435–454.
6.
FlaschelP (2010) Topics in Classical Micro- and Macroeconomics. New York: Springer.
7.
FleurbaeyM (1996) Théories Économiques de la Justice. Paris: Economica.
8.
FleurbaeyM (2014) The facets of exploitation. Journal of Theoretical Politics26: 653–676.
9.
FoleyDK (1982a) The value of money, the value of labour power, and the marxian transformation problem. Review of Radical Political Economics14: 37–47.
10.
FoleyDK (1982b) Realization and accumulation in a Marxian model of the circuit of capital. Journal of Economic Theory28: 300–319.
11.
FoleyDK (2010) What’s wrong with the fundamental existence and welfare theorems?Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization75: 115–131.
12.
FujimotoTFujitaY (2008) A refutation of commodity exploitation theorem. Metroeconomica59: 530–540.
13.
KrauseU (1982) Heterogeneous labour and the fundamental Marxian theorem. Review of Economic Studies48: 173–178.
14.
ManiquetF (2002) A study of proportionality and robustness in economies with a commonly owned technology. Review of Economic Design7: 1–15.
15.
MatsuoT (2008) Profit, surplus product, exploitation and less than maximized utility. Metroeconomica59: 249–265.
16.
MorishimaM (1974) Marx in the light of modern economic theory. Econometrica42: 611–632.
17.
MorishimaM (1989) Ricardo’s Economics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
18.
MoulinH (1990) Joint ownership of a convex technology: comparison of three solutions. Review of Economic Studies57: 439–452.
19.
RawlsJ (1971) A Theory of Justice. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
20.
RoemerJE (1980) A general equilibrium approach to Marxian economics. Econometrica48: 505–530.
21.
RoemerJE (1981) Analytical Foundations of Marxian Economic Theory. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
22.
RoemerJE (1982) A General Theory of Exploitation and Class. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
23.
RoemerJE (2010) Kantian equilibrium. Scandinavian Journal of Economics112: 1–24.
24.
RoemerJE (2015) On the problem of socialist economic design. Journal of Theoretical Politics27(1): 34–42.
25.
RoemerJESilvestreJE (1993) The proportional solution for economies with both private and public ownership. Journal of Economic Theory59: 426–444.
26.
RoemerJEVenezianiR (2004) What we owe our children, they their children…. Journal of Public Economic Theory6: 637-654.
27.
SenAK (1978) On the labour theory of value: some methodological issues. Cambridge Journal of Economics2: 175–190.
28.
SenAK (1985) Commodities and Capabilities. Amsterdam: North-Holland.
29.
TornblomK (1992) The social-psychology of distributive justice. In: ShererKR (ed.), Justice: Interdisciplinary Perspectives. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
30.
VenezianiR (2007) Exploitation and time. Journal of Economic Theory132: 189–207.
31.
VenezianiR (2013) Exploitation, inequality, and power. Journal of Theoretical Politics, 25(4): 526–545.
32.
VenezianiRYoshiharaN (2012) Exploitation and profits: a general axiomatic approach in convex economies with heterogeneous agents. DP N.579, IER, Hitotsubashi University.
33.
YoshiharaN (2003) Characterizations of bargaining solutions in production economies with unequal skills. Journal of Economic Theory108: 256–285.
34.
YoshiharaN (2010) Class and exploitation in general convex cone economies. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization75: 281–296.
35.
YoshiharaNVenezianiR (2009) Exploitation as the Unequal Exchange of Labour: An Axiomatic Approach. Working paper N.655, Queen Mary University of London.
36.
YoshiharaNVenezianiR (2010) Commodity content in a general input–output model: a comment. Metroeconomica61: 740–748.
37.
YoshiharaNVenezianiR (2011) Strong subjectivism in the theory of exploitation: a critique. Metroeconomica62: 53–68.
38.
YoshiharaNVenezianiR (2012) Profits and exploitation: a reappraisal. Advances in Mathematical Economics16: 85–109.
39.
YoshiharaNVenezianiR (2013) Exploitation of labour and exploitation of commodities: a “New Interpretation”. Review of Radical Political Economics45: 517–524.
