There is anecdotal evidence of a crisis in the recruitment and retention of general practitioners nationwide and particularly in inner cities. The relationship between quality of service and single-handed or group practice is uncertain and confounded by other aspects of practice structure and populations. The review examines the factors that influence doctors to enter and remain in general practice. It explores whether initiatives designed to address problems of recruitment and retention have been evaluated in the past and suggests how could they inform current initiatives.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Al-BashirM.M.ArmstrongD.British Journal of General Practice1991; 41: 6–8.
2.
AllenI.Doctors and Their Careers.London: Policy Studies Institute, 1998.
3.
BakerD.KleinR.Explaining outputs of primary health care: Population and practice factors. British Medical Journal1991; 303: 225–9.
4.
BakerM.WilliamsJ.PetcheyR.GPs in principle but not in practice: A study of vocationally trained doctors not currently working as principals. British Medical Journal1995; 310: 1301–4.
5.
BakerR.StreatfieldJ.What type of general practice do patients prefer? Exploration of practice characteristics influencing patient satisfaction. British Journal of General Practice1995; 45: 654–9.
6.
BakerR.ThompsonJ.Innovation in general practice: Is the gap between training and non-training practices getting wider?British Journal of General Practice1995; 4: 297–300.
7.
BeardowR.CheungK.StylesW. McN.Factors influencing the career choices of general practitioner trainees in North West Thames Regional Health Authority. British Journal of General Practice1993; 43449–53.
8.
BoothL.Best of both worlds for GPs practising single-handed. Financial Pulse1989 March 7: 26–7.
9.
BosanquetN.JarmanB.Primary health care in London – changes since the Acheson report. British Medical Journal1992; 305: 1130–3.
10.
BrearleyS. Manpower. British Medical Journal1992; 304: 832–4.
11.
CampbellJ.L.The reported availability of GPs and the influence of practice list size. British Journal of General Practice1996; 46: 465–8.
12.
CarlisleR.JohnstoneS.Factors influencing the response to advertisements for general practice vancancies. British Medical Journal1996; 313: 468–71.
13.
CartwrightA.AndersonR.General Practice Revisited: a Second Study of Patients and Their Doctors.London: Tavistock, 1981.
14.
ChambersR.WallD.CampbellI. Stresses, Coping mechanisms and job satisfaction in general practitioner registrars. British Journal of General Practice1996; 46: 343–8.
15.
ChudleyP.Better service given by single-handed practitioners. Pulse1986; 26 April.
16.
ClaysonM.Choosing the right practice. The Practitioner1994; 238: 176–8.
17.
CresswellJ.Battling to boost the standing of small-scale care. Doctor1991 30 May.
18.
Department of Health. GP Statistics Released (H93/1038). London: Department of Health, 1993.
19.
Department of Health. Primary Care: The Future.London: NHSE, 1996.
20.
DonaldA.G.Retreat from general practice [Editorial]. British Medical Journal1990; 301: 1060.
21.
DugganM.Primary Health Care. A Prognosis.London: IPPR, 1995.
22.
EcclesL.M.TownsendS.J.How many doctors does Britain need?British Medical Journal1993; 306: 647–8.
23.
EdgarK.Favouring a mythological traditional orthodoxy is absurd. [Letter]British Medical Journal1996; 312: 1422.
24.
FreemanG.K.RichardsS.C.How much personal care in four group practices?British Medical Journal1990; 301: 1028–30.
25.
FreemanG.K.RichardsS.C.Is personal continuity of care compatible with free choice of doctor? Patients' view on seeing the same doctor. Journal of General Practice1993; 4: 493–7.
26.
FugelliP.HealthI.The nature of general practice. British Medical Journal1996; 312: 456–7.
27.
GilesS.Cost-effective solo GPs reject new call to merge. Pulse1991: 51.
28.
GMSC. General Medical Services Committee, task force reported Medicopolitical Digest1996; 312: 14.
29.
GreenJ.M.The views of single-handed general practitioners: A qualitative study. British Medical Journal1993; 307: 607–10.
30.
GriffithsA.O.A Team future for general practice [Letter]. British Medical Journal1992; 304
31.
GroenewegenP.P.HuttenJ.B.F.van der VeldenK.List size, composition of practice and general practitioners' workload in the Netherlands. Social Science and Medicine1992; 34: 263–70.
32.
HarrisT.SilverT.RinkE.HiltonS.Vocational training for general practice in inner London. Is there a dearth? And if so, what is to be done?British Medical Journal1996; 312: 97–101.
33.
HaydenJ.A team future for general practice. [Editorial]British Medical Journal1992; 304: 728–9.
34.
HaysR.B.SandersonL.Forming large group practices: Is it worth it?Medical Journal of Australia1994; 161: 494–6.
35.
HopkinsJ.General practitioners are not as beleaguered as they were. [Letter]British Medical Journal1996; 312, 1422.
36.
JohnsonN.HaslerJ.MantD.RandallT.JonesL.YudkinP.General practice careers: Changing experience of men and women vocational trainees between 1974 and 1989. British Journal of General Practice1993; 43: 141–5.
37.
KirwanM.ArmstrongD.Investigation of burnout in a sample of British general practitioners. British Journal of General Practice1995; 45: 259–6.
38.
KobeltG.Health Economics.London: Office of Health Economics, 1996.
39.
LambertT.W.GoldacreJ.J.EdwardsC.ParkhouseJ.Career preferences of doctors who qualified in the United Kingdom in 1993 compared with those of doctors qualiying in 1974, 1977, 1980 and 1983. British Medical Journal1996; 313: 19–24.
40.
LeechN.Nostalgia doesn't help recruitment. [Letter]British Medical Journal1996; 312: 1422–3.
41.
LeeseB.BosanquetN.Changes in general practice organisation: Survey of general practitioners' views on the 1990 contract and fundholding. British Journal of General Practice1996; 46: 95–9.
42.
LewisG.WilkinsonG.Another British disease? A recent increase in the prevalence of psychiatric morbidity. Journal Epidemiology and Community Health1994; 47: 358–61.
43.
London Health Planning Consortium. Primary Health Care Study Group: Primary Health Care In Inner London.London: Department of Health and Social Security, 1981.
44.
LynchM.A.Effect of practice and patient population characteristics on the uptake of childhood immunizations. British Journal of General Practice1995; 45: 205–8.
45.
McBrideM.MetcalfeD.General practitioners' low morale: Reasons and solutions. British Journal of General Practice1995 May: 227–9.
46.
McCarthyM.Wilson-DavisK.McGavockH.Relationship between the number of partners in a general practice and the number of different drugs prescribed by that practice. British Journal of General Practice1992; 42: 13–7.
47.
GrayPereira D.P.Recruitment in general practice. The Practitioner1990; 234: 1011.
48.
PowellM.A.Need for and provision of general practice in London. British Journal of General Practice1990; 40: 372–5.
49.
RCGP General Practitioner Workload (RCGP Information Sheet No. 3)London: RCGP, 1996.
50.
RowsellR.MorganM.SarangiJ.General practitioner registrars' views about a career in general practice. British Journal of General Practice1995; 45: 601–4.
51.
SnowiseN.G.General practice partnerships: Till death us do part?British Medical Journal1992; 305: 398–400.
52.
SoutterJ.EcclesM.P.NewtonJ.Can we understand partnerships in general practice? A pilot study. Family Practice1996; 13: 152–5.
53.
TaylorM.W.MilneR.TaylorR.J.DuncanR.The state of general practice computing in Scotland and the characteristics of computerised practices: A survey of 948 practices. Health Bulletin1991; 49: 250–8.
54.
ThomasK.NichollJ.ColemanP.Assessing the outcome of making it easier for patients to change general practitioner: Practice characteristics associated with patient movements. British Journal of General Practice45: 581–86.
55.
TomlinsonS.Solo GPs ‘fail to give 24-hour care’Pulse1991; 51: 20.
56.
TuppenJ.The service is abused because it is perceived as being free. [Letter]British Medical Journal1996; 312: 1422.
57.
VaughanC.Career choices for generation X. British Medical Journal311: 525–6.