Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

This study examines the effect of Independent Practice Association (IPA) HMO membership on hospital total charges, ancillary charges and length of stay (LOS) for surgical patients. Intrahospital comparisons of IPA and traditional insurance patients are made after adjusting for surgical procedure, admission severity of illness, age, sex and year of admission. Our multiple regression model indicates that IPA patients undergoing 12 frequently occurring surgical procedures have lower resource use. Eight (80%) of the 10 study hospitals exhibit a negative IPA beta coefficient for total charges, ancillary charges and LOS. Five (50%) hospitals have statistically significant (p <0.05) negative coefficients for total charges, while one (10%) hospital has a significant positive coefficient. IPA patients exhibit adjusted total charges that are 6% lower than traditional insurance, ancillary charges that are 4.3% lower, and LOS that is 10% shorter.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bradbury

R. C.

Golec

J. H.

Stearns

F. E.

(1991). ‘Comparing hospital length of stay in independent practice association HMOs and traditional insurance programs’. Inquiry, 28:52–58.

Brewster

A. C.

Karlin

B. G.

Hyde

L. A.

Jacobs

C. J.

Bradbury

R. C.

Chae

Y. M.

(1985). ‘MEDISGRPS: A clinically based assproach to classifying hospital patients at admission’. Inquiry, 22:377–87.

Corporate Cost Management. (1989). Hospital charge adjustment methodology: Documentation. Gaithersburg, MA: Corporate Cost Management.

Dowd

B. E.

Johnson

A. N.

Madson

R. A.

(1986). ‘Inpatient length of stay in Twin Cities health plans’. Medical Care, 24:294–310.

Feldstein

P. J.

Wickizer

T. M.

Wheeler

J. R.

(1988). ‘Private cost containment: The effects of utilization review programs on health care use and expenditures’. New England Journal of Medicine, 318:1310–14.

Gray

B. H.

Field

M. J.

(eds). (1989). Controlling costs and changing patient care? The role of utilization management by third parties. Report of the Committee on Utilization Management by Third Parties, Institute of Medicine. Washington D C: National Academy Press.

Hillman

A. L.

(1987). ‘Financial incentives for physicians in HMOs’. New England Journal of Medicine, 317:1743–48.

Johnson

A. N.

Dowd

Morris

N. E.

Lurie

. (1989). ‘Differences in inpatient resource use by type of health plan’. Inquiry, 26:388–98.

Hornbrook

M. C.

Berki

S. E.

(1985). ‘Practice mode and payment method — effects on use, costs, quality, and access. Medical Care, 23: 484–511.

10.

Langwell

K. M.

(1990). ‘Structure and performance of health maintenance organizations: A review’. Health Care Financing Review, 12:71–90.

11.

Langwell

K. M.

Hadley

J. P.

(1989). ‘Evaluation of the Medicare competition demonstrations’. Health Care Financing Review, 11:65–80.

12.

Langwell

K. L.

Rossiter

Brown

Nelson

Berman

. (1987). ‘Early experience of health maintenance organizations under Medicare competition demonstrations’. Health Care Financing Review, 8:37–55.

13.

Luft

H. S.

(1987). Health Maintenance Organizations: Dimensions of Performance., New Brunswick, N J: Transaction Books.

14.

Marion Laboratories (1990). Marion Managed Care Digest, HMO Edition., Kansas City, Missouri: Marion Laboratories.

15.

Morrison

E. M.

Luft

H. S.

(1990). ‘Health maintenance organization environments in the 1980s and beyond’. Health Care Financing Review, 12:81–89.

16.

Russell

L. B.

(1989). Medicare's New Hospital Payment System: Is it Working?, Washington, D C: Brookings Institution.

17.

Wickizer

T. M.

(1990). ‘The effect of utilization review on hospital use: A review of the literature and an update on recent findings’. Medical Care Review, 47: 3 27–63.

18.

Wickizer

T. M.

Wheeler

J. R.

Feldstein

P. J.

(1989). ‘Does utilization review reduce unnecessary care and contain costs?’. Medical Care, 27:632–46.

Comparing Surgical Efficiency in Independent Practice Association HMOS and Traditional Insurance Programs

Abstract

Get full access to this article

References