Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

The consumption of professional and non-professional nursing resources on medical/surgical nursing units varies sharply among community hospitals. In an effort to explain the variation, this study examines several factors: socio-economic characteristics of the population; supply of registered nurses; hospital characteristics such as size, complexity and diversity of services; patient characteristics such as case mix index and nursing care acuity index; and production system characteristics such as efficiency of technical support systems and the structure of nursing care delivery.

Nursing skill mix varies more than the staffing levels among hospitals. The research suggests that factors associated with a clinical-rational model such as nursing acuity index and the efficiency of clinical/support systems explains little, whereas factors associated with economic-rational model of hospital revenues – like case mix, number of hospital services, poverty (through Medicaid program) and age distribution (through Medicare program) – do significantly affect nursing resource consumption. The results point to the presence of resource allocation to nursing based on hospital revenues rather than patient care needs.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Berke

(1954). ‘Centralized transportation service’. Modern Hospital, 82: 88–9.

Coffey

R. M.

Farley

D. E.

Lind

Wilson

(1988). ‘Nursing shortage in the hospital sector, 1982–87’. Secretary's Commission on Nursing, Volume II. Department of Health and Human Services.

Cromwell

Hewes

H. T.

Kelly

N. L.

Franklin

(1987). ‘Comparative trends in hospital expenses, finances, utilization, and inputs, 1970–81’. Health Care Financing Review, 9 (7).

Dornblaster

B. M.

Piedmont

E. B.

(1970). ‘Designing for nursing unit efficiency: A multi-disciplinary evaluation’. Health Services Research, 228–32.

Feldstein

P. J.

(1988). Health Care Economics. Wiley Series in Health Services. New York: John Wiley & Sons Inc., p 414.

Fetter

R. B.

Shin

Freeman

J. L.

Averil

R. F.

(1980). ‘Case mix definition by diagnosis-relating groups. Medical Care, 18 (1), supplement.

Flood

A. B.

Scott

W. R.

(1987). Hospital Structure and Performance. Johns Hopkins University Press.

Friesen

G. A.

(1986). ‘A mechanized supply system provides supplies where needed’. Hospitals, 40: 109–12.

Genrose

(ed) (1980). All-RN Nursing Staff. Nursing Resources, Concept Development Inc.

10.

Gentile

(1976). Patient Transportation — Presbyterian Hospital. Report No MT 0787, Center for Hospital Management Engineering, American Hospital Association, Chicago, IL.

11.

Giovanetti

Patient Classification Systems in Nursing: A Description and Analysis. DHEW Publication No (HRA) 78–22, HRP-0500501, National Technical Information Service, Department of Commerce, Springfield, VA 22161.

12.

Knickman

J. R.

Foltz

A-M.

(1985). ‘A statistical analysis of reasons for east-west differences in hospital use’. Inquiry, 22: 45–58.

13.

Kraegel

Mousseau

Goldsmith

Arora

(1974). Patient Care Systems. Philadelphia, PA: J. B. Lippincott Co.

14.

Lyons

McFaul

(1982). ‘Addressing the nursing shortage through materials management’. Hospital Materials Management Quarterly, 3 (4): 61–6.

15.

McKibbin

Brimmer

Clinton

Galliher

(1985). DRGs and Nursing Care. American Nurses Association, HCFA, Grant No 13-C-98421/7-02. Kansas City: ANA.

16.

Meyer

(1978). ‘Workload management system ensures stable nurse-patient ratio’. Hospitals, 52: 81–5.

17.

Reynolds

D. M.

Johnson

M. H.

Longe

R. L.

‘Medication delivery time requirements in centralized and decentralized unit dose drug distribution systems’. American Journal of Hospital Pharmacy, 35: 941–3.

18.

Rothberg

(1982). ‘Regional variations in hospital use: Introduction and overview’. In Rothberg

(ed) Regional Variations in Hospital Use: Geographic and Temporal Patterns in the US. Boston: D. C. Heath & Co.

19.

Schwartz

(1982). Demographic Trends and Hospital Utilization: The Elderly Population. Office of Public Policy Analysis, Policy Brief 41. Chicago: AHA.

20.

Shukla

R. K.

(1982). ‘Nursing care structures and productivity’. Hospital and Health Services Administration, November/December.

21.

Shukla

R. K.

(1983a). ‘All-RN model of nursing care delivery: A cost benefit evaluation’. Inquiry, 184–97.

22.

Shukla

R. K.

(1983b). ‘Technical and structural support systems and nurse utilization: Systems model’. Inquiry, 20: 381–9.

23.

Shukla

R. K.

(1986), Structure vs People and Nursing Performances: An Evaluation Study. Final Report, Grant No HS 03635, National Center for Health Services Research, Department of Health and Human Services.

24.

Shukla

R. K.

(1987). ‘The theory of support systems and nursing performance’. In Lewis

Spicer

J. G.

(eds) Human Resource Management Handbook. Rockville, MD: Aspen.

25.

Shukla

R. K.

Durney

(1984). Strategies for Improving Nurse-Utilization: A Historical Perspective – 1945–1982. Department of Health Administration, Medical College of Virginia, Virginia Commonwealth University, Richmond, Virginia.

26.

Simborg

D. W.

(1972). ‘Ward information management system: An evaluation’. Computers and Biomedical Research, 5: 484–97.

27.

Wan

Shukla

R. K.

(1987). ‘The contextual and organizational correlates of the quality of hospital nursing care’. Quality Review Bulletin, 13 (2): 61–64.

28.

Wilson

Prescott

P. A.

Aleksandrowicz

(1988). ‘Nursing: A major hospital cost component. Health Services Research, 22: 6.

29.

Wilson

Tedeschi

(1984). ‘Community correlates of hospital use’, Health Services Research, 19: 333–56.

30.

Wolf

Young

J. P.

(1965). ‘Staffing the nursing unit, part 1. Controlled variable staffing’. Nursing Research, 14 (3): 236–43.

Factors and Perspectives Affecting Nursing Resource Consumption in Community Hospitals

Abstract

Get full access to this article

References