This paper examines the data and research findings on hospital closures in order to understand better the phenomenon and to evaluate the seriousness of its impact. It presents a description of the patterns and trends and, from this, attempts to identify the factors which contribute to closings and the effects on the community, the physicians, and other hospitals. In examining the research findings, a number of managerial and research propositions are identified.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AlexanderJ. A.AmburgeyT. L. (1987). ‘The dynamics of change in the American hospital industry: Transformation or selection?’ Medical Care Review, 44 (2): 279–321.
2.
AlexanderJ. A.KaluznyA. D.MiddletonS. C. (1986). ‘Organizational growth, survival and death in the US hospital industry: A population ecology perspective’. Social Science and Medicine, 22 (3): 303–8.
3.
AltmanD.KilsteinS. M. (1983). ‘Hospital closures in perspective’. Health Services Research, 18 (Winter): 587–92.
4.
BerryD. E.SeaveyJ.TuckerT. (1988). ‘Frontier hospitals: Endangered species and public policy issue’. Hospital & Health Services Administration, 33 (4): 481–96.
5.
BickersC. R. (1986). ‘Demise of a hospital: The financial manager's perspective’. Healthcare Financial Review, 47 (January): 47.
6.
BrombergM. (1983). ‘Hospital closures’. Health Services Research, 18 (Winter): 579–91.
7.
BurdaD. (1988). ‘Hospital closures top record at 79-AHA’. Modern Healthcare, 18 (25 March): 4.
BurdaD.GreeneJ. (1989). ‘AHA closure list questioned’. Modern Healthcare, 19 (3 March): 6.
11.
CannedyL. L.PointerD. D.RuchlinH. S. (1973). ‘Viability and hospital failure: Methodological considerations and empirical evidence’. Health Services Research, 8 (27): 27–36.
12.
CherskovM. (1986). ‘Bankruptcy: Will it happen to you?’ Hospitals, 60 (5 December): 44–8.
13.
CleverleyW. O.NilsenK. (1980). ‘Assessing financial position with 29 key ratios’. Hospital Financial Management, 34 (1): 30–4.
14.
DallekG. (1983). ‘The loss of hospitals serving the poor’. Health Services Research, 18 (Winter): 593–7.
15.
DineD. D. (1988). ‘Clash between mission and money results in bankruptcy for Catholic hospital’. Modern Healthcare, 18 (2 September): 73–5.
16.
DombroskS.TracyR. M. (1978). ‘Impact of hospital closures on nearby hospitals studied’. Hospitals, 52 (1 December): 82–5.
17.
DranoveD.SatterthwaiteM.SindelarJ. (1986). ‘The effect of injecting price competition into the hospital market: The case of preferred provider organizations’. Inquiry, 23: 419–31.
18.
EricksonG. M.FinklerS. A. (1985). ‘Determinants of market share for a hospital's services’. Medical Care, 23 (8): 1003–18.
19.
ErmannD.AronoffR. (1980). ‘A study of central-city hospital changes’. Medical Care, 18 (7): 745–53.
20.
FalikM. (1983). ‘Hospital financial viability: When is government intervention appropriate?’ Health Services Research, 18 (Winter): 582–6.
21.
FihnS. D.WicherJ. B. (1988). ‘Withdrawing routine outpatient medical services: Effects on access and health’. Journal of General Internal Medicine, 3 (July/August): 356–62.
22.
FirsheinJ. (1986). ‘Rural hospitals get relief, but battle's not over’. Hospitals, 60 (5 December): 26–7.
23.
FrederickL. (1985). ‘Why rural hospitals are going down for the count’. Medical Economics (19 August): 25–33.
24.
FriedmanE. (1978). ‘The end of the line: When a hospital closes’. Hospitals, 52: 69–75.
25.
FriedmanE. (1987). ‘Demise of Philadelphia General an instructive case: Other cities treat public hospital ills differently’. JAMA, 257 (27 March): 1571–5.
26.
GiffordB. D.MullnerR. M. (1988). ‘Modeling hospital closure relative to organizational theory: The applicability of ecology theory's environmental determinism and adaptation perspectives’. Social Science and Medicine, 27 (11): 1287–94.
27.
GottliebS. R. (1978). ‘Reducing excess hospital capacity is a tough but necessary job’. Hospitals, 52: 63–8.
28.
GrossmanJ. H. (1986). ‘Community commitment, competition, and the future of academic medical centers’. Inquiry, 23: 245–52.
29.
HarrisJ. E. (1977). ‘The internal organization of hospitals: Some economic implications’. The Bell Journal of Economics, 8: 467–82.
30.
HendersonJ. A. (1988). ‘Wave of hospital closings is only one side of healthier story about market adjustment’. Modern Healthcare, 18 (9 September): 81.
31.
HernandezS. R.KaluznyA. D. (1983). ‘Hospital closure: A review of current and proposed research’. Health Services Research, 18 (Fall): 419–36.
32.
HofferberM. (1989). ‘Hospitals in critical condition’. Emergency (January): 45–7.
33.
HurleyR. E.KaluznyA. D. (1987). Organizational ecology and health services research: New answers for old and new questions'. Medical Care Review, 44 (2): 235–55.
34.
KennedyL.DumasM. B. (1983). ‘Hospital closures and survivals: An analysis of operating characteristics and regulatory mechanisms in three states’. Health Services Research, 18 (Winter): 489–512.
35.
LarkinH. (1989a). ‘Old and poor: Small rurals on financial edge’. Hospitals, 62 (20 November): 32–4.
36.
LarkinH. (1988b). ‘Industry financial crisis may be eased by hospital closures’. Hospitals, 62 (20 November): 34–6.
37.
LarkinH. (1988c). ‘Higher occupancy hasn't meant higher margins, at least in the Northeast’. Hospitals, 62 (20 November): 36–8.
38.
LongoD. R.ChaseG. A. (1984). ‘Structural determinants of hospital closure’. Medical Care, 22: 388–02.
39.
MannistoM. (1982). ‘Hospitals face 1,000 closures by 1990’. Hospitals, 56 (1 April): 23–4.
40.
MayerJ. D.KohlenbergE. R.SiefermanG. E.RosenblattR. A. (1987). ‘Patterns of rural hospital closure in the United States’. Social Science and Medicine, 24 (49): 327–34.
41.
McLaffertyS. (1982). ‘Neighborhood characteristics and hospital closures’. Social Science and Medicine, 16: 1667–74.
42.
McLaffertyS. (1988). ‘Predicting the effect of hospital closure on hospital utilization patterns’. Social Science and Medicine, 27 (3): 255–62.
43.
McNeilD.WilliamsR. (1978). Wide range of causes found for hospital closures'. Hospitals, 52: 76–81.
44.
MullnerR.ByreC. S.KubalJ. D. (1980). ‘Closed US community hospitals, 1972–1978: Perspectives and trends’. Social Sciences and Medicine, 14: 355–60.
45.
MullnerR.ByreC. S.KubalJ. D. (1983). ‘Hospital closure in the United States, 1976–1980: A descriptive overview’. Health Services Research, 18 (Fall): 437–50.
46.
MullnerR.ByreC. S.LevyP. S.KubalJ. D. (1982). ‘Closure among US community hospitals, 1976–1980’. Medical Care, 20: 699–709.
47.
MullnerR.KralovecP.McNeilD. (1987). ‘45% more community hospitals closed in '86‘. Hospitals, 32 (5 May): 32–4.
48.
MullnerR.McNeilD. (1986a). ‘Closings continue to hit smaller hospitals’. Hospitals, 60 (5 April): 93.
49.
MullnerR.McNeilD. (1986b). ‘Rural and urban hospital closures: A comparison’. Health Affairs, 5 (3): 131–41.
50.
MullnerR.McNeilD. L.AndesS. (1986). ‘Hospital closure: Who will be at risk in the upcoming decade?’ Healthcare Financial Management (January): 42–8.
MullnerR.RydmanR. J.WhitesD. G.RichR. F. (1989). ‘Rural community hospitals and factors correlated with their risk of closing’. Public Health Reports, 104 (4): 315–25.
53.
MullnerR.WhiteisD. G.McNeilD. (1988). ‘Record year for closures in 1987’. Hospitals, 62 (5 April): 33–6.
54.
PleinesK. M.WilliamsH. (1978). ‘Planning with the community in mind can prevent hospital closings’. Hospitals, 52: 87–90.
55.
PomrinseS. D. (1983). ‘Comments on hospital closings in New York City’. Health Services Research, 18 (Winter): 575–8.
56.
RiceM. F. (1987). ‘Inner city hospital closures/relocations: Race, income status, and legal issues’. Social Science and Medicine, 24 (11): 889–96.
57.
RobinsonM. L. (1988). ‘Economists see closures, cost cuts ahead’. Hospitals, 62 (5 January): 23–6.
58.
RyanG. M.FieldenJ. G. (1978). ‘The closure of maternity services in Massachusetts’. Obstetrics and Gynecology, 52 (3): 369–70.
SchwartzW. B.NewhouseJ. P.WilliamsA. P. (1985). ‘Is the teaching hospital an endangered species?’ The New England Journal of Medicine, 313: 157–62.
61.
SchatzkinA. (1984). ‘The relationship of inpatient racial composition and hospital closure in New York City’. Medical Care, 22: 379–87.
62.
SeayD.VladeckB. C.KramerP. S.GouldD. A.McCormackJ. J. (1986). ‘Holding fast to the good: The future of the voluntary hospital’. Inquiry, 23: 253–60.
63.
SheingoldS.BuchbergerT. (1986). ‘Implications of Medicare's Prospective Payment System for the provision of uncompensated hospital care’. Inquiry, 23: 371–81.
64.
ShepardD. S. (1983). ‘Estimating the effect of hospital closure on areawide inpatient hospital costs: A preliminary model and application’. Health Services Research, 18 (Winter): 513–49.
65.
SolovyA. T. (1988). ‘Plant closing provision would include hospitals’. Hospitals, 62 (20 June): 28.
66.
SolovyA. (1989). ‘Hospital closings reach 81 in 1988: AHA report’. Hospitals, 63 (5 March): 67.
