System-wide lean implementation in health care: A multiple case study

Abstract

Background

Lean practices have been widely used by health care organizations to meet efficiency, performance and quality improvement needs. The lean health care literature shows that the effective implementation of lean requires a holistic system-wide approach. However, there is still limited evidence on what drives effective system-wide lean implementation in health care. The existing literature suggests that a deeper understanding of how lean interventions interact with the organizational context is necessary to identify the critical variables to successfully sustain system-wide lean strategies.

Purpose and methodology: A multiple case study of three Italian hospitals is conducted with the aim to explore the organizational conditions that are relevant for an effective system-wide lean implementation. A conceptual framework, built on socio-technical system schemas, is used to guide data collection and analysis.

Findings: The analysis points out the importance to support lean implementation with an integrated and coordinated strategy involving the social, technical, and external components of the overall hospital system.

Keywords

health care implementation process lean multiple case study socio-technical system system-wide

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Walshe

Pseudoinnovation: the development and spread of healthcare quality improvement methodologies. Int J Qual Health Care 2009; 21: 153–159.

D’Andreamatteo

Ianni

Lega

et al . Lean in healthcare: a comprehensive review. Health Policy 2015; 119: 1197–1209.

Mazzocato

Savage

Brommels

et al . Lean thinking in healthcare: a realist review of the literature. Qual Safe Health Care 2010; 19: 376–382.

Carbone

Lega

Marsilio

et al.

Lean on lean? Indagine sul perché e come il lean management si sta diffondendo nelle aziende sanitarie italiane. In: Anessi Pessina

and Cantù

(eds) L’Aziendalizzazione della sanità italiana rapporto oasi. Milano: Egea, 2013, pp.393–427.

Ohno

Toyota production system: beyond large-scale production. Portland, OR: Productivity Press, 1988.

Womack

and Jones

DT.

Beyond Toyota: how to root our waste and pursue perfection. Harvard Business Rev 1996; 74: 140–158.

Hines

Holweg

and Rich

Learning to evolve. Int J Operat Prod Manage 2004; 24: 994–1011.

Holweg

The genealogy of lean production. J Operat Manage 2007; 25: 420–437.

Womack

Jones

and Roos

The machine that changed the world. New York: Rawson Associates, 1990.

10.

Waring

and Bishop

Lean healthcare: rhetoric, ritual and resistance. Soc Sci Med 2010; 71: 1332–1340.

11.

Brandao de Souza

Trends and approaches in lean healthcare. Leaders Health Serv 2009; 22: 121–139.

12.

Andersen

Røvik

and Ingebrigtsen

Lean thinking in hospitals: is there a cure for the absence of evidence? A systematic review of reviews. BMJ Open 2014; 4: e003873.

13.

Radnor

and Walley

Learning to walk before we try to run: adapting lean for the public sector. Pub Manage Rev 2008; 28: 13–20.

14.

Radnor

Implementing lean in health care: making the link between the approach, readiness and sustainability. Int J Ind Eng Manage 2011; 2: 1–12.

15.

Radnor

Holweg

and Warning

Lean in healthcare: the unfilled promise?

Soc Sci Med 2012; 74: 364–371.

16.

Andersen

How to design lean interventions to enable impact, sustainability and effectiveness. A mixed-method study. J Hosp Admin 2015; 4: 18–25.

17.

Brandao de Souza

and Pidd

Exploring the barriers to lean healthcare implementation. Publ Money Manage 2011; 31: 59–66.

18.

Centauri

Marsilio

Villa

et al . Implementare il modello Lean nelle organizzazioni sanitarie: il caso dell’Ospedale Galliera. Mecosan 2016; 100: 27–55.

19.

Al-Balushi

Sohal

Singh

et al . Readiness factors for lean implementation in healthcare settings – a literature review. J Health Organ Manag 2014; 28: 135–153.

20.

Aherne

Think lean. Nurs Manage 2007; 13: 13–15.

21.

Barlow

RD.

Performance improvement programs fighting a loss cause. Healthcare Purchas News 2009b; 33: 8–10.

22.

Bliss

Lean in healthcare – wow. Front Health Serv Manage 2009; 26: 39–42.

23.

Fillingham

Can lean save lives?

Leadersh Health Serv 2007; 20: 231–241.

24.

Graban

and Swartz

JE.

Change for health. Manage Serv 2012; 56: 35–39.

25.

Holden

RJ.

Lean thinking in emergency departments: a critical review. Ann Emerg Med 2011; 57: 265–278.

26.

Kim

Spahlinger

Kin

et al . Lean health care: what can hospitals learn from a world-class automaker? J Hosp Med 2006; 1: 191–199.

27.

Lodge

and Bamford

Health service improvement through diagnostic waiting list management. Leaders Health Serv 2007; 20: 254–265.

28.

Pedersen

ERG

and Huniche

Determinants of lean success and failure in the Danish public sector: a negotiated order perspective. Intl J Pub Sec Manage 2011; 24: 403–420.

29.

Radnor

Walley

Stephens

et al . Evaluation of the lean approach to business management and its use in the public sector. Edimburgh: Scottish Executive Social Research, 2006.

30.

Radnor

and Bucci

Evaluation of pacesetter, lean, senior leadership and operational management within HMRC processing. London: HM Revenue & Customs, 2007.

31.

Radnor

and Osborne

Lean: a failed theory for public services?

Pub Manage Rev 2013; 15: 265–287.

32.

Barlow

RD.

Efficiency dieting in supply chain operations. Healthcare Purchas News, Ind Guide 2009a; 8–11.

33.

Grant

and Wilcox

Uncorking bottlenecks. Health Manage Technol 2008; 29: 32–35.

34.

Joosten

Bongers

and Janssen

Application of lean thinking to health care: issues and observations. Int J Qual Health Care 2009; 21: 341–347.

35.

Nicosia

and Nicosia

Tecniche lean in sanità: più valore, meno spreco, meno errori col sistema toyota. Milano: FrancoAngeli, 2008.

36.

Spear

SJ.

Fixing healthcare from the inside, today. Harv Bus Rev 2005; 83: 78–91

37.

Stroupe

JM.

It’s the process: how lean strategies can streamline hospital design. Health Facil Manage 2012; 2: 25–23.

38.

Chan

Lee

LLY

et al . Lean techniques for the improvement of patients’ flow in emergency department. World J Emerg Med 2014; 5: 24–28.

39.

Dickson

Singh

Cheung

et al . Application of lean manufacturing techniques in the emergency department. J Emerg Med 2009; 37: 177–182.

40.

Nicosia

Flussi sotto controllo nell’ospedale snello e per intensità di cure. Manag Sanità. 2008; 34–38.

41.

Nicosia

Il nuovo ospedale è snello. Far funzionare gli ospedali con il lean healthcare: consigli pratici e sostenibilità. Milano: FrancoAngeli, 2010.

42.

Noble

and Lee

Just right: designing for hospital efficiency and flexibility. Health Facil Manage 2010; 23: 23–25.

43.

Soriano-Meier

Forrester

Markose

et al . The role of the physical layout in the implementation of lean management initiatives. Lean Six Sigma J 2011; 2: 254–269.

44.

Benneyan

Reduce process variation to drive improvements in quality. Hosp Health Networks 2011; 85: 16–17.

45.

Grunden

Lean at the front line: all hands on deck. Front Health Serv Manage 2009; 26: 33–37.

46.

Poksinska

The current state of Lean implementation in health care. A literature review. Qual Manage Health Care 2010; 19: 319–329.

47.

Toussaint

Why are we still underperforming?

Front Health Serv Manage 2009; 26: 27–32.

48.

Towne

Lean transformations: planning a ‘lean’ health care makeover. Health Facil Manage 2010; 23: 51–54.

49.

Westwood

James-Moore

Cooke

Going lean in the NHS. Coventry: NHS Institute for Innovation and Improvement, 2007.

50.

Kollberg

Dahlgaard

and Brehemer

Measuring lean initiatives in health care services: issues and findings. Int J Product Perf Mgmt 2007; 56: 7–24.

51.

Trist

and Bamforth

Some social and psychological consequences of the Longwall method. Hum Relat 1951; 4: 3–38.

52.

Leavitt

HJ.

Applying organizational change in industry: structural, technological and humanistic approaches. In: March JG (ed) Handbook of organizations. Chicago, IL, USA: Rand McNally, 1965, pp.1144–1170.

53.

Keating

Fernandez

Jacobs

et al . A methodology for analysis of complex socio-technical processes. Business Proc Manag J 2001; 7: 33–50.

54.

Davis

Challenger

Jayewardene

DNW

et al . Advancing socio-technical systems thinking: a call for bravery. Appl Ergonom 2014; 45: 171–180.

55.

Boulding

General systems theory – the skeleton of the science. Manage Sci 1956; 2: 197–208.

56.

Von Bertalanffy

General system theory: foundations, development, applications. New York: George Braziller Inc., 1969.

57.

Cherns

The principles of sociotechnical design. Hum Relat 1976; 29: 783–792.

58.

Dixon-Woods

and Martin

GP.

Does quality improvement improve quality?

Future Hosp J 2016; 3: 191–194.

59.

Marsilio

Torbica

and Villa

Health care multidisciplinary teams: the sociotechnical approach for an integrated system-wide perspective. Health Care Manage Rev 2016; 42: 303–314.

60.

Lega

Organizational design and development for healthcare services. New York: McGraw-Hill, 2005.

61.

Leatt

and Mapa

Government relations in the health care industry. London: Praeger, 2003.

62.

Moseley

Managing health care business strategy. Burlington: Jones & Bartlett Learning, 2008.

63.

Rivers

and Glover

SH.

Health care competition, strategic mission, and patient satisfaction: research model and propositions. J Health Organ Manag 2008; 22: 627–641.

64.

Mazzocato

Thor

Backman

et al . Complexity complicates lean: lessons from seven emergency services. J Health Organ Manage 2014; 28: 266–288.

65.

Eriksson

Holden

Williamsson

et al . A case study of three Swedish hospitals’ strategies for implementing lean production. Nordic J Work Life Studies 2016; 6: 105–131.

66.

Yin

RK.

Case study research: design and methods. 3rd ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, 2003.

67.

Anessi Pessina

Jommi

and Cantù

New funding arrangements in the Italian National Health Service. Int J Health Plann Manage 2001; 16: 347–368.

68.

Eisenhardt

Building theories from case study research. Acad Manage Rev 1989; 14: 532–550.

69.

Hsieh

and Shannon

SE.

Three approaches to qualitative content analysis. Qual Health Res 2005; 15: 1277–1288.

70.

Pope

Ziebland

and Mays

Qualitative research in healthcare. Analysing qualitative data.

BMJ 2000; 320: 114–116. Br Med J

71.

Graneheim

and Lundman

Qualitative content analysis in nursing research: concepts, procedures and measures to achieve trustworthiness. Nurse Educ Today. 2004; 24: 105–112.

72.

Andreasson

Eriksson

and Dellve

Health care managers’ views on and approaches to implementing models for improving care processes. J Nurs Manag 2016; 24: 219–227.

73.

Drotz

and Poksinska

Lean healthcare from employees’ perspectives. J Health Organ Manage 2014; 28: 177–195.

74.

Villa

Barbieri

and Lega

Restructuring patient flow logistics around patient care needs: implications and practicalities from three critical cases. Health Care Manag Sci 2009; 12: 155–165.

75.

Lega

and Calciolari

Coevolution of patients and hospitals: how changing epidemiology and technological advances create challenges and drive organizational innovation. J Healthcare Manage 2012; 57: 17–33.

76.

Gabutti

Mascia

and Cicchetti

Exploring “patient-centered” hospitals: a systematic review to understand change. BMC Health Serv Res 2017; 17: 364.

77.

Bohmer

Medicine’s service challenge: blending custom and standard care.

Health Care Manage Rev 2005; 30: 322–330.

78.

Chambers

Glasgow

and Stange

KC.

The dynamic sustainability framework: addressing the paradox of sustainment amid ongoing change. Implement Sci 2013; 8: 117.