Physician perceived market competition associated with barriers to delivery of quality care: Evidence from a national cross-sectional survey of physicians in the USA
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online February, 2015
Physician perceived market competition associated with barriers to delivery of quality care: Evidence from a national cross-sectional survey of physicians in the USA
While quality is of paramount concern in health care, there has been little research done examining physician attitudes towards quality of health care and their perceived competitiveness in the market place. Utilizing the national physician survey data (n = 4720), we undertook a bivariate and multivariate regression analysis to explore the association between physician perceived competition and barriers to quality of care. After adjusting personal and organizational factors, two quality care measures were found to be related to increased physician perceived market competition: (1) inadequate mechanism (patient’s inability to pay for care); (2) variations in practice (medical errors and untimeliness of medical reports). Overall our findings suggest the association between perceived market competition and barriers to quality of care. In physicians’ views the current managed care market system appears to be competitive but this market competition may not benefit practicing physicians in improving quality of patient care.
Institute of Medicine. Crossing the quality chasm: A new health system for the 21st century, Washington, DC: National Academy Press, 2001.
2.
Institute of Medicine. Preventing medication errors: Quality chasm series, Washington, DC: National Academy Press, 2007.
3.
WongHSMcNamaraPGreenbergW. Provider competition and health care quality: Challenges and opportunities for research. Int J Health Care Finance Econ2004; 4: 99–111.
4.
Gaynor M. What do we know about competition and quality in health care markets? NBER Working Paper. 2006.
5.
McGuireTGPaulyMV. Physician response to fee changes with multiple payers. J Health Econ1991; 10: 385–410.
6.
VickersJ. Concepts of competition. Oxford Econ Papers1995; 47: 1–23.
7.
Enthoven AC and Tollen LA. Competition in health care: It takes systems to pursue quality and efficiency. Health Aff (Millwood) 2005; Suppl Web Exclusives: W5-420-33.
8.
PorterMETeisbergEO. Redefining competition in health care. Harv Bus Rev2004; 82: 64–76, 136.
9.
MooneyGRyanM. Agency in health care: Getting beyond first principles. J Health Econ1993; 12: 125–135.
10.
ReinhardtUE. The theory of physician-induced demand reflections after a decade. J Health Econ1985; 4: 187–193.
11.
RiceTH. The impact of changing Medicare reimbursement rates on physician-induced demand. Med Care1983; 21: 803–815.
12.
BresnahanTReissP. Entry and competition in concentrated markets. J Polit Econ1991; 99: 977–1009.
13.
BrasureMStearnsSCNortonEC. Competitive behavior in local physician markets. Med Care Res Rev1999; 56: 395–414.
14.
CrandallLADwyerJWDuncanRP. Recruitment and retention of rural physicians: Issues for the 1990s. J Rural Health1990; 6: 19–38.
15.
SzafranOCrutcherRAChaytorsRG. Location of family medicine graduates’ practices. What factors influence Albertans’ choices?Can Fam Phys2001; 47: 2279–2285.
16.
RosenthalTCRosenthalGLLucasCA. Factors in the physician practice location puzzle: A survey of New York State residency-trained family physicians. J Am Board Fam Pract1992; 5: 265–273.
17.
GafniACharlesCWhelanT. The physician-patient encounter: The physician as a perfect agent for the patient versus the informed treatment decision-making model. Soc Sci Med1998; 47: 347–354.
18.
ScanlonDSwaminathanSLeeW. Does competition improve health care quality?Health Serv Res2008; 43: 1931–1951.
19.
FangHRizzoJ. Competition and physician-enabled demand: The role of managed care. J Econ Behav Organ2009; 72: 463–474.
20.
BovbjergRMarstellerJ. Health care market competition in six states: Implications for the poor, Washington, DC: The Urban Institute, 1998.
21.
FeldmanRSloanF. Competition among physicians, revisited. J Health Polit Policy Law1988; 13: 239–239.
22.
De JaegherKJegersM. A model of physician behaviour with demand inducement. J Health Econ2000; 19: 231–258.
23.
RossiterLWilenskyG. Identification of physician-induced demand. J Human Resour1984; 19: 231–244.
24.
ReinhardtUE. The theory of physician-induced demand: Reflections after a decade. J Health Econ1985; 4: 187–193.
25.
CromwellJMitchellJB. Physician-induced demand for surgery. J Health Econ1986; 5: 293–313.
26.
RizzoJABlumenthalD. Physician income targets: New evidence on an old controversy. Inquiry1994; 31: 394–404.
27.
CalemPRizzoJ. Competition and specialization in the hospital industry: An application of the Hotelling’s location model. South Econ J1995; 61: 1182–1198.
28.
BeitiaA. Hospital quality choice and market structure in a regulated duopoly. J Health Econ2003; 22: 1011–1036.
29.
TayA. Assessing competition in hospital care markets: The importance of accounting for quality differentiation. Rand J Econ2003; 34: 786–814.
30.
ShenYC. The effect of financial pressure on the quality of care in hospitals. J Health Econ2003; 22: 243–269.
31.
HoVHamiltonB. Hospital mergers and acquisitions: Does market consolidation harm patients?J Health Econ2000; 19: 767–791.
32.
MorriseyMA. Competition in hospital and health insurance markets: A review and research agenda. Health Serv Res2001; 36: 191–221.
33.
PaulyMV. Competition in medical services and the quality of care: Concepts and history. Int J Health Care Finance Econ2004; 4: 113–130.
34.
RomanoPSMutterR. The evolving science of quality measurement for hospitals: Implications for studies of competition and consolidation. Int J Health Care Finance Econ2004; 4: 131–157.
35.
ShortellSHughesE. The effects of regulation, competition, and ownership on mortality rates among hospital inpatients. N Engl J Med1988; 318: 1100–1107.
36.
ThomsonR. Competition among hospitals in the United States. Health Policy1994; 27: 205–231.
37.
KesslerDMcClellanM. Is hospital competition socially wasteful?Quart J Econ2000; 115: 577–615.
38.
KesslerDGeppertJ. The effects of competition on variation in the quality and cost of medical care. J Econ Manage Strategy2005; 14: 575–589.
39.
LiuHPhelpsCE. Nonprice competition and quality of care in managed care: The New York SCHIP market. Health Serv Res2008; 43: 971–987.
40.
The Center for Studying Health System Change. CTS Physician Surveys and the HSC 2008 Health Tracking Physician Survey 2008. http://www.hschange.com/index.cgi?data=04 (accessed 28 July 2010).
41.
Strouse R, Potter F, Davis T, et al. Health tracking physician survey methodology report. Washington, DC: Center for Studying Health System Change. http://www.hschange.com/CONTENT/1085/1085.pdf (2009, accessed 1 December 2010).
42.
Audet A-M, Doty MM, Shamasdin J, et al. Physicians’ views on quality of care: Findings from the Commonwealth Fund national survey of physicians and quality of care. The Commonwealth Fund, 2005.
43.
BlendonRJSchoenCDonelanK. Physicians’ views on quality of care: A five-country comparison. Health Affairs2001; 20: 233–243.
44.
DavisKDotyMMSheaK. Health information technology and physician perceptions of quality of care and satisfaction. Health Policy2009; 90: 239–246.
45.
FangHPeiferKLChenJ. Health information technology and physicians’ perceptions of healthcare quality. Am J Manag Care2011; 17: e66–70.
46.
National Institutes of Health. National Asthma Education and Prevention Program (NAEPP), Expert Panel Report: Guidelines for the Diagnosis and Management of Asthma. Bethesda, MD, 1991, pp. 91–3042.
47.
LaraMAllenFLangeL. Physician perceptions of barriers to care for inner-city Latino children with asthma. J Health Care Poor Underserved1999; 10: 27–44.
48.
Martin RolandD. Linking physicians’ pay to the quality of care—a major experiment in the United Kingdom. N Engl J Med2004; 2004: 1448–1454.
49.
LindenauerPKRemusDRomanS. Public reporting and pay for performance in hospital quality improvement. N Engl J Med2007; 356: 486–496.
50.
HarrisonJPLambiaseLRZhaoM. Organizational factors associated with quality of care in US teaching hospitals. J Health Care Finance2010; 36: 1–12.
51.
BrennanTAHebertLELairdNM. Hospital characteristics associated with adverse events and substandard care. JAMA1991; 265: 3265–3269.
52.
ChristianAHMillsTSimpsonSL. Quality of cardiovascular disease preventive care and physician/practice characteristics. J Gen Intern Med2006; 21: 231–237.
53.
BertholdHGouni-BertholdIBestehornK. Physician gender is associated with the quality of type 2 diabetes care. J Intern Med2008; 264: 340–350.
54.
RosenblattRAHartLGBaldwinLM. The generalist role of specialty physicians: Is there a hidden system of primary care?JAMA1998; 279: 1364–1370.
55.
MajumdarSRInuiTSGurwitzJH. Influence of physician specialty on adoption and relinquishment of calcium channel blockers and other treatments for myocardial infarction. J Gen Intern Med2001; 16: 351–359.
56.
StataCorpL. Stata statistical software: Release 13, College Station, TX: StataCorp LP, 2013.
