Patterns of Working Hours in Large-Scale Grocery Retailing in Britain and France: Convergence after 1992?

Abstract

As 1992 approaches, a major question being raised is to what extent the development of the Single European Market will allow the integration of societies and economies with different structures, laws and traditions, and encourage the convergence of organisational and institutional patterns across member states. This article explores this question by examining patterns of working hours in large-scale grocery retailing in two member states - Britain and France. Based on comparative fieldwork carried out in 1986 and 1987 it shows that patterns of working hours currently differ in terms of patterns of part-time hours (levels of use, length of contracts, shift lengths and patterns) and the types of flexibility in working hours, and seeks to explain these differences in terms of the differing social policies and industrial relations frameworks relating to part-time work and to working hours more generally in the two countries.

The article speculates on the possible effect of the Single European Market on large-scale grocery retailing as part of a wider assessment of factors likely to influence patterns of working hours in this sector after 1992. It finds that there are indeed pressures towards convergence, particularly affecting Britain, as a result of commercial, technological and European social policy measures with major implications for employers and for women's patterns of employment. It suggests, however, that in the short to medium term past national specificities will continue to maintain the differences found.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alexander, N. (1988) Retailing post-1992. A survey carried out amongst the UK's leading retail organisations, working paper series 88/28, Department of Business Studies, University of Edinburgh .

Afsa, C. and Marchand, O. (1990) `Temps de travail: uniformisation ou éclatement?' Economie et Statistique, 231, avril, 7-18 .

Beechey, V. (1989) `Women's employment in France and Britain: some problems of comparison' , Work, Employment and Society, 3, 3 369-378 .

Bieganski, R. (1983) Gestion de la Main-d'oeuvre dans le Secteur du Commerce, CEREQ , November.

Booz, Allen and Hamilton (1989) `Staffing Supermarkets in the 90s', The Coca-Cola Retailing Research Group Europe .

Brannen, J. and Moss, P. (1988) New Mothers at Work, Employment and Childcare, London: Unwin Hyman .

Caire, G. (1985) `La négociation collective en France', in Recherches Economiques et Sociales, nouvelle série, No. 13-14 et 2e trimestre 1985, Paris: Commissariat Général du Plan Service des Etudes et de la Recherche .

CEREQ (1990) Emploi, Travail, Formation dans la Grande Distribution a Prédominance Alimentaire: Evolution et Perspectives, Vols 1 and 2, Paris: CEREQ and l'ADEP .

Clausener, M. (1989) `Analyse comparative: bilans sociaux 1988' , LSA, no. 1188, 101-104 .

10.

Clausener, M. (1990) `Un système incontournable' , LSA, no. 1203, 152-153 .

11.

Clausener, M. (1990a) `Suma: une organisation novatrice' , LSA, no. 1194, 90-91 .

12.

Cosyns, J. , Loveridge, R. and Child, J. (1981) `Micro-electronics, organization, and the structuring of employment in retailing' , paper presented at the EGOS/SSRC Colloquium on Organizational Innovations in the 1980s, Strathclyde Business School, Glasgow.

13.

Dale, A. and Glover, J. (1990) An analysis of women's employment patterns in the UK, France and the USA: the value of survey based comparisons, Department of Employment research paper no. 75, London: HMSO .

14.

Dawson, J. (1982) Commercial Distribution in Europe, London: Croom and Helm .

15.

De Lange, W. (1986) `Control of working time: attuning working time to organisational or individual needs' , Labour and Society, 11, 1, 97-106 .

16.

Department of Employment (1989) New Earnings Survey, London: HMSO .

17.

DIY Superstore (1990) `European judgement supports part-timers' , 10, 2, 1 .

18.

Economist (1990) `More rights for the workers' , 28th July-3rd August, 76 .

19.

Employment Gazette (1989) January.

20.

European Documentation (1990) `1992 the Social Dimension', no. 2, Office for official publications of the European Communities .

21.

European Foundation (1985) `New Technology in Supermarkets', Consolidated Report, Dublin .

22.

Eurostat (1989) Labour Force Survey, Luxembourg: Statistical Office of the European Communities .

23.

Faivret, J. Ph. , Missika, J. L. and Wolton, D. (1980) Le Tertiaire Eclaté: le Travail sans Modèle, CFDT, Paris: Seuil .

24.

Fulop, C. (1964) Competition for Consumers. A Study of the Changing Channels of Distribution, Institute of Economic Affairs, London: Andre Deutsch .

25.

Futuribles (1985) `Conditions de vie et aspirations des Français' , Mars, 19-28 .

26.

Garnsey, E. (1984) `The provision and quality of part-time work: the case of Great Britain and France', unpublished study carried out for the Commission of the European Communities .

27.

Gowler, D. and Legge, K. (1982) `Dual-worker families', in Rapoport, R. M. , Rapoport, R. and Fogarty, M. P. (eds), Families in Britain, London: Routledge and Kegan Paul .

28.

Gray, D. (1989) `The price of a single market' , Retail Week, 31st March, 28 .

29.

Gregory, A. (1989) A Franco-British comparison of patterns of working hours in large-scale grocery retailing, with specific reference to part-time work, PhD thesis, Aston University.

30.

Guardian, `Work hours clash looms with Brussels' , July 26th, 2 .

31.

Guelaud, F. et al. (1989) La Flexibilité dans les Hypermarchés, Aix-en-Provence: Lest .

32.

Hantrais, L. (1985) `Leisure lifestyles and the synchronisation of family schedules: a Franco-British perspective' , World Leisure and Recreation, April, 18-24 .

33.

Hantrais, L. (1990) Managing Professional and Family Life. A Comparative Study of British and French Women, Aldershot: Dartmouth .

34.

Hantrais, L. , Clark, P. A. and Samuel, N. (1984) `Time-space dimensions of work, family and leisure in France and Great Britain' , Leisure Studies, 3, 303-317 .

35.

IMS (1986) Changing Working Patterns: How Companies Achieve Flexibility to Meet New Needs, London: NEDO .

36.

Industrial Relations Legal Information Bulletin (1989) 388, 7 November, 9 .

37.

INSEE (1988) Enquête sur l.Emploi, Paris: INSEE .

38.

INSEE (1989) Enquête sur l'Emploi, Paris: INSEE .

39.

Intersocial (1984) `Auchan. Des îlots de caisses auto-organisées améliorent à la fois climat et service' , 108, December, 4-6 .

40.

Intersocial (1985) `Faut-il brûler le Code du Travail?' , 113, May, 8-11 .

41.

Lees, R. and Worthington, S. (1989) `Achieving above-average profitability in retailing' , International Journal of Retailing, 4, 2, 17-35 .

42.

Lehmann, A. (1985) `Le travail à temps partiel de 1978 à 1983' , Travail et Emploi, 26, 47-58 .

43.

Lennon, P. (1990) `Facing the demographic challenge' , Employment Gazette, January, 41-44 .

44.

Martin, J. and Roberts, C. (1984) Women and Employment Survey: a Lifetime Perspective, OPCS, London: HMSO .

45.

Maruani, M. and Nicole-Drancourt, C. (1989) La flexibilité à temps partiel: conditions d'emploi dans le commerce, Paris: Documentation Française .

46.

Messerlin, P. (1982) La Révolution Commerciale, Paris: Bonnel .

47.

Moss, P. (1988) Childcare and Equality of Opportunity, Brussels: Consolidated report to the Commission of the European Communities .

48.

NEDO (1985) Employment Perspectives and the Distributive Trades, London: HMSO .

49.

NEDO Part-time Employment Group (1986) `Explanations for part-time employment growth', unpublished paper.

50.

Pearson, J. (1989) Food Retailing'89, A review of food retailing structures and trends, Watford: IGD .

51.

Points de Vente (1988) `La lecture optique: un bond en avant pour de nouveaux défis' , 352, 44-50 .

52.

Procter, I. et al. (1990) `Employment and domestic work: a comparison of samples of British and French women' , Paper presented at the British Sociological Association annual conference, University of Surrey.

53.

Smith, D. (1983) Service workers in the class structure: the case of shopworkers, DPhil thesis, Oxford University.

54.

Sparks, L. (1987) `An analysis of part-time employment in superstores', Report No. 13, Institute of Retail Studies, University of Stirling .

55.

Sparks, L. (1987a) `Training and skill levels in superstores', report no. 4, Institute for Retail Studies, University of Stirling .

56.

Summers, D. (1989) `Law on part-time workers challenged' , Financial Times, 21 June, 24/2.

57.

Teague, P. (1990) The European Community: the Social Dimension, London: Kogan Page .

58.

Travail et Emploi (1984) `Le travail à temps partiel' , 19, 31-36 .

59.

Trinder, C. (1986) Young People's Employment in Retailing, London: HMSO .

60.

USDAW (1989) `1992 and the Single European Market' , statement by the Executive Council to the 1989 annual delegate meeting.

61.

USDAW Today (1990), April, 1-2 .

62.

Walters, P. and Dex, S. (1990) `Feminisation of the labour force in Britain and France' , paper presented at the British Sociological Association annual conference, University of Surrey.

63.

Weston, C. (1991) `You're alright, Jacques' , Guardian, 24th May, 26 .