This paper examines gender bias in Burawoy's influential theory of the labour process and assesses the implications of this bias. Burawoy's theory states that the structure of the labour process, via its relative autonomy and key mechanisms (shopfloor games, internal labour markets and the industrial state) `manufactures consent'. This theory is criticized for ignoring gender as an important element in the operation of consent. It is argued that (a) gender is implicitly assumed in his theory in terms of a male bias, and (b) this gender bias creates a serious limitation since it does not apply to the work conditions faced predominately by women. Discussion focuses on how an analysis of gender highlights the problem of asserting a `relative autonomy' of the labour process.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Baron, J. & Bielby, W. (1986) `Men and Women at Work: Sex Segregation and Statistical Discrimination' , American Journal of Sociology91, 4.
2.
Bokemeier, J. & Lacy, W. (1986) `Job Value, Rewards and Work Conditions as Factors in Job Satisfaction among Men and Women' , Sociological Quarterly, 28, 2, 189-204 .
3.
Burawoy, M. (1979) Manufacturing Consent, Chicago: University of Chicago Press .
4.
Burawoy, M. (1982a) `The Written and the Repressed in Gouldner's Industrial Sociology' , Theory and Society, 11, 831-851 .
5.
Burawoy, M. (1982b) `The Resurgence of Marxism in American Sociology', Marxist Inquiries, Chicago: University of Chicago Press .
6.
Burawoy, M. (1985) The Politics of Production, Norfolk: Verso .
7.
Clawson, D. & Fantasia, R. (1983) `Beyond Burawoy: The Dialectics of Conflict and Consent on the Shop Floor' , Theory and Society, 12, 671-680 .
8.
Cockburn, C. (1988) `The Gendering of Jobs: Workplace Relations and the Reproduction of Sex Segregation', in Walby, S. (ed.) Gender Segregation at Work, Philadelphia: Open University Press .
9.
Connell, R. , Ashendon, D. , Kessler, S. & Dowsett, G. (1982) Making the Difference: Schools, Family and Social Division, Sydney: George Allen and Unwin .
10.
Feldberg, R. & Glenn, E. (1979) `Male and Female: Job Versus Gender Models in the Sociology of Work' , Social Problems, 26, 5, 524-538 .
11.
Findlay, S. (1988) `Feminist Struggles with the Canadian State: 1966-88' , Resources For Feminist Research17, 3, 5-9 .
12.
Fox, B. & Fox, J. (1987) `Occupational Gender Segregation in the Canadian Labour Force, 1931-1981' , Canadian Journal of Sociology and Anthropology, 24, 3, 374-397 .
13.
Gannage, C. (1987) `A World of Difference: The Case of Women Workers in a Canadian Garment Factory', in Maroney, H. and Luxton, M. (eds.) Feminism and Political Economy: Women's Work, Women's Struggles, Toronto: Methuen .
14.
Gartman, D. (1983) `Structuralist Marxism and the Labor Process: Where have the Dialectics Gone?' , Theory and Society, 12, 659-669 .
15.
Hartmann H , (1987) `Internal Labour Markets and Gender: a Case Study of Promotion', in C. Brown and J. Pechman Gender in the Workplace, Washington: Brookings Institute .
16.
Hearn, J. & Parkin, W. (1987) Sex at Work, Great Britain: Wheatsheaf .
17.
Heron, C. & Storey, R. (1986) On the Job in Canada, Kingston: McGill-Queens University Press .
18.
Kanter, R. (1977) Men and Women of the Corporation, New York: Basic Books .
19.
Knights, D. & Willmott, H. (1989) `Power and Subjectivity at Work: From Degradation to Subjugation in Social Relations' , Sociology, 23, 4, 535-558 .
20.
Labour Canada (1987) Women in the Labour Force, Ottawa: Women's Bureau .
21.
Langer, M. (1970) `Inside the New York Telephone Company', New York Review of Books.
22.
Littler, C. & Salaman, G. (1982) `Bravermania and Beyond: Recent Theories of the Labour Process' , Sociology, 16, 2.
23.
Livingstone, D. & Luxton, M. (1989) `Gender Consciousness at Work: Modification of the Male Breadwinner Norm Among Steelworkers and their Spouses' , Canadian Review of Sociology and Anthropology, 26, 2, 240-275 .
24.
Lorence, J. (1987) `A Test of “Gender” and “Job” Models of Sex Differences in Job Involvement' , Social Forces, 66, 1.
25.
Mahnkopf, B. (1986) `Hegemony and Consent: patterns of regulation in internal company social relations and their legitimation effect' , Berkeley Journal of Sociology, 31, 35-52 .
26.
Maines, D. & Hardesty, M. (1987) `Temporality and Gender' , Social Forces, 66, 102-120 .
27.
Mills, A. (1988) `Organization, Gender and Culture' , Organization Studies, 9, 3, 1988 .
28.
Northcott, H. & Lowe, G. (1987) `Job and Gender Influences in the Subjective Experience of Work' , Canadian Review of Sociology and Anthropology, 24, 1, 117-131 .
29.
Paukert, L. (1984) The Employment and Unemployment of Women in OECD countries, Paris: OECD .
30.
Phillips, A. & Taylor, B. (1980) `Sex and Skill: Notes Towards a Feminist Economics' , Feminist Review, 6, 79-88 .
31.
Pollert, A. (1981) Girls, Wives, Factory Lives, London: Macmillan .
32.
Roos, P. (1985) Gender at Work, Albany: State University of New York Press .
33.
Roy, D. (1958) `Banana Time' , Human Organization, 18, 158-168 .
34.
Rubery, J. (1978) `Structured Labour Markets: worker organization and low pay' , Cambridge Journal of Economics, 2.
35.
Ruggie, M. (1984) The State and Working Women, Princeton: Princeton University Press .
36.
Schooler, C. , Miller, K. & Richtand, C. (1985) `Work for the Household: its nature and consequences for husbands and wives' , American Journal of Sociology, 90, 1.
37.
Steedman, M. (1986) `Skill and Gender in the Canadian Clothing Industry 1890-1940' in C. Heron and R. Storey On the Job: Confronting the Labour Process in Canada, Kingston: McGill/Queens Press .
38.
Tancred-Sheriff, P. (1988) `Gender Distortion, Sexuality and Labour Process Theory', unpublished manuscript, McMaster University .
39.
Tanner, J. (1990) `Reluctant Rebels: A Case Study of Edmonton High School Dropouts', Canadian Review of Sociology and Anthropology, forthcoming.
40.
Thomas, R. (1982) `Citizenship and Gender in Work Organization: some consideration for theories of the labour process', in Burawoy, M. and Skocpol, T. (eds.) Marxist Inquiries, Chicago: University of Chicago Press .
41.
Thompson, P. (1983) The Nature of Work, Great Britain: Macmillan .
42.
Tienda, M. , Ortiz, V. & Smith, S.1987 ` Industrial Restructuring, Gender Segregation and Sex Differences in Earnings' , American Sociological Review, 52, 195-210 .
43.
Vallas, S. & Epstein, C. (1987) `Factory Regimes and Working Class Consciousness', unpublished manuscript, City University of New York .
44.
Wagner, D. , Ford, R. & Ford, T. (1986) `Can Gender Inequalities be Reduced?' , American Sociological Review, 51, 47-61 .
45.
Waite, L. , Haggstrom, G. & Kanouse, D. (1986) `The Effects of Parenthood on the Career Orientation and Job Characteristics of Young Adults' , Social Forces, 65, 43-73 .
46.
Walshok, M. (1981) Blue Collar Women, New York: Anchor Books .
47.
Wharton, A. & Baron, J. (1987) `So Happy Together? The impact of gender segregation on men at work' , American Sociological Review, 52, 574-587 .
48.
White, J. (1980) Women and Unions, Ottawa: Canadian Advisory Council on the Status of Women .
49.
Willis, P. (1979) Learning to Labour, New York: Columbia University Press .
50.
Willis, P. (1979) `Shopfloor Culture, Masculinity and the Wage Form', in Clarke, J.et al. (eds.) Working Class Culture, New York: St. Martins Press .
51.
Zimmer, L. (1988) `Tokenism and Women in the Workplace: the Limits of Gender-Neutral Theory' , Social Problems, 35, 1.
