The Road to Recovery? Some Evidence from Vacancies in One Labour Market

Abstract

Even during times of high unemployment, one often hears people express the view that there are plenty of jobs available for those who want to work. Indeed, recent government policy rests on the truth of this assumption. After criticising some of the survey evidence purportedly documenting a flourishing vacancy situation nationally, the paper presents a test of the assumption in Chesterfield in the summer of 1988. The assumption is shown to be wanting. The sheer number of vacancies was not large and certainly not sufficient for the number of unemployed in the locality. The jobs that were on offer were not attractive in terms of pay and conditions. A minority of the jobs were for full-time, permanent positions. Casualised working conditions, non-standard hours, self-employment and low pay featured predominantly. There was little evidence of a skills gap. Nonetheless, virtually all the jobs were being taken, the majority by people already in work. Falling unemployment figures alone must not be taken as heralding an economic recovery, since it seems that many are simply leaving the register.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service (1988) Labour Flexibility in Britain: the 1987 ACAS Survey, ACAS Head Office, 27 Wilton Street, London SW1X 7AZ.

Beveridge, W.H. (1944) Full Employment in a Free Society, London: Allen & Unwin .

Bowers, J.K. , Cheshire, P.C. and Webb, A.E. (1970) `The change in the relation-ship between unemployment and earnings increases: a review of possible explanations' , National Institute Economic Review, 54, November, 44-63 .

Budd, A. , Levine, P. and Smith, P. (1988) `Unemployment, vacancies and the long-term unemployed' , The Economic Journal, 98, December, 1071-1091 .

Champion, A.G. and Green, A.E. (1985) In search of Britain's booming towns: an index of local economic performance for Britain, University of Newcastle upon Tyne Centre for Urban and Regional Development Studies , Discussion paper no. 72.

Cox, G. (1988) Job Watch '88'; A Survey of Jobcentres in Greater Manchester in September 1988, Greater Manchester Low Pay Unit .

Curran, M. (1988) `Gender and recruitment: people and places in the labour market' , Work, Employment and Society, 2, 3, 335-351 .

Daniel, W.W. (1981) The Unemployed Flow: An Interim Report, Policy Studies Institute.

Department of Employment (1978) `Engagements and unfilled vacancies during 1977', Department of Employment Gazette, November.

10.

Department of Employment (1985) `Note on the change in compilation of vacancy statistics', Employment Gazette, October.

11.

Department of Employment (1988a) Employment for the 1990s , White paper presented to Parliament, Cm 540, London, HMSO.

12.

Department of Employment (1988b) Training for Employment , White paper presented to Parliament, Cmnd 316, London, HMSO.

13.

Dex, S. (1988) The Destinations of the Long-Term Unemployed who Left the Register, unpublished report to the Department of Employment.

14.

Dicks, M. and Hatch, N. (1989) `The relationship between employment and unemployment', Bank of England discussion paper no. 39.

15.

European Values Survey (1986) Technical documentation and codebook for the European Values Survey 1981, ESRC Data Archive, University of Essex, Wivenhoe Park, Colchester .

16.

Evans, A. (1977) `Notes on the changing relationship between registered unemployment and notified vacancies: 1961-66 and 1966-71' , Economica, 44, 179-196 .

17.

Fogarty, M. and Harding, S. (1986) Contrasting Values in Western Europe, London: Macmillan

18.

Foster, J.I. (1974) `The relationship between unemployment and vacancies in GB (1958-72): some further evidence' in D. Laidler and D.L. Purdy (eds.) Inflation and Labour Markets, Manchester: Manchester University Press .

19.

Gujurati, D. (1972) `The behaviour of unemployment and unfilled vacancies' , Economic Journal 82, March, 195-204 .

20.

Hunt, M. (1987) Job Check: A Survey of Vacancies in West Yorkshire, West Yorkshire Low Pay Unit .

21.

IFF Research Limited (1988) Vacancies and Recruitment Study, research report prepared for the Department of Employment's Employment Service, London, Department of Employment.

22.

Jackman, R. , Layard, P.R.G. and Pissarides, C.A. (1989) `On vacancies', London School of Economics , Centre for Labour Economics Discussion paper no. 1091.

23.

Layard, R. and Nickell, S.J. (1985) `The causes of British unemployment' , National Institute Economic Review, 111, 62-85 .

24.

Marsh, C. (1988) `Unemployment in Britain' in D. Gallie (ed.) Employment in Britain, Oxford: Basil Blackwell , 344-375.

25.

Meadows, P. , Cooper, H. and Bartholemew, R. (1988) The London Labour Market, Department of Employment, London, HMSO .

26.

Monitoring and Information Group (1988) Unemployment Report: March 1988, County Planning Department, Derbyshire County Council .

27.

Payne, J. (1987) `Does unemployment run in families? some findings from the General Household Survey' , Sociology, 21, 2, 199-214 .

28.

Pissarides, C. (1986) `Unemployment and vacancies in Britain' , Economic Policy, October, 499-559 .

29.

Smith, E. (1988) `Vacancies and recruitment in Great Britain' , Employment Gazette, April, 211-213 .

30.

Sudman, S. , Finn, A. and Lannom, L. (1984) `The use of bounded recall procedures in single interviews' , Public Opinion Quarterly, 48, 2, 520-524 .

31.

Taylor, D. (1989) `The vacancies argument' , Unemployment Bulletin, 29, 1-8 .

32.

Taylor, J. (1972) `The behaviour of unemployment and unfilled vacancies: Great Britain 1955-71; an alternate view' . Economic Journal 82, December, 1352-1365 .

33.

Unemployment Unit (1984) Unemployment Bulletin, 11, January, London: Unemployment Unit .

34.

White, M. (1983) Long-term Unemployment and Labour Markets, London: Policy Studies Institute .