Capitalism or Culture? A Comparative Analysis of the Position in the Labour Process and Labour Market of Lower White-Collar Workers in the Financial Services Sector of Britain and the Federal Republic of Germany

Abstract

This paper explores the impact of organizational/technological change on the position in the labour process and labour market of lower white-collar workers in the Financial Services sector of Britain and the Federal Republic of Germany. Differences in their position are explained by reference both to the `labour process' debate and to the notion of national cultural distinctions between the two societies. Particular emphasis is given to the system of vocational education and training and the way it shapes values and attitudes of both employers and workers. Different attitudes to skill among British and German employers are then linked to managerial strategies on labour utilization in relation to changing product markets.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abercrombie, N. and Urry, J. (1983) Capital, Labour and the Middle Classes. London: Allen and Unwin .

Baethge, M. Gerstenberger, F. , Oberbeck, H. , Schlosser, M. , Seltz, R. (1980) Bildungsexpansion und Beschäftigungslage von Angestellten. Unpublished research report. Soziologisches Forschungsinstitut Göttingen (SOFI) .

Baethge, M. , Gerstenberger, F. , Oberbeck, H. , Schlosser, M. , Seltz, R. (1982a) `Beschäftigungs- und Ausbildungspolitische Auswirkungen und Konsequenzen der Rationalisierung von Kaufmännisch-Verwaltenden Angestelltentätigkeiten'. SOFI-Mitteilungen 6, SOFI, Göttingen .

Baethge, M. , Gerstenberger, F. , Oberbeck, H. , Schlosser, M. , Seltz, R. (1983a) Entwicklungstendenzen von Ausbildungs - und Beschäftigungsstrukturen im Angestelltenbereich unter den Bedingungen eines erhöhten Angebots von Absolventen weiterführender Bildungseinrichtungen und fortschreitender Rationalisierung. Manuscript. SOFI, Göttingen .

Baethge, M. , Gerstenberger, F. , Oberbeck, H. , Schlosser, M. , Seltz, R. (1983b) Bildungsexpansion und Rationalisierung - Ergebnisse einer umfassenden Fallstudienreihe . Workshop Report edited by the Federal Minister for Education and Science, Bonn.

Barras, R. and Swann, J. (1983) The Adoption and Impact of Information Technology in the UK Insurance Industry. Report No. TCCR-83-014, London .

Beine, G. (1981) `Die Kaufmännische Berufsausbildung, in der Deutschen Bank'. Boehm, U., Littek, W., Ortmann, F. (Hg.), Rationalisierung der Büroarbeit und Kaufmännische Berufsausbildung. Frankfurt/New York: Campus Verlag .

Berger, U. (1983) Wachstum und Rationalisierung der industriellen Dienstleistungsarbeit - Zur `lückenhaften Rationalitat' der Industrieverwaltung. Doctoral Dissertation submitted at the University of Bielefeld.

Bücker-Gärtner, H. and Knicker, T. (1981) `Büroarbeit und Qualifikationsentwicklung'. Böhm, U., Littek, W., Ortmann, F. (Hg.), Rationalisierung der Büroarbeit und Kaufmännische Berufsausbildung. Frankfurt/New York: Campus Verlag .

10.

Braverman, H. (1974) Labor and Monopoly Capital. New York/London: Monthly Review Press .

11.

Burawoy, M. (1983) `Between the Labour Process and the State; the Changing Face of Factory Regimes Under Advanced Capitalism' . American Sociological Review 5: 587-605 .

12.

CEDEFOP (1982) In-firm training and career prospects for women in the Federal Republic of Germany, summary. Berlin .

13.

CEDEFOP (Hsg.) (1983) Informationstechnik und Ausbildung von Fachkräften im Dienstleistungsbereich. (BRD, Frankreich, Vereinigtes Konigsreich). Under the direction of A. Dirrheimer, Luxembourg .

14.

Child, J. (1981) `Culture, contingency and capitalism in the cross-national study of organizations', Research in Organizational Behaviour Vol. 3, Edited by B.M. Staw and L.L. Cumings .

15.

Child, J. , Loveridge, R. , Harvey, J. , Spencer, A. (1984) `Microelectronics and the Quality of Employment in the Service Sector', P. Marstrand (ed.), New Technology and the Future of Work.

16.

Child, J. and Tarbuck, M. (1985) `The Introduction of New Technologies: Managerial Initiative and Union Response in British Banks' , Industrial Relations Journal 3: 19-34 .

17.

Chiplin, B. and Sloane, P.J. (1976) Sex Discrimination in the Labour Market, Cambridge: CUP .

18.

Crompton, R. and Jones, G. (1984) White-Collar Proletariat, London: Macmillan .

19.

Dostal, W. (1983) Bildung and Beschäftigung im Technischen Wandel. Beitrag AB65, Institut f. Arbeits- u. Berufsforschung d. Bundesanstalt f. Arbeit . 2nd edition.

20.

Economists Advisory Group Ltd (ed.) (1981) The British and German Banking System: A Comparative Study, The Anglo-German Foundation .

21.

Edwards, R. (1979) Contested Terrain, London: Heinemann .

22.

Frazer, P. and Vittas, D. (1982) The Retail Banking Revolution. An International Perspective, London: Michael Lafferty Publication .

23.

Friedrich, J. , Wicke, F. und Wicke, W. (1982) Computereinsatz: Auswirkungen auf die Arbeit, Rowohlt Verlag .

24.

Grünewald, U. and Koch, R. (1981) `Informationstechnik in Büro und Verwaltung', Berichte zur beruflichen Bildung. Bundesinstitut f. Berufsforschung. Berlin .

25.

Hörning, K.-H. , Bücker-Gärtner, H. (1982) Angestellte im Grossbetrieb (Loyalität und Kontrolle im organisatorisch-technischen Wandel), Stuttgart: Enke Verlag .

26.

Hörning, K.-H. (1983) `Qualifikation im Widerspruch: Angestellte und ihre Tätigkeiten im technisch - organisatorischen Wandel', M. Haller , and W. Müller (eds), Beschäftigungssystem im gesellschaftlichen Wandel. Frankfurt/New York: Campus Verlag .

27.

Humml, K. (1980) `Rationalisierungsmassnahmen im Bankenbereich und Ansätze Gewerkschaftlicher Gegenwehr' , WSI Mitteilungen (Journal of the Economics and Social Sciences Institute of the DGB) 8: 445-455 .

28.

Hyman, R. and Price, R. (eds.) (1983) The New Working Class? White Collar Workers and their Organizations, London: Macmillan .

29.

Kerr, C. , Dunlop, J.T. , Harbisson, F.H. , Myers, C.A. (1962) Industrialism and Industrial Man. London: Heinemann .

30.

Kudera, W. , Ruff, K. , Schmidt, R. (1983) `Blue collar-white collar: grey collar?' Soziale Welt 3: 201-227 .

31.

Littek, W. (1984) Rationalization, Technical Change and Employee Reactions . Paper presented at the BSA Annual Conference at Bradford University, April 1984.

32.

Landes, D.S. (1977) The Unbound Prometheus. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .

33.

Lane, C. (1985) `White-Collar Workers in the Labour Process: the case of the FRG' , Sociological Review 2: 298-326 .

34.

Lee, D. (1982) `Beyond deskilling: skill, craft and class', Wood, S. (ed.), The Degradation of Work? London: Hutchinson .

35.

Littler, C.R. (1982) The Development of the Labour Process in Capitalist Societies. London: Heinemann .

36.

Loveridge, R. (1983) `Sources of Diversity in Internal Labour Markets' , Sociology 17: 44-62 .

37.

Murray, F. (1986) `Banking on Clerical Skills: New Technology and the Clearing Banks in the UK', Unpublished Working Paper, Sheffield City Polytechnic .

38.

Maurice, M. and Sellier, F. (1979) `Societal Analysis of Industrial Relations: A Comparison between France and West Germany' , British Journal of Industrial Relations, 17: 322-336 .

39.

Maurice, M. , Sorge, A. , Warner, M. (1980) `Societal Differences in Organising Manufacturing Units' , Organization Studies 1: 69-91 .

40.

Musgrave, P.W. (1967) Technical Change, the Labour Force and Education. Oxford: Pergamon Press .

41.

NEDO (1986) Changing Working Patterns. A Report by the Institute of Manpower Studies, London .

42.

Parsons, T. (1973) `Culture and Social System Revisited'. Schneider, L. and Bonjean, C.M. (eds.), The Idea of Culture in the Social Sciences, Cambridge: CUP .

43.

Piore, M.J. and Sabel, C. (1984) The Second Industrial Divide. New York: Basic Books .

44.

Povall, M. , de Jong, A. , Chalude, A.R. , Grozelier, A.-M. (1982) `Banking on Women Managers' . Management Today, February.

45.

Prais, S.J. (1981) `Vocational Qualifications of the Labour Force in Britain and Germany' , Review of the National Institute of Economic and Social Research 98: 47-59 .

46.

Rajan, A. (1984) New Technology and Employment in Insurance, Banking and Building Societies: Recent Experience and Future Impact. Special Report, Institute of Manpower Studies Series, Gower .

47.

Report and Recommendations of the Equal Opportunities Committee of the Banking Insurance and Finance Union (1981) Equality for Women - Proposals for Positive Action.

48.

Sabel, C. (1982) Work and Politics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .

49.

Saunders, C. & Marsden, D. (1981) Pay Inequalities in the European Community, London: Butterworth .

50.

Shaw, E.R. and Coulbeck, N.S. (1983) UK Retail Banking Prospects in the Competitive 1980s. January, Staniland Hall .

51.

Smith, S. , Wield, D. (1983) Features of Technical and Organizational Change in the Clearing Banks: an outline discussion with reference to Greater London. London Employment and Technology Research Working Paper No. 1.

52.

Smith, S. , Wield, D. (1984) Technical and Organizational Change in the Clearing Banks: Dilemmas for Employers. London Employment and Technology Research Working Paper No. 4.

53.

Sorge, A. and Warner, M. (1980) `Manpower Training, Manufacturing Organisation and Workplace Relations in Great Britain and West Germany' , British Journal of Industrial Relations 18: 318-333 .

54.

Stewart, A. , Prandy, K. , Blackburn, R.M. (1980) Social Stratification and Occupations. London: Macmillan Press .

55.

Storey, J. (1984) `The Phoney War? New Office Technology: Organization and Control', Knights, D. & Willmott, H. (eds.), Management and the Labour Process, London: Heinemann .

56.

Weltz, F. , Diezinger, A. , Lullies, V. , Marquardt, R. (1979) Junge Frauen zwischen Beruf und Familie. Soziologisches Forschungsinstitut Göttingen. Frankfurt/New York: Campus Verlag .

57.

Weiermair, K. (1981) `Relationships between Social Values, the Education System and the Structure and Performance of Labour Markets', Dlugos, G. and Weiermair, K. Management under Differing Value Systems. Berlin/New York: de Gruyter .