Canada’s public sector has historically provided good jobs, but its increasing reliance on temporary workers has important implications for job quality. We compare temporary and permanent workers in the public sector on three dimensions of job quality (employment security, access to benefits and income trajectories) to assess whether favourable conditions in the public sector are extended to temporary employees, or whether polarization between temporary and permanent workers is the norm. We find provisions related to employment security and access to leave benefits in public sector collective bargains are clearly two-tiered. Drawing on nationally representative panel data, we also find a persistent earnings gap between matched permanent and temporary employees. Further, although temporary public sector workers out-earn their private sector counterparts, the earnings disadvantage relative to matched permanent workers is more pronounced and longer lasting in the public sector. Underlying this difference is greater persistence in temporary employment within the public sector.
Amuedo-DorantesC (2000) Work transitions into and out of involuntary temporary employment in a segmented market: evidence from Spain. Industrial and Labor Relations Review53(2): 309–325.
2.
AndersonJBeatonJLaxerK (2006) The union dimension: mitigating precarious employment? In: VoskoLF (ed.) Precarious Employment: Understanding Labour Market Insecurity in Canada. Montreal, QC, Canada: McGill-Queen’s University Press, 301–317.
3.
BentolilaSDoladoJJ (1994) Labour flexibility and wages: lessons from Spain. Economic Policy9(18): 53–99.
4.
BoothALDoladoJJFrankJ (2002a) Symposium on temporary work: introduction. The Economic Journal112(480): 181–188.
5.
BoothALFrancesconiMFrankJ (2002b) Temporary jobs: stepping stones or dead ends?The Economic Journal112(480): 189–213.
6.
CaliendoMKopeinigS (2008) Some practical guidance for the implementation of propensity score matching. Journal of Economic Surveys22(1): 31–72.
7.
CaseyCAlachP (2004) ‘Just a temp?’ Women, temporary employment and lifestyle. Work, Employment and Society18(3): 459–480.
8.
ColvinAJ (2006) Flexibility and fairness in liberal market economies: the comparative impact of the legal environment and high-performance work systems. British Journal of Industrial Relations44(1): 73–97.
9.
ConleyH (2002) A state of insecurity: temporary work in the public services. Work, Employment and Society16(4): 725–737.
10.
DiMaggioPPowellWW (1983) The iron cage revisited: collective rationality and institutional isomorphism in organizational fields. American Sociological Review48(2): 147–160.
11.
FangTVermaA (2002) Union wage premium. Perspectives on Labour and Income3(9): 17–23.
12.
FudgeJVoskoLF (2001) Gender, segmentation and the standard employment relationship in Canadian labour law, legislation and policy. Economic and Industrial Democracy22(2): 271–310.
13.
FullerS (2005) Public sector employment and gender wage inequalities in British Columbia: Assessing the effects of a shrinking public sector. Canadian Journal of Sociology-Cahiers Canadiens De Sociologie30(4): 405–439.
14.
FullerS (2011) Up and on or down and out? Gender, immigration, and the consequences of temporary employment in Canada. Research in Social Stratification and Mobility29(2): 155–180.
15.
FullerSVoskoLF (2008) Temporary employment and social inequality in Canada: Exploring intersections of gender, race, and migration. Social Indicators Research88(1): 31–50.
16.
FullerSStecy-HildebrandtN (2014) Lasting disadvantage? Comparing career trajectories of matched temporary and permanent workers in Canada. Canadian Review of Sociology51(4): 293–324.
17.
FullerSStecy-HildebrandtN (2015) Career pathways for temporary workers: Exploring heterogeneous mobility dynamics with sequence analysis. Social Science Research50: 76–99.
18.
GalarneauD (2010) Temporary employment in the downturn. Perspectives on Labour and Income11(11): 5–17.
19.
GalarneauDSohnT (2013) Long-term trends in unionization. Insights on Canadian Society (November): 1–6.
20.
GarzM (2013) Labour market segmentation: standard and non-standard employment in Germany. German Economic Review14(3): 349–371.
21.
GashV (2008) Bridge or trap? Temporary workers’ transitions to unemployment and to the standard employment contract. European Sociological Review24(5): 651–668.
22.
GashVMcGinnityF (2007) Fixed-term contracts – the new European inequality? Comparing men and women in West Germany and France. Socio-Economic Review5: 467–496.
23.
GebelM (2010) Early career consequences of temporary employment in Germany and the UK. Work, Employment and Society24: 641–660.
24.
GieseckeJGroßM (2003) Temporary employment: chance or risk?European Sociological Review19(2): 161–177.
25.
GieseckeJGroßM (2004) External labour market flexibility and social inequality: temporary employment in Germany and the UK. European Societies6(3): 347–382.
HeinrichCJMueserPRTroskeKR (2005) Welfare to temporary work: implications for labor market outcomes. The Review of Economics and Statistics87(1): 154–173.
29.
HoggettP (1991) A new management in the public sector?Policy & Politics19(4): 243–256.
30.
HouFCoulombeS (2010) Earnings gaps for Canadian-born visible minorities in the public and private sectors. Canadian Public Policy36(1): 29–43.
31.
HousemanS (2001) Why employers use flexible staffing arrangements: evidence from an establishment survey. Industrial and Labor Relations Review55(1): 149–170.
32.
HsiehHFShannonSE (2005) Three approaches to qualitative content analysis. Qualitative Health Research15(9): 1277–1288.
33.
IlcanSMO’ConnorDMOliverML (2003) Contract governance and the Canadian public sector. Relations Industrielles / Industrial Relations58(4): 620–643.
34.
IlcanSMOliverMO’ConnorD (2007) Spaces of governance: gender and public sector restructuring in Canada. Gender, Place and Culture14(1): 75–92.
35.
JacksonA (2010) Work & Labour in Canada: Critical Issues. Toronto, ON, Canada: Canadian Scholars’ Press.
36.
JohnsonD (2002) Thinking Government: Ideas, Policies, Institutions, and Public-Sector Management in Canada. Peterborough, ON, Canada: Broadview Press.
37.
KahnLM (2007) The impact of employment protection mandates on demographic temporary employment patterns: international microeconomic evidence. The Economic Journal117: 333–356.
38.
KallebergAL (2000) Nonstandard employment relations: part-time, temporary and contract work. Annual Review of Sociology26: 341–365.
39.
KallebergALReskinBFHudsonK (2000) Bad jobs in America: standard and nonstandard employment relations and job quality in the United States. American Sociological Review65(2): 256–278.
40.
LeuvenESianesiB (2003) PSMATCH2: Stata module to perform full Mahalanobis and propensity score matching, common support graphing, and covariate imbalance testing. Version 4.0.4, 10 November 2010. University of Amsterdam and Institute for Fiscal Studies, London.
41.
LuciforaCMeursD (2006) The public sector pay gap in France, Great Britain and Italy. Review of Income and Wealth52(1): 43–59.
42.
MayringP (2014) Qualitative Content Analysis: Theoretical Foundation, Basic Procedures and Software Solution. Klagenfurt: Institute of Psychology and Center for Evaluation and Research.
43.
MoczaldoR (2015) Creating competitive advantages – the European CSR-strategy compared with Porter’s and Kramer’s shared value approach. Ekonomski Vjesnik28(1): 243–256.
PeckJTheodoreN (1998) The business of contingent work: growth and restructuring in Chicago’s temporary employment industry. Work, Employment and Society12(4): 655–674.
47.
PolaviejaJG (2005) Flexibility or polarization? Temporary employment and job tasks in Spain. Socio-Economic Review3(2): 233–258.
Public Service Commission of Canada (2010) Use of Temporary Help Services in Public Service Organizations: A Study by the Public Service Commission of Canada. Ottawa, ON, Canada: Government of Canada.
50.
Saint-MartinD (2000) Building the New Managerialist State: Consultants and the Politics of Public Sector Reform in Comparative Perspective. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
51.
SegalLSullivanD (1997) The growth of temporary services work. The Journal of Economic Perspectives11(2): 117–136.
52.
StinsonJ (2010) Labour casualization in the public sector. In: PupoNJThomasMP (eds) Interrogating the New Economy: Restructuring Work in the 21st Century. Toronto, ON, Canada: University of Toronto Press, 93–110.
53.
TiagiR (2010) Public sector wage premium in Canada: evidence from the labour force survey. Labour24(4): 456–473.
54.
TownsonM (2003) Women in Non-Standard Jobs: The Public Policy Challenge. Ottawa: Status of Women Canada.
55.
Van JaarsveldDDKwonHFrostAC (2009) The effects of institutional and organizational characteristics on work force flexibility: evidence from call centers in three liberal market economies. Industrial and Labor Relations Review62(4): 573–601.
56.
Van LanckerW (2011) The European world of temporary employment. European Societies14(1): 83–111.
57.
VoskoLF (2006) Precarious employment: towards an improved understanding of labour market insecurity. In: VoskoLF (ed.) Precarious Employment: Understanding Labour Market Insecurity in Canada. Montreal, QC, Canada: McGill-Queens University Press, 3–42.
58.
WilsonGRoscignoVJ (2016) Public sector reform and racial occupational mobility. Work and Occupations43(3): 259–293.
59.
WilsonGRoscignoVJHuffmanM (2015) Racial income inequality and public sector privatization. Social Problems62(2): 163–185.
60.
ZeytinogluIUMuteshiJK (2000) Gender, race and class dimensions of nonstandard work. Relations Industrielles / Industrial Relations55(1): 133–167.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
