In recent years marked changes have occurred in the way employers recruit and select agency workers, with this activity increasingly being outsourced to third party organizations providing ‘vendor managed services’ (VMS). Drawing on data from a study of English social services, this article explores the consequences of this outsourcing. The findings reveal that although VMS has delivered cost savings, it has also resulted in less effective placement matching, rising line manager workloads and concerns about service quality. In the conclusion the wider implications of VMS for the future development of partnerships between employers and employment agencies are discussed.
AtkinsonJ (1984) Manpower strategies for flexible organisations. Personnel Management16(8): 28–31.
2.
BERR (Department for Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform) (2008) Agency Working in the UK: A Review of the Evidence. Employment Relations Research Series Number 93. London: BERR.
3.
CareyM (2007) White-collar proletariat? Braverman, the deskilling/upskilling of social work and the paradoxical life of the agency care manager. Journal of Social Work7(1): 93–114.
4.
CIPD (2007) Recruitment, Retention and Turnover Survey. London: Chartered Institute of Personnel Development.
5.
CohenLMallonM (1999) The transition from organisational employment to portfolio work: perceptions of ‘boundarylessness’. Work, Employment and Society13(2): 329–52.
6.
ConleyH (2002) A state of insecurity: temporary work in the public services. Work, Employment and Society16(4): 725–37.
7.
CookeFL (2005) Modelling an HR shared services center: experiences from an MNC in the United Kingdom. Human Resource Management45(2): 211–27.
8.
CornesMMoriartyJBlendi-MahotaSChittleburghTHusseinSManthorpeJ (2010) Working for the Agency: The Role and Significance of Temporary Employment Agencies in the Adult Social Care Workforce. London: Social Care Workforce Research Unit, King’s College London.
9.
CunninghamIJamesP (2010) The outsourcing of social care in Britain: what does it mean for voluntary sector workers?Work, Employment and Society23(2): 363–75.
10.
Davis-BlakeABroschakJP (2000) Speed bumps or stepping stones: the effects of labour market intermediaries on relational wealth. In: LeanaCRRousseauDM (eds) Relational Wealth: The Advantages of Stability in a Changing Economy. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 91–115.
11.
DfES/DH (Department for Education and Skills and Department of Health) (2006) Options for Excellence – Building the Social Care Workforce of the Future. Leeds: Department of Health.
DouglasA (2003) Is Anybody Out There? Recruitment and Retention in Social Care in London. London: Community Care.
14.
DrukerJStanworthC (2001) Partnerships and the private recruitment industry. Human Resource Management Journal11(2): 73–88.
15.
ErridgeAGreerJ (2002) Partnerships and public procurment: building social capital through supply relations. Public Administration80(3): 503–22.
16.
Fernandez-MateoI (2007) Who pays the price of brokerage? Transferring constraint through price setting in the staffing sector. American Sociological Review72(2): 291–317.
17.
GallagherDGMcLean ParksJ (2001) I pledge thee my troth… contingently: commitment and the contingent work relationship. Human Resource Management Review11(3): 181–208.
18.
GrimshawDEarnshawJHebsonG (2003) Private sector provision of supply teachers: a case of legal swings and professional roundabouts. Journal of Education Policy18(3): 267–88.
19.
GrimshawDWillmottHRuberyJ (2005) Inter-organisational networks: trust, power and the employment relationship. In: MarchingtonMGrimshawDRuberyJWillmottH (eds) Fragmenting Work: Blurring Organisational Boundaries and Disordering Hierarchies. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 39–62.
20.
HansenF (2007) A permanent strategy for temporary hires. Workforce Management Magazine. URL (consulted December 2010): http://www.workforce.com/index.html
21.
HoqueKKirkpatrickI (2008) Making the core contingent: agency work and its consequences for UK public services. Public Administration86(2): 331–44.
22.
HoqueKKirkpatrickIDe RuyterALonsdaleC (2008) New contractual relationships in the agency worker market: the case of the UK NHS. British Journal of Industrial Relations46(3): 389–412.
23.
HunterLBeaumontPSinclairD (1996) A partnership route to human resource management. Journal of Management Studies33(2): 235–57.
24.
HunterLMcGregorAMacInnesJSproullA (1993) The ‘flexible firm’: strategy and segmentation. British Journal of Industrial Relations31(3): 383–407.
25.
Incomes Data Services (2003) Recruitment and Retention, Pay Levels and the Use of Agency Workers in Local Government. London: IDS.
26.
KirkpatrickIHoqueK (2006) A retreat from permanent employment? Accounting for the rise of professional agency work in UK public services. Work, Employment and Society20(4): 649–66.
27.
KlaasB (2008) Outsourcing and the HR function: an examination of trends and developments within North American firms. International Journal of Human Resource Management19(8): 1500–14.
28.
KlaasBHyeuksuengYGaineyTMcClendonJA (2005) HR in the small business enterprise: assessing the impact of PEO utilisation. Human Resource Management44(4): 433–48.
29.
KoeneBVan RiemsdijkM (2005) Managing temporary workers: work identity, diversity, operational HR choices. Human Resource Management Journal15(1): 76–92.
30.
KosnikTWong-MingJiDJHooverK (2006) Outsourcing vs insourcing in the human resource supply chain: a comparison of five generic models. Personnel Review35(6): 671–83.
31.
KundaGBarleySEvansJ (2002) Why do contractors contract? The experience of highly skilled technical professionals in a contingent labour market. Industrial and Labour Relations Review55(2): 234–61.
32.
LepakDPSnellSA (1999) The human resource architecture: towards a theory of human capital allocation and development. Academy of Management Review24(1): 31–48.
33.
LeverS (1997) An analysis of managerial motivations behind outsourcing practices in human resources. Human Resource Planning20(2): 37–47.
34.
Local Authority Workforce Intelligence Group (2006) Adult, Children and Young People: Local Authority Social Care Workforce Survey 2005. Report 36. London: LAWIG.
35.
London Centre of Excellence (2007) Transforming the Procurement of Temporary, Agency and Interim Staff: Your Toolkit for Success. URL (consulted June 2008) www.lcpe.gov.uk
36.
LonsdaleCCoxA (1998) Falling in with the out crowd. People Management4(20): 52–5.
37.
LonsdaleCKirkpatrickIHoqueKDe RuyterA (2010) Supplier behaviour and public contracting in the English agency nursing market. Public Administration88(3): 800–18.
PatelR (2005) Walking a tightrope. CPO Agenda1(3): 44–9.
44.
PeckJTheodoreNWardK (2005) Conflicting markets for temporary labour: employment liberalisation and the internationalisation of the staffing industry. Global Networks5(1): 3–26.
45.
PeelSBoxallP (2005) When is contracting preferable to employment? An exploration of management and worker perspectives. Journal of Management Studies42(8): 1676–97.
46.
PurcellJPurcellKTailbyS (2005) Temporary work agencies: here today, gone tomorrow?British Journal of Industrial Relations42(4): 705–25.
47.
REC (2010) Managed Services in Recruitment and Staffing (Volume 1). London: REC.
48.
REC/CIPD (2008) The Relationship between HR and Recruitment Agencies – A Guide to Productive Partnerships. London: Recruitment and Employment Confederation.
49.
RedmanTSnapeEHamiltonPWassJ (2007) Evaluating the human resource shared services model: evidence from the NHS. International Journal of Human Resource Management18(8): 1485–505.
50.
SakoM (2006) Outsourcing and off-shoring: implications for productivity of business services. Oxford Review of Economic Policy22(4): 499–512.
51.
SchlosserFTemplerAGhanamD (2006) How human resource outsourcing affects organisational learning in the knowledge economy. Journal of Labour Research47(3): 291–303.
52.
SpiezerI (2008) Firms re-evaluate reliability of vendor management system suppliers. Workforce Management Magazine. URL (consulted December 2010): http://www.workforce.com/index.html
53.
StoreyJQuintasPTaylorPFowleW (2002) Flexible employment contracts and their implications for product and process innovation. International Journal of Human Resource Management13(1): 1–18.
54.
TailbyS (2005) Agency and bank nursing in the UK National Health Service. Work, Employment and Society19(2): 369–89.
55.
TremblayMPatryMLanoieP (2008) Human resources outsourcing in Canadian organisations: an empirical analysis of the role of organisational characteristics, transaction costs and risks. International Journal of Human Resource Management19(4): 683–715.
56.
TUC (2007) Agency Workers: Counting the Cost of Flexibility. London: Equality and Employment Rights Department, Trades Union Congress.
57.
WardKGrimshawDRuberyJBeynonH (2001) Dilemmas in the management of temporary work agency staff. Human Resource Management Journal11(4): 3–21.
58.
WolfendenN (2007) Non-standard employment contracts in the IT sector: the shifting boundaries of control. Un-published PhD thesis, University of Leeds.
