In this article, I discuss the ways in which prostitution in Mumbai's main
red light area is produced and functions as a spectacle. I examine several
instantiations of discourses on prostitution in the city, including the press, and a
2003 HIV/AIDS prevention campaign which targeted female sex workers and their
clients. I argue that the spectacle of prostitution in Mumbai is framed by
international discourses of trafficking, as well as the local dialectics of stigma
and honor. I conclude by discussing prostitution in other parts of India, where
there is a greater degree of rights-based organizing.
Bhansal, Rohit
(2003) ‘Is the Golden Quadrilateral a Golden
Goose?’, The Financial Express (8 Dec. 2003),
http://www.financialexpress.com/fe_full_story.php?content_id=47945
(accessed Nov. 2005).
2.
Bhave, G.
,
C.P. Lindan
,
E.S. Hudes
,
S. Desai
,
U. Wagle
,
S.P. Tripathi
and
J.S. Mandel
(1995)
‘Impact of an Intervention on HIV, Sexually Transmitted Diseases,
and Condom Use among Sex Workers in Mumbai, India’
, AIDS9(suppl. 1):
S21–S30
.
3.
Boy, A.H.S.
(2004) ‘Biding Spectacular
Time’,review essay of Guy Debord'sSociety of the Spectacle,
http://library.nothingness.org/articles/4/en/display/70 (accessed 8 Dec. 2004).
4.
Center for Feminist Legal Research
(2004) Report on Cross Border Movements and Human
Rights.
New Delhi: CFLR
.
5.
Cheng, Sealing
(2004) ‘Good Intentions Can Do
Harm’, Korea Times (accessed 13 Dec. 2004).
6.
Deb, Kaushik
(2000)
‘Private Investment and Policy Developments in Transport Sector’
,Economic and Political Weekly5(14):
1277–1282
.
7.
Debord, Guy
(1994) Society of the Spectacle, tr. Donald
Nicholson-Smith.
New York: Zone Books
.
8.
D'Souza, Dilip
(2002) The Narmada Dammed.
New Delhi: Penguin Books India
.
9.
Dutta, Bishaka
(2002) In the Flesh, film.
10.
Forum Against the Oppression of Women (FAOW) (2006) personal communication, 3 June.
11.
Ghosh, Shohini
(2002) Tales of the Night Fairies, film.
12.
Gupta, Ruchira
(1997) The Selling of Innocents, film.
13.
Höjer, Birgitta
(2003)
‘The Discourse of Global Compassion and the Media’
, Nordicom (Nordic Research on Media and Communication) Review2:
19–29
.
14.
Hubbard, Phil
(1998)
‘Sexuality and Immorality in the City: Red-Light Districts and
the Marginalisation of Female Street Prostitutes’
,Gender, Place and Culture5(1):
55–72
.
15.
Immoral Traffic (Prevention) Act, revised (1990),
Delhi Government of India
.
16.
Jain, M.K.
,
T.J. John
and
G.T. Keusch
(1994)
‘Epidemiology of HIV and AIDS in India [Review]’
, AIDS8(suppl. 2):
S61–S75
.
17.
Jordan, Bobby
(2002) ‘The HIV Counsellors Who Sell their
Bodies at Night’, Sunday Times (7 April).
18.
Kapur, Ratna
(2003)
‘The “Other” Side of Globalization: The Legal
Regulation of Cross-Border Movements’
, Canadian Woman Studies22(3/4):
6 –15
.
19.
Kellner, Douglas
(2003) Media Spectacle.
New York: Routledge
.
20.
Kotiswaran, Prabha
(2001)
‘Preparing for Civil Disobedience: Indian Sex Workers and the Law’
, Boston College Third World Law Journal21(2):
161–242
.
21.
Kulick, Don
(2005)
‘Four Hundred Thousand Swedish Perverts’
,GLQ: A Journal of Gay and Lesbian Studies11(2):
205 –235
.
22.
Menan, Rajendra
(2001) ‘The Ironies of
Kamathipura’,The Hindu (3 June).
23.
Pais, P.
(1996)
‘HIV and India: Looking into the Abyss’
,Tropical Medicine and International Health1(3):
295 –304
.
24.
Patkar, Medha
, ed. (2004) River Linking: A Millennium Folly?Bangalore: National Alliance of
People's Movements and Initiative
.
25.
Population Services International
(2003) Will Balbir Pasha Get AIDS? A Case Study.
Washington, DC: Population Services International
.
26.
Shah, Svati (2005) ‘Seeing Sexual Commerce: Sex, Work, and
Migration in the City of Mumbai’, unpublished PhD dissertation, Department
of Sociomedical Sciences, Columbia University, New York.
27.
Shiva, Vandana
(2003) India on Fire: The Lethal Mix of Free Trade, Famine
and Fundamentalism in India.
New York: Seven Stories Press
.
28.
SNDT Women's University and Forum Against the Oppression of Women
(2005) Background and Working Conditions of Women Working as
Dancers in Dance Bars.
Mumbai: FAOW
.
29.
Sukhtankar, Ashwini (2002) ‘The Dangers of Dignity and the Hazards
of Health: Sexuality, Law, and the Language of Reform in
India’,unpublished 3rd year law paper, Harvard University School of Law.
30.
Sznaider, Natan
(1998)
‘The Sociology of Compassion: A Study in the Sociology of Morals’
, Cultural Values2(1):
117–139
.
31.
Tandon, Tripti
and
Anand Grover
(2006)
‘(W)Rec(T)ifying ITPA: Proposed Amendments to the Immoral Traffi
cking Prevention Act’
,From the Lawyers Collective21(3):
7–16
.
32.
Times News Network
(2003) ‘AIDS Campaign to Wind up by Jan
27’,Times of India (21 Jan.).
33.
United Nations
(1993) ‘Internal Migration of Women in
Developing Countries: Proceedings of the United Nations Expert Meeting on the
Feminization of Internal Migration’,Aguascalientes,
Mexico, 22–25 Oct. 1991.
New York: United Nations
.
34.
US State Department
(2004) Trafficking in Persons Report.
Washington, DC: US State Department
, http://gvnet.com/humantrafficking/00-Ratings.htm (accessed
June 2005).
