This article analyzes the conflicts and contradictions released by the processes of
democratization and globalization in Bangladesh as they are played out between two
competing groups of rural patrons: the clergy and the developmental non-governmental
organizations. Both groups vie for rural dominance by fighting over the role of
women in society. By investigating the violent circumstances surrounding a poor
women’s rally in 1998, I examine how, in this conflict, these women were
vulnerably situated in relation to the clergy and the NGO. The Bangladeshi state,
which has fostered an Islamic ideology, remains complicit in this violation of
women. I further argue that the good intentions of feminist NGOs are constrained in
their ability to offer an autonomous critique of NGO practices because of their
structural dependence on the NGOs.
Ahamad, Emajuddin
and
Dil Roushan Jinnat Ara Nasrin
(n.d.) ‘Islam in Bangladesh’, URL (consulted
June 2004): http://www.power-xs.de/delta/islam.html
3.
Bangladesh Bureau of Education and Information Statistics (BANBEIS)
(2003) URL (consulted Feb. 2003): http://www.banbeis.org/dbbb/insprol.html
4.
Barlas, Asma
(2003) ‘Believing Women’ in
Islam: Unreading Patriarchal Interpretations of the Quran.
Austin, TX: University of Texas Press
.
5.
Connell, Joseph
(2001) ‘The Bengal Muslims and the State:
Secularism or Humanity for Bangladesh’, in
Rafiuddin Ahmed
(ed.) Understanding the Bengal Muslims, pp.
179–208.
New Delhi: Oxford University Press
.
6.
Counts, Alex
(1996) Who Needs Credit?New Delhi: Research Press
.
7.
Daily Star
(2001) ‘Fatwa Illegal, Declares HC’
(3 Jan., Dhaka).
8.
Feldman, Shelley
(1998) ‘Representing Islam: Manipulating Gender,
Shifting State Policies, and Class Frustrations in
Bangladesh’, in
Patricia Jeffrey
and
Amrita Basu
(eds) Appropriating Gender: Women’s Activism and Politicized
Religion in South Asia, pp. 33–52.
New York and London: Routledge
.
9.
Feldman, Shelley
(2001) ‘Gender and Islam in Bangladesh: Metaphor
and Myth’, in
Rafiuddin Ahmed
(ed.) Understanding the Bengal Muslims, pp.
209–235.
New Delhi: Oxford University Press
.
10.
Goetz, Anne-Marie
and
Sengupta Rina
(1996)
‘Who Takes the Credit? Gender, Power and Control over Loan Use in
Rural Credit Programs in Bangladesh’
, World Development24(1):
45–64
.
11.
Harrison, Christine M.
(2002)
‘Tough Row to Hoe: Can CEDAW’s Optional Protocol Help
Muslim Women in Rural Bangladesh Realize their Right to Development?’
, Praxis, Fletcher School Journal of Development Studies18:
4-4
.
12.
Hashmi, Taj-ul
(2000) Women and Islam in Bangladesh: Beyond Subjection and
Tyranny.
New York: St Martin’s Press
.
13.
Hossain, Sara and Suzanne Turner
(2001) ‘Abduction for Forced Marriage: Rights and
Remedies in Bangladesh and Pakistan’, Report submitted by
INTERIGHTS, Ain-o-Salish Kendro (Bangladesh) and Shirkat Giha (Pakistan) to the
British Home Office’s Working Group on Forced Marriage.
14.
Kabeer, Naila
(1991) ‘The Quest for National
Identity’, in
Deniz Kandiyoti
(ed.) Women, Islam and the State, pp.
115–143.
Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press
.
15.
Kandiyoti, Deniz
(1995) ‘Reflections on the Politics of Gender in
Muslim Societies: From Nairobi to Beijing’, in
Mahnaz Afkhami
(ed.) Faith and Freedom: Women’s Human Rights in the Muslim
World, pp. 19–32.
Syracuse, NY: Syracuse University Press
.
16.
Karim, Lamia (2001a) ‘Development and its Discontents: NGOs, Women
and the Politics of Social Mobilization in Bangladesh’, dissertation, Rice
University: Houston, TX.
17.
Karim, Lamia
(2001b)
‘Politics of the Poor? NGOs and Grass-roots Political
Mobilization of the Poor’
, Political and Legal Anthropology Review24(1):
92–107
.
18.
Mannan, Manzurul
(1994) Fatwabazz Against BRAC? Are they Alone?Dhaka: BRAC, Research and Evaluation Department
.
19.
Mascarenhas, Anthony
(1986) Bangladesh: A Legacy of Blood.
London: Hodder & Stoughton
.
20.
Muhith, A.M.A.
(1978) Bangladesh: Emergence of a Nation.
Dhaka: Bangladesh Books International
.
21.
Murshid, Tazeen
(1995) The Sacred and the Secular: Bengali Muslim Discourses,
1877–1977.
Calcutta and New York: Oxford University Press
.
22.
Murshid, Tazeen
(2004) ‘Women, Islam and the State: Subordination
and Resistance’, URL (consulted June 2004): http://www.lib.uchicago.edu/e/su/southasia/Tazeen.html.
23.
Ong, Aihwa
(1987) Spirits of Resistance and Capitalist Discipline:
Factory Women in Malaysia.
New York: State University of New York Press
.
24.
Pereira, Faustina
(2003)
‘Legislating Justice in the Postcolonial Subcontinent’
, Paper presented for the Jeremiah Lecture Series,
University of Oregon, Eugene, OR.
25.
Prothom Alo
(1998a) ‘Brahmanbariar NGO Shanggitio Ghar-Bari Loot
Hoyechey’ (Houses of NGO Members Looted in Brahmanbaria) (12 Dec.).
26.
Prothom Alo
(1998b) ‘Brahmanbariay Shohinshutar Pechone Sharther
Khela’ (The Play of Personal Politics behind the Brahmanbaria
Melee) (13 Dec.).
27.
Rahman, Aminur
(1999)
‘Microcredit Initiatives for Equitable and Sustainable
Development: Who Pays?’
, World Development27(1):
67–82
.
28.
Samaj Chetona
(1998) ‘Brahmanbaria: Fatwa Brittanto O Dadan
Brittanto’ (
Brahmanbaria: Fatwa and its Relationship to Moneylending
) (Dec.): 12–15.
29.
Sassen, Saskia
(1998) Globalization and its Discontents.
New York: New York Press
.
30.
Shehabuddin, Elora
(1999)
‘Contesting the Illicit: Gender and the Politics of Fatwas in Bangladesh’
, Signs24:
1011–1044
.
31.
Sikand, Yoginder
(2001) ‘Madrassah Education in South
Asia’, Himal, URL (June 2004): http://himalmag.com
32.
Sobhan, Rehman
(1997) ‘The Political Economy of
Micro-Credit’, in
Geoffrey Wood
and
Iffath Sharif
(eds) Who Needs Credit? Poverty and Finance in Bangladesh, pp.
131–141.
Dhaka: University Press
.
33.
Todd, Helen
(1996) Women at the Center.
Dhaka: University Press
.
