The recasting of Chinese socialism: The Chinese New Left since 2000

Abstract

In post-Mao China, a group of Chinese intellectuals who formed what became the New Left (新左派) sought to renew socialism in China in a context of globalization and the rise of social inequalities they associated with neo-liberalism. As they saw it, China’s market reform and opening to the world had not brought greater equality and prosperity for all Chinese citizens. As part of China Information’s research dialogue on the intellectual public sphere in China, this article provides a historical survey of the development of the contemporary Chinese New Left, exploring the range of ideas that characterized this intellectual movement. It takes as its focus four of the most prominent New Left figures and their positions in the ongoing debate about China’s future: Wang Shaoguang, Cui Zhiyuan, Wang Hui, and Gan Yang.

Keywords

contemporary China market reform end of history New Left Chinese socialism Maoism democracy statism

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Anderson

Perry 佩里·安德森

(2002) 新自由主义的历史和教训 (History and lessons of neo-liberalism). Trans. Fei

Xinlu 费新录

. 天涯 (Frontiers), no. 3: 162–70.

Bell

Daniel A.

(2015) The China Model: Political Meritocracy and the Limits of Democracy. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Cheek

Timothy

(2015) The Intellectual in Modern Chinese History. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Cui

Zhiyuan 崔之元

(1994) 制度创新与第二次思想解放 (Institutional innovation and the second thought liberation) 二十一世纪 (Twenty-first century), no. 24: 5–16.

Cui

Zhiyuan 崔之元

(1994) ‘国家能力’辩证观 (The dialectical view of ‘state capacity’). 二十一世紀 (Twenty-first century), no. 21: 19–21.

Cui

Zhiyuan 崔之元

(1995) 再论‘第二次思想解放’与制度创新 – 兼答各位评论者(Rethinking the ‘second thought liberation’ and institutional innovation – Responding to all comments). 二十一世紀 (Twenty-first century), no. 27: 134–45.

Cui

Zhiyuan 崔之元

(1996) 鞍钢宪法与后福特主义 (Angang constitution and post-Fordism). 读书 (Readings), no. 3: 11–21.

Cui

Zhiyuan 崔之元

(1997) 第二次思想解放与制度创新 (The second thought liberation and institutional innovation). Hong Kong: Oxford University Press.

崔之元: 小康社会主义与中国未来: 小资产阶级宣言 (Cui Zhiyuan: Well-off socialism and the future of China: Declaration of the petty bourgeoisie) (2004) 12 November. http://www.aisixiang.com/data/4610.html, accessed 21 May 2015.

10.

Deng

Jun

Smith

Craig A.

(2018) The rise of New Confucianism and the return of spirituality to politics in mainland China. China Information 32(2): forthcoming.

11.

Dirlik

Arif 阿里夫·德里克

(2007) 后社会主义? – 反思‘有中国特色的社会主义’ (Post-socialism? – Reflections on ‘socialism with Chinese characteristics’). Trans. Er

Dong 尔东

. In: Yuan

Jie 苑洁

(ed.) 后社会主义 (Post-socialism). Beijing: 中央编译出版社 (Central compilation and translation press), 25–44.

12.

Fukuyama

Francis

(1992) The End of History and the Last Man. London: Free Press.

13.

Gan

Yang 甘阳

(1997) 从经济民族走向政治民族: 中国政治改革的中心问题 (From economic nation to political nation: The central problem of China’s political reform). In: Yang 甘阳

Gan

Zhiyuan 崔之元

Cui

(eds) 中国改革的政治经济学 (Political economy of China’s reform). Hong Kong: Oxford University Press, 3–8.

14.

Gan

Yang 甘阳

(1999) 自由主义: 贵族的还是平民的? (Liberalism: For the noble or for the common people?). 读书 (Readings), no. 1: 85–94.

15.

Gan

Yang 甘阳

(2003) 中国自由左派的由来 (The origin of China’s liberal left). In: Gong

Yang 公羊

(ed.) 思潮: 中国新左派及其影响 (Trends: China’s New Left and its influence). Beijing: 中國社会科学出版社 (China social sciences press), 110–20.

16.

Gan

Yang 甘阳

(2012) 文明, 国家, 大学 (Civilization, state, and university). Beijing: 生活·读书·新知三联书店 (SDX joint publishing).

17.

(2015) Political Thought and China’s Transformation: Ideas Shaping Reform in Post-Mao China. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.

18.

Zehou 李泽厚

Liu

Zaifu 刘再复

(1995) 告别革命: 回望二十世纪中国 (Farewell to revolution: Looking back at 20th-century China). Hong Kong: 天地圖書有限公司 (Cosmos books).

19.

Zonggui

(2014) Between Tradition and Modernity: Philosophical Reflections on the Modernization of Chinese Culture. Oxford: Chartridge Books Oxford.

20.

Hua

Galway

Matthew

(2018) Freedom and its limitations: The contemporary mainland Chinese debate over liberalism. China Information 32(2): forthcoming.

21.

Mao

Zedong

(1998) On the question of the differentiation of the three worlds, 22 February 1974. In: Mao Zedong on Diplomacy. Beijing: Foreign Languages Press.

22.

Pan

Wei 潘维

(2009) 中国模式: 解读人民共和国的60年 (Chinese model: Interpreting 60 years of the People’s Republic). Beijing: 中央编译出版社 (Central compilation and translation press).

23.

Przeworski

Adam

Wallerstein

Michael

(1986) Popular sovereignty, state autonomy, and private property. European Journal of Sociology/Archives Européennes de Sociologie/Europäisches Archiv für Soziologie 27(2): 215–59.

24.

Roemer

John

(1986) ‘Rational choice’ Marxism: Some issues of method and substance. In: Roemer

John

(ed.) Analytical Marxism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

25.

Tang

Xiaobing

McConaghy

Mark

(2018) Liberalism in contemporary China: Questions, strategies, and directions. China Information 32(1): 121–38.

26.

Wang

Hui 汪晖

(1997) 当代中国的思想状况与现代性问题 (Contemporary Chinese thought and the question of modernity). 天涯 (Frontiers), no. 5: 133–50.

27.

Wang

Hui

(2003) China’s New Order: Society, Politics, and Economy in Transition. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

28.

Wang

Hui 汪晖

(2004–8) 现代中国思想的兴起 (The rise of modern Chinese thought). 4 vols. Beijing: 生活·读书·新知三联书店 (SDX joint publishing).

29.

Wang

Hui 汪晖

(2007) 去政治化的政治, 霸权的多重构成与60年代的消逝 (Depoliticized politics, the multiple composition of hegemony, and the lapse of 1960s). 开放时代 (Open times), no. 2: 5–41.

30.

Wang

Hui 汪晖

(2008) 去政治化的政治: 短20世纪的终结与90年代 (Depoliticized politics: The end of the 20th century and the 1990s). Beijing: 生活·读书·新知三联书店 (SDX joint publishing).

31.

Wang

Hui 汪晖

(2010) 中国崛起的经验及其面临的挑战 (The experience of China’s rise and its challenges). 文化纵横 (Beijing review), no. 2: 24–35.

32.

Wang

Hui 汪晖

(2014) 代表性断裂与后政党政治 (Representative fracture and post-party politics). 开放时代 (Open times), no. 2: 70–9.

33.

Wang

Hui

(2016) China’s Twentieth Century: Revolution, Retreat, and the Road to Equality. Ed. Thomas

Saul

. London: Verso.

34.

Wang

Shaoguang 王绍光

(1991) 关于‘市民社会’的几点思考 (A few points of reflections on ‘civil society’). 二十一世紀 (Twenty-first century), no. 8: 102–14.

35.

Wang

Shaoguang 王绍光

(1994) 国家在市场经济转型中的作用 (The role of the state in market transformation). 战略与管理 (Strategy and management), no. 2: 90–6.

36.

Wang

Shaoguang 王绍光

(1995) 分权的底线 (The bottom line of authority’s decentralization). 战略与管理 (Strategy and management), no. 2: 37–56.

37.

Wang

Shaoguang 王绍光

(2000) 权力的代价与改革的路径依赖 (The cost of power and the path to reform). 战略与管理 (Strategy and management), no. 5: 112–15.

38.

Wang

Shaoguang 王绍光

(2002) 左脑的思考 (Left-brain thinking). Tianjin: 天津人民出版社 (Tianjin people’s publishing house).

39.

Wang

Shaoguang 王绍光

(2007) 安邦之道: 国家转型的目标与途径 (Ampang road: The goal and approach of national transformation). Beijing: 生活·读书·新知三联书店 (SDX joint publishing).

40.

Wang

Shaoguang 王绍光

(2010) 袪魅與超越: 反思民主, 自由, 平等, 公民社会 (Disenchantment and transcendence: Reflexion on democracy, freedom, equality and civil society). Hong Kong: 三联书店 (Joint publishing).

41.

Wang

Shaoguang 王绍光

(2014) 代表型民主与代表型民主 (Representative democracy versus representational democracy). 开放时代 (Open times), no. 2: 152–74.

42.

Wang

Shaoguang 王绍光

Angang 胡鞍钢

(1993) 中国国家能力报告 (A report on China’s state capacity). Shenyang: 辽宁人民出版社 (Liaoning people’s publishing house).

43.

Yang

Dali 杨大力

(1994) 对‘濒危论’的几点反驳 (Some retorts on the ‘thesis of imminent danger’). 二十一世紀 (Twenty-first century), no. 21: 15–18.

44.

Zhu

Xueqin 朱学勤

(1994) 道德理想国的覆灭: 从卢梭到罗伯斯庇尔 (The destruction of moral utopia: From Rousseau to Robespierre). Shanghai: 上海三联书店 (Shanghai joint publishing) .