Game of Loans: The Relationship Between Education Debt,Social Responsibility Concerns,and Making a Career Choice in the Public,Private,and Nonprofit Sectors

Abstract

The public and nonprofit sectors generally pay less than the private sector, and individuals are willing to forgo higher salaries in exchange for greater intrinsic satisfaction derived from making a contribution to society. However, personal financial considerations, such as education debt, may discourage individuals from pursuing careers in lower paying sectors even if they are predisposed to public service motivation (PSM). We surveyed a sample of graduating students to investigate if (a) education debt discourages students from pursuing lower paying public or nonprofit careers and (b) whether PSM overrides the considerations students might make about entering lower paying sectors as their education debt rises. First, we find that education debt has a marginal effect on initially selecting private over public and nonprofit careers. Rising education debt may discourage students from public sector careers after controlling for PSM. We also find that rising education debt may discourage students from nonprofit careers even with high levels of PSM. The present study enhances our understanding of how financial considerations, in the form of education debt, may influence a student’s initial choice in pursuing public, private, and nonprofit careers.

Keywords

public service motivation career choice education debt student loans nonprofit employment

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Accenture. (2016). Insights from the Accenture Strategy 2016 U.S. College Graduate Employment Study. Retrieved from https://www.accenture.com/t20160512T073844Z__w__/us-en/_acnmedia/PDF-18/Accenture-Strategy-2016-Grad-Research-Gig-Experience-Unleash-Talent.pdf#zoom=50

Alonso

Lewis

G. B.

(2001). Public service motivation and job performance: Evidence from the federal sector. The American Review of Public Administration, 31, 363-380.

Andruska

E. A.

Hogarth

J. M.

Fletcher

C. N.

Forbes

G. R.

Wohlgemuth

D. R.

(2014). Do you know what you owe? Students’ understanding of their student loans. Journal of Student Financial Aid, 44, 125-148.

Bassous

(2015). What are the factors that affect worker motivation in faith-based nonprofit organizations? VOLUNTAS: International Journal of Voluntary and Nonprofit Organizations, 26, 355-381.

Behymer

Cockriel

I. W.

(1988). Career choice conflict. Journal of Career Development, 15, 134-140.

Bellante

Link

A. N.

(1981). Are public sector workers more risk averse than private sector workers? ILR Review, 34, 408-412.

Bellé

(2013). Experimental evidence on the relationship between public service motivation and job performance. Public Administration Review, 73, 143-153.

Bleemer

Brown

Lee

van der Klaauw

(2014). Debt, jobs, or housing: What’s keeping millennials at home? (Federal Reserve Bank of New York Staff Report No. 700). Retrieved from https://www.newyorkfed.org/medialibrary/media/research/staff_reports/sr700.pdf

Borzaga

Tortia

(2006). Worker motivations, job satisfaction, and loyalty in public and nonprofit social services. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 35, 225-248.

10.

Bozeman

(2015). Public service motivation concepts and theory: A critique. Public Administration Review, 75, 700-710.

11.

Bright

(2007). Does person-organization fit mediate the relationship between public service motivation and the job performance of public employees? Review of Public Personnel Administration, 27, 361-379.

12.

Buelens

Van den Broeck

(2007). An analysis of differences in work motivation between public and private sector organizations. Public Administration Review, 67, 65-74.

13.

Camilleri

(2006). Towards developing an organisational commitment-public service motivation model for the Maltese public service employees. Public Policy and Administration, 21, 63-83.

14.

The Canadian Press. (2017, February 14). Government to write off $178 million in unpaid federal student loans. The Star. Retrieved from https://www.thestar.com/news/canada/2017/02/14/government-to-write-off-178-million-in-unpaid-federal-student-loans.html

15.

Castaing

(2006). The effects of psychological contract fulfilment and public service motivation on organizational commitment in the French civil service. Public Policy and Administration, 21, 84-98.

16.

Chetkovich

(2003). What’s in a sector? The shifting career plans of public policy students. Public Administration Review, 63, 660-674.

17.

Cho

S. H.

Kiss

D. E.

(2015). Understanding student loan decisions: A literature review. Family and Consumer Sciences Research Journal, 43, 229-243.

18.

Choi

(2014). Debt and college students’ life transitions: The effect of educational debt on career choice in America. Journal of Student Financial Aid, 44, 24-41.

19.

Choi

(2016). Work values, job characteristics, and career choice decisions: Evidence from longitudinal data. The American Review of Public Administration, 47, 779-796. doi:10.1177/0275074016653469

20.

Christensen

R. K.

Wright

B. E.

(2011). The effects of public service motivation on job choice decisions: Disentangling the contributions of person-organization fit and person-job fit. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 21, 723-743.

21.

Clerkin

R. M.

Coggburn

J. D.

(2012). The dimensions of public service motivation and sector work preferences. Review of Public Personnel Administration, 32, 209-235.

22.

Clerkin

R. M.

Paynter

S. R.

Taylor

J. K.

(2009). Public service motivation in undergraduate giving and: Volunteering decisions. The American Review of Public Administration, 39, 675-698.

23.

Crewson

P. E.

(1997). Public-service motivation: Building empirical evidence of incidence and effect. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 7, 499-518.

24.

Dur

Zoutenbier

(2014). Working for a good cause. Public Administration Review, 74, 144-155.

25.

Eisold

(2010, August 23). Why are the poor more generous? We are more generous to members of our own group [Psychology Today Blog]. Retrieved from https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/hidden-motives/201008/why-are-the-poor-more-generous

26.

Elliott

Lewis

(2015). Student debt effects on financial well-being: Research and policy implications. Journal of Economic Surveys, 29, 614-636.

27.

Ferguson

S. J.

Wang

(2014). Graduating in Canada: Profile, Labour Market Outcomes and Student Debt of the class of 2009-2010. Ottawa, Ontario: Statistics Canada.

28.

Field

(2009). Educational debt burden and career choice: Evidence from a financial aid experiment at NYU law school. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 1, 1-21.

29.

Frederickson

H. G.

Hart

D. K.

(1985). The public service and the patriotism of benevolence. Public Administration Review, 45, 547-553.

30.

Gabris

G. T.

Simo

(1995). Public sector motivation as an independent variable affecting career decisions. Public Personnel Management, 24, 33-51.

31.

Georgellis

Iossa

Tabvuma

(2011). Crowding out intrinsic motivation in the public sector. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 21, 473-493.

32.

Grayson

M. S.

Newton

D. A.

Thompson

L. F.

(2012). Payback time: The associations of debt and income with medical student career choice. Medical Education, 46, 983-991.

33.

Hansen

M. N.

(1997). Social and economic inequality in the educational career: Do the effects of social background characteristics decline? European Sociological Review, 13, 305-321.

34.

Henstra

McGowan

R. A.

(2016). Millennials and public service: An exploratory analysis of graduate student career motivations and expectations. Public Administration Quarterly, 40, 490-516.

35.

Houston

D. J.

(2000). Public-service motivation: A multivariate test. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 10, 713-727.

36.

Houston

D. J.

(2006). “Walking the walk” of public service motivation: Public employees and charitable gifts of time, blood, and money. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 16, 67-86.

37.

Howe

(2014). How the millennial generation is transforming employee benefits. Benefits Quarterly, 30(2), 8-14.

38.

Jepsen

D. A.

Sheu

H. B.

(2003). General job satisfaction from a developmental perspective: Exploring choice—Job matches at two career stages. The Career Development Quarterly, 52, 162-179.

39.

Kim

Vandenabeele

(2010). A strategy for building public service motivation research internationally. Public Administration Review, 70, 701-709.

40.

King

Lewis

G. B.

(2017). Nonprofit Pay in a Competitive Market: Wage Penalty or Premium? Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 46, 1073-1091.

41.

Kjeldsen

A. M.

Jacobsen

C. B.

(2013). Public service motivation and employment sector: Attraction or socialization? Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 23, 899-926.

42.

Knutsen

W. L.

Chan

(2015). The phenomenon of staff volunteering: How far can you stretch the psychological contract in a nonprofit organization? VOLUNTAS: International Journal of Voluntary and Nonprofit Organizations, 26, 962-983.

43.

Lammam

Palacios

Ren

Clemens

(2015). Comparing government and private sector compensation in Canada. Retrieved from https://www.fraserinstitute.org/sites/default/files/comparing-government-and-private-sector-compensation-in-canada.pdf

44.

Lee

Y. J.

(2012). Behavioral implications of public service motivation: Volunteering by public and nonprofit employees. The American Review of Public Administration, 42, 104-121.

45.

Lee

Y. J.

Wilkins

V. M.

(2011). More similarities or more differences? Comparing public and nonprofit managers’ job motivations. Public Administration Review, 71, 45-56.

46.

Leisink

Steijn

(2009). Public service motivation and job performance of public sector employees in the Netherlands. International Review of Administrative Sciences, 75, 35-52.

47.

Lewis

G. B.

Frank

S. A.

(2002). Who wants to work for the government? Public Administration Review, 62, 395-404.

48.

Lewis

G. B.

E. S. W.

(2013). Sexual orientation, work values, pay, and preference for public and nonprofit employment: Evidence from Canadian postsecondary students. Canadian Public Administration, 56, 542-564.

49.

Locke

E. A.

(1976). The nature and causes of job satisfaction. In Dunnette

M. D.

(Ed.), Handbook of industrial and organizational psychology (pp. 1297-1343). Chicago, IL: Rand McNally.

50.

Lyons

S. T.

Duxbury

L. E.

Higgins

C. A.

(2006). A comparison of the values and commitment of private sector, public sector, and parapublic sector employees. Public Administration Review, 66, 605-618.

51.

Mann

G. A.

(2006). A motive to serve: Public service motivation in human resource management and the role of PSM in the nonprofit sector. Public Personnel Management, 35, 33-48.

52.

McGinnis Johnson

J. M.

E. S. W

. (2015). Money talks or millennials walk: The effect of compensation on nonprofit millennial workers sector-switching intentions. Review of Public Personnel Administration, 36, 283-305.

53.

Minicozzi

(2005). The short term effect of educational debt on job decisions. Economics of Education Review, 24, 417-430.

54.

Moulton

Feeney

M. K.

(2010). Public service in the private sector: Private loan originator participation in a public mortgage program. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 21, 547-572.

55.

Moynihan

D. P.

Pandey

S. K.

(2007). The role of organizations in fostering public service motivation. Public Administration Review, 67, 40-53.

56.

E. S. W.

Gossett

C. W.

(2013). Career choice in Canadian public service: An exploration of fit with the millennial generation. Public Personnel Management, 42, 337-358.

57.

E. S. W.

Gossett

C. W.

Chinyoka

Obasi

(2016). Public vs private sector employment: An exploratory study of career choice among graduate management students in Botswana. Personnel Review, 45, 1367-1385.

58.

E. S. W.

Lyons

S. T.

Schweitzer

(2017). Millennials in Canada: Young workers in a challenging labour market. In Parry

McCarthy

(Eds.), The Palgrave handbook of age diversity and work (pp. 325-344). Basingstoke, UK: Palgrave Macmillan.

59.

E. S. W.

Sears

G. J.

(2015). Toward representative bureaucracy: Predicting public service attraction among underrepresented groups in Canada. Review of Public Personnel Administration, 35, 367-385.

60.

Pandey

S. K.

Wright

B. E.

Moynihan

D. P.

(2008). Public service motivation and interpersonal citizenship behavior in public organizations: Testing a preliminary model. International Public Management Journal, 11, 89-108.

61.

Park

S. M.

Word

(2012). Driven to service: Intrinsic and extrinsic motivation for public and nonprofit managers. Public Personnel Management, 41, 705-734.

62.

Perry

J. L.

Hondeghem

(2008). Motivation in public management: The call of public service. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.

63.

Perry

J. L.

Hondeghem

Wise

L. R.

(2010). Revisiting the motivational bases of public service: Twenty years of research and an agenda for the future. Public Administration Review, 70, 681-690.

64.

Perry

J. L.

Wise

L. R.

(1990). The motivational bases of public service. Public Administration Review, 50, 367-373.

65.

Perry

V. G.

(2011). Charging ahead: An exploratory study of financial decision-making among millennial consumers. In Lamdin

D. J.

(Ed.), Consumer knowledge and financial decisions (pp. 129-144). New York, NY: Springer.

66.

Ritz

(2011). Attraction to public policy-making: A qualitative inquiry into improvements in PSM measurement. Public Administration, 89, 1128-1147.

67.

Ritz

Brewer

G. A.

Neumann

(2016). Public service motivation: A systematic literature review and outlook. Public Administration Review, 76, 414-426.

68.

Rohlfing

Navarro

Maniya

O. Z.

Hughes

B. D.

Rogalsky

D. K.

(2014). Medical student debt and major life choices other than specialty. Medical Education Online, 19, 1-10.

69.

Rose

R. P.

(2013). Preferences for careers in public work: Examining the Government-Nonprofit divide among undergraduates through public service motivation. The American Review of Public Administration, 43, 416-437.

70.

Rothstein

Rouse

C. E.

(2011). Constrained after college: Student loans and early-career occupational choices. Journal of Public Economics, 95, 149-163.

71.

Sagan

(2016, May 30). As student debt climbs to an average past $25K, schools invest in battling the mental-health issues it causes. National Post. Retrieved from http://news.nationalpost.com/news/canada/as-student-debt-climbs-to-an-average-past-25k-schools-invest-in-battling-the-mental-health-issues-it-causes

72.

Saltzstein

A. L.

Ting

Saltzstein

G. H.

(2001). Work-family balance and job satisfaction: The impact of family-friendly policies on attitudes of federal government employees. Public Administration Review, 61, 452-467.

73.

Smith

P. C.

Kendall

L. M.

Hulin

(1969). The measurement of satisfaction in work and behavior. Chicago, IL: Raud McNally.

74.

Steijn

(2008). Person-environment fit and public service motivation. International Public Management Journal, 11, 13-27.

75.

Taylor

(2012). Public service motivation and work preferences of the Millennials in Australia. In Ng

Lyons

Schweitzer

(Eds.), Managing the new workforce: International perspectives on the millennial generation (pp. 20-41). Northampton, UK: Edward Elgar.

76.

Taylor

, & Pew Research Center. (2014). The next America: Boomers, millennials, and the looming generational showdown. New York, NY: Public Affairs.

77.

Vandenabeele

(2007). Toward a public administration theory of public service motivation: An institutional approach. Public Management Review, 9, 545-556.

78.

Vandenabeele

(2011). Who wants to deliver public service? Do institutional antecedents of public service motivation provide an answer? Review of Public Personnel Administration, 31, 87-107.

79.

Van de Walle

Steijn

Jilke

(2015). Extrinsic motivation, PSM and labour market characteristics: A multilevel model of public sector employment preference in 26 countries. International Review of Administrative Sciences, 81, 833-855.

80.

Winter

Thaler

(2016). Does motivation matter for employer choices? A discrete-choice analysis of medical students’ decisions among public, nonprofit, and for-profit hospitals. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 45, 762-786.

81.

Word

Park

S. M.

(2015). The new public service? Empirical research on job choice motivation in the nonprofit sector. Personnel Review, 44, 91-118.

82.

Wright

B. E.

Christensen

R. K.

(2010). Public service motivation: A test of the job attraction–selection–attrition model. International Public Management Journal, 13, 155-176.

83.

Wright

B. E.

Moynihan

D. P.

Pandey

S. K.

(2012). Pulling the levers: Transformational leadership, public service motivation, and mission valence. Public Administration Review, 72, 206-215.

84.

Wright

B. E.

Pandey

S. K.

(2008). Public service motivation and the assumption of person—Organization fit: Testing the mediating effect of value congruence. Administration & Society, 40, 502-521.