Economic Consequences of Hiring an Auditor With Industry Expertise: An Empirical Analysis Among NPOs

Abstract

This study examines economic consequences of auditor choice in the Belgian nonprofit (NP) setting, where the identity of both the audit firm and the audit partner is required to be disclosed. Specifically, we examine the influence of auditor choice in favor of an auditor with industry expertise on future contributions (being the sum of donations and grants) received among a large sample of Belgian nonprofit organizations (NPOs). Consistent with a signaling perspective, our results indicate that NPOs benefit from engaging an audit partner with industry expertise, by positively influencing future contributions received by the NPO. However, we observe no significant effect of audit firm industry expertise on future contributions received. Our results therefore suggest that NPOs’ resource providers presume that industry expertise is situated at the signing partner level rather than at the audit firm level.

Keywords

auditor choice nonprofit organization contribution financial reporting auditor industry expertise

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abadie

Drukker

Herr

J. L.

Imbens

G. W.

(2004). Implementing matching estimators for average treatment effects in Stata. Stata Journal, 4, 290-311.

Abraham

(1999). Financial accountability in nonprofit organisations: Voluntary audit as self-regulation. Third Sector Review, 5, 25-40.

Amin

Harris

E. E.

(2017). Nonprofit stakeholder response to going-concern audit opinions. Journal of Accounting, Auditing & Finance, 32, 329-349.

Atan

Zainon

Wah

Y. B.

(2012). Quality information by charity organizations and its relationship with donations. In Jha

M. K.

Lazard

Zaharim

Sopian

(Eds.), Recent advances in business administration (pp. 118-123). Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Balsam

Krishnan

Yang

J. S.

(2003). Auditor industry specialization and earnings quality. Auditing: A Journal of Practice & Theory, 22, 71-97.

Beattie

Goodacre

Pratt

Stevenson

(2001). The determinants of audit fees—Evidence from the voluntary sector. Accounting and Business Research, 31, 243-274.

Burks

J. J.

(2015). Accounting errors in nonprofit organizations. Accounting Horizons, 29, 341-361.

Calabrese

T. D.

(2011). Do donors penalize nonprofit organizations with accumulated wealth? Public Administration Review, 71, 859-869.

Carcello

Nagy

(2004). Client size, auditor specialization, and fraudulent financial reporting. Managerial Auditing Journal, 19, 651-668.

10.

Carey

Knechel

W. R.

Tanewski

(2013). Costs and benefits of mandatory auditing of for-profit private and not-for-profit companies in Australia. Australian Accounting Review, 64, 43-53.

11.

Chi

H.-Y.

Chin

C.-L.

(2009). Reducing restatements with increased industry expertise. Contemporary Accounting Research, 26, 729-765.

12.

Chi

H.-Y.

Chin

C.-L.

(2011). Firm versus partner measures of auditor industry expertise and effects on auditor quality. Auditing: A Journal of Practice & Theory, 30, 201-229.

13.

Christiaens

Vanhee

Verbruggen

Milis

(2008). Verenigingen en stichtingen: Vergelijkend en empirisch onderzoek van de boekhoudregelingen [Associations and foundations: Comparative and empirical examination of the accounting rules]. Bruges, Belgium: Die Keure.

14.

Craswell

A. T.

Francis

J. R.

Taylor

S. L.

(1995). Auditor brand name reputations and industry specializations. Journal of Accounting & Economics, 20, 297-322.

15.

Crawford

Dunne

Hannah

Stevenson

(2009). An exploration of Scottish charities’ governance and accountability. Edinburgh: The Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland.

16.

Datar

Feltham

Hughes

(1991). The role of audits and audit quality in valuing new issues. Journal of Accounting & Economics, 14, 3-49.

17.

DeAngelo

(1981). Auditor size and audit quality. Journal of Accounting & Economics, 3, 183-199.

18.

DeFond

M. L.

Jiambalvo

(1991). Incidence and circumstances of accounting errors. The Accounting Review, 66, 643-655.

19.

Deis

D. R.

Giroux

G. A.

(1992). Determinants of audit quality in the public sector. The Accounting Review, 67, 462-479.

20.

Eldenburg

L. G.

Gunny

K. A.

Hee

K. W.

Soderstrom

(2011). Earnings management using real activities: Evidence from nonprofit hospitals. The Accounting Review, 86, 1605-1630.

21.

Emanuele

Simmons

(2004). Does government spending crowd out donations of time and money? Public Finance Review, 32, 498-511.

22.

Enjolras

(2002). The commercialization of voluntary sport organizations in Norway. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 31, 352-376.

23.

Feng

N. C.

(2014). Economic consequences of going concern audit opinions in nonprofit charitable organizations. Journal of Governmental & Nonprofit Accounting, 3, 20-34.

24.

Ferguson

Francis

J. R.

Stokes

D. J.

(2003). The effects of firm-wide and office-level industry expertise on audit pricing. The Accounting Review, 78, 429-448.

25.

Francis

J. R.

Maydew

E. L.

Sparks

H. C.

(1999). The role of Big 6 auditors in the credible reporting of accruals. Auditing: A Journal of Practice & Theory, 18, 17-34.

26.

Haggar-Guenette

Hamdad

Laronde-Jones

Pan

(2009). The satellite account of nonprofit institutions and volunteering (Catalogue No. 13-015-X58). Ottawa, Canada: Statistics Canada.

27.

Hamilton

L. C.

(2012). Statistics with stata. Boston, MA: Cengage.

28.

Harris

E. E.

Krishnan

(2012). The impact of tarnished auditor reputation on nonprofit income. International Journal of Auditing, 16, 130-145.

29.

Harris

E. E.

Petrovits

Yetman

M. H.

(2015). The effect of nonprofit governance on donations: Evidence from the revised form 990. The Accounting Review, 90, 579-610.

30.

Hyndman

McMahon

(2011). The hand of government in shaping accounting and reporting in the UK charity sector. Public Money & Management, 31, 167-174.

31.

Jegers

(2011). On the capital structure of non-profit organisations: A replication and extension with Belgian data. Financial Accountability & Management, 27, 18-31.

32.

Jegers

(2013). Do nonprofit organizations manage earnings? An empirical study. Voluntas, 24, 953-968.

33.

Jetty

Beattie

(2012). The determinants of audit committees: Evidence from the charity sector. Public Money & Management, 32, 371-378.

34.

Jones

C. L.

Roberts

A. A.

(2006). Management of financial information in charitable organizations: The case of joint-cost allocations. The Accounting Review, 81, 159-178.

35.

Keating

E. K.

Fischer

Gordon

T. P.

Greenlee

(2005). The single audit act: How compliant are nonprofit organizations? Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting & Financial Management, 17, 285-309.

36.

Keating

E. K.

Parsons

L. M.

Roberts

A. A.

(2008). Misreporting fundraising: How do nonprofit organizations account for telemarketing campaigns? The Accounting Review, 83, 417-446.

37.

Kitching

(2009). Audit value and charitable organizations. Journal of Accounting and Public Policy, 28, 510-524.

38.

Krishnan

G. V.

(2003). Audit quality and the pricing of discretionary accruals. Auditing: A Journal of Practice & Theory, 22, 109-126.

39.

Krishnan

Yetman

(2006). Expense misreporting in nonprofit organizations. Accounting Review, 81, 399-420.

40.

Leone

A. J.

Van Horn

R. L.

(2005). How do nonprofit hospitals manage earnings? Journal of Health Economics, 24, 815-837.

41.

Lopez

D. M.

Rich

K. T.

Smith

P. C.

(2013). Auditor size and internal control reporting differences in nonprofit healthcare organizations. Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting & Financial Management, 25, 41-68.

42.

Lowensohn

Johnson

L. E.

Elder

R. J.

Davies

S. P.

(2007). Auditor specialization, perceived audit quality, and audit fees in the local government audit market. Journal of Accounting and Public Policy, 26, 705-732.

43.

Maduras

N. P.

(2004). Effects of nonprofit organization wealth and efficiency on private donations to large nonprofit organizations. Research in Government and Nonprofit Accounting, 11, 71-91.

44.

O’Keefe

T. B.

King

R. D.

Gaver

K. M.

(1994). Audit fees, industry specialization and compliance with GAAS reporting standards. Auditing: A Journal of Practice & Theory, 13, 41-55.

45.

Owhoso

E. V.

Messier

W. F.

Lynch

J. G.

(2002). Error detection by industry-specialized teams during sequential audit review. Journal of Accounting Research, 40, 883-900.

46.

Parsons

L. M.

(2003). Is accounting information form nonprofit organizations useful to donors? A review of charitable giving and value-relevance. Journal of Accounting Literature, 22, 104-129.

47.

Pearson

T. A.

Brooks

R. C.

Neidermeyer

A. A.

(1998). The determinants of monitoring costs in non-profit organizations. Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting & Financial Management, 10, 499-512.

48.

Petrovits

Shakespeare

Shih

(2011). The causes and consequences of internal control problems in nonprofit organizations. The Accounting Review, 86, 325-357.

49.

Pettijohn

S. L.

Boris

E. T.

De Vita

C. J.

Fyffe

S. D.

(2013). Nonprofit-government contracts and grants: Findings from the 2013 national survey. Washington, DC: The Urban Institute.

50.

Privett

Erhun

(2011). Efficient funding: Auditing in the nonproﬁt sector. Manufacturing & Service Operations Management, 13, 471-488.

51.

Reheul

A.-M.

Van Caneghem

Verbruggen

(2013a). Auditor performance, client satisfaction and client loyalty: Evidence from Belgian non-profits. International Journal of Auditing, 17, 19-37.

52.

Reheul

A.-M.

Van Caneghem

Verbruggen

(2013b). Audit report lags in the Belgian non-profit sector: An empirical analysis. Accounting and Business Research, 43, 138-158.

53.

Reheul

A.-M.

Van Caneghem

Verbruggen

(2014). Financial reporting lags in the non-profit sector: An empirical analysis. Voluntas, 25, 352-377.

54.

Reichelt

J. K.

Wang

(2010). National and office-specific measures of auditor industry expertise and effects on audit quality. Journal of Accounting Research, 48, 647-686.

55.

Samelson

Lowensohn

Johnson

L. E.

(2006). The determinants of perceived audit quality and auditee satisfaction in local government. Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting & Financial Management, 18, 139-166.

56.

Seltman

H. J.

(2015). Experimental design and analysis. Carnegie Mellon University. Retrieved from http://www.stat.cmu.edu/~hseltman/309/Book/Book.pdf

57.

Solomon

Shields

M. D.

Whittington

O. R.

(1999). What do industry-specialist auditors know? Journal of Accounting Research, 37, 191-208.

58.

Tanyi

Raghunandan

Barua

(2010). Audit report lags after voluntary and involuntary auditor changes. Accounting Horizons, 24, 671-688.

59.

Tate

(2007). Auditor change and auditor choice in nonprofit organizations. Auditing: A Journal of Practice & Theory, 26, 47-70.

60.

Tate

Feng

N. C.

(2013). Perceived quality auditors in the nonprofit sector: Evidence from request for proposal choices. Mustang Journal of Accounting & Finance, 4, 65-96.

61.

Teoh

S. H.

Wong

T. J.

(1993). Perceived auditor quality and the earnings response coefficient. The Accounting Review, 68, 346-366.

62.

Thornton

Belski

(2010). Financial reporting quality and price competition among nonprofit firms. Applied Economics, 42, 2699-2713.

63.

Tinkelman

(2004). Using nonprofit organization-level financial data to infer managers’ fund-raising strategies. Journal of Public Economics, 88, 2181-2192.

64.

Titman

Trueman

(1986). Information quality and the valuation of new issues. Journal of Accounting & Economics, 8, 159-172.

65.

Torres

Pina

(2003). Accounting for accountability and management in NPOs. A comparative study for four countries: Canada, the United Kingdom, the USA and Spain. Financial Accountability & Management, 19, 265-285.

66.

Trussel

J. M.

Parsons

L. M.

(2008). Financial reporting factors affecting donations to charitable organizations. Advances in Accounting, 23, 263-285.

67.

Tuckman

H. P.

Chang

C. F.

(1991). A methodology for measuring the financial vulnerability of charitable nonprofit organizations. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 20, 445-460.

68.

Verbruggen

Christiaens

(2012). Do non-profit organizations manage earnings toward zero profit and does governmental financing play a role? Canadian Journal of Administrative Sciences, 29, 205-217.

69.

Verbruggen

Christiaens

Milis

(2011). Can resource dependence and coercive isomorphism explain nonprofit organizations’ compliance with reporting standards? Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 40, 5-32.

70.

Verbruggen

Christiaens

Reheul

Van Caneghem

(2015). Analysis of audit fees for nonprofits: Resource dependence and agency theory approaches. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 44, 734-754.

71.

Verbruggen

Reheul

A.-M.

Van Caneghem

Dierick

Christiaens

Vanhee

(2011). Het bedrijfsrevisoraat in de verenigingssector/Le révisorat d’entreprises dans le secteur associatif. Antwerpen, Belgium: ICCI & Maklu.

72.

Vermeer

T. E.

Edmonds

C. T.

Asthana

S. C.

(2014). Organizational form and accounting choice: Are nonprofit or for-profit managers more aggressive? The Accounting Review, 89, 1867-1893.

73.

Vermeer

T. E.

Raghunandan

Forgione

D. A.

(2009). Audit fees at U.S. non-profit organizations. Auditing: A Journal of Practice & Theory, 28, 289-303.

74.

Vermeer

T. E.

Raghunandan

Forgione

D. A.

(2013). Going-concern modified audit opinions for non-profit organizations. Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting & Financial Management, 25, 113-134.

75.

Watts

R. L.

Zimmerman

J. L.

(1986). Positive accounting theory. Englewood Cliffs, CA: Prentice-Hall.

76.

Weisbrod

B. A.

Dominguez

N. D.

(1986). Demand for collective goods in private nonprofit markets: Can fundraising expenditures help overcome free-rider behavior? Journal of Public Economy, 30, 83-96.

77.

Wren

(2009). Study into the contribution of the not for profit sector. Strawberry Hills, Australia. Australian Council of Social Service.