Testing the Conventional Wisdom Regarding Volunteer Programs: A Longitudinal Analysis of the Service Corps of Retired Executives and the U.S. Small Business Administration
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online December, 2002
Testing the Conventional Wisdom Regarding Volunteer Programs: A Longitudinal Analysis of the Service Corps of Retired Executives and the U.S. Small Business Administration
Conventional wisdom holds that volunteer programs save money and raise the level of services provided by an organization but threaten paid positions. This study tests these assumptions qualitatively and quantitatively based on the experience of the U.S. Small Business Administration (SBA) and its volunteer program, the Service Corps of Retired Executives (SCORE). The authors examined the SBA’s history with SCORE using interviews, records, and reports and then applied interrupted time-series statistical analysis to 42 years of budget, employment, and output data. The authors found evidence that SBA services increased with SCORE but found no support for stereotypes of adversarial relationships between volunteers and paid staff, volunteer replacement of paid personnel, or cutbacks in agency budget to compensate for the addition of an unpaid workforce. This study has broad implications for both public agencies and nonprofit organizations, sounding a cautionary note that conventional assumptions regarding the impact of volunteers on budget and paid staff may need to be reevaluated.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Armbrister, T.
(1993, September). This town fired its government. Readers Digest, 143(857), 73-76.
2.
Brown, J.
(1983). Government volunteers: Why and how?Journal of Volunteer Administration, 2(1), 9-18.
3.
Brown, W. (1991, August 7). Correspondence with Jeffrey Brudney from Winifred Brown, Executive Director, Mayor’s Voluntary Action Center, City of New York.
4.
Brudney, J. L.
(1986, winter). The SBA and SCORE: Coproducing management assistance services. Public Productivity Review, 40, 57-67.
5.
Brudney, J. L.
(1990). Fostering volunteer programs in the public sector. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
6.
Brudney, J. L.
(1993). Volunteer involvement in the delivery of public services: Advantages and disadvantages. Public Productivity and Management Review, 16(3), 283-197.
7.
Brudney, J. L.
(1995a). The involvement of volunteers in the delivery of services: Myth and management. In S. W. Hayes & R. C. Kearney (Eds.), Public personnel administration (3rd ed., 319-330). Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
8.
Brudney, J. L.
(1995b). Preparing the organization for volunteers. In T. D. Connors (Ed.), The volunteer management handbook. New York: John Wiley.
9.
Brudney, J. L.
(1999, autumn). The effective use of volunteers: Best practices for the public sector. Law and Contemporary Problems, 62, 219-255.
10.
Brudney, J. L.
, & Kellough, J. E. (2000). Volunteers in state government: Involvement, management and benefits. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 29(1), 111-130.
11.
Chambré, S. M.
(1989). Kindling points of light: Volunteering as public policy. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 18(3), 249-268.
12.
Chase, A. G.
(1973). Federal support of the vital majority: The development of the U.S. Small Business Administration. In D. Carson (Ed.), Essays marking the twentieth anniversary of the U.S. Small Business Administration (p. 261-261). Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
13.
Chase, A.
(1992). Calling all points of light. Governing, 5(7), 24-25.
14.
Clarke, H. D.
, & Stewart, M. C. (1994). Prospections, retrospections, and rationality: The “bankers” model of presidential approval reconsidered. American Journal of Political Science, 38(4), 1104-1123.
15.
Cochrane, D.
, & Orcutt, G. H. (1949, March). Application of least squares regression to relationships containing auto-correlated error terms. American Statistical Association Journal, 44, 32-61.
16.
Connelly, M.
(1996). The catch-22 of reinventing corrections: Training volunteers to offset costs. Journal of Volunteer Administration, 14(4), 21-27.
17.
Connors, T. D.
(Ed.). (2001). The nonprofit handbook. New York: John Wiley.
18.
Cook, T. D.
, & Campbell, D. T. (1979). Quasi-experimentation: Design and analysis for field settings. Chicago: Rand McNally.
19.
Cromwell, J. B.
, Hannan, M. J., Labys, W. C., & Terraza, M. (1994). Multivariate tests for time series models. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
20.
Duncombe, S.
(1985). Volunteers in city government: Advantages, disadvantages and uses. National Civic Review, 74(9), 356-364.
21.
Duncombe, S.
(1986). Volunteers in city government: getting more than your money’s worth. National Civic Review, 75(5), 291-301
22.
Durant, R. F.
, Kluesner, T., & Legge, J. S., Jr. (1992). Domestic programs, budget outlays, and the Reagan Revolution: Atest of competing theories in four policy arenas. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 2(4), 369-386.
23.
Durant, R. F.
, Legge, J. S., Jr., & Moussios, A. (1998). People, profits, and service delivery: Lessons from the privatization of British Telecom. American Journal of Political Science, 42(1), 117-140.
24.
Ellis, S. J.
(1996). From the top down: The executive role in volunteer program success. Philadelphia: Energize.
25.
Ellis, S. J.
, & Noyes, K. H. (1990). By the people. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
26.
Ferris, J. M.
(1988). “The use of volunteers in public service production: Some demand and supply considerations”. Social Science Quarterly, 69(1), 3-23.
27.
Fischer, L. R.
, & Schaffer, K. B. (1993). Older volunteers: A guide to research and practice. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
28.
Garand, J. C.
(1985). Partisan change and shifting expenditure priorities in the American states, 1945-1978. American Politics Quarterly, 13(4), 355-391.
29.
General Accounting Office
. (1990, November). Small business efforts to improve activities of the Service Corps of Retired Executives: Report to congressional requesters (GAO/RCED-91-5). Washington, DC: Author.
30.
Goldsmith, S.
(1999). The twenty-first century city: resurrecting urban America. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.
31.
Gotbaum, V.
, & Barr, E. (1976). On volunteerism. Social Policy, 7(3), 50-51.
32.
Gross, D.
, & Breaux, D. (1991). Historical trends in U.S. Senate elections, 1912-1988. American Politics Quarterly, 19(3), 284-309.
33.
Hamilton, L. C.
(2002). Statistics with stata. Florence, KY: Duxbury Thomson Learning.
34.
Hatry, H. P.
(1983). A review of private approaches for delivery of public services. Washington, DC: Urban Institute.
35.
Holmes, M. D.
, Daudistel, H. C., & Taggart, W. A. (1992). Plea bargaining policy and state district court caseloads: An interrupted time series analysis. Law & Society Review, 26(1), 139-159.
36.
“How parent volunteers can save the schools”. (1991, August 19). U.S. News & World Report, 66-68.
37.
International City Management Association
. (1989). Service delivery in the 90s: Alternative approaches for local governments (pp. 46-57). Washington, DC: Author.
38.
Knapp, M.
(1994). Time is money: The costs of volunteering in Britain today. Journal of Volunteer Administration, 12(3), 1-11.
39.
Legge, J. S., Jr.
(1985). Abortion policy: An evaluation of the consequences for maternal and infant health. Albany: SUNY Press.
40.
Lewis-Beck, M. S.
, & Alford, J. R. (1980, December). Can government regulate safety? The coal mine example. American Political Science Review, 74, 745-756.
41.
Lokemoen, K.
(2001). Volunteerism often overlooked resource in small cities. P A Times, 24(11), 1-1, 3-3.
42.
Marando, V. L.
(1986). Local service delivery: Volunteers and recreation councils. Journal of Volunteer Administration, 4(4), 16-24.
43.
Mausner, C.
(1988). The underlying dynamics of staff-volunteer relationships. Journal of Volunteer Administration, 6(4), 5-9.
44.
McCroskey, J.
(1983, winter). Are volunteers worth the effort?Public Welfare, 41, 5-8.
45.
McCurley, S.
, & Lynch, R. (1996). Volunteer management. Downers Grove, IL: Heritage Art.
46.
McDowall, D.
, McCleary, R., Meidinger, E. E., & Hay, R. A., Jr. (1980). Interrupted time series analysis. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
47.
Meier, K. J.
(1993). Politics and the bureaucracy. Pacific Grove, CA: Brooks/Cole.
48.
Meier, K. J.
, & Brudney, J. L. (2002). Applied statistics for public administration (5th ed.). Fort Worth, TX: Harcourt College Publishers.
49.
Mohr, L. B.
(1995). Impact analysis for program evaluation. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
50.
Moon, G. C.
(1967). An evaluation of selected management aspects of the Small Business Administration SCORE program. University Microfilms International.
51.
Moon, G. C. (1969, September 11). Management assistance to small business: Program memorandum. Unpublished memorandum, U.S. Small Business Administration.
52.
Nellis, E. A.
(1989). ASCORE that counts: The story of the Service Corps of Retired Executives. Washington, DC: SCORE Association.
53.
“The new rangers”. (1993, November 22). Leadership, 29-29.
54.
Osborne, D.
, & Gaebler, T. (1992). Reinventing government. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
55.
Putnam, R. D.
(2000). Bowling alone: The collapse and revival of American community. New York: Simon & Schuster.
56.
Pynes, J.
(1997). Human resources management for public and nonprofit organizations. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
57.
Rainey, H. G.
(1997). Understanding and managing public organizations (2nd ed.). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
58.
Rockville Consulting Group
. (1980, January). Highlight report: Major impact study of SBA management assistance programs. Washington, DC: Office of Policy Planning and Budgeting and Office of Management Assistance, U.S. Small Business Administration.
59.
Rosenbaum, L. R.
(1984). Review of the Service Corps of Retired Executives Program. Washington, DC: U.S. Small Business Administration.
60.
Rourke, F. E.
(1984). Bureaucracy, politics, and public policy. New York: Little, Brown.
61.
Ryan, M.
(1994, May 1). Ask not what your town can do for you …Parade Magazine, p. 14-14.
62.
Savas, E. S.
(2000). Privatization and public-private partnerships. New York: Chatham House.
63.
Stringer, G.
(1985). Staff/volunteer relationship “perceptions”. Journal of Volunteer Administration, 3(3), 7-10.
64.
U.S. Small Business Administration
. (1954a, January 31). First semi-annual report of the U.S. Small Business Administration. Washington, DC: Author.
65.
U.S. Small Business Administration
. (1954b). Second semi-annual report of the U.S. Small Business Administration. Washington, DC: Author.
66.
U.S. Small Business Administration
. (1957-1995). Selected Annual Reports of the U.S. Small Business Administration. Washington, DC: Author.
67.
U.S. Small Business Administration
. (1977). Study report: Management assistance organization and performance. Washington, DC: Author.
68.
Valente, C. F.
, & Manchester, L. D. (1984). Rethinking local services: Examining alternative delivery approaches. In Management Information Service Special Report, No. 12. Washington, DC: International City Management Association.
69.
Vizza, C.
(1990, summer). Volunteers in public service: Mutual benefits abound. Voluntary Action Leadership, 12-21.
70.
Walter, V.
(1987). Volunteers and bureaucrats: Clarifying roles and creating meaning. Journal of Voluntary Action Research, 16(3), 22-32.
71.
Walter, V.
(1993). For all the wrong reasons? Implementing volunteer programs in public organizations. Public Productivity & Management Review, XVI(3), 271-282.
72.
Willing, P. R.
(1982). A history of the management assistance and educational programs of the Small Business Administration from 1953 to 1978. University Microfilms International.
73.
Wilson, J. Q.
(1989). Bureaucracy: What government agencies do and why they do it. New York: Basic Books.
