This article presents an economic model for community choice between volunteer and professional fire protection services. Using data from the Indiana State Fire Marshal and the 1991 U.S. census, regression techniques were used to estimate the share of county population served by volunteer fire protection from variables measuring community demands for fire protection and relative costs of volunteer and professional departments. The results provide evidence that professional departments are cost-effective at high levels of fire protection and volunteer departments are cost-effective at low levels of fire protection. Per capita income, population density, education, property value, percentage of renters, farm receipts, and the percentage of commuters were found to be significant determinants of fire protection choice.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Ahlbrandt, R.
(1973). Efficiency in the provision of fire services. Public Choice, 16, 1-5.
2.
Bice, D. C.
, & Hoyt, W. H. (2000). The impact of mandates and tax limits on voluntary contributions to local public services: An application to fire protection services. National Tax Journal, 55(1), 79-105.
3.
Borcherding, T. E.
, & Deacon, R. T. (1972). The demand for the services of non-federal governments. American Economic Review, 62, 891-901.
4.
Brudney, J.
, & Duncombe, W. (1992). An economic evaluation of paid, volunteer, and mixed staffing options for public services. Public Administration Review, 52(5), 474-480.
5.
Brueckner, J. K.
(1981). Congested public goods: The case of fire protection. Journal of Public Economics, 15, 45-58.
6.
Congleton, R. D.
, & Bennett, R. W. (1995). On the political economy of state highway expenditures: Some evidence of the relative performance of alternative choice models. Public Choice, 84, 1-24.
7.
Duncombe, W.
(1991). Demand for local public services revisited: The case of fire protection. Public Finance Quarterly, 19(4), 412-436.
8.
Duncombe, W.
(1992). Costs and factor substitution in the provision of local fire services. Review of Economics and Statistics, 74, 180-184.
9.
Hayes, K.
(1986). Local public good demands and demographic effects. Applied Economics, 18, 1039-1045.
10.
Hilke, John C.
(1986). The impact of volunteer firefighters on local government spending and taxation. Municipal Finance Journal, 7, 33-44.
11.
Indiana State Emergency Management Agency
. (1995). Emergency medical services (EMS) registry annual report. Indianapolis, IN: Author.
12.
Indiana State Office of Public Safety, Public Safety Training Institute
. (1996). Number of residents served by volunteer fire departments Indiana (Report). Indianapolis, IN: Author.
13.
McDavid, J. C.
(1986). Part-time fire fighters in Canadian municipalities: Cost and effectiveness comparisons. Canadian Public Administration, 29(3), 377-387.
14.
Mueller, D. C.
(1989). Public choice II. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
15.
Perkins, K. B.
(1987). Volunteer fire departments: Community integration, autonomy and survival. Human Organization, 46, 342-348.
16.
Perkins, K. B.
(1990). Volunteer fire and rescue corporations: Structure, process and survival. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 19(4), 359-369.
17.
Perkins, K. B.
, & Metz, C. W. (1988). Note on commitment and community among volunteer firefighters. Sociological Inquiry, 58, 117-121.
18.
Pommerehne, W. W.
, & Schneider, F. (1978). Fiscal illusion, political institutions, and local public spending: Some neglected relationships. Kyklos, 31, 381-408.
19.
Reid, G. J.
(1991). Tests of institutional versus non-institutional models of local public expenditure determination. Public Choice, 70, 315-333.
20.
Romer, T.
, & Rosenthal, H. (1979). The elusive median voter. Journal of Public Economics, 12, 143-170.
21.
Sass, T. R.
(1991). The choice of municipal government structure and public expenditures. Public Choice, 71, 71-87.
22.
Simpson, C.
(1996). A fraternity of danger. American Journal of Economics and Sociology, 55, 17-34.
23.
Southwick, L., Jr.
, & Butler, R. (1985). Fire department demand and supply in large cities. Applied Economics, 17, 1043-1064.
24.
Stevens, J. B.
, & Mason, R. (1996). Political markets, property tax referenda, and local school spending. Public Choice, 86, 257-277.
25.
Thompson, A. M.
, & Bono, B. A. (1993). Work without wages: The motivation for volunteer firefighters. American Journal of Economics and Sociology, 52(3), 323-343.
26.
Turnbull, G. K.
, & Djoundourian, S. S. (1994). The median voter hypothesis: Evidence from general purpose local governments. Public Choice, 81, 223-240.
