Discipline and Power in the Digital Age: The Case of the US Consumer Data Broker Industry

Abstract

While many scholars have commented on the rise of consumer finance, few have sought to critically explore a largely invisible segment of this industry: the multi-billion dollar consumer data broker industry. The industry has amassed trillions of digital consumer records, or ‘big data’, that are stockpiled, analyzed, and sold. The odious under-regulation of this industry, as well as the role it plays in consumer debt and data breaches, often flies under the radar of critical social analyses. I adopt a neo-Gramscian approach to make sense of the material, historical, and social dimensions of this phenomenon. This article asks: what are the sources and nature of this industry’s power, and how does it relate to consumer debt? The analysis suggests that these systems demonstrate how financial capital can constitute certain domains of public policy.

Keywords

international political economy US consumer data broker industry debt disciplinary neoliberalism

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Acxiom (2009) 2009 Annual Report. Little Rock, AR: Acxiom.

Acxiom (2012) Response to Representative Markey. Available (consulted 3 July 2013) at: http://markey.house.gov/sites/markey.house.gov/files/documents/Acxiom.pdf

Aslam

(2008) Report Says U.S. Lenders Prey on Minorities. Available (consulted 22 July 2012) at: http://ipsnorthamerica.net/news.php?idnews=1251

Barba

Pivetti

(2009) Rising household debt: its causes and macroeconomic implications – a long-period analysis. Cambridge Journal of Economics 33(1): 113–137.

Barrett

(1995) Databasing in the 90s: data and what we’re doing with it! Direct Marketing 58(5): 40.

Barrett

Hendricks

Singleton

. (2001) Panel II: the conflict between commercial speech and legislation governing the commercialization of private sector data. Fordham Intellectual Property, Media and Entertainment Law Journal 11(1): 58–95.

Blue

(2012) Congressional Inquiry Responses Released: Data Brokers Refuse to Name Sources. Zero Day. Available (consulted 15 June 2013) at: http://www.zdnet.com/congressional-inquiry-responses-released-data-brokers-refuse-to-name-sources-7000007235/

Boyce

(2002) Beyond privacy: the ethics of consumer information systems. Paper presented at IS2002: Informing Science + IT Education Conference, June, Cork, Ireland.

Burkitt

(2010) Draft Bill Aims to Protect Consumer Privacy. Available (consulted 14 March 2012) at: http://www.forbes.com/2010/05/04/boucher-bill-advertising-marketing-online-ads-iab-google-facebook-cmo-network-privacy-regulation.html

10.

Carey

(2010) Racial Predatory Loans Fueled US Housing Crisis: Study. Available (consulted 14 May 2012) at: http://www.reuters.com/article/2010/10/04/us-usa-foreclosures-race-idUSTRE6930K520101004

11.

Castells

(1997) Information Age, Economy, Society and Culture: The Power of Identity. Oxford: Blackwell.

12.

Cate

Litan

Staten

. (2003) Financial Privacy, Consumer Prosperity, and the Public Good: Maintaining the Balance. Available (consulted 10 August 2012) at: http://www.ftc.gov/bcp/workshops/infoflows/statements/cate01.pdf

13.

CBS News (2005) ChoicePoint to Pay $15M over Breach. Available (consulted 24 February 2012) at: http://www.cbsnews.com/2100-205_162-1241889.html

14.

CFPB (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau) (2012) Learn about the Bureau. Available (consulted 29 October 2012) at: http://www.consumerfinance.gov/the-bureau/

15.

Consumer News (2009) FTC Uses Kid Gloves on ChoicePoints 2nd Data Breach. Available (consulted 23 January 2012) at: http://news.consumerreports.org/money/2009/11/choicepoint-data-broker-financial-records-breach-federal-trade-commission-hack-kid-gloves-.html

16.

Curry

(1997) The digital individual and the private realm. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 87(4): 681–699.

17.

Deleuze

(1992) Postscript on Societies of Control. October 59(Winter): 3–7.

18.

Democratic Press Office (2012) Rockefeller Seeks Information about Data Brokers’ Practices. Available (consulted 14 June 2013) at: http://www.commerce.senate.gov/public/index.cfm?p=PressReleases&ContentRecord_id=a42a865a-be30-4171–8278-86ee0a8c76fb

19.

Dillon

(2010) The value of long form Canadian census for long term national and international research. Canadian Public Policy 36(3): 389–393.

20.

Downey

(2012) Abine on CNN: Why Big Companies Buy and Sell your Data. Available (consulted 23 May 2013) at: http://www.abine.com/blog/2012/abine-on-cnn-why-big-companies-buy-and-sell-your-data/#more-3482

21.

Drozdenko

Drake

(2002) Optimal Database Marketing: Strategy, Development and Datamining. London: Sage Publications.

22.

Epsilon (2012) Letter in Response to Congressional Inquiry. Available (consulted 10 June 2013) at: http://markey.house.gov/sites/markey.house.gov/files/documents/Epsilon.pdf

23.

FBI (Federal Bureau of Investigation) (2001) Guidance Regarding the Use of ChoicePoint for Foreign Intelligence Collection or Foreign Counterterrorism Investigations. Available (consulted 4 March 2012) at: http://epic.org/privacy/choicepoint/cpfbia.pdf

24.

Federal Reserve Bank of New York (2012) Household Debt and Credit Report. Available (consulted 12 December 2012) at: http://www.newyorkfed.org/householdcredit/

25.

Federal Trade Commission (2009) Statement of Rights for Identity Theft Victims. Available (consulted 20 April 2012) at: http://www.ftc.gov/bcp/edu/pubs/consumer/idtheft/idt09.pdf

26.

Federal Trade Commission (2011) FTC Releases List of Top Consumer Complaints in 2010; Identity Theft Tops the List Again. Available (consulted 12 February 2012) at: http://www.ftc.gov/opa/2011/03/topcomplaints.shtm

27.

Federal Trade Commission (2012a) Resolution Directing Use of Compulsory Access to Collect Information Regarding Data Brokers. Available (consulted 2 July 2013) at: http://www.ftc.gov/os/2012/12/121218databrokersresolution.pdf

28.

Federal Trade Commission (2012b) Protecting Consumer Privacy in an Era of Rapid Change. Available (consulted 20 May 2013) at: http://ftc.gov/os/2012/03/120326privacyreport.pdf

29.

Federal Trade Commission (2012c) FTC to Study Data Broker Industry’s Collection and Use of Consumer Data. Available (consulted 21 May 2013) at: http://www.ftc.gov/opa/2012/12/databrokers.shtm

30.

Foucault

(1980) Power/Knowledge: Selected Interviews and Other Writings 1972–1977. Brighton: Harvester.

31.

Foxman

Kilcoyne

(1993) Information technology, marketing practice and consumer privacy: ethical issues. Journal of Public Policy and Marketing 12(1): 106–119.

32.

Gill

(1991) Reflections on global order and sociohistorical time. Alternatives 16(3): 275–314.

33.

Gill

(ed.) (1993) Gramsci, Historical Materialism and International Relations. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

34.

Gill

(1995) Globalization, market civilization, and disciplinary neoliberalism. Millennium: Journal of International Studies 24(3): 399–423.

35.

Gill

(1997) Finance, production and panopticism: inequality, risk and resistance in an era of disciplinary neoliberalism. In: Gill

(ed.) Globalization, Democratization and Multilateralism London: Macmillan, 51–75.

36.

Gill

(1998a) European governance and new constitutionalism: economic and monetary union and alternatives to disciplinary neoliberalism in Europe. New Political Economy 3(1): 5–26.

37.

Gill

(1998b) New constitutionalism, democratization and global political economy. Pacifica Review: Peace, Security and Global Change 10(1): 23–38.

38.

Gill

(2000) The constitution of global capitalism. Paper presented at the International Studies Association Annual Convention, 14–18 March, Los Angeles, CA.

39.

Gill

(2003) Constitutionalizing inequality and the clash of globalizations. International Studies Review 4(2): 47–65.

40.

Gill

Law

(1989) Global hegemony and the structural power of capital. International Studies Quarterly 36(December): 475–499.

41.

Goodhart

(2008) The Financial Economists Roundtable’s Statement on Reforming the Role of SROs in the Securitization Process. Available (consulted 21 March 2012) at: http://www.voxeu.org/index.php?q=node/2667

42.

Goodwin

(1991) Privacy: recognition of a consumer right. Journal of Public Policy and Marketing 10(1): 149–166.

43.

Goss

(1995) ‘We know who you are and we know where you live’: the instrumental reality of geodemographic systems. Economic Geography 71(2) 171–198.

44.

Haggerty

Ericson

(2000) The surveillant assemblage. British Journal of Sociology 51(4): 605–622.

45.

Harper

(2005) When Data Security Regulations Fail, There Is an Alternative. Available (consulted 23 January 2012) at: http://www.cato.org/pub_display.php?pub_id=11476

46.

Harper

(2009) Venable LLP Summary of FTC Roundtable Discussion on Exploring Privacy. Available (consulted 20 April 2012) at: http://www.iab.net/media/file/DC1DOCS1-%23377212-v10-FTC_Roundtable_Discussion_on_Privacy.pdf

47.

Hlupic

(ed.) (2003) Knowledge and Business Process Management. London: Idea Group Publishing.

48.

ISG (Information Solutions Group) (2011) Customer Profile. Information Solutions Group. Available (consulted 14 March 2012) at: http://www.infosolutionsgroup.com/customer_profile.htm

49.

Kear

(2013) Governing homo subprimicus: beyond financial citizenship, exclusion, and rights. Antipode 45(4) 926–946.

50.

Lace

(2005) The Glass Consumer: Life in a Surveillance Society. Bristol: Policy, for National Consumer Council.

51.

Langenderfer

Linnhoff

(2004) The emergence of biometrics and its effects on consumers. The Journal of Consumer Affairs 39(2): 314–338.

52.

Langley

(2008) The Everyday Life of Global Finance: Saving and Borrowing in Anglo America. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

53.

Latham

Sassen

(2005) Digital Formations: IT and New Architectures in the Global Realm. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

54.

Leadbeater

(1988) Power to the person. Marxism Today 1988(October): 14–19.

55.

Lyon

(2001) Surveillance and Society: Monitoring Everyday Life. Buckingham: Open University Press.

56.

Manzerolle

(2010) The virtual debt factory: towards an analysis of debt and abstraction in the American credit crisis. Cognition, Communication, Cooperation 8(2): 221–236.

57.

Manzerolle

Smeltzer

(2011) Consumer databases and commercial mediation of identity: a medium theory analysis. Surveillance and Society 8(3): 323–337.

58.

Markey

(2012) Letters to Major Data Brokers. Available (consulted 10 June 2013) at: http://markey.house.gov/content/letters-major-data-brokers

59.

Marron

(2007) ‘Lending by numbers’: credit scoring and the constitution of risk within American consumer credit. Economy and Society 36(1): 103–133.

60.

Miller

Rose

(1990) Governing economic life. Economy and Society 19(1): 1–31.

61.

Monahan

(2009) Identity theft vulnerability: neoliberal governance through crime construction. Theoretical Criminology 13(2): 155–176.

62.

Murphy

Tooze

(eds) (1991) Newman

(2011) New Consumer Financial Protection Bureau Should Regulate Online Advertising of Financial Products. Huffington Post, 16 August 2011. Available (consulted 10 January 2013) at http://www.huffingtonpost.com/nathan-newman/new-consumer-financial-pr_b_928063.html

63.

New York Times (2004) US Calls Release of JetBlue Data Improper. The New York Times, 21 February. Available (consulted 2 September 2012) at: http://www.nytimes.com/2004/02/21/business/us-calls-release-of-jetblue-data-improper.html

64.

New York Times (2012) Consumer Data, But not for Consumers. The New York Times, 21 July. Available (consulted 2 September 2012) at: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/07/22/business/acxiom-consumer-data-often-unavailable-to-consumers.html?pagewanted=all

65.

O’Harrow

(2006) No Place to Hide. New York, NY: Free Press.

66.

Peck

Tickell

(2002) Neoliberalizing space. Antipode 34(3): 380–404.

67.

Poster

(1990) The Mode of Information: Poststructuralism and Social Context. Cambridge: Polity Press.

68.

Privacy Rights Clearing House (2011) Data Breaches: A Year in Review. Available (consulted 2 March 2012) at: http://www.privacyrights.org/data-breach-year-review-2011

69.

Reuters (2013) Senate Banking Panel Approves Obama’s SEC, CFPB Choices. Available (consulted 19 March 2013) at: http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/03/19/us-sec-cfpb-appointments-idUSBRE92I0NE20130319

70.

Rivera

Cotto-Escalera

Desai

. (2008) Foreclosed: State of the Dream 2008. Boston, MA: United for a Fair Economy.

71.

Roth

Wasburn

(2012) Data Brokers Face Blurring Lines, Increased Regulatory Risks. Bloomberg Law. Available (consulted 23 January 2012) at: http://about.bloomberglaw.com/2012/08/22/data-brokers-face-blurring-lines/

72.

Ruggles

(2005) Automating Interaction: Formal and Informal Knowledge in the Digital Network Economy. Cresskill, NJ: Hampton Press.

73.

Selby

(2007) Engaging Foucault: discourse, liberal governance and the limits of Foucauldian IR. International Relations 21(3): 324–345.

74.

Singel

(2003) Acxiom Opts Out of Opt-Out. Wired. Available (consulted 29 November 2012) at: http://www.wired.com/politics/security/news/2003/11/61240

75.

Shearmur

(2010) A world without data? The unintended consequences of fashion in geography. Urban Geography 31(8): 1009–1017.

76.

Soederberg

(2013) The US debtfare state and the credit card industry: forging spaces of dispossession. Antipode 45(2): 493–512.

77.

Solove

(2004) The Digital Person: Technology and Privacy in the Information Age. New York, NY: New York University Press.

78.

Stevens

(2010) Federal Information Security and Data Breach Notification Laws. Congressional Research Service. Available (consulted 12 March 2012) at: http://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/secrecy/RL34120.pdf

79.

Tanner

(2013) Finally You’ll Get to See the Secret Consumer Dossier They Have on You. Forbes, 25 June 2013. Available (consulted 3 July 2013) at: http://www.forbes.com/sites/adamtanner/2013/06/25/finally-youll-get-to-see-the-secret-consumer-dossier-they-have-on-you/

80.

Thomas

(2009) Little brother’s big book: the case for a right of audit in private databases. CommLaw Conspectus: Journal of Communications Law and Policy 18(1): 155–197.

81.

Turner

(2003) Official Transcript Proceedings: Information Flows – the Costs and Benefits to Consumers and Businesses of the Collection and Use of Consumer Information. Federal Trade Commission. Available (consulted 23 February 2012) at: http://www.ftc.gov/bcp/workshops/infoflows/infoflowstranscript.pdf

82.

Van Dijk

(2010) Property, privacy and personhood in a world of ambient intelligence. Ethics and Information Technology 12(1): 57–69.

83.

Week (2012) Acxiom Corp: The ‘Faceless Organization that Knows Everything About You’. The Week. Available (consulted 2 September 2012) at: http://theweek.com/article/index/229508/acxiom-corp-the-faceless-organization-that-knows-everything-about-you

84.

Whiting

(2004) Data Demands Respect. Information Week. Available (consulted 20 April 2012) at: http://www.informationweek.com/news/51000186?pgno=1

85.

Worthen

(2011) Breach Brings Scrutiny. Wall Street Journal Available (consulted 23 June 2013) at: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704587004576245131531712342.html

86.

Zwick

Knott

(2009) Manufacturing consumers: database as a new means of production. Journal of Consumer Culture 9(2): 221–247.