The Question of Radicalism in Sheldon Wolin’s Political Thought: A Marxist Perspective

Abstract

It is widely accepted that Sheldon Wolin has revitalized the tradition of radicalism in the context of modern political thought, as evidenced by his contribution to the debate on the so-called death of political philosophy and his forceful critique of Rawls and modern political liberalism. However, Wolin’s fugitive democracy has met with opposition. This paper investigates fugitive democracy from a Marxist perspective and questions whether fugitive democracy can actually confront crucial socio-political issues such as the lack of democracy for the masses in the production of social wealth. Moreover, Wolin’s misinterpretation and rejection of Marx’s theory of democracy and politics leads him to a misconceived view of the Marxian philosophy of history and the progress of political societies as a whole, a misconception that leads to inconsistencies within his own work. And finally, although Wolin seems to be a radical democrat and appears to hold a worldview close to that of socialists, he in fact, despite his criticisms, follows a liberal logic.