Cleaning Power and Abrasivity of European Toothpastes

Abstract

For 41 toothpastes available to European consumers in 1995, the cleaning efficacy was evaluated in comparison with abrasivity on dentin (RDA value). For cleaning power assessment, a modified pellicle cleaning ratio (PCR) measurement method was developed. The method is characterized by a five-day tea-staining procedure on bovine front teeth slabs on a rotating wheel, standardized brushing of the slabs in a V8 cross-brushing machine, and brightness measurement by a chromametric technique. All tested products were in accordance with the new DIN/ISO standard 11609 for toothpastes in terms of dentin abrasivity. Not a single product exceeded an RDA value of 200. The majority of toothpastes (80%) had an RDA value below 100. Only three products surpassed the reference in cleaning power. Most products (73%) had a cleaning power (PCR value) between 20 and 80. The correlation between cleaning power and dentin abrasion was low (r = 0.66), which can be explained with the different influence on dentin and stains by factors like abrasive type, particle surface and size, as well as the chemical influence of other toothpaste ingredients. Some major trends could be shown on the basis of abrasive types. The ratio PCR to RDA was rather good in most silica-based toothpastes. A lower ratio was found in some products containing calcium carbonate or aluminum trihydrate as the only abrasive. The addition of other abrasives, such as polishing alumina, showed improved cleaning power. Some active ingredients, especially sequestrants such as sodium tripolyphosphate or AHBP, also improve the PCR/ RDA ratio by stain-dissolving action without being abrasive. The data for some special anti-stain products did not differ significantly from standard products. Compared with data measured in 1988, a general trend toward reduced abrasivity without loss of cleaning efficacy could be noticed on the European toothpaste market. This may be mostly due to the increased use of high-performance abrasives such as hydrated silica.

Keywords

dental stain dentin abrasivity cleaning power method.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Barbakow F. Lutz F. , Imfeld T. (1987). Abrasives in dentifrices and prophylaxis pastes . Quintessence Int 18:17-22.

Davis WB , Rees DA ( 1975). A parametric test to measure the cleaning power of toothpaste . J Soc Cosmet Chem 26:217-225.

Grabenstetter RJ , Broge RW , Jackson FL , Radike AW (1958). The measurement of the abrasion of human teeth by dentifrice abrasives : a test utilizing radioactive teeth. J Dent Res 17:1060-1068.

Hefferren JJ (1976). A laboratory method for assessment of dentifrice abrasivity. J Dent Res 55:563-573.

Klüppel H-J. , Ploger W. , Forg F. , Umbach W. (1986). Parameters for assessing the cleaning power of toothpastes. J Soc Cosmet Chem 37:211-223.

Lobene RR (1968). Effect of dentifrices on tooth stains with controlled brushing. J Am Dent Assoc 77:849-866.

Lobene RR (1982). Clinical studies of the cleaning functions of dentifrices. J Am Dent Assoc 105:798-802.

Marcus JJ , Ginzler E. (1982). Method for determining the cleaning power of dentifrice products. Information manual. St. Louis: Missouri Analytical Laboratories, Inc.

Stookey GK , Burkhard TA , Schemehorn BR (1982). In vitro removal of stain with dentifrices. J Dent Res 61:1236-1239.

10.

Sturzenberger OP (1978). Clinical cosmetic tooth cleaning study with dentifrices containing phosphates. Report of the American Dental Association Collaborative Study. Presented at the meeting of the ADA-FDI Dentifrice Function Committee, September 14-15, London .