Several indices have been used to describe the clinical appearance of dental fluorosis. The purpose of this paper is to describe and compare the three principal ones in use today: those developed by Dean (1934, 1942), Thylstrup and Fejerskov (1978), and Horowitz et al. (1984). A recent index (Fluorosis Risk Index) developed by Pendrys (1990) is also included in this review. The continued use of Dean's classification system and derived index (CFI) for more than a half century is testimony to its simplicity and utility. The index has been criticized because the unit of analysis is the person, because criteria are unclear for some categories, or that they lack sensitivity, particularly for severe fluorosis, and because of the way in which data are summarized and reported. The Thylstrup and Fejerskov Index is appealing to clinicians and epidemiologists alike in that it corresponds closely to histological changes that occur in dental fluorosis and to enamel fluoride concentrations, thereby having biological validity. The TSIF described by Horowitz et al. makes a useful contribution because it provides clearer diagnostic criteria and provides for an analysis based on esthetic concerns. The Fluorosis Risk Index appears to be particularly useful for analytical epidemiologic studies, because it is designed to permit a more accurate identification of associations between age-specific exposures to fluoride and the development of dental fluorosis. All three indices in common use today provide useful indices for the study of dental fluorosis. The utility of the Fluorosis Risk Index will be determined as it receives wider use. The selection of one of these indices for use in an epidemiologic study depends in large measure on the purpose of the study. Research needs to continue on the validity of these indices, particularly for mild fluorosis, and on the public's perception of the cosmetic appearance of teeth with different severity levels of fluorosis.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Ainamo J., Cutress TW (1982). An epidemiological index of developmental defects of dental enamel (DDE index). Commission on Oral Health. Int Dent J32:159-167.
2.
Al-Alousi W., Jackson D., Compton G., Jenkins OC (1975). Enamel mottling in a fluoride and in a non-fluoride community. Br Dent J138:9-15, 56-60.
3.
Baelum V., Manji F., Fejerskov O. (1986). Posteruptive tooth age and severity of dental fluorosis in Kenya. Scand J Dent Res94:405-410.
4.
Bagramian RA, Narendran S., Ward M. ( 1989). Relationship of dental caries and fluorosis to fluoride supplement history in a non-fluoridated sample of schoolchildren. Adv Dent Res3:161-167.
5.
Bischoff JI, van der Merwe EH, Retief DH, Barbakow HF, Cleaton-Jones PE (1976). Relationship between fluoride concentration in enamel, DMFT index, and degree of fluorosis in a community residing in an area with a high level of fluoride. J Dent Res55:37-42.
6.
Bohaty BS, Parker WA, Seale NS, Zimmerman ER (1989). The prevalence of fluorosis-like lesions associated with topical and systemic fluoride usage in an area of optimal water fluoridation . Pediatr Dent11:125-128.
7.
Bratthall D., Serinirach R., Carlsson P., Lekfuangfu S. (1986). Streptococcus mutans and dental caries in urban and rural schoolchildren in Thailand. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol14:274-276.
8.
Brouwer ID, Backer Dirks 0, DeBruin A., Hautvast JG (1988). Unsuitability of World Health Organization guidelines for fluoride concentrations in drinking water in Senegal. Lancet1(8579):223-225.
9.
Burger P., Cleaton-Jones P., du Plessis, J., de Vries J. (1987). Comparison of two fluorosis indices in the primary dentition of Tswana children. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol15:95-97.
10.
Butler W., Segreto VA, Collins EM (1985). Prevalence of dental mottling in school-aged lifetime residents of 16 Texas communities. Am J Publ Hlth75:1408-1412.
11.
Clarkson J. (1989). Review of terminology, classifications, and indices of developmental defects of enamel. Adv Dent Res3:104-109.
12.
Clarkson J., O'Mullane D. (1989). A modified DDE index for use in epidemiological studies of enamel defects. J Dent Res68:445-450.
13.
Clarkson JJ, O'Mullane DM (1992). Prevalence of enamel defects/fluorosis in fluoridated and non-fluoridated areas in Ireland. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol20:196-199.
14.
Cleaton-Jones P., Hargreaves JA (1990). Comparison of three fluorosis indices in a Namibian community with twice optimum fluoride in the drinking water. Tydskr Tandheelkd Ver S Afr45:173-175.
15.
Curzon Mej, Spector PC (1977). Enamel mottling in a high strontium area of the U.S.A. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol5:243-247.
16.
Cutress TW, Suckling GW (1982). The assessment of non-carious defects of enamel . Int Dent J32:117-122.
Dean HT ( 1934). Classification of mottled enamel diagnosis. J Am Dent Assoc21:1421-1426.
19.
Dean HT ( 1942). The investigation of physiological effects by the epidemiological method. In: Moulton FR, editor. Fluorine and dental health. Pub. No. 19. Washington (DC): American Association for the Advancement of Science , 23-31.
20.
Dean HT, Elvove E. (1937). Further studies on the minimal threshold of chronic endemic dental fluorosis. Publ Hlth Rep52:1249-1264.
21.
Dean HT, McKay FS (1939). Production of mottled enamel halted by a change in common water supply. Am J Publ Health29:590-596.
22.
Dean HT, Dixon RM, Cohen C. (1935). Mottled enamel in Texas. Publ Hlth Rep50:424-442.
23.
Dean HT, McKay FS, Elvove E. (1938). Mottled enamel survey of Bauxite, Ark., ten years after a change in the common water supply. Publ Hlth Rep53:1736-1748.
24.
Dean HT, Elvove E., Poston RF (1939). Mottled enamel in South Dakota. Publ Hlth Rep54:212-228.
25.
Dean HT, Jay P., Arnold FA, Elvove E. (1941). Domestic water and dental caries. II. A study of 2,832 white children aged 12-14 years, of eight suburban Chicago communities, including L. acidophilus studies of 1,761 children. Publ Hlth Rep56:761-792.
26.
Diefenbach VL, Nevitt GA, Frankel JM (1965). Fluoridation and the appearance of teeth. J Am Dent Assoc71 :1129-1137.
27.
Driscoll WS, Horowitz HS, Meyers RJ, Heifetz S., Kingman A., Zimmerman ER (1983). Prevalence of dental caries and dental fluorosis in areas with optimal and above-optimal water fluoride concentrations. J Am Dent Assoc107 :42-47.
28.
Driscoll WS, Horowitz HS, Meyers RJ, Heifetz SB, Kingman A., Zimmerman ER (1986). Prevalence of dental caries and dental fluorosis in areas with negligible, optimal, and above-optimal fluoride concentrations in drinking water. J Am Dent Assoc113:29-33.
29.
Eklund SA, Burt BA, Ismail AI, Calderone JJ (1987). High-fluoride drinking water, fluorosis, and dental caries in adults. J Am Dent Assoc114:324-328.
30.
Evans RW (1989). Changes in dental fluorosis following an adjustment to the fluoride concentration of Hong Kong's water supplies. Adv Dent Res3:154-160.
31.
Evans RW, Stamm JW (1991). Dental fluorosis following downward adjustment of fluoride in drinking water. J Publ Hlth Dent51:91-98.
32.
Fdi (1982). An epidemiological index of developmental defects of dental enamel (DDE index). Technical Report No. 15. Int Dent J321:159-167.
33.
Fejerskov O., Manji F., Baelum V., Moller IJ (1988). Dental fluorosis: a handbook for health workers . Copenhagen: Munksgaard.
34.
Forrest JR, James PM (1956). A blind study of enamel opacities and dental caries prevalence after 8 years of fluoridation of water. Br Dent J119:319-322.
35.
Granath L., Widenheim J., Birkhed D. (1985). Diagnosis of mild enamel fluorosis in permanent maxillary incisors using two scoring systems. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol13:273-276.
36.
Grobler SR, van Wyk CW, Kotze D. (1986). Relationship between enamel fluoride levels, degree of fluorosis and
37.
caries experience in communities with a nearly optimal and a high fluoride level in the drinking water. Caries Res20:284-288.
38.
Haikel Y., Cahen PM, Turlot JC, Frank RM (1989a). Dental caries and fluorosis in children from high and low fluoride areas of Morocco. ASDC J Dent Child56:378-381.
39.
Haikel Y., Cahen PM, Turlot JC, Frank RM (1989b). The effects of airborne fluorides on oral conditions in Morocco. J Dent Res68:1238-1241.
40.
Heifetz SB, Driscoll WS, Horowitz HS, Kingman A. (1988). Prevalence of dental caries and dental fluorosis in areas with optimal and above-optimal water fluoride concentrations: a 5-year follow-up survey. J Am Dent Assoc116:490-495.
41.
Holm AK, Andersson JR (1982). Enamel mineralization disturbances in 12-year-old children with known early exposure to fluorides. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol10:335-339.
42.
Holt RD, Winter GB, Fox B., Askew R. (1990). Enamel opacities in children whose mothers took part in a dental health education scheme. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol18:74-76.
Horowitz HS, Heifetz SB, Driscoll WS, Kingman A., Myers RJ (1984). A new method for assessing the prevalence of dental fluorosis-the Tooth Surface Index of Fluorosis. J Am Dent Assoc109:37-41.
45.
Ishii T., Suckling G. (1986). The appearance of tooth enamel in children ingesting water with a high fluoride content for a limited period during early tooth development. J Dent Res65:974-977.
46.
Ishii T., Suckling G. (1991). The severity of dental fluorosis in children exposed to water with a high fluoride content for various periods of time. J Dent Res70:952-956.
47.
Ismail AI, Brodeur JM, Kavanagh M., Boisclair G., Tessier C., Picotte L. (1990). Prevalence of dental caries and dental fluorosis in students, 11-17 years of age, in fluoridated and non-fluoridated cities in Quebec. Caries Res24:290-297.
48.
Jackson D. (1961). A clinical study of non-endemic "mottling of enamel" . Arch Oral Biol5:212-223.
49.
Jackson D., James Pmc, Wolfe WB (1975). Fluoridation in Anglesey: a clinical study. Br Dent J138:165-171.
50.
Kumar JV, Green EL, Wallace W., Carnahan T. (1989). Trends in dental fluorosis and dental caries prevalences in Newburgh and Kingston, NY. Am J Publ Hlth79:565-569.
51.
Larsen MJ, Kirkegaard E., Fejerskov O., Poulsen S. (1985a). Prevalence of dental fluorosis after fluoride-gel treatments in a low-fluoride area. J Dent Res64:1076-1079.
52.
Larsen MJ, Richards A., Fejerskov O. (1985b). Development of dental fluorosis according to age at start of fluoride administration. Caries Res19:519-527.
53.
Larsen MJ, Kirkegaard E., Poulsen S., Fejerskov O. (1986). Enamel fluoride, dental fluorosis and dental caries among immigrants to and permanent residents of five Danish fluoride areas . Caries Res20:349-355.
54.
Larsen MJ, Kirkegaard E., Poulsen S. (1987). Patterns of dental fluorosis in a European country in relation to the fluoride concentration of drinking water. J Dent Res66:10-12.
55.
Larsen MJ, Senderovitz F., Kirkegaard E., Poulsen S., Fejerskov O. (1988). Dental fluorosis in the primary and the permanent dentition in fluoridated areas with consumption of either powdered milk or natural cow's milk. J Dent Res67:822-825.
56.
Larsen MJ, Kirkegaard E., Poulsen S., Fejerskov O. (1989). Dental fluorosis among participants in a non-supervised fluoride tablet program. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol17:204-206.
57.
Leverett D. (1986). Prevalence of dental fluorosis in fluoridated and nonfluoridated communities-a preliminary investigation. J Publ Hlth Dent46:184-187.
58.
Lewis HA, Chikte UM, Butchart A. (1992). Fluorosis and dental caries in schoolchildren from rural areas with about 9 and 1 ppm F in the water supplies. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol20:53-54.
59.
Mabelya L., Konig KG, van Palenstein Helderman WH (1992). Dental fluorosis, altitude, and associated dietary factors. Caries Res26:65-67.
60.
Manji F., Baelum V., Fejerskov O. (1986a). Dental fluorosis in an area of Kenya with 2 ppm fluoride in the drinking water. J Dent Res65:659-662.
61.
Manji F., Baelum V., Fejerskov O. (1986b). Fluoride, altitude and dental fluorosis. Caries Res20:473-480.
62.
Manji F., Baelum V., Fejerskov O., Gemert VM (1986c). Enamel changes in two-low fluoride areas of Kenya . Caries Res20:371-380.
63.
Mann J., Sgan-Cohen HD, Dakuar A., Gedalia I. (1985). Tea drinking, caries prevalence and fluorosis among northern Israeli Arab youth. Clin Prev Dent7:23-26.
64.
Mann J., Tibi M., Sgan-Cohen HD (1987). Fluorosis and caries prevalence in a community drinking above-optimal fluoridated water. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol15:293-295.
65.
Mann J., Mahmoud W., Ernest M., Sgan-Cohen H., Shoshan N., Gedalia I. (1990). Fluorosis and dental caries in 6-8-year-old children in a 5 ppm fluoride area. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol18:77-79.
66.
McKay FS (1929). The establishment of a definite relation between enamel that is defective in its structure, as mottled enamel, and the liability to decay. Dent Cosmos71:747-755.
67.
McKay FS, Black GV (1916). Investigation of mottled teeth. Dent Cosmos58:477-484, 627-644, 781-792, 894-904.
68.
Moller IJ (1970). Clinical standards used for diagnosing fluorosis . In: McClure FJ, editor. Water fluoridation. The search and the victory. US Department of Health, Education, and Welfare. Bethesda, MD: National Institute of Dental Research, 72.
69.
Moller IJ (1982). Fluorides and dental fluorosis. Int Dent J32:135-147.
70.
National Institute of Dental Research (1991 ). Oral Health Surveys of the National Institute of Dental Research: Diagnostic Criteria and Procedures. NIH Publication No.
71.
91-2870.
72.
Nevitt GA, Frankel JM, Witter DM (1963). Occurrence of non-fluoride opacities and non-fluoride hypoplasias of enamel of 588 children ages 9 to 14 years. J Am Dent Assoc66:65-69.
73.
Opinya GN, Valderhaug J., Birkeland JM, Lokhen P. (1991). Fluorosis of deciduous teeth and first permanent molars in a rural Kenyan community. Acta Odontol Scand49 :197-202.
74.
Osuji OO, Leake JL, Chipman ML, Nikiforuk G., Locker D., Levine N. (1988). Risk factors for dental fluorosis in a fluoridated community. J Dent Res67:1488-1492.
75.
Pendrys DG (1990). The Fluorosis Risk Index: a method for investigating risk factors. J Publ Hlth Dent50:291-298.
76.
Pendrys DG, Katz RV ( 1989). Risk of enamel fluorosis associated with fluoride supplementation, infant formula, and fluoride dentifrice use. Am J Epidemiol130 :1199-1208.
77.
Pindborg JJ (1982). Aetiology of developmental enamel defects not related to fluorosis. Int Dent J32:123-134.
78.
Richards A., Fejerskov O., Baelum V. (1989). Enamel fluoride in relation to severity of human dental fluorosis. Adv Dent Res3:147-153.
79.
Riordan PJ, Banks JA (1991). Dental fluorosis and fluoride exposure in Western Australia. J Dent Res70:1022-1028.
80.
Rozier RG, Dudney GG (1981). Dental fluorosis in children exposed to multiple sources of fluoride: implications for school fluoridation programs. Publ Hlth Rep96:542-546.
81.
Russell AL (1961). Differential diagnosis of fluoride and nonfluoride enamel opacities. Publ Hlth Dent21:143-146.
82.
Schamschula RG, Sugar E, Un PSH, Toth K, Barmes DE, Adkins BL (1985). Physiological indicators of fluoride exposure and utilization: an epidemiological study. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol13:104-107.
83.
Segreto VA, Camann D., Collins EM, Smith CT (1984). A current study of mottled enamel in Texas. J Am Dent Assoc108:56-59.
84.
Small BW, Murray JJ (1978). Enamel opacities: prevalence, classifications and aetiological considerations. J Dent6:33-42.
85.
Songpaisan Y., Davies GN (1989). Dental caries experience in the Changmai/Lamphun provinces of Thailand. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol17:131-135.
86.
Symposium IV: Fluoride and enamel defects (1989). Adv Dent Res3:98-99.
87.
Szpunar SM, Burt BA ( 1988). Dental caries, fluorosis, and fluoride exposure in Michigan schoolchildren. J Dent Res67:802-806.
88.
Thylstrup A., Fejerskov O. (1978). Clinical appearance of dental fluorosis in permanent teeth in relation to histologic changes. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol6:315-328.
89.
Warnakulasuriya KA, Balasuriya S., Perera Paj, Peiris Lcl (1992). Determining optimal levels of fluoride in drinking water for hot, dry climates-a case study in Sri Lanka. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol20:364-367.
90.
Wenzel A., Thylstrup A. (1982). Dental fluorosis and localized enamel opacities in fluoride and nonfluoride Danish communities. Caries Res16:340-348.
91.
Williams JE, Zwemer JD (1990). Community water fluoride levels, preschool dietary patterns, and the occurrence of fluoride enamel opacities. J Publ Hlth Dent50:276-281.
92.
Woltgens Jhm, Etty EJ, Nieuwland WM, Lyaruu DM (1989). Use of fluoride by young children and prevalence of mottled enamel. Adv Dent Res3:177-182.
93.
Woolfolk MW, Faja BW, Bagramian RA (1989). Relation of sources of systemic fluoride to prevalence of dental fluorosis. J Publ Hlth Dent449:78-82.
94.
World Health Organization (1987). Oral health surveys: basic methods. 3rd ed. Geneva: The World Health Organization .
95.
Zimmerman ER (1954). Fluoride and non-fluoride enamel opacities. Publ Hlth Rep69:1115-1120.
