Much variation exists in the practice of dentistry with regard to diagnosis of caries and recommendations for treatment. This is a particular problem with respect to the replacement of restorations, with responsible factors related to both the patient and the dentist. The aim of this paper is to look at factors, exclusive of clinical data, that may explain why there is so much variation in the practice of dentistry, and specifically pertaining to replacement of restorations. Due to the paucity of studies related specifically to dentists, findings from physician studies will be presented. No studies are available that compare variation in medical and dental practices, but since both professions deal with the provision of health care and function in similar circumstances, comparisons are arguably generalizable between the two groups. Development of clinical judgment will be explored based on dental training experiences, and two explanatory models of practice pattern variation will be discussed—the dentist as a self-fulfilling practitioner and the dentist as the patient's agent. Along with these models, the matter of uncertainty in clinical practice and the development of routines will also be discussed in light of explaining variations.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Anusavice, K.J., Ed. (1989): Quality Evaluation of Dental Restorations : Criteria for Placement and Replacement , Chicago: Quintessence Publishing Co., pp. 412-415.
2.
Bailit, H.L.; Balzer, J.A.; and Clive, J. (1983): Evaluation of Focused Dental Utilization Review System, Med Care21: 437-485.
3.
Bailit, H.L.; Chiriboga, D.; Grasso, J.; Damuth, L.; and Willemain, T.R. (1979): A New Intermediate Dental Outcome Measure, Amalgam Replacement Rate, Med Care17: 780-786.
4.
Bailit, H.L. and Clive, J. (1981): The Development of Dental Practice Profiles, Med Care19: 30-46.
5.
Berry, C.; Held, P.J.; Kehrer, B.; Marheim, L.; and Rein-Hardt, U. (1980): Canadian Physicians' Supply Response to Universal Health Insurance: The First Years in Quebec (Preliminary Results). In: Physicians and Financial Incentives, J.R. Gabels, J. Taylor, N.T. Greenspan, and M. Blaxall , Eds., Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, pp. 57-59.
6.
Bloor, M. (1976): Bishop Berkley and the Adenotonsillectomy Enigma: An Exploration of Variation in the Social Construction of Medical Disposals , Sociology20:43-61.
7.
Blumberg, M.S. (1982): Regional Differences in Hospital Use Standardized by Reported Morbidity, Med Care10: 931-944.
8.
Boyd, M. (1988): Amalgam Replacement: Are Our Decisions Based on Fact or Tradition? In: Quality Evaluation of Dental Restorations : Criteria for Placement and Replacement, K.J. Anusavice, Ed., Chicago: Quintessence Publishing Co., pp. 73-82.
9.
Boyd, M.A. and Richardson, A.S. (1985): Frequency of Amalgam Replacement in General Practice, J Can Dent Assoc51: 763-766.
10.
Chassin, M.R. (1983): Variations in Hospital Length of Stay: Their Relationship to Health Outcomes, Washington, D.C.: Office of Technology Assessment, Congress of the United States.
11.
Coleman, J.S.; Katz, E.; and Menzel, H. (1966): Medical Innovation: A Diffusion Study, New York: Bobbs-Merrill.
12.
Connell, F.A.; Day, R.W.; and Logerfo, J.P. (1981): Hospitalization of Medicaid Children: Analysis of Small Area Variations in Admission Rates, Am J Public Health71: 606-613.
13.
Conrad, D.A. and Milgrom, P. (1983): Market Forces. In: Reducing the Cost of Dental Care, R.T. Kurle and L. Meskin, Eds., Minneapolis : University of Minnesota Press, pp. 3-34.
14.
Daniels, M. and Schroeder, S.A. (1977): Variation Among Physicians in Use of Laboratory Tests: Relation to Clinical Productivity and Outcomes of Care, Med Care15: 482-487.
15.
Davies, J.A. (1984): The Relationship Between Change of Dentist and Treatment Received in the General Dental Service, Br Dent J157: 322-324.
16.
Desharnais, S.; Kibe, N.M.; and Barbus, S. (1983): Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Michigan Hospital Laboratory On-site Review Project, Inquiry20: 328-333.
17.
Eisenberg, J.M. (1979): Sociological Influence on Decision Making by Clinicians , Ann Intern Med90: 957-964.
18.
Eisenberg, J.M. (1986): Doctor's Decision and the Cost of Medical Care , Ann Arbor, MI: Health Administration Press Perspectives, pp. 5-77.
19.
Gabel, J.R. and Rice, T.H. (1985): Reducing Public Expenditures for Physician Service: The Price of Paying Less, J Health Polit Law9: 595-609.
20.
Goldberg, J.; Tanzer, J.; Munster, E.; Amara, J.; Thal, F.; and Birkhed, D. (1981): Cross-sectional Clinical Evaluation of Recurrent Enamel Caries, Restoration of Marginal Integrity, and Oral Hygiene Status , J Am Dent Assoc102: 635-641.
21.
Grembowski, D.; Conrad, D.; and Milgrom, P. (1985): Utilization of Dental Services in the United States and an Insured Population, Public Health Brief75: 87-89.
22.
Hadley, J. (1979): Physician Participation in Medicaid: Evidence from California, Health Serv Res14: 266-280.
23.
Hazelkorn, H.M. (1985): A Comparison of Dental Treatment Plans under Different Reimbursement Systems, J Publ Health Policy6: 223-235.
24.
Healey, H.J. and Phillips, R.W. (1949): A Clinical Study of Amalgam Failures, J Dent Res28: 439-446.
25.
Hemenway, D. and Fallon, D. (1985): Testing for Physician-induced Demand with Hypothetical Cases, Med Care23: 344-349.
26.
Jorgensen, K.D. and Wakamoto, S. (1968): Occlusal Amalgam Fillings: Marginal Defects and Secondary Caries, Odont Tidskrft76: 43-54.
27.
Klausner, L.H. and Charbeneau, G.T. (1985): Amalgam Restorations: A Cross-section Survey of Placement and Replacement, J Mich Dent Assoc76: 249-252.
28.
Lavelle, C.L.B. (1976): A Cross-sectional Longitudinal Survey into the Durability of Amalgam Restorations, J Dent4: 139-143.
29.
Manning, W.G.; Bailit, H.L.; Benjamin, B.; and Newhouse, J.P. (1985): The Demand for Dental Care: Evidence from a Randomized Trial in Health Insurance, J Am Dent Assoc110: 895-902.
30.
Marcus, M. and Schoen, M.H. (1983): Dentist's Preference for Treatment Planning and Their Relationship to Oral Health Status. Final Report, UCLASchool of Dentistry.
31.
Maryniuk, G.A. (1985): Clinicians' Perceptions of Restoration Longevity , J Dent Educ49: 769-772.
32.
Maryniuk, G.A. (1988): Variability of Amalgam Replacement Decisions and Their Impact on Cost, J Dent Res67: 356, Abst. No. 1946.
33.
Maryniuk, G.A. and Brunson, W.D. (1989): When to Replace Amalgam Restorations with "Faulty" Margins: A Pilot Study, Gen Dent37: 463-467.
34.
Maryniuk, G.A. and Kaplan, S.A. (1986): Longevity of Restorations : Survey Results of Dentist's Estimates and Attitudes, J Am Dent Assoc112: 39-45.
35.
Maryniuk, G.A.; Tulloch, J.F.C.; and McNutt, R.A. (1988): A Clinical Decision Analysis of "Faulty" Amalgam Replacement : When to Re-evaluate or Replace?, Med Decision Making8:348 (Abst).
36.
McPherson, K.; Wennberg, J.E.; Hovind, O.B.; and Clif-Ford, P. (1981): Small-Area Variation in the Use of Common Surgical Procedures: An International Comparison of New England, England and Norway , N Engl J Med307: 1310-1314.
37.
Mjor, LA (1981): Placement and Replacement of Restorations, Oper Dent6: 49-54.
38.
Newhouse, J.P.; Manning, W.G.; Morris, C.N.; Orr, L.L.; Duan, N.; Keeler, E.B.; Leibowitz, A.; Marquis, K.H.; Marquis, M.S.; Phelps, C.E.; and Brook, R.H. (1981): Some Interim Results from a Controlled Trial of Cost Sharing in Health Insurance, N Engl J Med305: 1501-1507.
39.
Nuttall, N.M. and Elderton, R.J. (1983): The Nature of Restorative Dental Treatment Decisions , Br Dent J154: 363-365.
40.
Pauly, M.V. (1980): Doctors and Their Workshops, Chicago: National Bureau of Economic Research, The University of Chicago Press.
41.
Read, J.L.; Stern, R.S.; Thibodeau, L.A.; Geer, D.E., Jr.; and Klapholz, H. (1983): Variations in Antenatal Testing over Time and Between Clinic Settings, J Am Med Assoc249: 1605-1609.
42.
Richardson, A.S. and Boyd, M.A. (1973): Replacement of Silver Amalgam Restorations by 50 Dentists During 246 Working Days, J Can Dent Assoc8: 556-559.
Rossiter, L.F. and Wilensky, G.R. (1983): A Re-examination of the Use of Physician Services: The Role of Physician-initiated Demand, Inquiry20: 162-172.
45.
SCHOEN, M.H. (1985): Personal communication.
46.
Soderholm, K.J. (1989): Correlation Between Marginal Discrepancies of Amalgams and the Incidence of Recurrent Caries. In: Quality Evaluation of Dental Restorations: Criteria for Placement and Replacement , K.J. Anusavice, Ed., Chicago: Quintessence Publishing Co., pp. 95-110.
47.
Wennberg, J.E.; Barnes, B.A.; and Zubkoff, M. (1982): Professional Uncertainty and the Problems of Supplier-induced Demand, Soc Sci Med16: 811-824.
48.
Wennberg, J.E. and Gittelsohn, A. (1982): Variations in Medical Care Among Small Areas, Sci Am246: 120-134.
49.
Wilensky, G.R. and Rossiter, L.F. (1983): The Relative Importance of Physician-induced Demand for Medical Care, Milbank Mem Fund61: 252-277.
50.
Winkler, J.D.; Lohr, K.N.; and Brook, R.H. (1985): Persuasive Communication and Medical Technology Assessment, Arch Int Med145: 314-317.
