Deterioration of Restorative Materials and the Risk for Secondary Caries

Abstract

This article reviews the literature related to marginal deterioration of amalgam restorations and the risk for secondary caries. Background information on this characteristic material failure is provided, including how it is measured clinically, its rate of progress with time, and the responsible microstructural mechanisms. The association between degree of marginal fracture and recurrent or secondary caries is reviewed in clinical and in vitro studies. Earlier clinical investigations and a more recent laboratory study demonstrated a strong correlation between gap size and recurrent caries for a caries-active environment, supporting replacement of defective restorations for preventive reasons. However, more recent clinical data show the complex and equivocal nature of this association. Poor specificity and validity for detection of recurrent caries with an explorer and mirror further complicate interpretation of some trials and decision-making in clinical practice. Improved methods of diagnosing recurrent caries and further studies of the factors influencing its initiation and progression are needed.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Anusavice, K.J. , Ed. (1989): Quality Evaluation of Dental Restorations : Criteria for Placement and Replacement , Chicago: Quintessence Publishing Co., Inc.

Bailit, H.L. ; Chiriboga, D. ; Grasso, J. ; Damuth, L. ; and Willemain, T.R. (1979): A New Intermediate Dental Outcome Measure: Amalgam Replacement Rate, Med Case 17:783-786.

Bergman, G. and Linden, L. (1969): The Action of the Explorer on Incipient Caries , Svensk Tandlek T 62:629-634.

Derand, T. ; Birkhed, D. ; and Edwardsson, S. (1990): Secondary Caries Related to Various Marginal Gaps Around Amalgam Restorations in vitro, Swed Dent J (submitted)

Ekstrand, K. ; Qvist, V. ; and Thylstrup, A. (1987): Light Microscope Study of the Effect of Probing in Occlusal Fissures, Caries Res 21:368-374.

Fairhurst, C.W. and Ryge, G. (1962): X-ray Diffraction Investigation of the Sn-Hg Phase in Dental Amalgam. In: Advances in X-ray Analysis, Vol. 5, W. M. Muelles , Ed., New York: Plenum Press.

Goldberg, J. (1986): Dental Materials: Clinical Evaluation. In: Encyclopedia of Materials Science and Engineering, M.B. Bener , Ed., Oxford: Pergamon Press, pp. 1088-1093.

Goldberg, J. ; Tanzer, J. ; Munster, E. ; Amara, J. ; Thal, F. ; and Birkhed, D. (1981): Cross-sectional Clinical Evaluation of Recurrent Enamel Caries, Restoration Marginal Integrity, and Oral Hygiene Status, J Am Dent Assoc 102:635-641.

Hamilton, J.C. ; Moffa, J.P. ; Ellison, J.A. ; and Jenkins, W.A. (1983): Marginal Fracture Not a Predictor of Longevity for Two Dental Amalgam Alloys: A Ten-Year Study, J Prosthet Dent 50:200-202.

10.

Jorgensen, K.D. and Wakumoto, S. (1968): Occlusal Amalgam Fillings: Marginal Defects and Secondary Caries, Odont Tidskrift 76:43-53.

11.

Kusy, R.P. and Leinfelder, K.F. (1977): Pattern of Wear in Posterior Composite Restorations, J Dent Res 56:544.

12.

Leinfelder, K.F. (1985): Evaluation of Clinical Wear of Posterior Composite Resins. In: Posterior Composite Resin Dental Restorative Materials , G. Vanherle and D.C. Smith , Eds., Netherlands : P. Szulc Publishing Co., pp. 501-509.

13.

Leinfelder K.F. and Lemons, J.E. (1988): Clinical Restorative Materials and Techniques , Philadelphia: Lea and Febiger .

14.

Mahler, D.B. (1988): Research on Dental Amalgam, Adv Dent Res 2:71-82.

15.

Mahler, D.B. and Marantz, R.L. (1979a): The Effect of Time on the Marginal Fracture Behavior of Amalgam, J Oral Rehabil 6:391-398.

16.

Mahler, D.B. and Marantz, R.L. (1979b): The Effect of the Operator on the Clinical Performance of Amalgam, J Am Dent Assoc 99:38-41.

17.

Mahler, D.B. ; Terkla, L.G. ; Van Eysden, J. ; and Reisbick, M.H. (1970): Marginal Fracture versus Mechanical Properties of Amalgam, J Dent Res 49:1452-1457.

18.

Marek, M. ; Hockman, R.F. ; and Okabe, T. (1976): In vitro Corrosion of Dental Amalgam Phases, J Biomed Mater Res 10 :789-804.

19.

Merrett, M.C.W. and Elderton, R.J. (1984): An in vitro Study of Restorative Dental Treatment Decisions and Dental Caries, Br Dent J 157:128-133.

20.

Phillips, R.W. ; Avery, D.R. ; Mehra, R. ; Swartz, M.L. ; and McCune, R.J. (1972): Observations on a Composite Resin for Class II Restorations: Two-year Report, J Prosthet Dent 28 :164-169.

21.

Ryge, G. and Snyder, M. (1973): Evaluating the Clinical Quality of Restorations , J Am Dent Assoc 87:369-377.

22.

Soderholm, K.J. ; Antonson, D.E. ; and Fischl-Schweiger, W. (1989): Correlation Between Marginal Discrepancies at the Amalgam/Tooth Interface and Recurrent Caries. In: Proceedings, Quality Evaluation of Dental Restorations: Criteria for Placement and Replacement, K.J. Anusavice , Ed., Chicago: Quintessence Publishing Co., Inc., pp. 95-108.