The Role of Toothbrushing in the Prevention and Treatment of Periodontal Disease: Personal Experience of Both Clinical and Experimental Observation for More than Thirty Years

Abstract

There have been dramatic developments in the theory and therapy of periodontal disease in the last few decades. This paper focuses on the role of toothbrushing in the treatment and prevention of periodontal disease, based on the author's personal experience gained from both clinical and experimental observations for more than 30 years.

Even in the recent past, periodontal disease was considered to be untreatable because of various misconceptions regarding its etiology. Attention was concentrated mainly on systemic factors. As a result, periodontallyinvolved teeth were extracted mostly due to lack of technical know-how. The author devoted his primary investigative efforts to systemic factors and found that those were only minimally significant. Later, after using wild and captive monkeys to make extensive experimental studies on local factors, he was convinced that food habit (hard, fibrous, or soft) contributes directly to the etiology of periodontal disease which is restricted in the oral environment itself.

Today it is well-established that accumulation of bacterial plaque on the tooth surface is the most important single factor responsible for periodontal disease, and systemic influence can merely modify the condition. Therefore, the accumulated plaque should be mechanically removed by toothbrushing. The essence of mechanical toothbrushing is not only to remove the plaque but also to compensate for the mechanical stimulation of the gingiva (gingival massage), which is lacking with modern soft food. This lecture reviews the effect of methodical toothbrushing obtained from both clinical and experimental studies in animals.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Burwasser, P. and Hill, T.J. (1939): The Effect of Hard and Soft Diets on the Gingival Tissue in Dogs, J Dent Res 18 :389-391.

Imagawa, Y. ; Ishikawa, J. ; and Okawara, S. (1961): Effect of Tooth Brushing to Prevent and Cure Periodontal Disease, Dental Outlook (Shikai-Tembo) 18:1299-1305.

Ishikawa, J. (1959a): Study on Gingival Hyperplasia Associated with Diphenylhydantoin Administration. (1) Clinical and Statistical Investigation of Gingival Hyperplasia in Epileptic Patients, J Jpn Conserv Dent 2:147-168.

Ishikawa, J. (1959b): Study on Gingival Hyperplasia Associated with Diphenylhydantoin Administration. (2) Experimental Study on Gingival Hyperplasia by Diphenylhydantoin in Cats, J Jpn Conserv Dent 2:169-178.

ISHIKAWA, J. (1965): Gingival Hyperplasia Associated with Dilantin Administration, Dental Outlook (Shikai-Tembo) 26:757-762. ISHIKAWA, J. (1986): Why Should We Human-beings Brush Our Teeth?, Tokyo: Ishiyaku Publishers.

Ishikawa, J. ; Ohkawara, S. ; Kawamura, T. ; and Takeshita, E. (1965): Effect of Tooth Brushing upon Gingival Hyperplasia Associated with Dilantin Administration, J Jpn Assoc Stomatol (Kokubyogak-kai) 32:266.

Ishikawa, J. and Yamazaki, K. (1964): Oral Findings of a Group of Wild Japanese Monkeys Living in Mt. Takasaki. In: Japanese Monkeys in Takasakiyama , J. Intani , J. Ikeda , and T. Tanaka , Eds., Tokyo: Keiso-Shobu, pp. 139-151.

Ishikawa, J. and Yamazaki, K. (1974): Comparison of Gingival Condition of Monkey Groups in Different Food Environment, IADR Progr & Abst 53: Abst. No. 820.

Leonard, H.J. (1948): Is Massage a Valuable Treatment in Gingivitis and Periodontitis?, J Periodont 19:63.

10.

Okawara, S. (1965): The Effects of Tooth Brushing on the Gingival Tissue, J Jpn Conserv Dent 8:135-165.

11.

Uchiyama, J. (1981): Clinical and Histometric Analysis of Effect of Tooth Brushing on Experimental Gingivitis in Monkeys, J Jpn Periodont 23:249-272.

12.

Yamazaki, K. (1968): An Epidemiological Study of Periodontal Disease in Japanese Monkeys Fed on Natural and Artificial Diets, J Jpn Assoc Stomatol (Kokubyogakkai) 35:91-109.