Optical measuring techniques- such as holography, contouring, moire, and speckle- offer new nondestructive possibilities for bridging the gap between in vitro and in vivo measurements in dentistry, and thus increase the possibility of achieving more accurate and sometimes more objective diagnosis and therapy. This presentation is an attempt to illuminate the future prospects of holography and speckle in the dental field by giving a survey of the past in combination with a vision of the future. Holographic determination of implant properties and polymer testing are discussed to show that different prosthodontic constructions and different dental materials can be tested to obtain information about their deformational behavior. Conditions such as loading, temperature, and moisture are no obstacle, and functional tests can be carried out on realistic objects with complex shapes and various thicknesses as well as on test samples. This can be a great advantage in that it facilitates the laboratory testing of samples of real size and shape under the same conditions as those in clinical testing. Although the oral environment gives rise to a very complex situation, including many parameters with unknown relations and magnitudes, optical methods sometimes provide a picture of the total course of events. Furthermore, clinical time can be saved this way by a reduction of the time needed for treatment of the patient. The future is exciting, but it requires further developments using different optical methods. This is not an utopia; interdisciplinary collaborations and communications between the technical and dental fields are imperative.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Abramson, N. (1981): The Making and Evaluation of Holograms, London: Academic Press.
2.
Altschuler, B. (1973): Holodontography: An Introduction to Dental Laser Holography. In: Report SAM-TR-73-4, Aerospace Medicine, Brooks Air Force Base, Texas.
3.
Azizov, M.A.; Bakhtin, V.G.; and Polukhina, S.P. (1985): Primenenie Optichesko i Holografii diia Isledovaniia Napriazhenno-deformirovannogo Sostoiannia Zubnykh Mostovidnykh Protezov iz Metalla, Stomatol64: 66-68.
4.
Blandin, M.; Duron, C.; and Soulet, H. (1977): Study by Holographic Interferometry of Dimensional Variability in Precision-moulding Materials used in Odontology, SPIE136: 130-134.
5.
Bowley, W.W.; Burstone, C.; Koenig, H.A.; and Siat-Kowski, R. (1974): Prediction of Tooth Displacements Using Laser Holography and Finite Element Technique-Proceedings of the Symposium of Commission V, International Society of Photogrammetry, Biostereometrics74: 241-273.
6.
Burstone, C-J. and Pryputniewicz, R.J. (1980): Holographic Determination of Centers of Rotation Produced by Orthodontic Forces, Am J Orthod77: 396-409.
7.
Burstone, C.J.; Pryputniewicz, R.J.; and Bowley, W.W. (1978 a): Holographic Measurement of Tooth Mobility in Three Dimensions, J Periodont Res13: 283-294.
8.
Burstone, C.J.; Pryputniewicz, R.J.; and Bowley, W.W. (1978 b): Determination of Arbitrary Tooth Displacements , J Dent Res57: 663-664.
9.
Burstone, C.J.; Every, T.W.; and Pryputniewicz, R.J. (1982 a): Holographic Measurement of Incisor Extrusion, Am J Orthod82: 1-9.
Burstone, C.J.; Pryputniewicz, R.J.; and Pryputniewicz, E.J. (1983): Quantitative Studies of Tooth and Bone Motions by Laser Speckle Method, J Dent Res62: 655, Abst. No. 51 (IADR).
12.
Champy, M.; Wille, A.; Pharok, P.; Meyrueis, P.; Gross-Mann, M.; and Liegois, C. (1979): Accurate Iconics Studies of Osteosynthesis of Jaws, SPIE211: 74-79.
13.
Crane, R.B. (1970): Use of Laser-produced Speckle Pattern to Determine Surface Roughness, J Opt Soc Am60: 1658-1663.
14.
De Schryver, F.M. and Kuliralo, M. (1985): Measurement of Roughness on Teeth by Means of Holographic Correlation, SPIE525: 154-157.
15.
Dermaut, L.R. and Beerden, L.I. (1981): The Effects of Class II Elastic Force on a Dry Skull Measured by Holographic Interferometry, Am J Orthod79: 296-304.
16.
Dermaut, L.R. and Van Den Bulcke, M.M. (1986): Evaluation of Intrusive Mechanics of the Type Segmented Arch on a Macerated Human Skull Using the Laser Reflection Technique and Holographic Interferometry, Am J Orthod89: 251-263.
17.
Dirtoft, I. (1980): Dimensional Changes due to Imbibition in Different Processed Dentures, J Dent Res59(Sp Iss D): 1902, Abst. No. 21 (Div. Abst.).
18.
Dirtoft, I. (1982): Holographic Measurement of Deformation in Complete Upper Dentures III. Clinical Application, IADR Progr & Abst61: 222, Abst. No. 395.
19.
Dirtoft, I.; Abramson, N.; and Sandstrom, U. (1979): Holographic Measuring of Deformations in Complete Upper Dentures, SPIE211: 106-110.
20.
Dirtoft, I. and Abramson, N. (1982): Holographic Measurement of Deformation in Complete Upper Dentures-Clinical Application. In: Springer Series in Optical Sciences, Vol. 31, G. von Bally and P. Greguss, Eds., Berlin : Springer, pp. 100-104.
21.
Dirtoft, I. (1983): Dental Holography, SPIE370: 108-111.
22.
Dirtoft, I.; Abramson, N.; and Terselius, B. (1984 a): Sorption in Dentures Measured by Holography and Other Methods, J Dent Res63 (Sp Iss B): No. 1068.
23.
Dirtoft, I. (1985): Holography-a New Method for Deformation Analysis of Upper Complete Dentures in vitro and in vivo, Stockholm : Almqvist & Wiksell International.
24.
Dirtoft, I.; Jansson, J.-F.; and Abramson, N. (1985 b): Using Holography for Measurement of in vivo Deformation in a Complete Maxillary Denture, J Prosthet Dent54: 843-846.
25.
Dirtoft, I.; Abramson, N.; and Jansson, J.-F. (1986): The Use of Holography in Non Destructive Evaluation . In: Proceedings, PolymerNde, K.H.G. Ashbee , Ed., Lancaster: Technomic Publishing Co. , pp. 237-238.
26.
Dirtoft, I.; Jansson, J.-F.; and Abramson, N. (1987 a): Hologram Interferometry for Deformation Analysis of Plastic Products with Complex Shapes, Appl Opt (submitted).
27.
Dirtoft, I.; Terselius, B.; and Abramson, N. (1987 b): Holography-a New Method to Follow Dimensional Changes in Maxillary Complete Dentures, J Biomed Mater Res (submitted).
28.
Dirtoft, I.; Terselius, B.; and Abramson, N. (1987 c): Swelling Measured by Holography and Weighing in Upper Complete Dentures Immersed in Water, J Clin Mater (submitted).
29.
Dirtoft, I. and Jansson, J.-F. (1986 a): Holography for Deformation Analysis of an Implant Bridge During Loading, J Dent Res65 (Sp Iss B): 775, Abst. No. 448 (IADR).
30.
Dirtoft, I. and Jansson, J.-F. (1986 b): Holography for Deformation Analysis of a Fixed Dental Prosthesis During Loading in vitro. In: Current Clinical Practice, Series No. 29, D. van Steenberghe , Ed., Amsterdam: Excerpta Medica , pp. 366-370.
31.
Dorheide, J. and Hoyer, H.-C. (1981): Holografische Schwingungsuntersuchungen am Menschlischen Schadel, Umfallheilkunde84: 345-349.
32.
Ferr, J.C.; Legoux, R.; Helary, J.L.; Albugues, F.; Le Floch, C.; Bouteyre, J.; Lumineau, J.P.; Chevalier, C.; Le Cloarec, A.Y.; and Orio, E. (1985): Study of the Mandible under Static Constraints by Holographic Interferometry. New Biomedical Deductions, Anat Clin7: 193-201.
33.
Fuchs, P. and Schott, D. (1973 a): Anwendung der Holographie bei Verformungsmessungen des menschlicher Gesichtsschadels, Dtsch Zahnärztl Z28: 90.
34.
Fuchs, P. and Schott, D. (1973 b): Holografische Interferometrie zur Darstellung von Verformungen des menschlichen Gesichtsschadels, Monatsschr Zahnheilkd83: 1468-1482.
35.
Goedgebuer, J.P.; Spajer, M.; and Vienot, J.Ch. (1979): Holographic Evaluation of the Dimensional Stability of Elastic Impression Silicones Used in Dentistry . In: Springer Series in Optical Sciences, Vol. 18, G. von Bally, Ed., Berlin: Springer, pp. 165-169.
36.
Hewitt, A.B. (1977): An Investigation using Holographic Interferometry of Surface Strain in Bone Induced by Orthodontic Forces: A Preliminary Report , Br J Orthod4: 39-41.
37.
Iroshnikova, E.S.; Kudrin, A.B.; Perk, O.N.; and Polukhina, S.P. (1982): Primenenie Holografichensko i Interferometrii diia Issledovaniia Visochnonizhnecheliustnoga Sustava, Stomatol61: 46-47.
38.
Kaseyama, H. (1978): Dynamical Studies on the Human Skull by the Holography-interference Method. 2. Morphological Significance of Human Skull in the Loadings on the Teeth (author's trans.), Shikwa Gakuho78: 1537-1560.
39.
Keating, P.J.; Parker, R.A.; Keane, D.; and Wright, L. (1984): The Holographic Storage of Study Models, Br J Orthod11: 119-125.
40.
Kobayshi, K.; Kouhara, A.; and Kiyomura, H. (1978): The Relationship between the Movement of Molars and the Transmission of Orthodontic Force in Extraoral Anchorage-Theoretical Analysis and Holography, Nippon Kyosei Shika Gakkai Zasshi37: 187-194.
41.
Kragt, G. (1981): Initial Dentofacial Orthopedic Reactions. A Holographic Study. Thesis, Groningen, The Netherlands.
42.
Kragt, G. and Borsboom, P.C.F. (1980): Bone Displacement as a Function of Time of Force Application to a Macerated Human Skull, J Biomed Mater Res14: 813-815.
43.
Kragt, G.; Ten Bosch, J.J.; and Borsboom, P.C.F. (1979): Measurement of Bone Displacement in a Macerated Human Skull Induced by Orthodontic Forces; a Holographic Study , J Biomech12: 905-910.
44.
Kragt, G.; Duterloo, H.S.; and Ten Bosch, J.J. (1982): The Initial Reaction of a Macerated Human Skull Caused by Orthodontic Cervical Traction Determined by Laser Metrology, Am J Orthod81: 49-56.
45.
Kragt, G. and Duterloo, H.S. (1982): The Initial Effects of Orthopedic Forces: A Study of Alterations in the Craniofacial Complex of a Macerated Human Skull Owing to High-pull Headgear Traction, Am J Orthod81: 57-64.
46.
Leith, E.N. (1969): Investigation of Holographic Testing Techniques . Institute of Science and Technology, AD, 857061, 2420-5-P, Willow Run Laboratories, University of Michigan , Ann Arbor.
47.
Liljeborg, A.; Johannsen, G.; and Rydén, H. (1985): The Laser Reflection Method. Computerized Analysis of Speckle Pattern, Swed Dent J9: 213-218.
48.
Matsumoto, T.; Fujita, T.; Nagata, R.; Iwata, K.; Sug-Imura, T.; and Kakudo, Y. (1979): Measurements of Deformations of Teeth and Mandibles due to Occlusal Forces. In: Springer Series in Optical Sciences, Vol. 18, G. von Bally, Ed., Berlin: Springer, pp. 170-176.
49.
Matsumoto, T.; Fujita, T.; Nagata, R.; Iwata, K.; Sug-Imura, T.; and Kakudo, Y. (1981): Holographic Investigation of Tooth Deformations . In: Springer Series in Optical Sciences, Vol. 31, G. von Bally and P. Greguss , Eds., Berlin: Springer, pp. 105-109.
50.
MEYRUEIS, P.; PHAROK, M.; and FONTAINE, J. (1977): Holographic Interferometry in Osteosynthesis, SPIE 136: 202-205. MINCHAM, W.; THURGATE, S.M.; and LEWIS, A.J. (1981): Measurement of Dimensional Stability of Elastomeric Impression Materials by Holographic Interferometry, Aust Dent J 26: 395-399.
51.
Nagai, M.; Miyairi, H.; and Muramatsu, A. (1976): Measurements of Denture Base Deflection by Holography , Reports of the Institute for Medical & Dental Engineering10: 77-82.
52.
Pavlin, P. (1981): Holographic Evaluation of Hard Tissue Reactions on the Human Skull during Slow Maxillary Expansion. Thesis, Zagreb, Yugoslavia.
53.
Pavlin, D.; Vukicevic, D.; and Rajic, Z. (1979): Strain Distribution in the Facial Skeleton Arising from Orthodontic Appliance Activity. In: Springer Series in Optical Sciences, Vol.18, G. von Bally, Ed., Berlin: Springer, pp. 177-182.
54.
Pavlin, D. and Vukicevic, D. (1984): Mechanical Reactions of Facial Skeleton to Maxillary Expansion Determined by Laser Holography, Am J Orthod85: 498-507.
55.
Pirel, C. (1976): Contribution a l'etude de la stabilité dimensioneel des elastomèrés silikonés et recherche de protocoles expérimenteaux. Ph.D. dissertation, Lyon: Universite Christian Bernard.
56.
Pryputniewicz, R.J. and Burstone, C.J. (1979): The Effect of Time and Force Magnitude on Orthodontic Tooth Movement, J Dent Res58: 1754-1764.
57.
Pryputniewicz, R.J. and Burstone, C.J. (1982): A New Technique for Studies of Tooth and Bone Motions, IADR Progr & Abst61: 281, Abst. No. 926.
58.
Pryputniewicz, R.J. (1985): Pulsed Laser Holography in Studies of Bone Motions and Deformations, Opt Eng24: 832-839.
59.
Pryputniewicz, R.J. and Bowley, W.W. (1978): Techniques of Holographic Displacement Measurement: An Experimental Comparison, Appl Opt17: 1748-1756.
60.
Redmalm, G.; Johannsen, G.; and Ryden, H. (1985): Lustre Changes on Teeth. The Use of Laser Light for Reflection Measurements of the Tooth Surface-in vivo, Swed Dent J9: 29-35.
61.
Redmalm, G. and Ryden, H. (1979): Dentifrice Abrasivity. The Use of Laser Beams for Comparative Studies in vitro of Surface Changes, Swed Dent J3: 91-100.
62.
Redmalm, G. and Ryden, H. (1984): Dentifrice Abrasivity. The Use of Laser Light and Supplemental Techniques for Characterizing Toothpastes Containing Different Abrasives. An in vitro Study, Swed Dent J8: 57-66.
63.
Redmalm, G.; Ryden, H.; Johannsen, G.; and Soder, P.Ö. (1981): Lustre Changes on Teeth. The Use of Laser Beams for Comparative Studies in vivo, Swed Dent J5: 241-246.
64.
Reinhardt, W.; Reinhardt, R.; and Wenke, L. (1985): Hologramminterferometrische Untersuchungen als erganzende Moglichkeit der Instrumentellen Okklusionsanalyse, Stomatol35: 9-13.
65.
Ryden, H. (1980): The Laser Reflection Method Measurements of Tooth Movements, Thesis, Stockholm, Sweden.
66.
Ryden, H.; Bjelkhagen, H.; and Martensson, B. (1982 a): Tooth Position Measurements on Dental Casts Using Holographic Images, Am J Orthod81: 310-313.
67.
Ryden, H.; Bjelkhagen, H.; and Soder, P.-O. (1974): The Use of Laser Beams for Measuring Mobility and Tooth Movement : An in vitro Study, J Periodont45: 283-287.
68.
Ryden, H.; Bjelkhagen, H.; and Soder, P.-O. (1975): The Use of Laser Beams for Measuring Mobility and Tooth Movement : An in vitro Study, J Periodont46: 421-425.
69.
Ryden, H.; Bjelkhagen, H.; and Sandstrom, U. (1979): A Laser Instrument for Measuring Tooth Movements , J Periodont50: 265-269.
70.
Ryden, H.; Bjelkhagen, H.; and Soder, P.-O. (1982 b): Movements of Healthy and Periodontally Involved Teeth Measured with Laser Reflection Technique, J Periodont53: 439-445.
71.
SCHWANINGER, B.; SCHMIDT, R.J.; and HURST, R.V.V. (1977): Holography in Dentistry, J Am Dent Assoc 95: 814-817. SENDA, A.; YOSHINO, H.; SAITO, K.; WATANABE. T.; HARA, G.; and TAWATA, M. (1979): Study on the Deformation of Impression, Preliminary Report: Application of the Holographic Interferometry, Aichi Gakuin Daisaku Shissakkai Shi 17: 205-215.
72.
Spajer, M. and Goedgebuer, J.-P. (1979): Interferometric Studies of the Dimensional Variations of Silicone Elastomers, Optics and Laser Technol11:100-102.
73.
Von Bally, G. and Kumpf, W. (1985): Holographic Vibration Analysis of the Human Skull , Arch Oto Rhino Laryngol241:70.
74.
Vienot, J.-Ch.; Goedgebuer, J.P.; and Lacourt, A. (1977): Space and Time Variables in Optics and Holography: Recent Experimental Aspects, Appl Opt16: 454-461.
75.
Vogel, A. (1986): Vergleich zweier empfindlicher Speckle-Messtechniken angewandt auf Verformungsmessungen an Zahnen, Optik72: 95-101.
76.
Wedendal, P. (1974): Dental Holographic Interferometry in Laboratory Installation and in vivo, Thesis, Stockholm, Sweden.
77.
Wedendal, P.R. and Bjelkhagen, H.I. (1973): Dental Holographic Interferometry in vivo Utilizing a Ruby Laser System, Acta Odontol Scand32: 131-145.
78.
Wedendal, P.R. and Bjelkhagen, H.I. (1974a): Holographic Interferometry on the Elastic Deformation of Prosthodontic Appliances as Simulated by Bar Elements, Acta Odontol Scand32: 189-199.
79.
Wedendal, P.R. and Bjelkhagen, H.I. (1974b): Dental Holographic Interferometry in vivo Utilizing a Ruby Laser System. II. Clinical Application, Acta Odontol Scand32: 345-356.
80.
Wedendal, P.R.; Alfredsson, H.; Bjelkhagen, H.I.; and Niia, L. (1974): The Tolerance within a Special Screw-lock System Determined by Means of Laser Metrology, I C D, Sc Ed Bull7: 27-30.
81.
Wesson, A.; Goldstein, G.; and Schulman, A. (1986): Stress Analysis of Fixed Prosthodontic Frameworks Utilizing Holographic Interferometry, J Dent Res65: 317, Abst. No. 1334 (AADR).
82.
Wictorin, L.; Bjelkhagen, H.; and Abramson, N. (1972): Holographic Investigation of the Elastic Deformation of Defective Gold Solder Joints, Acta Odontol Scand30: 659-670.
83.
Yoshino, H.; Kanamari, K.; Hashimoto, M.; Tani, T.; Mizuno, T.; Kondo, M.; and Senda, A. (1985): Effect of the Tray on the Deformation of the Impression. A Holography Interferometric Study, Aichi Gakuin Daigaku Shigakkai Shi23: 300-307.
