The widespread expansion of school choice policies has bolstered the consumer-education paradigm where parents compete for what they perceive to be a limited number of high quality schools. In this comparative case study, we examine advantaged White parents’ perceptions of meritocracy in the context of a competitive elementary and high school choice system in New York City. We find that parents’ critique the choice policies and the unfair burdens they place on low-income and immigrant families while engaging in opportunity hoarding to ensure their children’s privileged access to the most competitive schools, all while dismissing claims that school choice is meritocratic. Ultimately, advantaged parents’ suggest returning to neighborhood zoning which would preserve their access to exclusive, high performing schools and avoid the stress and inequities of school choice policies. This study offers further examples of the powerful influence of contradictory White discourse in the context of education policy and reform.
AdamsonF.AstrandB.Darling-HammondL. (Eds.). (2016). Global education reform: How privatization and public investment influence education outcomes. Routledge.
BallS. J.BoweR.GewirtzS. (1996). School choice, social class and distinction: The realization of social advantage in education. Journal of Education Policy, 11(1), 89–112.
6.
BallS. J.VincentC. (1998). “I heard it on the grapevine”: “Hot” knowledge and school choice. British Journal of Sociology of Education, 19, 377–400.
BloomH. S.UntermanR. (2014). Can small high schools of choice improve educational prospects for disadvantaged students?Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 33(2), 290–319.
12.
BourdieuP. (1974). Cultural reproduction and social reproduction. In BrownR. (Ed.), Knowledge, education, and cultural change: Papers in the sociology of education (pp. 71–84). Tavistock.
13.
BourdieuP. (1986). The forms of capital. In RichardsonJ. (Ed.), Handbook of theory and research for the sociology of education, (pp. 241–258). Greenwood.
BulkleyK. E.MarshJ. A.StrunkK. O.HarrisD. N.HashimA. K. (2020). Challenging the one best system: The portfolio management model and urban school governance. Harvard Education Press.
16.
CalarcoJ. M. (2018). Negotiating opportunities: How the middle class secures advantages in school. Oxford University Press.
17.
CarlsonD.LaveryL.WitteJ. F. (2011). The determinants of interdistrict open enrollment flows evidence from two states. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 33, 76–94.
18.
ChubbJ. E.MoeT. M. (1990). Politics, markets, and America’s schools. Brookings Institution.
19.
CohenG. A. (1989). On the currency of egalitarian justice. Ethics, 99, 906–944.
20.
CooperC. W. (2005). School choice and the standpoint of African American mothers: Considering the power of positionality. The Journal of Negro Education, 74(2), 174–189.
21.
CorbinJ.StraussA. (2008). Basics of qualitative research. Sage.
22.
CrozierG.ReayD.JamesD.JamiesonF.BeedellP.HollingworthS.WilliamsK. (2008). White middle-class parents, identities, educational choice and the urban comprehensive school: Dilemmas, ambivalence and moral ambiguity. British Journal of Sociology of Education, 29(3), 261–272.
23.
CucchiaraM. B. (2013). Marketing schools, marketing cities: Who wins and who loses when schools become urban amenities. The University of Chicago Press.
24.
CucchiaraM. B.HorvatE. M. (2014). Choosing selves: The salience of parental identity in the school choice process. Journal of Education Policy, 29(4), 486–509.
25.
DebsM.KafkaJ.MakrisM. V.RodaA. (2023). Happiness-oriented parents: An alternative perspective on privilege and choosing schools. American Journal of Education, 129(2), 145–176. https://doi.org/10.1086/723066
26.
DenzinN. K.LincolnY. (Eds.). (2005). Handbook of qualitative research (3rd ed.). Sage.
27.
DiemS.WeltonA. D. (2020). Anti-racist educational leadership and policy: Addressing racism in public education. Routledge
28.
DuncanG. J.MurnaneR. J. (2011). Whither opportunity? Rising inequality, schools and children’s life changes. Russell Sage Foundation.
EricssonA.PoolR. (2016). Peak: Secrets from the new science of expertise. Random House.
32.
EvansS. A. (2021). “I wanted diversity, but not so much”: Middle-class white parents, school Choice, and the persistence of anti-Black stereotypes. Urban Education. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1177/00420859211031952
33.
FishR. E. (2016). The racialized construction of exceptionality: Experimental evidence of race/ethnicity effects on teachers’ interventions. Social Science Research, 62, 317–334. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ssresearch.2016.08.007
34.
GodleyA. (2013). Equivocal equity: The struggles of a white middle-class urban school parent, and grassroots advocate. Research in the Teaching of English, 48(2), 250–260.
35.
GottfredsonL. S. (1997). Mainstream science on intelligence: An editorial with 52 signatories, history, and bibliography. Intelligence, 24(1), 13–23.
36.
HagermanM. A. (2018). White kids: Growing up with privilege in a racially divided America. New York University Press.
37.
HamiltonL. S.GuinK. (2005). Understanding how families choose schools. In BettsJ. R.LovelessT. (Eds.), Getting choice right: Ensuring equity and efficiency in education policy (pp. 40–60). Brookings Institution Press.
38.
HarrisC. I. (1993). Whiteness as property. Harvard Law Review, 106, 1707–1791.
39.
HeynemanS. P. (2009). International perspectives on school choice. In BerendsM.SpringerM. G.BALLOUD.HerbertiW. (Eds.), Handbook of research on school choice (pp. 97–114). Routledge.
40.
HillP.T.CampbellC.HarveyJ. (2001). It takes a city: Getting serious about urban school reform. Brookings Institution Press.
41.
HoweM. J.DavidsonJ. W.SlobodaJ. A. (1998). Innate talents: Reality or myth?Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 21(3), 399–407.
HugheyM. (2022). Superposition strategies: How and why White people say contradictory things about race. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA, 119(9), e2116306119. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2116306119
44.
JabbarH.FongC. J.GermainE.LiD.SanchezJ.SunW. L.DevallM. (2022). The competitive effects of school choice on student achievement: A systematic review. Educational Policy, 36(2), 247–281.
45.
JabbarH.LenhoffS. W. (2019). Parent decision-making and school choice. In MerendsM.PrimusA.SpringerM. G. (Eds.), The handbook of research on school choice (2nd ed., p. 14). Routledge.
46.
KhanS. R. (2011). Privilege: The making of an adolescent elite at St. Paul’s School. Princeton University Press.
47.
KimelbergS. M.BillinghamC. M. (2013). Attitudes toward diversity and the school choice process. Urban Education, 48(2), 198–231.
48.
KohliR.PizarroM.NevárezA. (2017). The “new racism” of K–12 schools: Centering critical research on racism. Review of Research in Education, 41(1), 182–202.
LareauA. (2003). Unequal childhoods: Class, race, and family life. University of California Press.
51.
LareauA.GoyetteK. (Eds.). (2014). Choosing homes, choosing schools. Russell Sage.
52.
LeonardoZ.ZembylasM. (2013) Whiteness as technology of affect: Implications for educational praxis, Equity & Excellence in Education, 46(1), 150–165. https://www.doi.org/10.1080/10665684.2013.750539
53.
LewisA. E.DiamondJ. B. (2015). Despite the best intentions: How racial inequality thrives in good schools. Oxford University Press.
54.
LipsitzG. (2006). The possessive investment of whiteness: How white people profit from identity politics. Temple University Press.
55.
MacKenzieP. (2010). School choice in an international context. Journal of Research in International Education, 9(2), 107–123.
56.
MaderN.HemphillC.AbbasQ. (2018). The paradox of choice: How school choice divides New York City elementary schools. Center for New York City Affairs.
57.
MarkovitzD. (2019). The meritocracy trap: How America’s foundational myth feeds inequality, dismantles the middle class, and devours the elite. Penguin Press.
58.
Mayorga-GalloS. (2019). The white-centering logic of diversity ideology. American Behavioral Scientist, 63(13), 1789–1809. https://doi.org/10.1177/0002764219842619
59.
NathansonL.CorcoranS.Baker-SmithC. (2013). High school choice in New York City: A report on the school choices and placements of low-achieving students. Institute for Education and Social Policy. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED541824.pdf
60.
New York City Department of Education. (2019). New York City graduation rates.
OrfieldG.FrankenbergE. (2013). Educational delusions? Why choice can deepen inequality and how to make schools fair. University of California Press.
63.
PhillippoK.GriffinB.Del DottoJ.LennixC. G.HaT. (2021). Seeing merit as a vehicle for opportunity and equity: Youth respond to school choice policy. The Urban Review, 53, 591–616.
64.
Posey-MaddoxL. (2014). When middle-class parents choose urban schools: Class, race & the challenge of equity in public education. University of Chicago Press.
65.
Posey-MaddoxL.KimelbergS.CucchiaraM. (2013). Middle-class parents and urban public schools: Current research and future directions. Sociology Compass, 8, 446–456.
66.
Posey-MaddoxL.de RoystonM. M.HolmanA. R.RallR. M.JohnsonR. A. (2021). No choice is the “right” choice: Black parents’ educational decision-making in their search for a “good” school. Harvard Educational Review, 91(1), 38–61.
67.
RangvidB. S. (2007). Living and learning separately? Ethnic segregation of school children in Copenhagen. Urban Studies, 44, 1329–1354.
68.
RavitchD. (2010). The death and life of the great American school system: How testing and choice are undermining education. Basic Books.
69.
ReayD.BallS. J. (1998). ‘Making their minds up’: Family dynamics of school choice. British Educational Research Journal, 24(4), 431–448.
70.
RichardsE. (2020, January13). New York is in uproar over push to ax gifted programs. This school is doing it anyway. USA Today.
71.
RodaA. (2015). Inequality in gifted and talented programs: Parental choices about status, school opportunity, and second-generation segregation. Palgrave Macmillan.
72.
RodaA. (2017). Parenting in the age of high stakes testing: Gifted and talented admissions and the meaning of parenthood. Teachers College Record, 119(8), 1–53.
73.
RodaA. (2018). School choice and the politics of parenthood: Exploring parent mobilization as a catalyst for the common good. Peabody Journal of Education, 93(4), 430–449.
74.
RodaA.WellsA. S. (2013). School choice policies and racial segregation: Where White parents’ good intentions, anxiety, and privilege collide. American Journal of Education, 119(2), 261–293.
75.
RoweE. (2016). Middle-class school choice in urban spaces: The economics of public schooling and globalized education reform. Routledge.
76.
Sattin-BajajC. (2014). Unaccompanied minors: Immigrant youth, school choice, and the pursuit of equity. Harvard Education Press.
77.
Sattin-BajajC.RodaA. (2018). Opportunity hoarding in school choice contexts: The role of policy design in promoting middle class parents’ exclusionary behaviors. Educational Policy, 34(7), 992–1035.
78.
SchneiderM.TeskeP.MarschallM. (2000). Choosing schools: Consumer choice and the quality of American schools. Princeton University Press.
SingerJ.LenhoffS. W. (2022). Race, geography, and school choice policy: A critical analysis of Detroit students’ suburban school choices. AERA Open, 8. https://doi.org/10.1177/23328584211067202
82.
StevensM. L. (2007). Creating a class: College admissions and the education of elites. Harvard University Press.
83.
TillyC. (1999). Durable inequality. University of California Press.
84.
UnderhillM. (2019). ‘Diversity is important to me’: White parents and exposure-to-diversity parenting practices. Sociology of Race and Ethnicity, 5(4), 486–499.
85.
WakelingP.SavageM. (2015). Entry to elite positions and the stratification of higher education in Britain. The Sociological Review, 63(2), 290–320.
86.
WarikooN. (2016). The diversity bargain: And other dilemmas of race, admissions, and meritocracy at elite universities. University of Chicago Press.
87.
WeisL.CipolloneK.JenkinsH. (2014). Class warfare: Class, race, and college admissions in top-tier secondary schools. University of Chicago Press.
88.
WellsA. S.SernaI. (1996). The politics of culture: Understanding local political resistance to detracking in racially mixed schools. Harvard Educational Review, 66(1), 93–11.
89.
WilsonT. S. (2016). Interest, not preference: Dewey and reframing the conceptual vocabulary of school choice. Educational Theory, 66(1–2), 147–163.
