Educational policy research on teacher unionization in the United States has been dominated by two theoretical perspectives: rent-seeking and teacher voice. While bringing valuable insights to bear, these views have mutated into rigid and often ideologically charged alternatives with strong normative claims about teacher collective bargaining. Drawing from a political economy framework, this article advances a distinct theoretical perspective focusing on the progressive coalition building activities of teachers’ unions (i.e., organizing and mobilizing to promote the interests of working people in policymaking). This perspective resolves previous theoretical anomalies of union behavior; provides many new avenues for research; and highlights distinct considerations for the practice of teacher organizing.
AnziaS. F.MoeT. M. (2015). Public sector unions and the costs of government. The Journal of Politics, 77(1), 114–127.
3.
AnziaS. F.MoeT. M. (2016). Do politicians use policy to make politics? The case of public-sector labor laws. American Political Science Review, 110(4), 763–777.
4.
AshbyS. K.BrunoR. (2016). A fight for the soul of public education: The story of the Chicago teachers strike. ILR Press.
5.
BaronE. J. (2018). The effect of teachers’ unions on student achievement in the short run: Evidence from Wisconsin’s Act 10. Economics of Education Review, 67, 40–57.
6.
BasciaN. (Ed.). (2015). Teacher unions in public education: Politics, history, and the future. Palgrave Macmillan.
7.
BrunnerE.HymanJ.JuA. (2020). School finance reforms, teachers’ unions, and the allocation of school resources. The Review of Economics and Statistics, 102, 473–489.
8.
ChoiY.ChungI. H. (2016). Voice effects of public sector unions on turnover: Evidence from teacher contracts. Public Personnel Management, 45(2), 213–233.
9.
ClarkeS. E. (2017). Local place-based collaborative governance: Comparing state-centric and society-centered models. Urban Affairs Review, 53(3), 578–602.
10.
CohenD. K.MehtaJ. D. (2017). Why reform sometimes succeeds: Understanding the conditions that produce reforms that last. American Educational Research Journal, 54(4), 644–690.
ConstantL. M. (2006). When money matters: Campaign contributions, roll call votes, and school choice in Florida. State Politics & Policy Quarterly, 6(2), 195–219.
13.
CowenJ. M.StrunkK. O. (2015). The impact of teachers’ unions on educational outcomes: What we know and what we need to learn. Economics of Education Review, 48, 208–223.
14.
DomhoffG. W. (1967). Who rules America?Prentice-Hall.
D’AmicoD. (2016). Teachers’ rights versus students’ rights: Race and professional authority in the New York City public schools, 1960–1986. American Educational Research Journal, 53(3), 541–572.
17.
FarberH. S.HerbstD.KuziemkoI.NaiduS. (2018). Unions and inequality over the twentieth century: New evidence from survey data. National Bureau of Economic Research, Inc.
18.
FeigenbaumJ.Hertel-FernandezA.WilliamsonV. (2018). From the bargaining table to the ballot box: Political effects of right to work laws. (Working Paper Series, No. 24259). National Bureau of Economic Research.
19.
FermanB.PalazzoloN. (2017). Challenges to coalition building: Confronting power with creativity. In FermanB. (Ed.), The fight for America’s schools: Grassroots organizing in education (pp. 17–32). Harvard Education Press.
20.
FingerL. K. (2018). Vested interests and the diffusion of education reform across the states. Policy Studies Journal, 46(2), 378–401.
21.
FlavinP.HartneyM. T. (2015). When government subsidizes its own: Collective bargaining laws as agents of political mobilization. American Journal of Political Science, 59(4), 896–911.
22.
FrandsenB. R. (2016). The effects of collective bargaining rights on public employee compensation: Evidence from teachers, firefighters, and police. ILR Review, 69(1), 84–112.
23.
FreemanR. B.MedoffJ. L. (1984). What do unions do? Basic Books.
24.
FrymerP.GrumbachJ. M. (2021). Labor unions and white racial politics. American Journal of Political Science, 65(1), 225–240.
25.
GilensM.PageB. I. (2014). Testing theories of American politics: Elites, interest groups, and average citizens. Perspectives on Politics, 12(3), 564–581.
26.
GoldsteinD. (2014). The teacher wars: A history of America’s most embattled profession. Anchor Books.
27.
GroffP. J. (1960). The NEA and school desegregation. The Journal of Negro Education, 29(2), 181–186.
28.
HackerJ. S.PiersonP. (2010). Winner-take-all politics: How Washington made the rich richer–and turned its back on the middle class. Simon & Schuster.
29.
HanE. S.KeefeJ. (2022). Teachers’ unions: Engaging teachers and improving student achievement in states that prohibit collective bargaining. Educational Policy, 36(2), 407–439.
30.
HannawayJ.RotherhamA. J. (Eds.). (2006). Collective bargaining in education: Negotiating change in today’s schools. Harvard Education Press.
31.
HartneyM.FlavinP. (2011). From the schoolhouse to the statehouse: Teacher union political activism and U.S. State education reform policy. State Politics & Policy Quarterly, 11(3), 251–268.
32.
HenigJ. R. (2013). The end of exceptionalism in American education: The changing politics of school reform. Harvard Education Press.
33.
HenigJ. R.HulaR. C.OrrM.PedescleauxD. S. (1999). The color of school reform: Race, politics, and the challenge of urban education. Princeton University Press.
34.
HenigJ. R.JacobsenR.ReckhowS. (2019). Outside money in school board elections: The nationalization of education politics. Harvard Education Press.
35.
Hertel-FernandezA. (2018). Policy feedback as political weapon: Conservative advocacy and the demobilization of the public sector labor movement. Perspectives on Politics, 16(2), 364–379.
36.
Hertel-FernandezA. (2019). State capture: How conservative activists, big businesses, and wealthy donors reshaped the American states–and the nation. Oxford University Press.
37.
HirschmanA. O. (1970). Exit, voice, and loyalty: Responses to decline in firms, organizations, and states. Harvard University Press.
38.
HoxbyC. M. (1996). How teachers’ unions affect education production. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 111(3), 671–718.
39.
JohnsonS. M.DonaldsonM. L.MungerM. S.PapayJ. P.QazilbashE. K. (2009). Leading the local: Teachers union presidents chart their own course. Peabody Journal of Education, 84(3), 374–393.
40.
JohnsonS. M.KraftM. A.PapayJ. P. (2012). How context matters in high-need schools: The effects of teachers’ working conditions on their professional satisfaction and their students’ achievement. Teachers College Record, 114(10), 1–39.
41.
KahlenbergR. D. (2006). The history of collective bargaining among teachers. In HannawayJ.RotherhamA. (Eds.), Collective bargaining in education (pp. 7–27). Harvard Education Press.
42.
KellyN. J.WitkoC. (2012). Federalism and American inequality. The Journal of Politics, 74(2), 414–426.
43.
KuslerM. (2014). Letter to the senate on the minimum wage fairness act (s. 2223) [Press release]. Retrieved from http://www.nea.org/home/58968.htm
44.
LeviM. (2003). Organizing power: The prospects for an American labor movement. Perspectives on Politics, 1(1), 45–68.
45.
LovenheimM. F.WillénA. (2019). The long-run effects of teacher collective bargaining. American Economic Journal Economic Policy, 11(3), 292–324.
46.
LyonM. A. (2021). Heroes, villains, or something in between? How “Right to Work” policies affect teachers, students, and education policymaking. Economics of Education Review, 82, 102–105.
47.
LyonM. A.HenigJ. R. (2019). Blurring lines? How locally based collaborations handle the redistribution/development tradeoff. Urban Affairs Review, 55(4), 1100–1124.
48.
MariannoB. D.KilbrideT.TheobaldR.StrunkK. O.CowenJ. M.GoldhaberD. (2018). Cut from the same cloth? Comparing urban district CBAs within states and across the United States. Educational Policy, 32(2), 334–359.
49.
MariannoB. D.StrunkK. O. (2018). The bad end of the bargain?: Revisiting the relationship between collective bargaining agreements and student achievement. Economics of Education Review, 65, 93–106.
50.
McCartinJ. A.SneidermanM.BP-WeeksM. (2020). Combustible convergence: Bargaining for the common good and the #RedforEd uprisings of 2018. Labor Studies Journal, 45(1), 97–113.
51.
MillsC. W. (1956). The power elite. Oxford University Press.
52.
MoeT. M. (2011). Special interest: Teachers unions and America’s public schools. Brookings Institution Press.
53.
MoeT. M. (2015). Vested interests and political institutions. Political Science Quarterly, 130(2), 277–318.
54.
MosimannN.PontussonJ. (2017). Solidaristic unionism and support for redistribution in contemporary Europe. World Politics, 69(3), 448–492.
55.
MurphyM. (1990). Blackboard unions: The AFT and the NEA, 1900-1980. Cornell University Press.
56.
Osborne-LampkinL.Cohen-VogelL.FengL.WilsonJ. J. (2018). Researching collective bargaining agreements: Building conceptual understanding in an era of declining union power. Educational Policy, 32(2), 152–188.
57.
PaglayanA. S. (2019). Public-Sector unions and the size of government. American Journal of Political Science, 63(1), 21–36.
58.
PerrilloJ. (2012). Uncivil rights: Teachers, unions, and race in the battle for school equity. University of Chicago Press.
59.
PiersonP. (1993). When effect becomes cause: Policy feedback and political change. World Politics, 45(4), 595–628.
60.
PodairJ. E. (2002). The strike that changed New York: Blacks, whites, and the ocean Hill-Brownsville crisis. Yale University Press.
61.
PooleW. L. (2000). The construction of teachers’ paradoxical interests by teacher union leaders. American Educational Research Journal, 37(1), 93–119.
62.
PooleW. L. (2015). Defending teachers’ rights and promoting public education: Evolving and emerging union strategies within a globalized neoliberal context. In BasciaN. (Ed.), Teacher unions in public education: Politics, history, and the future (pp. 11–31). Palgrave Macmillan.
63.
RavitchD. (2007). Why teacher unions are good for teachers—and the public. American Education, 30(4), 6–9.
RottmanC.KuehnL.StewartC.TurnerJ.ChamberlainJ. (2015). Remembering, reimagining, and reviving social justice unionism. In BasciaN. (Ed.), Teacher unions in public education: Politics, history, and the future (pp. 53–67). Palgrave Macmillan.
66.
RousmaniereK. (2005). Citizen teacher: The life and leadership of Margaret Haley. SUNY Press.
67.
SchattschneiderE. E. (1960). The semisovereign people: A realist’s view of democracy in America. Holt, Rinehart and Winston.
68.
SchragerA.WitwerR. (2016). Blueprint: How the Democrats won Colorado (and why Republicans everywhere should care). Fulcrum Publishing.
69.
ShirleyD. (2016). Entrenched enemies, tactical partners, or steadfast allies? Exploring the fault lines between teacher unions and community organizing in the United States. Leadership and Policy in Schools, 15(1), 45–66.
70.
SmallerH. (2015). Gender and status: Ontario teachers’ associations in the nineteenth century. In BasciaN. (Ed.), Teacher unions in public education: Politics, history, and the future (pp. 11–31). Palgrave Macmillan.
StrunkK. O. (2011). Are teachers’ unions really to blame? Collective bargaining agreements and their relationships with district resource allocation and student performance in California. Education Finance and Policy, 6(3), 354–398.
73.
StrunkK. O.CowenJ. M.GoldhaberD.MariannoB. D.KilbrideT.TheobaldR. (2018). It is in the contract: How the policies set in teachers’ unions’ collective bargaining agreements vary across states and districts. Educational Policy, 32(2), 280–312.
74.
StrunkK. O.McEachinA. (2011). Accountability under constraint: The relationship between collective bargaining agreements and California schools’ and districts’ performance under No Child Left behind. American Educational Research Journal, 48(4), 871–903.
75.
Todd-BrelandE. (2018). A political education: Black politics and education reform in Chicago since the 1960s by Chapel Hill. The University of North Carolina Press.
76.
VanHeuvelenT. (2020). The right to work, power resources, and economic inequality. American Journal of Sociology, 125(5), 1255–1302.
77.
VerbaS.SchlozmanK. L.BradyH. E. (1995). Voice and equality: Civic voluntarism in American politics. Harvard University Press.
78.
WarrenD. T. (2010). The American labor movement in the age of Obama: The challenges and opportunities of a racialized political economy. Perspectives on Politics, 8(3), 847–860.
79.
WeinerL. (2015). The teachers’ trifecta: Democracy, social justice, mobilization. In BasciaN. (Ed.), Teacher unions in public education: Politics, history, and the future (pp. 189–199). Palgrave Macmillan.
80.
WestK. L.MykereziE. (2011). Teachers’ unions and compensation: The impact of collective bargaining on salary schedules and performance pay schemes. Economics of Education Review, 30(1), 99–108.
