The relatively recent shift of family caregiving to the public market of service work raises questions about how to theorize paid caregiving. This article examines how to conceptualize child rearing when it is transferred to a paid worker. The gendered character of commodified caregiving is complicated by structural locations of race and class that define the employer-employee relationship. Previous discussions of paid child care work as emotionally meaningful work have been criticized as idealizations that mask the exploitative nature of the work. Yet, emotional meaning is not simply a cover-up or an idealization of the labor; rather, it is an integral component of the work of caregiving, the practice of which is distorted by societal assumptions about gender and race. To better understand paid child care work, the significance of emotional meaning, as well as gender, race, and ethnic dimensions of paid child care work need to be explored.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Abel, Emily K.
, and Margaret K. Nelson. 1990. Circles of care: An introductory essay. In Circles of care: Work and identity in women's lives, edited by Emily K. Abel and Margaret K. Nelson.Albany: State University of New York Press.
2.
Auerbach, Stevanne.
1975. What parents want from day care. In Child care: Comprehensive guide—Philosophy, programs, and practices for the creation of quality services for children. Vol. 1, Rationale for child care services: Programs vs. politics, edited by Stevanne Auerbach with James A. Rivaldo.New York: Human Sciences Press.
Benston, Margaret.1969. The political economy of women's liberation.Monthly Review21 (September): 13-27.
5.
Child Care Employees Project.
1989. Who cares? Child care teachers and the quality of care in America—Executive summary of the National Child Care Staffing Study.Oakland, CA: CCEP.
6.
Cobble, Dorothy Sue.
1993. Introduction: Remaking unions for the new majority. In Women and unions: Forging a partnership, edited by Dorothy Sue Cobble.Ithaca, NY: ILR Press.
7.
Colen, Shellee.
1989. “Just a little respect”: West Indian domestic workers in New York City. In Muchachas no more, edited by Elsa M. Chaney and Mary Castro.Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
DeVault, Marjorie L.
1991. Feeding the family.Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
10.
Dill, Bonnie Thornton.
1988. “Making your job good yourself”: Domestic service and the construction of personal dignity. In Women and the politics of empowerment, edited by Ann Bookman and Sandra Morgen.Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
11.
Ehrenreich, Barbara.1984. Life without father: Reconstructing socialist-feminist theory.Socialist Review14 (1): 48-57.
12.
Fisher, Berenice
, and Joan Tronto. 1990. Toward a feminist theory of caring. In Circles of care: Work and identity in women's lives, edited by Emily K. Abel and Margaret K. Nelson.Albany: State University of New York Press.
13.
Genovese, Elizabeth Fox.
1988. Within the plantation household.Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.
14.
Glenn, Evelyn Nakano.
1986. Issei, Nisei, war bride: Three generations of Japanese American women in domestic service.Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
15.
Hartmann, Heidi.1981. The family as the locus of gender, class, and political struggle: The example of housework. Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society6:366-94.
16.
Hartsock, Nancy.
1983. The feminist standpoint: Developing the ground for a specifically feminist historical materialism. In Discovering reality, edited by Sandra Harding and Merrill Hintikka.Boston: D. Reidel.
17.
Hays, Sharon.
1996. Cultural contradictions of motherhood.New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
18.
Hertz, Rosanna.
1986. More equal than others: Women and men in dual-career marriages.Berkeley: University of California Press.
19.
Hertz, Rosanna.1997. A typology of approaches to child care: The centerpiece of organizing family life for dual-earner couples.Journal of Family Issues18:355-85.
20.
Hertz, Rosanna
, and Faith Ferguson.1996. Child care choice and constraints in the United States: Social class, race, and the influence of family views.Journal of Comparative Family Studies27:249-80.
21.
Hochschild, Arlie.
1983. The managed heart: Commercialization of human feeling.Berkeley: University of California Press.
22.
Jakubovics, Jerry.1988. Perry Mendel: Turning child care into a cash business.Management Review77 (6): 11-13.
23.
Larner, Mary
, and Anne Mitchell.1992. Meeting the child care needs of low-income families.Child & Youth Care Forum21:317-34.
24.
Leira, Arnlaug.
1990. Coping with care: Mothers in a welfare state. In Gender and caring: Work and welfare in Britain and Scandinavia, edited by Clare Ungerson.New York: Harvester Wheatsheaf.
25.
Luttrell, Wendy.1984. Beyond the politics of victimization.Socialist Review14 (1): 42-47.
26.
Macdonald, Cameron Lynne.
1996. Shadow mothers: Nannies, au pairs, and invisible work. In Working in the service society, edited by Cameron Lynne Macdonald and Carmen Sirianni.Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
27.
Macdonald, Cameron Lynne.1998. Manufacturing motherhood: The shadow work of nannies and au pairs.Qualitative Sociology21 (1): 25-53.
28.
Macdonald, Cameron Lynne
, and Carmen Sirianni. 1996. The service society and the changing experience of work. In Working in the service society, edited by Cameron Lynne Macdonald and Carmen Sirianni.Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
29.
National Commission on Working Women.
1986. Who cares for kids? A report on child care providers.Washington, DC: NCWW.
30.
Nelson, Margaret.
1990. Negotiated care: The experience of family day care providers.Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
31.
Oakley, Ann.
1974. Women's work.New York: Pantheon Books.
32.
Palmer, Phyllis.
1989. Domesticity and dirt: Housewives and domestic servants in the United States, 1920-1945.Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
33.
Reskin, Barbara
, and Heidi Hartmann. 1986. Women's work, men's work: Sex segregation on the job.Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
34.
Rollins, Judith.
1985. Between women: Domestics and their employers.Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
35.
Romero, Mary.1987. Domestic service in the transition from rural to urban life: The case of la chicana.Women's Studies13: 199-222.
36.
Romero, Mary.
1992. Maid in the U.S.A.New York: Routledge.
37.
Rubin, Gayle.
1975. The traffic in women: Notes on the political economy of sex. In Toward an anthropology of women, edited by Rayna Rapp.New York: Monthly Review Press.
38.
Ruddick, Sara.
1982. Maternal thinking. In Rethinking the family: Some feminist questions, 1st ed., edited by Barrie Thorne with Marilyn Yalom.New York: Longman.
39.
Rutman, Deborah.1996. Child care as women's work: Workers' Experiences of powerfulness and powerlessness.Gender & Society10:629-49.
40.
Sargent, Lydia.
1981. Women and revolution: A discussion of the unhappy marriage of Marxism and feminism, edited by Lydia Sargent.Boston: South End Press.
41.
Sokoloff, Natalie.
1980. Between money and love.New York: Praeger.
42.
Tuominen, Mary.1992. Gender, class, and motherhood: The legacy of federal child care policy.Affilia: Journal of Women and Social Work37 (2): 8-25.
43.
Tuominen, Mary. 1994a. The conflicts of caregiving: Gender, race-ethnicity, and the changing political economy of child care labor. Ph.D. diss., University of Oregon.
44.
Tuominen, Mary.1994b. The hidden organization of labor: Gender, race-ethnicity, and child care work in the formal and informal economy.Sociological Perspectives37:229-45.
45.
Tuominen, Mary.1998. Motherhood and the market: Mothering and employment opportunities among Mexicana, African American, and Euro-American family day care workers.Sociological Focus31 (1): 59-77.
46.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
1981. Family day care in the United States: Summary of findings [The National Day Care Home Study], Vol. 1. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
47.
U.S. Department of Labor.
1997. Facts of working women. No. 98-1. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
48.
Uttal, Lynet. 1993. Shared mothering: Reproductive labor, child care, and the meanings of motherhood. Ph.D. diss., University of California, Santa Cruz.
49.
Uttal, Lynet.1996a. Custodial care, surrogate care, and coordinated care: Employed mothers and the meaning of child care.Gender & Society10:291-311.
50.
Uttal, Lynet.1996b. Racial safety and cultural maintenance: The child care concerns of employed mothers of color.Ethnic Studies Review19 (1): 43-59.
51.
Uttal, Lynet.1997. “Trust your instincts”: Racial-ethnic and class-based preferences in employed mothers' child care choices.Qualitative Sociology20:253-74.
52.
Vogel, Lise.
1989. Marxism and the oppression of women: Toward a unitary theory.New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
53.
West, Candace
, and Sarah Fenstermaker.1995. Doing difference.Gender & Society9:8-37.
54.
West, Candace
, and Don Zimmerman.1987. Doing gender.Gender & Society1:125-51.
55.
Wrigley, Julia.
1995. Other people's children: An intimate account of dilemmas facing middle-class parents and the women they hire to raise their children.New York: Basic Books.
56.
Zinsser, Caroline.
1991. Raised in east urban: Child care changes in a working class community.New York: College Teachers Press.
