Some feminists have seen sex role theory as limited, even dangerous; others see it as useful mid-range theory. This article sheds light on this debate through an examination of the discourse of the men's liberation movement of the 1970s. Men's liberation leaders grappled with the paradox of simultaneously acknowledging men's institutional privileges and the costs of masculinity to men. The language of sex roles was the currency through which they negotiated this paradox. By the late 1970s, men's liberation had disappeared. The conservative and moderate wings of men's liberation became an anti-feminist men's rights movement, facilitated by the language of sex roles. The progressive wing of men's liberation abandoned sex role language and formed a profeminist movement premised on a language of gender relations and power. The article ends with a discussion of the implications of this case for debates about sex role theory, and urges the study of contemporary organizations whose discourse is based on the language of sex roles.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Adams, M.
1985. Child of the glacier. In Men freeing men: Exploding the myth of the traditional male, edited by F. Baumli. Jersey City, NJ: New Atlantis.
2.
Andersen, D.
1977. Warren the success object. In For men against sexism, edited by Jon Snodrass. Albion, CA: Times Change Press.
3.
Arendell, Terry
. 1992. After divorce: Investigations into father absence. Gender & Society6:562-586.
4.
Balswick, Jack
, and Charles Peek. 1971. The inexpressive male: A tragedy of American society. Family Coordinator20:363-368.
5.
Baumli, Francis
, ed. 1985. Men freeing men: Exploding the myth of the traditional male. Jersey City, NJ: New Atlantis.
6.
Bertoia, C. E.
, and J. Drakich. 1995. The fathers' rights movement: Contradictions in rhetoric and practice. In Fatherhood: Contemporary theory, research and social policy, edited by W. Marsiglio. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
7.
Brannon, Robert
. 1976. The male sex role: Our culture's blueprint of manhood, and what it's done for us lately. In The forty-nine percent majority: The male sex role, edited by Deborah S. David and Robert Brannon, 14-15, 30-32. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
8.
Brannon, Robert
. 1981-82. Are the “Free Men” a faction of our movement?M: Gentle Men for Gender Justice7 (winter).
9.
Brod, Harry
. 1987. The making of masculinities: The new men's studies. Boston: Allen & Unwin.
10.
Clatterbaugh, Kenneth
. 1990. Contemporary perspectives on masculinity: Men, women, and politics in modern society. Boulder, CO: Westview.
11.
Coltrane, S.
, and N. Hickman. 1992. The rhetoric of rights and needs: Moral discourse in the reform of child custody and child support laws. Social Problems39:400-420.
12.
Connell, R.W.
1983. The concept of role and what to do with it. In Which way is up?: Essays on sex, class, and culture, by R. W. Connell. Sydney, London, Boston: Allen & Unwin.
13.
Connell, R.W.
. 1987. Gender and power. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
14.
Doyle, R.
1985. Divorce. In Men freeing men: Exploding the myth of the traditional male, edited by Frances Baumli. Jersey City, NJ: New Atlantis.
15.
Ehrenreich, Barbara
. 1983. The hearts of men: American dreams and the flight from commitment. New York: Anchor/Doubleday.
16.
Farrell, Warren
. 1974. The liberated man. New York: Random House.
17.
Farrell, Warren
. 1993. The myth of male power: Why men are the disposable sex. New York: Simon & Schuster.
18.
Fasteau, Marc Feigen
. 1974. The male machine. New York: McGraw-Hill.
19.
Free Men
. 1997. National Coalition of Free Men. Web Page.
20.
Gerzon, Mark
. 1982. A choice of heroes: The changing faces of America's manhood. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
21.
Goldberg, Herb
. 1976. The hazards of being male: Surviving the myth of masculine privilege. New York: Signet.
22.
Goldberg, Herb
. 1979. The new male: From macho to sensitive but still all male. New York: Signet.
23.
Hacker, Helen
. 1957. The new burdens of masculinity. Marriage and Family Living3:227-233.
24.
Haddad, R.
1985. Concepts and overview of the men's liberation movement. In Men freeing men: Exploding the myth of the traditional male, edited by F. Baumli. Jersey City, NJ: New Atlantis.
25.
Hanisch, C.
1975. Men's Liberation. In Feminist revolution, edited by Redstockings. New York: Random House.
26.
Reprint, in Men and masculinity, edited by J. H. Pleck and J. Sawyer. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
27.
Henley, Nancy
. 1970. Male chauvinism: Attitudes and practices. Newsletter of the New University Conference. Chicago.
28.
Jourard, S. M.
1971. Some lethal aspects of the male role. In The transparent self, edited by S. M. Jourard. Princeton, NJ: Van Nostrand.
29.
Kimmel, Michael S.
1987. Changing men: New directions in research on men and masculinity. Newbury Park: Sage.
30.
Komarovsky, Mirra
. 1946. Cultural contradictions and sex roles. American Journal of Sociology52:184-189.
31.
Komarovsky, Mirra
. 1992. The concept of social role revisited. Gender & Society6:301-313.
32.
Logan, D.
1985. Men abused by women. In Men freeing men: Exploding the myth of the traditional male, edited by F. Baumli. Jersey City, NJ: New Atlantis.
33.
Lopata, H. Z.
, and B. Thorne. 1978. On the term “sex roles.”Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society3:718-721.
34.
Men's Consciousness-Raising Group
. 1971. Unbecoming men. Washington, DC: Times Change.
35.
Messner, Michael A.
1997. Politics of masculinities: Men in movements. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
36.
Messner, Michael A.
. Forthcoming. Radical feminist and socialist feminist men's movements in the U.S. In Feminism and men: Toward a relational feminism, edited by S. Schacht and D. Ewing. New York: New York University Press.
37.
Nardi, P.
1994. Do ask and do tell: Stonewalling men's studies. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Pacific Sociological Association, San Diego, CA, April.
38.
Nichols, Jack
. 1975. Men's liberation: A new definition of masculinity. New York: Penguin.
39.
Panghorn, K.
1985. The murdered husband: Family violence and women's lib. In Men freeing men: Exploding the myth of the traditional male, edited by F. Baumli. Jersey City, NJ: New Atlantis.
40.
Parsons, Talcott
, and Robert Bales. 1955. Family, socialization and interaction process. New York: Free Press.
41.
Pleck, J. H.
1974. Men's power with women, other men, and in society: A men's movement analysis. In Women and men: The consequences of power, edited by D. V. Hiller and R. Sheets. Cincinnati, OH: University of Cincinnati, Office of Women's Studies.
42.
Pleck, J. H.
. 1976. The male sex role: Definitions, problems, and sources of change. Journal of Social Issues32:155-164.
43.
Pleck, J. H.
. 1982. The myth of masculinity. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
44.
Pleck, J. H.
, and R. Brannon. 1978. Male roles and the male experience: Introduction. Journal of Social Issues34:1-4.
45.
Pleck, Joseph H.
, and Jack Sawyer. 1974. Men and masculinity. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
46.
Saunders, D. G.1988. Other “truths” about domestic violence: A reply to McNeely and Robinson-Simpson. Social Work32:179-183.
47.
Sawyer, Jack
. 1970. The male liberation movement. A workshop presented at the Women's Liberation Teach-in, Northwestern University, 8 March. Published in revised form in 1970 as “On male liberation,” Liberation (August-September-October).
48.
Schwartz, M. D.1987. Gender and injury in spousal assaults. Sociological Focus20:61-75.
49.
Snodgrass, Jon
. 1977. For men against sexism. Albion, CA: Times Change.
50.
Stacey, J.
, and B. Thorne. 1985. The missing feminist revolution in sociology. Social Problems32:301-316.
51.
Straton, Jack C.1994. The myth of the “battered husband syndrome.”Masculinities2:79-82.
52.
Zinn, Martha Baca
, Lynn Weber Cannon, Elizabeth Higgenbotham and Bonnie Thornton Dill. 1986. The costs of exclusionary practices in women's studies. Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society11:290-303.
