This article explores the reasons some pregnant women enter maternity homes with the plan to place their babies for adoption. The authors discuss changes in maternity homes over the twentieth century and report on findings from a survey of currently licensed homes in Texas. Next, the authors discuss the findings from fieldwork and in-depth interviews with residents of two maternity homes. They identify three major reasons why birth mothers enter maternity homes: (1) the desire to escape abusive or stressful family lives, (2) the desire to avoid the stigma of placing a child for adoption, and (3) the desire to provide their children, and in some cases themselves, with a stable and loving family life. The authors contend that entering a maternity home with the intention of placing their babies for adoption represents an effort on the part of birth mothers to reconfigure their own, often impoverished family lives.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Bachrach, C. A.1986. Adoption plans, adopted children, and adoptive mothers.Journal of Marriage and the Family48:243-53.
2.
Bachrach, C. A.
, K. S. Stolley, and K. A. London.1992. Relinquishment of premarital births: Evidence from the National Survey Data.Family Planning Perspectives24:27-32.
3.
Bartholet, E.
1993. Family bonds: Adoption and the politics of parenting.Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
4.
Belkin, L.1998. Now accepting applications for my baby.New York Times Magazine, 5April, 58-62.
5.
Carp, E. W.
1998. Family matters: Secrecy and disclosure in the history of adoption.Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
6.
Chippindale-Bakker, V.
, and L. Foster.1996. Adoption in the 1990's: Socio-demographic determinants of biological parents choosing adoption.Child Welfare75:337-55.
7.
Cocozzelli, C.1989. Predicting the decision of biological mothers to retain or relinquish their babies for adoption: Implications for open adoption.Child Welfare68:33-44.
8.
Daly, K. J.1994. Adolescent perceptions of adoption: Implications for resolving an unplanned pregnancy.Youth & Society25:330-50.
9.
Day, D.
1979. The adoption of Black children: Counteracting institutional discrimination.Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.
10.
Deykin, E. Y.
, L. Campbell, and P. Patti.1984. The postadoption experience of surrendering parents.American Journal of Orthopsychiatry54:271-80.
11.
Dworkin, R. J.
, J. T. Harding, and N. B. Schreiber.1993. Parenting or placing: Decision making by pregnant teens.Youth & Society25:75-92.
12.
Festinger, T. B.1971. Unwed mothers and their decisions to keep or surrender children.Child Welfare50:253-62.
13.
Gabriel, T.1996. High-tech pregnancies test hope's limit.New York Times, 7January, 1, 10, 11.
14.
Gross, J.1989. Anti-abortion revival: Homes for the unwed.New York Times, 23July, 1, 25.
15.
Grow, L. J.1979. Today's unmarried mothers: The choices have changed.Child Welfare58:363-71.
16.
Kalmuss, D.
, P.B. Namerow, and L.F. Cushman.1991. Adoption versus parenting among young pregnant women.Family Planning Perspectives23:17-23.
17.
Kaplan, E. B.
1997. Not our kind of girl: Unraveling the myths of Black teenage motherhood.Berkeley: University of California Press.
18.
Kunzel, R. G.
1993. Fallen women, problem girls: Unmarried mothers and the professionalization of social work, 1890-1945.New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
19.
Leynes, C.1980. Keep or adopt: A study of factors influencing pregnant adolescents' plans for their babies.Child Psychiatry and Human Development11:105-12.
20.
Lightman, E.
, and B. Schlesinger. 1982. Pregnant adolescents in maternity homes: Some professional concerns. In Pregnancy in adolescence: Needs, problems, and management, edited by I. R. Stuart and F. C. Wells.New York: Van Nostrand Reinhold.
21.
Luker, K.
1996. Dubious conceptions: The politics of teenage pregnancy.Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
22.
McLaughlin, S. D.
, S. E. Pearce, D. L. Manninen, and L. D. Winges.1988. Do adolescents who relinquish their children fare better or worse than those who raise them?Family Planning Perspectives20:25-32.
23.
Melina, L. R.
, and S. K. Roszia. 1993. The open adoption experience.New York: HarperPerennial.
24.
Meyer, H. J.
, W. Jones, and E. F. Borgatta.1956. The decision by unwed mothers to keep or surrender their babies.Social Work1:103-09.
25.
Nathanson, C.
1991. Dangerous passage: The social control of sexuality in women's adolescence.Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
26.
Pannor, R.
, A. Baran, and A. D. Sorosky.1978. Birth parents who relinquished babies for adoption revisited.Family Process17:329-37.
27.
Resnick, M. D.1984. Studying adolescent mothers' decision making about adoption and parenting.Social Work29:5-10.
28.
Resnick, M. D.
, R. W. Blum, J. Bose, M. Smith, and R. Toogood.1990. Characteristics of unmarried adolescent mothers: Determinants of child rearing versus adoption.American Journal of Orthopsychiatry60:577-84.
29.
Rothman, B. K.
1989. Recreating motherhood: Ideology and technology in a patriarchal society.New York: Norton.
30.
Sandven, K.
, and M. D. Resnick.1990. Informal adoption among Black adolescent mothers.American Journal of Orthopsychiatry60:210-24.
31.
Sobol, M. P.
, and K. J. Daly.1992. The adoption alternative for pregnant adolescents: Decision making, consequences, and policy implications.Journal of Social Issues48:143-61.
32.
Solinger, R.
1992. Wake up little Susie: Single pregnancy and race beforeRoe v. Wade.New York: Routledge.
33.
Weinman, M. L.
, M. Robinson, J. T. Simmons, N. B. Schreiber, and B. Stafford.1989. Pregnant teens: Differential pregnancy resolution and treatment implications.Child Welfare68:45-55.
34.
Yngvesson, B.1997. Negotiating motherhood: Identity and difference in open adoptions.Law and Society Review31:31-80.
35.
Yordan, E. E.
, and R. A. Yordan.1993. The maternity home for adolescents: A concept from the past fulfilling a contemporary need.Connecticut Medicine57:65-68.
36.
Zelizer, V. A.
1986. Pricing the priceless child: The changing social value of children.New York: Basic Books.
