Advice can be highly problematic interactionally, especially in pretest counseling sessions for HIV and AIDS where the advice concerns the already highly charged topic of sexual behavior. However, there is surprisingly little research examining the delivery and receipt of advice. Using detailed transcripts obtained during twenty-five pretest counseling sessions in a clinic that tests for HIV, this study examines the various ways that counselors deliver advice to clients and the ways that clients respond to that advice. Analysis concerns structures of advice giving that are collaboratively produced to maintain an ambiguity between the giving of advice and the giving of information. Implications of these findings both for counseling and for ethnography and conversation analysis are discussed.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
The AIDS antibody blood test: A guide to patient counseling. 1988. Produced and distributed by Network for Continuing Medical Education, Secaucus, NJ. 15 min. Vidoecassette.
2.
Bauman, L. J.
, and K. Siegal.1987.Misperception among gay men of the risk for AIDS associated with their sexual behavior.Journal of Applied Social Psychology17:329-350.
3.
Costello, B. 1990. The delivery and receipt of recommendations in the doctor patient encounter. Unpublished master's thesis, Department of Sociology, University of Wisconsin—Madison.
4.
Dingwall, R.
1977. The social organization of health visitor training.London: Croom Helm.
5.
Drew, P.
, and J. Heritage. 1992. Analyzing talk at work: An introduction. In Talk at work, edited by P. Drew and J. Heritage, 3-65. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
6.
Gill, V. T.
, and D. W. Maynard.1995. On “labeling” in actual interaction: Delivering and receiving diagnoses of developmental disabilities.Social Problems42:12-37.
7.
Heritage, J.
, and S. Sefi. 1992. Dilemmas of advice: Aspects of the delivery and reception of advice in interactions between health visitors and first time mothers. In Talk at work, edited by P. Drew and J. Heritage, 359-417. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
8.
Hopper, R.1990-91. Ethnography and conversation analysis afterTalking Culture. Research on Language and Social Interaction24:333-350.
9.
Jefferson, G.1974. Error correction as an interactional resource.Language and Society2:181-199.
10.
Jefferson, G.
, and J. R. E. Lee.1981. The rejection of advice: Managing the problematic convergence of a “troubles-teller” and a “service encounter.”Journal of Pragmatics5:399-422.
11.
Kaplan, H. S.
, C. J. Sager, and R. Schiavi.1985. AIDS and the sex therapist.Journal of Sex and Marital Therapy11:210-214.
12.
Kelley, J. A.
1990. Looking ahead: HIV risk reduction.FOCUS: A Guide to AIDS Research and Counseling, May, 1-2.
13.
Matuszak, D. L.
, E. Israel, J. T. Horman, and J. M. Joseph.1987. HIV antibody testing.Maryland Medical Journal36:40-43.
14.
Maynard, D.
1984. Inside plea bargaining: The language of negotiation.New York: Plenum.
15.
Maynard, D.
1989. On the ethnography and analysis of discourse in institutional settings. In Perspectives on social problems, vol. 1, edited by J. A. Holstein and G. Miller, 127-146. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.
16.
Maynard, D.
1992. On clinicians co-implicating recipients' perspective in the delivery of diagnostic news. In Talk at work, edited by P. Drew and J. Heritage, 331-358. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
17.
McCreaner, A.
1989. Pre-test counseling. In Counseling in HIV infection and AIDS, edited by J. Green and A. McCreaner, 21-27. Oxford: Blackwell Scientific.
18.
McKusick, L.
1990. Changing sexual behavior. In AIDS and sex: An integrated biomedical and biobehavioral approach, edited by B. Voeller, J. Machover Reinisch, and M. Gottlieb, 155-167. New York: Oxford University Press.
19.
Miller, G.1994. Toward ethnographies of institutional discourse: Proposal and suggestions.Journal of Contemporary Ethnography23:280-306.
20.
Moeman, M.
1988. Talking culture.Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
21.
Morgen, K. B.1987. Counseling and HIV: Test results and risk reduction.Maryland Medical Journal36:44-46.
22.
Nelson, C. K.1994. Ethnomethodological positions on the use of ethnographic data in conversation analytic research.Journal of Contemporary Ethnography23:307-329.
23.
Nokes, K.
1991. Pre-test and post-test counseling. In HIV positive: Perspectives on counseling, edited by M. Tallmer, C. Clason, R. F. Lampke, A. H. Kutscher, E. Braun, and F. E. Selder, 68-80. Philadelphia: The Charles Press.
24.
Perakyla, A.
, and D. Silverman.1991. Reinterpreting speech-exchange systems: Communication formats in AIDS counseling.Sociology25:627-651.
25.
Peyrot, M.1987. Circumspection in psychotherapy: Structures and strategies of counselor client interaction.Semiotica65:249-268.
26.
Pomerantz, A.
1984. Pursuing a response. In Structures of social action, edited by J. M. Atkinson and J. Heritage, 152-163. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
27.
Sacks, H.
1992. Lectures on conversation. Vol. 1: fall 1964-spring 1968. Oxford: Blackwell.
28.
Sacks, H.
, E. Schegloff, and G. Jefferson.1974. A simplest systematics for the organization of turn-taking for conversation.Language50:696-735.
29.
Schegloff, E.
1982. Discourse as an interactional achievement: Some uses of “uh-huh” and other things that come between sentences. In Georgetown University Round-table on Language and Linguistics, edited by D. Tannen, pp. 71-93. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press.
30.
Schegloff, E.
1987. Between macro and micro: Contexts and other connections. In The micro-macro link, edited by J. Alexander, B. Giesen, R. Munch, and N. Smelser, pp. 207-234. Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press.
31.
Silverman, D.
1993. Interpreting qualitative data: Methods for analysing talk, text and interaction.London: Sage.
32.
Silverman, D.1994. Describing sexual activities in HIV counseling: The cooperative management of the moral order.Text14:427-453.
33.
Silverman, D.
Forthcoming. Managing advice giving in AIDS counseling: The advice-as-information sequence. In The discourse of counselling, edited by D. Silverman and A. Perakyla.London: Sage.
34.
Silverman, D.
, R. Bor, R. Miller, and E. Goldman. 1992. “Obviously the advice is then to keep safer sex”: Advice giving and advice reception in AIDS counselling. In AIDS: Rights, risk and reason, edited by P. Aggleton, P. Davies, and G. Hart, 174-191. London: Falmer.
35.
Silverman, D.
, and A. Perakyla.1990. AIDS counseling: The interactional organization of talk about “delicate” issues.Sociology of Health and Illness12:293-318.
36.
Silverman, D.
, A. Perakyla, and R. Bor.1992. Discussing safer sex in HIV counseling: Assessing three communication formats.AIDS Care4:69-82.
37.
Spencer, J. W.1994. Mutual relevance of ethnography and discourse.Journal of Contemporary Ethnography23:267-279.
38.
Wisconsin Department of Health and Social Services.
1986. Information and recommendations for prevention and control of HIV related infections through counseling and contact notification.Madison: Wisconsin Department of Health and Social Services.
39.
World Health Organization.
1990. Guidelines for counseling about HIV infection and disease.WHO AIDS Series, no. 8. Geneva: World Health Organization.
